Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so hurt to have been replaced by a Physician's Associate?

457 replies

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 09:40

I'm a junior doctor who 'specialises' in psychiatry. Due to having a young family, entering training is not the right thing for me to do currently. For those who do not know much about the training pathways, these tend to involve moving around a lot, a fairly high out-of-hour burden, keeping a portfolio and revising for exams. I just can't make this work around my family, my husband's job (involves a lot of travel) and the childcare I have access to.

For the last few years, I've worked as a locum at my local psychiatric hospital. I've worked pretty much full time and gone well above my designated hours and work load. In particular, in addition to my usual responsibilities, I've taken on the physical health needs for a lot of patients and (I think!) made some real progress. This is something that can get overlooked in psychiatry.

I am perfectly happy with my pay but for context, I am not one of the mega-rich locum doctors the newspapers talk of. I earn around £23/hour and obviously have no sick pay or AL. Several times I've been approached about having a full time non-locum role for around £32k. I've always been really enthusiastic about this but there has never been the funding.

Anyway, I've recently been told that they don't need me anymore as they have a new physician's associate. I'm really sad and hurt. I've gone above and beyond for this job. I can't understand how there is funding for a PA who will earn more than I would have done and can't do a lot of what I can do. They won't be able to prescribe (I spend a lot of time prescribing and dealing with very heavy duty psychiatric medications) or detain patients (I perform emergency detentions under the MHA not infrequently). They won't have the same medical background I have to manage the physical health of the patients. I just can't really understand what they can do that I can't!

This isn't a problem unique to me. Lots of junior doctors locum not because they want lots of money (as the media might tell you) but because they can't make training work - or, in many cases, because there aren't enough training positions at all! Many of these positions are now being replaced by PAs. I know people who have left medicine because of it and now, I think I might have to too.

AIBU to be so hurt and sad and think it's just not fair?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
prawncocktailskips · 17/12/2023 22:28

@Nearlythere80 Exactly. Widening participation is a totally different issue and not unique to medicine. I think all students good enough to do medicine should have the support and financial means to get there and would support any policy to achieve that. I also think all patients deserve the best doctor possible and no one has the right to be a doctor. I think it's incredibly sad and unfair that there are so many out there who would make excellent doctors but never got the opportunity due to their background. However, I do not believe that this means they are entitled to play doctor without a medical degree to make things fair. As I said, the priority is always, always, always the patients and it would also be incredibly unfair to support any policy that will lead to worse healthcare for poorer patients.

Getting bogged down in doctor privilege helps nothing in this situation. Of course private school helps, as does tutoring, as does having doctor relatives and not having to work throughout university. We all know that and we acknowledge it where relevant, but I really can't see how it is when it comes to PAs as I really can't agree that PAs should exist as a non-traditional route into medicine.

OP posts:
Salacia · 17/12/2023 22:20

Private education definitely gives you a leg up at interview and getting into medical school (as somebody who interviews for my local medical school and knows a bit about admissions stats etc). A lot of medical schools are doing great work in widening access but there’s still a long way to go (not that I’d encourage anybody from any background into medicine in the UK).

I’m not convinced it makes much difference in terms of getting through the actual medical course and professional exams however. Anecdotally a lot of my peers from a private background struggled a little with the self study nature of medicine. Certainly the majority of those who didn’t make it to the end of the degree in my cohort came from the more privileged end of the spectrum. I believe the big decider in professional exams is if a candidate studied at a UK medical school or abroad (presumably due to familiarity with exam styles).

Nearlythere80 · 17/12/2023 22:15

Let's not get distracted here. Lack of diversity in current doctors is not the reason for the overall number of doctors.

Coi: posh public school educated white female doctor. None of those features have stopped me from working hard and doing, frankly, a hard job really well.

Cranb3rryF122 · 17/12/2023 22:12

“They are still fab doctors and I think it's pretty impossible to be tutored through interviews and medical school.”

Oh come on let’s be honest that’s why people pay for private because their dc get the tutoring on top of an elite education. And if mummy and daddy were doctors their offspring will be getting interview tutoring the like of which others won’t ever have access to. Doesn’t mean others would make lesser doctors.

prawncocktailskips · 17/12/2023 20:43

Wow, glad to see people still commenting.

@Possimpible I don't pass judgement on someone's intelligence by their spelling. I know lots of very smart people with dyslexia, and plenty more without who are liable to making spelling mistakes, particularly at the end of an 80 hour week ... I think @Nearlythere80 is making very good points. Of course it's not the case that any given doctor is more intelligent than any given PA. Of course doctors are as capable as anyone else of saying and doing silly things. However, it is also the case that every doctor has had to pass pretty rigorous exams. You can't coast your way through medical school. Widening participation is very important and something medical schools are increasingly aware of. However, IMO the focus should be on ensuring all capable students have an equal chance of getting into and through medical school rather than in reducing the academic requirements to be a doctor. It's not fair for the public to accept lesser healthcare to make up for elitism in medical school, and no one has the god given right to be a doctor / doctor figure at the expense of their patients. I'm very willing to hear and learn about the roles of PAs in the NHS and where they might be useful. I'm more uneasy when people's arguments involve the fact they weren't able to go to medical school. Being a doctor isn't a right. It's a massive responsibility, and fitness to practice and accepting our limitations is drummed into us from day one. By the way, I was state educated. It's true that a higher proportion than average of my cohort were privately educated. They are still fab doctors and I think it's pretty impossible to be tutored through interviews and medical school. There's an awful lot of differences between the 'haves' and 'have-nots' in this country - ensuring everyone has access to doctors who have met rigorous academic standards seems pretty important to me.

@mumsneedwine you sound like such a lovely supportive mum, and thanks for being so lovely and supportive on my thread. I've really appreciated all of your comments.

@Hayliebells good point. I earn by far the least of all my friends (despite the best A-levels and longest most rigorous degree). Funnily enough, there are some who really refuse to believe how much I earn and have always insisted I must be presenting figures without overtime or that I can't really work the hours I claim!

OP posts:
mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 20:39

@SD1978 but doctors HAVE to rotate. It's not a choice they make. If this is the issue then let doctors stay in one place once finished foundation. Problem sorted. No need for PA.

SD1978 · 17/12/2023 20:32

There is more reliability though in a contracted HCW than a locum. A locum has no commitment (theoretically) and can leave, pick hours, not turn up (theoretically) as they wish. So I guess the hospital has more reliability with a PA than a locum junior Dr, from their perspective

mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 20:11

@Possimpible I'll leave this here for you.

To be so hurt to have been replaced by a Physician's Associate?
Nearlythere80 · 17/12/2023 20:10

Yes elitism and arrogance are common retorts to statements about entirely feasible differences between groups. Those sorts of remarks are why people feel uncomfortable even raising it.
It's just not plausible to be able to pass through medical school and then post-graduate training (whilst working) and be less than intelligent by any particular measure.

mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 20:09

And here we go. Doctor bashing is as common as teacher bashing.
My family grew up in a 2 bed council flat. I was FSM. My parents left school at 15 (my husbands at 14). Because they had to work for money.
Elistist ? Really. Idiot.

Possimpible · 17/12/2023 20:07

mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 14:50

@Cranb3rryF122 you don't know, that's the problem. Know the only profession that didn't get a colour for their scrubs ? Yup, doctors.

This just isn't true. Maybe in your trust but in mine doctors/surgeons are in light blue, med students in black, A&E consultants in green. I'm a different profession and we have to provide our own scrubs.

Possimpible · 17/12/2023 20:05

Nearlythere80 · 17/12/2023 14:36

It's suprised me how much interest this thread has gathered. I'd believed that the public hate doctors now, and think we are entitled, elitist, greedy and paradoxically stupid/failing to do or know things deliberately that someone else would do much better and cheaper and more happily.

We are stuck in this horrible situation where we don't have enough doctors (see our numbers compared to healthcare systems we like to imagine we are comparable to), beds or other staff, and whereby it has become totally unacceptable to say that the reason for that is because people don't want to pay for what quality healthcare really costs.

The PA vs junior dr situation has arisen due to our collective fear of articulating the difference between people who apply to med school and people who seek alternative routes to provision of clinical care. The difference, brace yourself, is educational attainment, in terms of academic achievement and application of hard work throughout secondary school age. Then you end up with a cohort of people who are better able to assimilate large volumes of information, deal with pattern recognition more swiftly, and cope with missing information more accurately. We are so aghast at the idea of saying that (in general) doctors are more intelligent and this is a good thing, and worthy of better t&c and retention, that we would rather chuck away 'ungrateful' doctors who have had the temerity to attempt a bit of a normal life before the age of 35.

seriously the decline of healthcare in the uk is in a great part due to the 'everyone is sick of experts' anti-elitism that is racing us towards the most basic provision of first aid type healthcare that only

there I've said it

Based on the post, I do think you're elitist tbh. And arrogant. I've worked with lots of doctors who are not that intelligent. Mummy and daddy are doctors and they've put them through private school and tutoring to get into med school. The spelling is shocking - 'steriods' is one that I see a lot!

mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 16:43

@Hayliebells bonkers isn't it ! 5 years, so more than a masters, and earn less than most graduate trainee jobs.
Last night my DD was holding the cardiac bleep in a v large hospital. A&E had over 150 patients and ambulances piling up at the door. She ended up doing a 15 hour shift as so bad and so short staffed. For £15.33 an hour.
She doesn't want to strike and can't afford it, but feels she has no choice, if she is to stay in the UK. It's more than pay now - it's training numbers, PAs and just generally being made to feel like crap. Her seniors sound awesome but many of them are leaving. Australia offering up to £125,000 next year !

Cranb3rryF122 · 17/12/2023 15:32

I’d have more confidence at a GP surgery to demand a doctor. Our GP is well worth waiting 2 weeks for and I can do that without being a pain. However in a busy overstretched ward I would feel awful being difficult. My dd has been in a lot the last 3 years. We generally get doctors I think at ward rounds but it’s when people drop in for interventions and discussions at other times that is a worry.

Has your union thought of doing an information campaign re this as the vast majority of people don’t know?If it was more widely known and people were encouraged to push for doctors and reassured that it’s ok to do so you may get more support.

Nearlythere80 · 17/12/2023 15:22

Hayliebells · 17/12/2023 15:18

A bit off topic but how can a qualified doctor (and one with some experience by the sounds of it, you’re not just fresh out of uni), only earn £32k? And there’s still no money for that it seems! When pay for graduates in sectors like marketing is higher fresh out of uni, and all that’s required is a three year BA(Hons), with no responsibility for anything much, let alone for people’s lives, that’s absolutely mad. Honestly I’d switch career OP, I don’t know much about the alternatives but some PPs have suggested what sound like viable alternatives. We won’t have any doctors left at this rate, or they’ll come from abroad. I know the vast majority do already, but supposedly a big chunk of the population don’t like immigrants much, so I don’t understand why they keep voting for the party that’s engineering this scenario.

Not off topic at all, and exactly why the junior drs are striking next week.

Hayliebells · 17/12/2023 15:18

A bit off topic but how can a qualified doctor (and one with some experience by the sounds of it, you’re not just fresh out of uni), only earn £32k? And there’s still no money for that it seems! When pay for graduates in sectors like marketing is higher fresh out of uni, and all that’s required is a three year BA(Hons), with no responsibility for anything much, let alone for people’s lives, that’s absolutely mad. Honestly I’d switch career OP, I don’t know much about the alternatives but some PPs have suggested what sound like viable alternatives. We won’t have any doctors left at this rate, or they’ll come from abroad. I know the vast majority do already, but supposedly a big chunk of the population don’t like immigrants much, so I don’t understand why they keep voting for the party that’s engineering this scenario.

SawX · 17/12/2023 15:06

Cranb3rryF122 · 17/12/2023 14:55

But who has the confidence to demand to see a doctor when you’ve been waiting to see anybody?

We all should. It's worth waiting another hour to see a real doctor. And if you're desperately ill that another hour would make a difference, it's even more important that you aren't 'treated' by a pretend doctor.

Don't worry that the doctors will think you're difficult or demand. Most of them want PAs gone as well.

Nearlythere80 · 17/12/2023 15:02

Cranb3rryF122 · 17/12/2023 14:45

Are PA the ones in burgundy on wards? How do you know if you’re being treated by one instead of a doctor?

I don’t think the public hate doctors.

Surely part of the problem is the elitist system of applying to med school with privately educated students unfairly represented. Plenty more are capable of a medical degree however there are very few places and hoards of perfectly capable students are turned down.

doctor are not given uniforms.

the uk doesn't want to pay for more doctors in training, whoever fills the places available doesn't make the difference to that

Cranb3rryF122 · 17/12/2023 14:55

But who has the confidence to demand to see a doctor when you’ve been waiting to see anybody?

SawX · 17/12/2023 14:53

Are PA the ones in burgundy on wards? How do you know if you’re being treated by one instead of a doctor?

If they don't start by clearly announcing their role "I'm X, a junior doctor/ registrar / PA" then ask what they are. If they're a PA, ask to see a real doctor.

mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 14:50

@Cranb3rryF122 you don't know, that's the problem. Know the only profession that didn't get a colour for their scrubs ? Yup, doctors.

mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 14:48

@Nearlythere80 perfectly put. My DD went to the local comp, worked incredibly hard to get goods grades and jump through all the hoops to get into Uni. Then 5 years hard slog through Covid. To end up being paid the same as she earned stacking shelves at Waitrose.

She wants to stay, she wants the NHS to work. But she doesn't even know if she'll have a job after F2. Yup, we are going to have unemployed doctors as not enough jobs for them. But hey, let's get more medical school places.

To fix this :
Pay doctors the equivalent of their 2008 pay (not all at once, but have a plan to do so in the next 3-5 years, like Scotland)
Fund enough training places for the number of medical school places so everyone can progress who wants to
Don't increase PAs until we know what they are supposed to be for and they have a defined scope of practice (& do not expect doctors to carry their liability)
Stop rotational training. Why do you need to move every few years. Settle and work at hospitals up to an hour away. Offer more money if some places see less popular. Then doctors could be 'part of the team' too

I say all this as an outsider looking in. I may be completely wrong, but it's all a big mess.

Cranb3rryF122 · 17/12/2023 14:45

Are PA the ones in burgundy on wards? How do you know if you’re being treated by one instead of a doctor?

I don’t think the public hate doctors.

Surely part of the problem is the elitist system of applying to med school with privately educated students unfairly represented. Plenty more are capable of a medical degree however there are very few places and hoards of perfectly capable students are turned down.

Nearlythere80 · 17/12/2023 14:36

It's suprised me how much interest this thread has gathered. I'd believed that the public hate doctors now, and think we are entitled, elitist, greedy and paradoxically stupid/failing to do or know things deliberately that someone else would do much better and cheaper and more happily.

We are stuck in this horrible situation where we don't have enough doctors (see our numbers compared to healthcare systems we like to imagine we are comparable to), beds or other staff, and whereby it has become totally unacceptable to say that the reason for that is because people don't want to pay for what quality healthcare really costs.

The PA vs junior dr situation has arisen due to our collective fear of articulating the difference between people who apply to med school and people who seek alternative routes to provision of clinical care. The difference, brace yourself, is educational attainment, in terms of academic achievement and application of hard work throughout secondary school age. Then you end up with a cohort of people who are better able to assimilate large volumes of information, deal with pattern recognition more swiftly, and cope with missing information more accurately. We are so aghast at the idea of saying that (in general) doctors are more intelligent and this is a good thing, and worthy of better t&c and retention, that we would rather chuck away 'ungrateful' doctors who have had the temerity to attempt a bit of a normal life before the age of 35.

seriously the decline of healthcare in the uk is in a great part due to the 'everyone is sick of experts' anti-elitism that is racing us towards the most basic provision of first aid type healthcare that only

there I've said it

mumsneedwine · 17/12/2023 13:46

@coffeeaddict77 I believe the ST1 told them they would kill the patient if they prescribed as asked. PA went off in a huff to consultant who gave the correct drug. ST1 never even spoken to to say well done/thank you/sorry.

It seems the 'be kind' and 'one team' mantra doesn't apply to doctors. I don't understand why.

Swipe left for the next trending thread