Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so hurt to have been replaced by a Physician's Associate?

457 replies

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 09:40

I'm a junior doctor who 'specialises' in psychiatry. Due to having a young family, entering training is not the right thing for me to do currently. For those who do not know much about the training pathways, these tend to involve moving around a lot, a fairly high out-of-hour burden, keeping a portfolio and revising for exams. I just can't make this work around my family, my husband's job (involves a lot of travel) and the childcare I have access to.

For the last few years, I've worked as a locum at my local psychiatric hospital. I've worked pretty much full time and gone well above my designated hours and work load. In particular, in addition to my usual responsibilities, I've taken on the physical health needs for a lot of patients and (I think!) made some real progress. This is something that can get overlooked in psychiatry.

I am perfectly happy with my pay but for context, I am not one of the mega-rich locum doctors the newspapers talk of. I earn around £23/hour and obviously have no sick pay or AL. Several times I've been approached about having a full time non-locum role for around £32k. I've always been really enthusiastic about this but there has never been the funding.

Anyway, I've recently been told that they don't need me anymore as they have a new physician's associate. I'm really sad and hurt. I've gone above and beyond for this job. I can't understand how there is funding for a PA who will earn more than I would have done and can't do a lot of what I can do. They won't be able to prescribe (I spend a lot of time prescribing and dealing with very heavy duty psychiatric medications) or detain patients (I perform emergency detentions under the MHA not infrequently). They won't have the same medical background I have to manage the physical health of the patients. I just can't really understand what they can do that I can't!

This isn't a problem unique to me. Lots of junior doctors locum not because they want lots of money (as the media might tell you) but because they can't make training work - or, in many cases, because there aren't enough training positions at all! Many of these positions are now being replaced by PAs. I know people who have left medicine because of it and now, I think I might have to too.

AIBU to be so hurt and sad and think it's just not fair?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Locutus2000 · 07/12/2023 09:55

Vettrianofan · 06/12/2023 23:12

That's interesting. Which NHS trusts?

Here's one

EG168814 - Physician Associate:Woodend Hospital

https://apply.jobs.scot.nhs.uk/Job/JobDetail?JobId=169179

Vettrianofan · 06/12/2023 23:12

ScrantonDunderMifflin · 06/12/2023 18:25

Quite disheartening reading all these comments about PAs but oh well.
Saw multiple people celebrating the fact they 'aren't employed in Scotland' - sorry to disappoint but there are lots of PAs working in Scotland.

That's interesting. Which NHS trusts?

Villagetoraiseachild · 06/12/2023 23:11

Hopefully, down the line you will be grateful for them having liberated you.
100% it's not personal, its a business decision. You sound like a fabulous human being. Please take the opportunity to reflect on how else you can experience career fulfillment at an appropriate pay grade that fits with sustaining a family life and your own health and happiness.
(Friend works in similar role in Germany but different system there).

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 19:38

Thanks so much for taking the time to reply @AgeingDoc, I really appreciate it. You’re right in that it isn’t a pre-existing vacancy. I suspect / have been told as much pre-funding but it’s reassuring to hear this again. Thank you!

OP posts:
AgeingDoc · 06/12/2023 18:53

Apologies if I'm repeating stuff OP - the thread is too long for me to read right now - but speaking as someone who was until fairly recently Clinical Director of a large department in a hospital I would urge you not to see this as a personal slight. In reality it is highly unlikely that this is a decision to replace you as a person.
It's far more likely that the Business Manager for your Directorate (or whatever the equivalent in your Trust is called) has money saving targets and reduction of the locum bill is often a priority. Whilst you as an individual may not be particularly expensive, as I am sure you know, locum costs in general are high and you'll probably be lumped in with everyone else. Also, from a service delivery perspective, having posts filled by locums, even long term ones is often less than ideal for lots of reasons and there is frequently a lot of pressure on departments to come up with staffing strategies that are seen as sustainable in the long term.
Personally, I am not a fan of PAs in general. I also locked horns with management on plenty of occasions as their proposed cost savings were not infrequently risky and not even likely to save money in the longer term, but I do have some understanding of the pressures they are under.
I presume you are not employed to cover a pre existing non training grade vacancy? If you are, then it should have been fairly straightforward to employ you permanently but specifically creating a job isn't always as easy as it sounds like it should be. If you are being employed to cover a gap in what should be a training rotation then a Trust can't necessarily unilaterally decide to change that to say, a Specialty Doctor or Trust Grade post. And if there isn't an existing substantive post at all, then management /HR will be looking at how that role will be best filled in the long term. Whilst they may have you there, ideal for the role right now, there's no guarantee that you are going to be there forever (and from what you've said, in all honesty, for your own sake you probably shouldn't be) and they need to think how that work can be delivered longer term. Finding another "you" might be quite difficult whilst replacing a PA is potentially fairly easy.
I do sympathise. I am no fan of PAs and I know that it's really hard juggling family commitments with a medical career. I'm sorry that you're in this predicament. But please don't let it knock your confidence. It almost certainly is a longer term financial and workforce planning decision and no reflection on you as an individual. I hope you find a new direction with better prospects soon.

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 06/12/2023 18:43

Mirabai · 06/12/2023 15:34

I have to go, but I would say that I think there is a place for PAs but with far better defined role, far more training and drastically reduced function.

Good luck OP, I hope you find an alternative role that suits you.

I'm genuinely unclear on what place there is for PAs. What place is there for them when we already have Advanced Nurse Practitioners who can do everything that a PA can do and more ie prescribe. ANPs also have years of experience behind them. I'm really not sure why this additional role has been introduced when we already have HCPs who can fulfil the PA role and responsibilities and more.

ScrantonDunderMifflin · 06/12/2023 18:25

Quite disheartening reading all these comments about PAs but oh well.
Saw multiple people celebrating the fact they 'aren't employed in Scotland' - sorry to disappoint but there are lots of PAs working in Scotland.

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 17:47

@Lola2121 you're right. I wish I could re-train as a PA sometimes! Someone upthread asked me about pay. Yes, I would 100% take the pay to work social hours only in a fully supported well-defined role, rather than being the punching bag of the hospital (or so it feels). I know, logically, that decisions are made based purely on cost effectiveness and the balance of staff retention (I think, anyway!). But with doctors being replaced by PAs who are paid more than us and who we have to prescribe for, it's really hard to feel valued at all.

OP posts:
prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 17:45

Yes @PlusThyme sorry I didn't comment on your article. I actually read it when it came out. Really sobering reminder of what we all went through...

OP posts:
Cliffest · 06/12/2023 17:43

My friend is a recently retired consultant psychiatrist. She says she is certain she wouldn't have reached, or remained until retirement, at that level if she had been able to have children. Op, you sound like a committed and caring doctor, I hope you can find a way through and can remain in medicine.

And @PlusThyme I read your article - it made me cry :(.

Lola2121 · 06/12/2023 17:37

Sorry to hear about whats happened OP..Its happening in General Practice too.
No more jobs for recently trained Gps but plenty of jobs for PA/ Anp.
Going to medical school is a waste of time.
Just become a PA instead.

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 17:27

Oliviant · 06/12/2023 17:17

I am a consultant psychiatrist. Your supervision and on call support arrangements don’t sound great.

A locum like you would be snapped up at my Trust.

I am in awe of junior doctors who navigate the system with kids. When I did my MRCPsych, it was the colleagues with young children who kept failing. They simply didn’t have time to revise. I had the luxury of time. I was able to pass my exams and become a consultant at 30. Before I had kids. That would be impossible for someone with children.

I have huge admiration and sympathy for trainee doctors who have kids and do training. With the exams and oncalls. Even part-time is tough as you have to do the same stuff for your portfolios. I look at my juniors with children and there is still so little understanding in the system. Last-minute rotas, long distances to travel, no consideration at all for family life. It was hard enough for me without children.

I think it’s appalling you are being replaced by a PA. I hope the BMA fights this one to the end.

Thank you for being so understanding - I really appreciate it. Just hearing someone acknowledge the realities makes me feel a bit better.

OP posts:
coffeeaddict77 · 06/12/2023 17:22

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 15:39

@Salacia, I so so agree with you that medicine has lost its status and doctors skills, intelligence, dedication and commitment is just not respected to it's true value.

The general public has no idea what the job entails, physically, mentally and psychologically. The number of paperwork and bureaucracy is mad. This is why though I am in support of freeing their time and commitment to do what is more complex and are trained for rather than focusing on the mundane every common tasks.

A new patient is referred with symptoms of MS. Never ever appropriate to be seen at first appointment by a PA. Consultants only or Junior Doctor whose specialised. 2 years down the line, the patients is seen every 6 months to check on progression of the disease, symptoms, side effects of medication, or discuss social issues such as finances, social care and need to be sign posted to the right agency...that would be a waste of consultant appointment and a PA review is totally appropriate. If the patient has deteriorated beyond expectation, suddenly don't do so well on their meds, is experiencing new symptoms or has now co-morbidies, they should then be reviewed by a doctor.

A junior doctor wouldn't be appropriate for the initial MS appointment at all. A PA review wouldn't be appropriate for many patients between consultant neurologist appointments either. What do they do about the drug treatment many patients will be on for example? At the moment patients would be seen by specialist MS nurses who coordinate their care with other health care professionals as necessary.

Oliviant · 06/12/2023 17:17

I am a consultant psychiatrist. Your supervision and on call support arrangements don’t sound great.

A locum like you would be snapped up at my Trust.

I am in awe of junior doctors who navigate the system with kids. When I did my MRCPsych, it was the colleagues with young children who kept failing. They simply didn’t have time to revise. I had the luxury of time. I was able to pass my exams and become a consultant at 30. Before I had kids. That would be impossible for someone with children.

I have huge admiration and sympathy for trainee doctors who have kids and do training. With the exams and oncalls. Even part-time is tough as you have to do the same stuff for your portfolios. I look at my juniors with children and there is still so little understanding in the system. Last-minute rotas, long distances to travel, no consideration at all for family life. It was hard enough for me without children.

I think it’s appalling you are being replaced by a PA. I hope the BMA fights this one to the end.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 17:13

Ascubudr · 06/12/2023 17:09

This is how it used to be. I am old enough to remember the 2002 contract coming in . Managers had massively underestimated how many hours we did, most of us ended u on band 3.

Described here
https://www.juniordoctorfinance.co.uk/what-is-junior-doctor-pay-banding/#:~:text=The%20%E2%80%9Cold%E2%80%9D%202002%20contract,%2C%20Scotland%20or%20Northern%20Ireland).

It’s the logical way to structure things! It’s like locum shifts being significantly better paid OOH - if you want someone to do something a bit crap, you have to compensate them or they have no incentive to do it.

coffeeaddict77 · 06/12/2023 17:12

It is very worrying how much doctors are suddenly being replaced by less qualified staff. I think it is only matter of time before things starts to go horribly wrong and they try to employ doctors again only to find they have gone to Australia or have stopped practicing as doctors altogether.

Sonhash · 06/12/2023 17:11

Yes I would agree that doctors and nurses should be included in the ARRS funding

Ascubudr · 06/12/2023 17:09

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 17:01

I don’t see why it couldn’t happen! Just because things are bad in multiple sectors doesn’t mean we have to continue down that path for reasons of fairness. I’d be supportive of anyone in any role lobbying for increased pay for antisocial hours. AFAIK this is how doctors are paid in Australia.

This is how it used to be. I am old enough to remember the 2002 contract coming in . Managers had massively underestimated how many hours we did, most of us ended u on band 3.

Described here
https://www.juniordoctorfinance.co.uk/what-is-junior-doctor-pay-banding/#:~:text=The%20%E2%80%9Cold%E2%80%9D%202002%20contract,%2C%20Scotland%20or%20Northern%20Ireland).

Spacecowboys · 06/12/2023 17:07

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 17:01

I don’t see why it couldn’t happen! Just because things are bad in multiple sectors doesn’t mean we have to continue down that path for reasons of fairness. I’d be supportive of anyone in any role lobbying for increased pay for antisocial hours. AFAIK this is how doctors are paid in Australia.

Really? In a sector where it takes about 6-8 months to get an agreement for more than a 2% pay rise. Decreasing enhancements I can see happening, not increasing them. We already have a disparity according to banding.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 17:01

Spacecowboys · 06/12/2023 16:58

That won’t happen though, especially when other sectors get no uplift in pay for weekends etc, even those on minimum wage ( which is shocking of course). I still remember their plan to remove enhancements when agenda for change came in, until they realised it would be a large pay cut for most nurses.

I don’t see why it couldn’t happen! Just because things are bad in multiple sectors doesn’t mean we have to continue down that path for reasons of fairness. I’d be supportive of anyone in any role lobbying for increased pay for antisocial hours. AFAIK this is how doctors are paid in Australia.

BadSkiingMum · 06/12/2023 16:59

@prawncocktailskips
Thanks, unfortunately I think this pattern is being seen across public sector roles. But it is very rare to have one professional grouping speak out in support of another, or even notice what is happening.

Ultimately it is the people at the bottom of the pyramid who will be replaced by non-human workers i.e. refuse collectors might be replaced by an intelligent robotic arm that can collect the bin as long as it’s placed in a specific spot.

But the prospects don’t look promising for traditional professions either. Even the widespread availability of medical information online has eroded respect for doctors - not saying that’s right, but it’s quite likely the case. Remote surgery has implications for that profession. I have also heard of moves to generate giant legal databases, with every possible permutation of legal opinion, that will dramatically reduce the need for legal staff. And of course AI is the next big problem!

Perhaps a life of health and leisure beckons? But I suspect there will be some very painful changes first.

Spacecowboys · 06/12/2023 16:58

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:53

Yes, so paying those shifts more will attract more people to do them who won’t mind them as much as you! We should pay more for antisocial hours to attract people to those shifts. This would allow you to do less of them, and someone else to do more but in return for more money!

That won’t happen though, especially when other sectors get no uplift in pay for weekends etc, even those on minimum wage ( which is shocking of course). I still remember their plan to remove enhancements when agenda for change came in, until they realised it would be a large pay cut for most nurses.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:53

Spacecowboys · 06/12/2023 16:50

I only want to do the out of hours/ unsocial hours I have to do, no more. A lot of our team are the same. So I wouldn’t be prepared to do more so someone else could do less, everyone’s different. The shifts you describe are the norm for me and our team. Ive never gotten used to night shifts. Headaches and nausea are the norm whilst I’m on them.

Yes, so paying those shifts more will attract more people to do them who won’t mind them as much as you! We should pay more for antisocial hours to attract people to those shifts. This would allow you to do less of them, and someone else to do more but in return for more money!

Spacecowboys · 06/12/2023 16:50

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:07

I think most women would be happy to do more OOH if they got paid enough to cover the childcare for it. That is the crux of the matter. Doctors used to be paid enough to have full time nannies- those days are sadly long gone. I’ve never understood why we don’t get a significant uplift for OOH - then those who are willing to take those shifts (and some people love them!) get paid their worth for them.

how much would someone have to pay you to work random 12h days, one week of nights a month and 1 in 2 or 3 weekends?

I only want to do the out of hours/ unsocial hours I have to do, no more. A lot of our team are the same. So I wouldn’t be prepared to do more so someone else could do less, everyone’s different. The shifts you describe are the norm for me and our team. Ive never gotten used to night shifts. Headaches and nausea are the norm whilst I’m on them.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:41

Ascubudr · 06/12/2023 16:40

Interestingly that is equivalent to my £25,000 in Y2K and probably what they are worth.

Agreed! I think that would be a fair salary for an FY1.

Swipe left for the next trending thread