Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so hurt to have been replaced by a Physician's Associate?

457 replies

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 09:40

I'm a junior doctor who 'specialises' in psychiatry. Due to having a young family, entering training is not the right thing for me to do currently. For those who do not know much about the training pathways, these tend to involve moving around a lot, a fairly high out-of-hour burden, keeping a portfolio and revising for exams. I just can't make this work around my family, my husband's job (involves a lot of travel) and the childcare I have access to.

For the last few years, I've worked as a locum at my local psychiatric hospital. I've worked pretty much full time and gone well above my designated hours and work load. In particular, in addition to my usual responsibilities, I've taken on the physical health needs for a lot of patients and (I think!) made some real progress. This is something that can get overlooked in psychiatry.

I am perfectly happy with my pay but for context, I am not one of the mega-rich locum doctors the newspapers talk of. I earn around £23/hour and obviously have no sick pay or AL. Several times I've been approached about having a full time non-locum role for around £32k. I've always been really enthusiastic about this but there has never been the funding.

Anyway, I've recently been told that they don't need me anymore as they have a new physician's associate. I'm really sad and hurt. I've gone above and beyond for this job. I can't understand how there is funding for a PA who will earn more than I would have done and can't do a lot of what I can do. They won't be able to prescribe (I spend a lot of time prescribing and dealing with very heavy duty psychiatric medications) or detain patients (I perform emergency detentions under the MHA not infrequently). They won't have the same medical background I have to manage the physical health of the patients. I just can't really understand what they can do that I can't!

This isn't a problem unique to me. Lots of junior doctors locum not because they want lots of money (as the media might tell you) but because they can't make training work - or, in many cases, because there aren't enough training positions at all! Many of these positions are now being replaced by PAs. I know people who have left medicine because of it and now, I think I might have to too.

AIBU to be so hurt and sad and think it's just not fair?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 15:03

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:57

What does having a PA in that situation gain vs a junior doctor?
Some areas, they can't even get the junior doctors. Junior doctors also need a lot of support. Many consultants complain that the just graduate ones are more hard work than many HCAs! Top qualifying doctors go to the top Trusts, so there is a big difference between top graduates and those who just scrap by and where each pick to go in terms of skills, confidence, independence etc...

Another issue is that when you invest your time and money in Junior Doctors, you do with an expectation that they will look for promotions, so you have to start over and over again, wasting more time and money over the years. Band 7 staff are much more likely to remain in their role for much longer so training them is more cost and time efficient.

They are also under Agenda for Change so more time to spend in clinics specifically. Junior doctors need time to further their studies, dedicate time for training to meet the requirements of promotions etc... They can also be fetter used to do evening, nights and weekend shifts.

And more reasons but these are the nain ones.

I’m afraid I don’t understand your point about “not enough junior doctors” when there is so much competition for specialty training, resulting in doctors having to take consecutive F3 years.

Your other point seems to be the fact that we’re rotational. We hate this too. It is not a choice. If rotating is cost ineffective then why make junior doctors do it? You can’t on one hand say it’s essential, and on the other say it’s so bad that it means we’re replacing you with PAs.

I also don’t understand your point on “top doctors”. Are you saying that an average PA is better than a doctor who didn’t get into the top deanery? I would contest that strongly. (And I don’t have a chip here. I personally got into my first choice - and nationally most competitive - deanery).

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:57

What does having a PA in that situation gain vs a junior doctor?
Some areas, they can't even get the junior doctors. Junior doctors also need a lot of support. Many consultants complain that the just graduate ones are more hard work than many HCAs! Top qualifying doctors go to the top Trusts, so there is a big difference between top graduates and those who just scrap by and where each pick to go in terms of skills, confidence, independence etc...

Another issue is that when you invest your time and money in Junior Doctors, you do with an expectation that they will look for promotions, so you have to start over and over again, wasting more time and money over the years. Band 7 staff are much more likely to remain in their role for much longer so training them is more cost and time efficient.

They are also under Agenda for Change so more time to spend in clinics specifically. Junior doctors need time to further their studies, dedicate time for training to meet the requirements of promotions etc... They can also be fetter used to do evening, nights and weekend shifts.

And more reasons but these are the nain ones.

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 06/12/2023 14:57

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 10:13

I totally agree. I also couldn’t make training work as a doctor with a young family, so have left medicine altogether. It’s impossible to get a nursery to do Wednesday and Thursday 8am-10pm (to cover a 9-9shift) then next week have them not go in on Monday and Tuesday, the week after on a Friday from 12pm-midnight… and if the public think you can afford to get a full time live in nanny on a junior doctor’s salary then they are kidding themselves.

People will only wake up when more mistakes start being publicised (as is inevitable!). I just hope we haven’t lost all of our doctors before it’s too late.

Lack of flexible childcare is a massive issue for HCPs. I'm a nurse and am a single mum to my little one. I can't do shift work as early shifts start at 7am, late shifts finish at 9/10pm and there are weekends as well. Neither can I do community as they expect me to do 1 in 3 weekends, which I would be happy to do if there was childcare available. So presently, I'm doing vaccination shifts on the nurse bank, however when these are no longer available (they peak in winter and tail off at the start of the year) then I don't know what I'll do.

What an absolute shame that we're losing knowledgeable, experienced healthcare professionals due to how family unfriendly the NHS is.

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:49

Waiting at 24 is one thing - getting into your early/mid/late 30s and waiting is very different (again, speaking as somebody juggling medical training, albeit in a non-on call specialty alongside ivf)
I totally agree. There's also a difference between deciding to have a child in your late 20s and early early 40s.

Also, many female doctors manage both. Some are even pregnant before finishing medical school! Those with children do get priority in where they are located. Even males whose partner is pregnant. It can be done but with a level of sacrifices that are above what most professions require/expect. That however comes with the choice of career.

Can you do both? Yes. Can you do both easily? No. Can you do both whilst you prioritise you role as a mum and still get the same opportunities? Rarely, unless you are extremely lucky.

TheKeatingFive · 06/12/2023 14:49

Having children frequently changes how we're able to do our jobs, in all kinds of fields. I entered a career with significant foreign travel as part of it. I couldn't do that with kids, it just wasn't possible.

I was able to side step into a slightly different role, but plenty in my industry weren't and ended up falling out of that career or retraining in something else. It's not unusual at all.

I miss what I used to do - I loved it - but it's simply not possible with different commitments. 🤷‍♀️

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 14:46

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:42

They are increasing medical school places, but this year I think it was 3 out of 4 doctors who applied for specialty training did not get a place. So what will that mean?
The problem is that Junior Doctors at the start especially, need a lot of support, guidance and ongoing training. And who dies it? Higher trained doctors and consultants. How can these have time to give if they are spending clinical time seeing patients other less qualified are perfectly capable of doing just because they want to?

This is why managers are required because many clinicians do struggle to understand economies of scale and benefit optimisation. They only see what they do and want to do, and assume it is the best way. OP herself admits she doesn't understand the system. This is why medical students are now taught about the functioning of the NHS and role of management.

It doesn't make sense to pay more for someone to do a task someone cheaper can undertake whilst patients who require their skills wait longer and longer to be seen.

As said, PA's role is often to assess symptoms, review benefits or detriments of the drug regime they are on. Do general checks, consider social needs, gather all information a consultant needs to decide on treatment. PAs with experience can then start to come up with options, follow treatment pathways because for some patients, it will be the same for a large group of patients they see.

I see your point, but did you see my post up thread about what an assistant could do that would really free up doctor’s time?

My own experience with PAs is that they took up valuable consultant training time that I myself would desperately have wanted. Could we not have junior doctors in clinics taking the less complex patients, having vital learning experiences discussing patients with the consultant before and after? What does having a PA in that situation gain vs a junior doctor? They were also often in theatre assisting, while I was left on the ward because I was the only one who could prescribe (which is rather essential when you’re the only doctor for the afternoon post ward round!)

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:42

They are increasing medical school places, but this year I think it was 3 out of 4 doctors who applied for specialty training did not get a place. So what will that mean?
The problem is that Junior Doctors at the start especially, need a lot of support, guidance and ongoing training. And who dies it? Higher trained doctors and consultants. How can these have time to give if they are spending clinical time seeing patients other less qualified are perfectly capable of doing just because they want to?

This is why managers are required because many clinicians do struggle to understand economies of scale and benefit optimisation. They only see what they do and want to do, and assume it is the best way. OP herself admits she doesn't understand the system. This is why medical students are now taught about the functioning of the NHS and role of management.

It doesn't make sense to pay more for someone to do a task someone cheaper can undertake whilst patients who require their skills wait longer and longer to be seen.

As said, PA's role is often to assess symptoms, review benefits or detriments of the drug regime they are on. Do general checks, consider social needs, gather all information a consultant needs to decide on treatment. PAs with experience can then start to come up with options, follow treatment pathways because for some patients, it will be the same for a large group of patients they see.

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 14:39

Yep - doctors can't become PAs. Otherwise I'd be the first in line to do my own job with more supervision and more pay Grin

@vivainsomnia thank you for the apology re. the child comment. It's a very hard pill to swallow that having children really does set one so far back. Not sure how any medical school interview at 17/18 could really select for who will be best for the job. Would be curious to hear thoughts. I was a bright eyed and bushy tailed 17 year old who wanted to change the world. Now I'm an exhausted mother being run down by the NHS who just wants to use the degree I worked so hard to earn without major sacrifice. I really, really, really didn't understand the realities of being a doctor when I applied. No 16 year old gets taken on work experience to shadow the F1. I sat in with a lovely local GP who had come in on his day off to introduce me to some handpicked lovely patients. Night shifts, monopoly employer, exams etc. weren't mentioned. Yes I probably should have done my research but not much I can do about that now! Also, as it's been said in this thread, it's impossible to really understand until you're going through it. I tolerated it far better as an f1 and f2 but I've changed since having my children. I'm (far) more exhausted, more risk averse, far more stressed about getting time off, less time to revise for exams, obvious childcare concerns etc. Perhaps I'm not really meant to be a doctor at all reading this back. I'm not a type A go-getter for sure.

OP posts:
StephenKatona · 06/12/2023 14:39

and nurses unless they do years of extra training. This means both practice nurses and GPs with become scarcer in General Practice too unless ARRS funding can be used to pay their salaries.

Vettrianofan · 06/12/2023 14:37

Mirabai · 06/12/2023 14:28

I’ve no idea I’m English. But a Scottish PA was awarded PA of the year so there must be some roll out somewhere.

Yep with a quick Google search I spotted an article about one at the Golden Jube.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 14:34

Yes! I think because they know many of us would do it 😂

Salacia · 06/12/2023 14:34

@Mirabai - yep! I actually know quite a few doctors who would have considered switching from medicine to PA for the quality of life/no rotations/better pay/no on call/better training which I presume is why…

Mirabai · 06/12/2023 14:31

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 14:30

Amazingly doctors are the only people forbidden from becoming PAs! It’s a specific exclusion on the PA course.

😂 Seriously?

StephenKatona · 06/12/2023 14:31

Apologies if this has already been suggested but have you shared your story with a newspaper? If you can find one to cover your story you could ask them to call for all staff to be funded from the same pot of money by allowing doctors and nurses to be funded by ARRS funds. The 'free labour' that ARRS funding provides is too tempting for hospital trusts. You could start a 10 Downing St petition calling for ARRS funding to include doctors and nurses. I'm currently waiting for one for GPs to be approved by the government and wish I'd included hospital doctors and nurses but can't edit it as far as I know.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 14:30

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:28

It’s fine to say doctors can remain for the most complex stuff but actually we don’t all want to, and in this case, the PA is just taking on my job minus some of the things I did. It’s not freeing up any doctor time! It would be great if we all just wanted to work OOH and see the hardest cases and spend the rest of time over seeing PAs and ANPs but .. we don’t
But it's not just about what doctors want to do but what works best for the NHS. Doctors do currently find themselves doing things that other qualified people can do cheaper and where there is more available workforce. It is much easier to replace a PA than a qualified doctor.

I do apologise for my comment about children, I do appreciate that it is not all about choice of timing, but ultimately, going into Medical Studies is accepting that you're taking a pathway that involves your career being a significant focus of your life if not the main. This is why I understand interviews are so intense as it's not about picking just the cleverest students, but those who have big ambitions and a full understanding of the sacrifices they might have to make.

It does come across that ultimately, you'd be happier with a PA role rather doctor/consultant. Is it something you could consider?

Amazingly doctors are the only people forbidden from becoming PAs! It’s a specific exclusion on the PA course.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 14:29

@Moraxella I’m currently getting all of my babies out of the way before doing something more permanent. But I’ve been doing some writing - mainly about medicine so I might run out of topics soon…! (The pay per hour is exponentially better than medicine).

I wrote this for the times during Covid:
https://unherd.com/2021/01/inside-the-covid-ward/

If anyone has any suggestions of what to do please do let me know. I think we get a bit blinkered about other jobs in medicine, because it’s so different from the private world and you get into it so young! It can feel very daunting to leave.

Inside the Covid ward

All of our patients who die, do so alone. There is nobody to hold their hand. Nobody to comfort them

https://unherd.com/2021/01/inside-the-covid-ward/

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:28

It’s fine to say doctors can remain for the most complex stuff but actually we don’t all want to, and in this case, the PA is just taking on my job minus some of the things I did. It’s not freeing up any doctor time! It would be great if we all just wanted to work OOH and see the hardest cases and spend the rest of time over seeing PAs and ANPs but .. we don’t
But it's not just about what doctors want to do but what works best for the NHS. Doctors do currently find themselves doing things that other qualified people can do cheaper and where there is more available workforce. It is much easier to replace a PA than a qualified doctor.

I do apologise for my comment about children, I do appreciate that it is not all about choice of timing, but ultimately, going into Medical Studies is accepting that you're taking a pathway that involves your career being a significant focus of your life if not the main. This is why I understand interviews are so intense as it's not about picking just the cleverest students, but those who have big ambitions and a full understanding of the sacrifices they might have to make.

It does come across that ultimately, you'd be happier with a PA role rather doctor/consultant. Is it something you could consider?

Mirabai · 06/12/2023 14:28

Vettrianofan · 06/12/2023 14:12

I am not aware of any in Scotland but stand to be corrected of course....

I’ve no idea I’m English. But a Scottish PA was awarded PA of the year so there must be some roll out somewhere.

Moraxella · 06/12/2023 14:23

Out of interest @PlusThyme what job do you do now? (Fellow (potentially ex-) medic)

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 14:22

I agree on maximising doctors’ time, but how are they supposed to rule out a rare diagnosis if they haven’t reviewed the patient themselves and simply sign off the PA’s prescription? How can you take clinically responsibility for a patient you have never interacted with? This is why they do not reduce workload, they just cause two people to do the same review!
The way it works in my hospital is that the doctor will see the patient in outpatient, so will get to know them and the issue. The follow-ups will be undertaken by the PAs. There is normally a 1/2h joint meeting before the start of clinic to briefly discuss patients and likely events. There is then another team meeting after clinics to review each decision, intention, future appointment etc... The whole process has saved the doctor about 6 hours to focus on more complex patients. They will always attend MDTs, undertake investigations, do research, teach etc...

Reviews very often consist of discussion on how treatment is going. Whether it is working, not, nit as it should, side effects etc...all this information is gathered by the PA and shared with the consultant, and together, or at MDT, the doctor suggest another course of treatment.

If this is not how it works, then the protocols are not being followed up as they should.

sheepisheep · 06/12/2023 14:22

Just to add - I'm a GP who ended up in GP because I couldn't face the thought of another 5 years training in my first choice specialty. I'm now working in a bit of a niche GP role within that specialty, and not doing any "traditional" GP at all. I have certainly seen adverts for similar roles for GPs within psychiatry. The benefit here is enormous flexibility once you complete comparatively short training (assuming you're meeting the requirements for GP appraisal and revalidation).

If you were to consider that route, there are some training programs that offer 24 months of GP (so only 12 months in secondary care). LTFT training is easy to get. Good luck, whatever you end up choosing!

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 14:21

@Scirocco I'm not sure how much my employer has really had to do with it to be honest. I've been working with 2-3 consultants who have managed all my shifts and repeatedly asked higher up for a full time post. I've never met 'higher up'. I've probably been really naive about it all. But I guess I've lost nothing as it's been good for the past few years. I just really, really can't get my head around how this all works and who thought a PA would be better.

Yes I've thought about LTFT training but still unsure how I'd make the OOH work with my husband's job currently. I guess we need to sit down and have a proper talk about it all. Just more pressingly than I previously thought. I've been down on medicine for a while though and this just makes me want to leave completely. I can't bear to go back into the realities of exams and night shifts and never getting my annual leave and rotating around and always being new ... It's been really wonderful working longterm with the same team and having people know my name rather than being 'doctor!'. This is why I get particularly annoyed when everyone gets excited about PAs as they don't rotate. I wish we didn't! In pretty much every F1/2 rotation I did I was working on at least 3 different wards and rarely worked with the same team twice. Do people think we actually enjoy that? I had one job where I worked on three different totally unrelated specialties (one on days, one on weekends and one on nights)! Totally unrelated but just having a little rant now Blush

OP posts:
Vettrianofan · 06/12/2023 14:20

I have read about one scooping an award whilst working at the Golden Jubilee in Glasgow so they are out there.... just not in abundance like other parts of the UK.

Scirocco · 06/12/2023 14:13

@prawncocktailskips As a fellow doctor, I hear you. I've had several colleagues in similar situations and it's so frustrating.

You may have considered this already, but have you explored options for doing the training programme flexibly/part-time? Trainees can work LTFT and it might be a way to get a bit more stability and job security? Depending on where you are and what other commitments you and your family have, of course.

A good speciality/staff-grade doctor or clinical fellow with experience in psychiatry can be a very valuable resource for a clinical team, so I'm surprised that your employer has made the decision to go with what sounds like the less cost- and resource-effective option. I suspect there'll be other mental health teams that would be glad to have you on board if they don't!

I'd suggest speaking with the BMA, too. They may not be able to do much as it's a locum post, but if nothing else it lets them know what's going on.

Vettrianofan · 06/12/2023 14:12

Mirabai · 06/12/2023 14:11

Or they’ve already been filled…?

I am not aware of any in Scotland but stand to be corrected of course....

Swipe left for the next trending thread