Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so hurt to have been replaced by a Physician's Associate?

457 replies

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 09:40

I'm a junior doctor who 'specialises' in psychiatry. Due to having a young family, entering training is not the right thing for me to do currently. For those who do not know much about the training pathways, these tend to involve moving around a lot, a fairly high out-of-hour burden, keeping a portfolio and revising for exams. I just can't make this work around my family, my husband's job (involves a lot of travel) and the childcare I have access to.

For the last few years, I've worked as a locum at my local psychiatric hospital. I've worked pretty much full time and gone well above my designated hours and work load. In particular, in addition to my usual responsibilities, I've taken on the physical health needs for a lot of patients and (I think!) made some real progress. This is something that can get overlooked in psychiatry.

I am perfectly happy with my pay but for context, I am not one of the mega-rich locum doctors the newspapers talk of. I earn around £23/hour and obviously have no sick pay or AL. Several times I've been approached about having a full time non-locum role for around £32k. I've always been really enthusiastic about this but there has never been the funding.

Anyway, I've recently been told that they don't need me anymore as they have a new physician's associate. I'm really sad and hurt. I've gone above and beyond for this job. I can't understand how there is funding for a PA who will earn more than I would have done and can't do a lot of what I can do. They won't be able to prescribe (I spend a lot of time prescribing and dealing with very heavy duty psychiatric medications) or detain patients (I perform emergency detentions under the MHA not infrequently). They won't have the same medical background I have to manage the physical health of the patients. I just can't really understand what they can do that I can't!

This isn't a problem unique to me. Lots of junior doctors locum not because they want lots of money (as the media might tell you) but because they can't make training work - or, in many cases, because there aren't enough training positions at all! Many of these positions are now being replaced by PAs. I know people who have left medicine because of it and now, I think I might have to too.

AIBU to be so hurt and sad and think it's just not fair?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
ScrantonDunderMifflin · 07/12/2023 17:47

'get rid of them' - as if they're some sort of enemy. There are lots of hard working passionate PAs.
I did really well at school and uni, I stupidly didn't go into medicine straight after school but did science and got a really good science job. Every day I have been regretting not going into medicine after school because I can't afford it now that I have a mortgage, family etc.
PA is a great option for people like me but is it really worth it given all the abuse?

Harleyband · 07/12/2023 17:46

This has been going on for a long time in the US- many practices are covered wholly by NPs or PAs. Nobody sees the need to invest in training more doctors when you can hire a (slightly) cheaper PA. Many young people are actually choosing PA school over medical school- it's cheaper, faster and allows for career switching with ease (no need to train in one specialty for years). Many of the PAs I work with are excellent but they do not have the breadth of knowledge to recognize and manage unusual situations. In the end you get what you pay for.

Moll2020 · 07/12/2023 17:46

It’s very unfair, my son in law is a junior doctor and is sitting his exam to get onto the training pathway. He has sat it once and is in the top 20% but can’t find a placement as if you don’t score in the top 10% there is nothing as the roles are being filled by PAs.

Sidge · 07/12/2023 17:45

I understand how you feel.

I work in primary care. We have 2 PAs now in our surgery. As lovely as they are, they just don’t have the training or experience that doctors do. Or even nurses - I’m a very experienced nurse practitioner, with qualifications up the ying yang. I train doctors in some areas and am now expected to “train” PAs, as my role is eroded.

More of my work, in which I have 25 years experience, is being taken from me and given to PAs, HCAs and pharmacy technicians. I do wonder why I spent so many years studying and training and learning sometimes.

Oh and the PAs start on 8 grand a year more than I’m on, just to rub salt in the wound!

SawX · 07/12/2023 17:42

Everyone who is concerned about this (which should be everyone who uses the NHS) please ask to know exactly what kind of practitioner you're seeing at an appointment, and refuse to see a PA. If patients, nurses, and real doctors all push back, we might get rid of them.

BadSkiingMum · 07/12/2023 17:39

Locutus2000 · 07/12/2023 12:46

It seems that as long as you can get a consultant on the phone, this counts as adequate supervision.

Oh well, we're all a Physician Associate now then!

FT2015 · 07/12/2023 17:37

please speak to the BMA about this if you are a member. Also look at med twitter - there has been a lot of backlash about exactly your situation

ScrantonDunderMifflin · 07/12/2023 17:37

Creeping into NHS Scotland, seriously...
There are plenty of them in Scotland already.

prawncocktailskips · 07/12/2023 13:01

Finteq · 07/12/2023 12:37

One of the most eye opening things I've ever read was an extract from the book-

Rich dad,poor dad.

It's about financial literacy.

The main character wants to learn how to make money so starts working for a local entrepreneur- so he can learn his secrets.

He gets worked like a dog. Working late,puts it all in,and basically gets treated like crap. Doing manual work. Working extra days,weekends etc. He is exhausted but keeps going back he wants to learn from the businessman.

And it's only when he says he's gonna leave that he's told- if he had carried on coming into work the business man would have sacked him. And refused to mentor him.

You learn- the business man extracts all the work he can from his employees for the least amount of payment and cares not a jot for their wellbeing, and no one ever made cash by working for someone else.

The way to make cash is not by being an employee- but being the boss- but anyway that's not really relevant to this thread.

But basically the NHS's job is to get as much labour they can for the least amount of cash- they don't care about your wellbeing, or how hard you've worked.

You keep repeating how hard you've worked- they don't care.

The relationships you've made- they don't care

How much the Consultants like you- they don't make the decisions.

If the trust can do the job for less,as a locum with no employment rights you are the first to go.

You need to stop caring about propping up the NHS and take care of yourself- because trust me the NHS does not care one jot.

Where I work. The government give us cash to help recruit. But we aren't allowed to spend it on doctors, only PA'S,pharmacists,physios- and basically not who the patients actually want to see. It's all driven by the government.

Take care of yourself.

Thanks @Finteq. Some important lessons and things to think about. It is so tough because we never meet those who make the decisions about our employment, where we work, what time off we get etc. They don’t know or care about our individual circumstances and work ethic. But who we do see is the patient who won’t get to go home to their families if we don’t skip lunch to do their discharge or the colleague who will miss an important event if we don’t cover their shift or the consultant who already stays late and will stay even later if we insist on leaving on time with our jobs half done. These people do care about how hard we work but have zero power over our conditions. Not unique to the NHS I assume but a bit sad all the same, and it’s tough to look after yourself first as the people you have to face are not your employers but patients and relatives and colleagues who rely on you and will be directly and typically immediately affected if you don’t go the extra mile…

OP posts:
Locutus2000 · 07/12/2023 12:46

BadSkiingMum · 07/12/2023 12:09

Just writing from a patient perspective I find that vacancy a bit alarming because it is situated in the 'Hospital at home' setup in Glasgow. I thought that PAs were supposed to be working in a hospital or primary care setting, with a doctor close at hand. How is that the case if they are going out on the road, visiting people at home?

It seems that as long as you can get a consultant on the phone, this counts as adequate supervision.

Finteq · 07/12/2023 12:37

prawncocktailskips · 07/12/2023 11:05

I suppose you’re right but I think most of us working in the NHS are emotionally invested. If we weren’t we’d go and find better conditions doing something else. The NHS relies an awful lot on our good will to make up for staffing and resource shortages. It does hurt when we all have not infrequent reminders that to them, we are just a number whereas to us, our careers are our vocations. This is an extreme example but I’m sure every doctor, nurse, HCA, porter, physio, PA and more on this thread will have had times when they’ve felt very unvalued at work.

One of the most eye opening things I've ever read was an extract from the book-

Rich dad,poor dad.

It's about financial literacy.

The main character wants to learn how to make money so starts working for a local entrepreneur- so he can learn his secrets.

He gets worked like a dog. Working late,puts it all in,and basically gets treated like crap. Doing manual work. Working extra days,weekends etc. He is exhausted but keeps going back he wants to learn from the businessman.

And it's only when he says he's gonna leave that he's told- if he had carried on coming into work the business man would have sacked him. And refused to mentor him.

You learn- the business man extracts all the work he can from his employees for the least amount of payment and cares not a jot for their wellbeing, and no one ever made cash by working for someone else.

The way to make cash is not by being an employee- but being the boss- but anyway that's not really relevant to this thread.

But basically the NHS's job is to get as much labour they can for the least amount of cash- they don't care about your wellbeing, or how hard you've worked.

You keep repeating how hard you've worked- they don't care.

The relationships you've made- they don't care

How much the Consultants like you- they don't make the decisions.

If the trust can do the job for less,as a locum with no employment rights you are the first to go.

You need to stop caring about propping up the NHS and take care of yourself- because trust me the NHS does not care one jot.

Where I work. The government give us cash to help recruit. But we aren't allowed to spend it on doctors, only PA'S,pharmacists,physios- and basically not who the patients actually want to see. It's all driven by the government.

Take care of yourself.

Vettrianofan · 07/12/2023 12:33

BadSkiingMum · 07/12/2023 12:09

Just writing from a patient perspective I find that vacancy a bit alarming because it is situated in the 'Hospital at home' setup in Glasgow. I thought that PAs were supposed to be working in a hospital or primary care setting, with a doctor close at hand. How is that the case if they are going out on the road, visiting people at home?

All it's doing is cheapening the healthcare service.

Vettrianofan · 07/12/2023 12:30

BadSkiingMum · 07/12/2023 12:09

Just writing from a patient perspective I find that vacancy a bit alarming because it is situated in the 'Hospital at home' setup in Glasgow. I thought that PAs were supposed to be working in a hospital or primary care setting, with a doctor close at hand. How is that the case if they are going out on the road, visiting people at home?

Worrying isn't it? Glad I posted about NHS Scotland otherwise another poster would not have noticed that advert.

Peablockfeathers · 07/12/2023 12:09

YireosDodeAver · 07/12/2023 10:44

Yabu to be "hurt" - employers owe you nothing except the contractual pay as agreed, and their legal obligations to employment law. If you are 'hurt' you are too emotionally invested.

Take your skills to a role where they are wanted. There's no shame in being a staff-grade doctor off the training-track to consultancy if that's what works for you. If that particular employer would rather have a P.A. than a locum then that's their choice and won't have been based on emotions or any other personal reason.

The point is they probably wouldn't rather have a PA than a doctor but are being strong armed into it by a different pot of funding. There's nothing a PA can offer that a JD can't, and with the chronic shortages up the chain we should be investing in doctors. If you're a trust with a squeezed budget though of course if you're offered 'free' money over having to dip into your existing funding to fill a role then it doesn't take a genius to realise the majority will do this. Its awful, and it's fine for highly qualified professionals to be disgusted at the erosion of their profession and the direction its heading. Scores of doctors are leaving with is an issue, taking their skills to somewhere they're actually valued as you say; but where does that leave patients? With sub standard care from a lesser qualified workforce, sounds really aspirational.

BadSkiingMum · 07/12/2023 12:09

Locutus2000 · 07/12/2023 09:55

Just writing from a patient perspective I find that vacancy a bit alarming because it is situated in the 'Hospital at home' setup in Glasgow. I thought that PAs were supposed to be working in a hospital or primary care setting, with a doctor close at hand. How is that the case if they are going out on the road, visiting people at home?

prawncocktailskips · 07/12/2023 11:54

@Spacecowboys this has been the case in every department I’ve worked in and my med school friends working around the country all report the same sadly. Glad it’s not the case where you work though - gives me a bit of hope that things are better somewhere out there! Funnily enough, my male med school peers experience this far less … Hmm

OP posts:
Spacecowboys · 07/12/2023 11:25

prawncocktailskips · 07/12/2023 10:10

Agree. Jobs that frequently fall on junior doctors in my experience (because there is no one to do them and junior doctors can't really say no for reasons I've touched on above) include fixing printers, tracking down equipment and paperwork over the hospital, running blood tests to labs when the system to send them is broken, staying on the phone to GP surgeries / care homes etc. for hours to try and find out basic information about a patient, re-stocking equipment cupboards, arranging translators, running discharge letters to pharmacy, running investigation forms to the correct location etc. Any pushback usually involves a smarmy comment about the doctor in question thinking they are 'too good' for such a job. I don't think I'm 'too good' for anything, but if there is 1 doctor for 60 patients I don't think it's a good idea to have that doctor going on frequent 15 minute round trips to run errands that anyone could do around the hospital. Having people to do those jobs in hospital would make such a difference. Even just someone to answer the phone! Any HCP on this thread will know how difficult it is to contact another ward for information because there is no one available to answer the phones (likewise, many relatives will also know this pain!). Even better would be having the staff to do bloods and ECGs. I've never worked anywhere with a functioning phlebotomy service...

This doesn’t sound right. I am an acp and don’t do any of those jobs you have listed there, other people do them. I think when you look back on this in the future , you will realise you have probably had a lucky escape.

prawncocktailskips · 07/12/2023 11:05

YireosDodeAver · 07/12/2023 10:44

Yabu to be "hurt" - employers owe you nothing except the contractual pay as agreed, and their legal obligations to employment law. If you are 'hurt' you are too emotionally invested.

Take your skills to a role where they are wanted. There's no shame in being a staff-grade doctor off the training-track to consultancy if that's what works for you. If that particular employer would rather have a P.A. than a locum then that's their choice and won't have been based on emotions or any other personal reason.

I suppose you’re right but I think most of us working in the NHS are emotionally invested. If we weren’t we’d go and find better conditions doing something else. The NHS relies an awful lot on our good will to make up for staffing and resource shortages. It does hurt when we all have not infrequent reminders that to them, we are just a number whereas to us, our careers are our vocations. This is an extreme example but I’m sure every doctor, nurse, HCA, porter, physio, PA and more on this thread will have had times when they’ve felt very unvalued at work.

OP posts:
Vettrianofan · 07/12/2023 11:03

Locutus2000 · 07/12/2023 09:55

Just goes to show that they are now creeping into NHS Scotland 👀 thanks for searching. I tried looking on NHS Scotland recruitment pages and couldn't see any. As another poster rightly said it may be that all posts have been filled.

YireosDodeAver · 07/12/2023 10:44

Yabu to be "hurt" - employers owe you nothing except the contractual pay as agreed, and their legal obligations to employment law. If you are 'hurt' you are too emotionally invested.

Take your skills to a role where they are wanted. There's no shame in being a staff-grade doctor off the training-track to consultancy if that's what works for you. If that particular employer would rather have a P.A. than a locum then that's their choice and won't have been based on emotions or any other personal reason.

prawncocktailskips · 07/12/2023 10:10

Peablockfeathers · 07/12/2023 10:03

There are ward and other jobs that PAs could and should safely do but there's push back against that because the argument is that its too boring, and if you have a member of staff on the team who doesn't rotate it's easier to train them for some of the more interesting stuff than support a new doctor every 6 months. They were called physican assistants previously afterall. There is a role for someone to do certain tasks, but I don't think personally PAs are it on the pay band they're at. A hybrid HCA with administrative duties as part of the role or something with better pay would be better. There's a very clear agenda at play though.

Agree. Jobs that frequently fall on junior doctors in my experience (because there is no one to do them and junior doctors can't really say no for reasons I've touched on above) include fixing printers, tracking down equipment and paperwork over the hospital, running blood tests to labs when the system to send them is broken, staying on the phone to GP surgeries / care homes etc. for hours to try and find out basic information about a patient, re-stocking equipment cupboards, arranging translators, running discharge letters to pharmacy, running investigation forms to the correct location etc. Any pushback usually involves a smarmy comment about the doctor in question thinking they are 'too good' for such a job. I don't think I'm 'too good' for anything, but if there is 1 doctor for 60 patients I don't think it's a good idea to have that doctor going on frequent 15 minute round trips to run errands that anyone could do around the hospital. Having people to do those jobs in hospital would make such a difference. Even just someone to answer the phone! Any HCP on this thread will know how difficult it is to contact another ward for information because there is no one available to answer the phones (likewise, many relatives will also know this pain!). Even better would be having the staff to do bloods and ECGs. I've never worked anywhere with a functioning phlebotomy service...

OP posts:
Peablockfeathers · 07/12/2023 10:08

ScrantonDunderMifflin · 06/12/2023 18:25

Quite disheartening reading all these comments about PAs but oh well.
Saw multiple people celebrating the fact they 'aren't employed in Scotland' - sorry to disappoint but there are lots of PAs working in Scotland.

The best thing for PAs would be to fight for a clear scope to be agreed and to be regulated, and to support their doctor colleagues in fighting for better pay. Sorry to say i doubt there'll be much support by many whilst the scope keeps creeping and whilst a PA with less responsibility, less knowledge, working more social hours, who doesn't have to rotate and gets paid more than a doctor and that's fair enough. The PA role is definitely morphing in many trusts and some are working well beyond their scope. There's nothing a PA offers that a doctor can't, but because funding is coming from a different pot settings admist a purposefully shortage of training posts etc settings are strong armed into employing PAs.

This isn't personal towards individual PAs, and it's unfortunate that many universities are being purposefully misleading in their recruitment material that makes people think the role is something it shouldn't be; but it's not unfair or sad that people are rightfully highlighting the issues with this.

Peablockfeathers · 07/12/2023 10:03

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 06/12/2023 18:43

I'm genuinely unclear on what place there is for PAs. What place is there for them when we already have Advanced Nurse Practitioners who can do everything that a PA can do and more ie prescribe. ANPs also have years of experience behind them. I'm really not sure why this additional role has been introduced when we already have HCPs who can fulfil the PA role and responsibilities and more.

There are ward and other jobs that PAs could and should safely do but there's push back against that because the argument is that its too boring, and if you have a member of staff on the team who doesn't rotate it's easier to train them for some of the more interesting stuff than support a new doctor every 6 months. They were called physican assistants previously afterall. There is a role for someone to do certain tasks, but I don't think personally PAs are it on the pay band they're at. A hybrid HCA with administrative duties as part of the role or something with better pay would be better. There's a very clear agenda at play though.

prawncocktailskips · 07/12/2023 10:02

Villagetoraiseachild · 06/12/2023 23:11

Hopefully, down the line you will be grateful for them having liberated you.
100% it's not personal, its a business decision. You sound like a fabulous human being. Please take the opportunity to reflect on how else you can experience career fulfillment at an appropriate pay grade that fits with sustaining a family life and your own health and happiness.
(Friend works in similar role in Germany but different system there).

Thank you for being so kind, much appreciated.

OP posts: