Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be so hurt to have been replaced by a Physician's Associate?

457 replies

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 09:40

I'm a junior doctor who 'specialises' in psychiatry. Due to having a young family, entering training is not the right thing for me to do currently. For those who do not know much about the training pathways, these tend to involve moving around a lot, a fairly high out-of-hour burden, keeping a portfolio and revising for exams. I just can't make this work around my family, my husband's job (involves a lot of travel) and the childcare I have access to.

For the last few years, I've worked as a locum at my local psychiatric hospital. I've worked pretty much full time and gone well above my designated hours and work load. In particular, in addition to my usual responsibilities, I've taken on the physical health needs for a lot of patients and (I think!) made some real progress. This is something that can get overlooked in psychiatry.

I am perfectly happy with my pay but for context, I am not one of the mega-rich locum doctors the newspapers talk of. I earn around £23/hour and obviously have no sick pay or AL. Several times I've been approached about having a full time non-locum role for around £32k. I've always been really enthusiastic about this but there has never been the funding.

Anyway, I've recently been told that they don't need me anymore as they have a new physician's associate. I'm really sad and hurt. I've gone above and beyond for this job. I can't understand how there is funding for a PA who will earn more than I would have done and can't do a lot of what I can do. They won't be able to prescribe (I spend a lot of time prescribing and dealing with very heavy duty psychiatric medications) or detain patients (I perform emergency detentions under the MHA not infrequently). They won't have the same medical background I have to manage the physical health of the patients. I just can't really understand what they can do that I can't!

This isn't a problem unique to me. Lots of junior doctors locum not because they want lots of money (as the media might tell you) but because they can't make training work - or, in many cases, because there aren't enough training positions at all! Many of these positions are now being replaced by PAs. I know people who have left medicine because of it and now, I think I might have to too.

AIBU to be so hurt and sad and think it's just not fair?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Ascubudr · 06/12/2023 16:40

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:32

I misremembered, top of band 7 then (https://x.com/tomstocks1982/status/1550259605057536002?s=46)

which is about 35% less than they’re currently paid!

Interestingly that is equivalent to my £25,000 in Y2K and probably what they are worth.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:32

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:26

I have no idea, some daft government initiative made up by managers who couldn't cope with a patient-facing role I assume, as I said upthread.

I think an F1 would probably be more of a band 6 though, not an 8

I misremembered, top of band 7 then (https://x.com/tomstocks1982/status/1550259605057536002?s=46)

which is about 35% less than they’re currently paid!

https://x.com/tomstocks1982/status/1550259605057536002?s=46

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:31

BadSkiingMum · 06/12/2023 16:28

The problem is that this is how it starts out. It started out exactly the same way in education i.e. the alternative practitioner ‘freeing up’ the professional. But it doesn’t stay that way once that helpful new person is in the building and there’s a sudden bout of sickness, a bereavement, a resignation or someone’s suspended from duty. They aren’t just a theoretical PA whom no-one trusts; they’re Jane, who is always so cooperative and patients really seem to like her…

See my posts upthread for what has happened in teaching, with HLTA and cover supervisors being used to cover classes once the legal requirement for qualified teachers to teach classes had been removed. Thinking about it, it definitely contributed to me leaving the profession because when I later wanted to return to work after maternity leave those flexible cover roles (most primary schools previously had several cover teachers) were much more sparse than they had been before - even in London. They were still out there, but there certainly wasn’t the same high demand for qualified teachers to do these roles.

Hey ho, it’s all in the past for me now. I thought the unions were wrong and overreacting at the time but oh how wrong I was!

This is really interesting and sorry I missed your post upthread. Seriously depressing though. I asked my teacher friend who seemed surprised I didn't know this was happening! I genuinely had no idea.

OP posts:
prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:29

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:23

This is just... having a job? Getting on with colleagues and doing the grunt work when you're new. I'm NHS myself, but lots of us would not be able to cope in a corporate environment.

No it's not. Starting a new job and your colleagues purposely refusing to do something they're meant to do so you have to do it on top of your own work load? Being told to make your colleagues tea and biscuits so they don't bully you? Being unable to raise complaints about harassment, sexism, unfair rotas, staying hours late etc. because your seniors will refuse to sign you off? Accepting bullying from nurses because otherwise they'll close ranks and you'll see it reflected on your MSF? (all of which, by the way, disproportionately affects non-white british doctors...) Should we not speak out about these things? If you're NHS you must know bullying is rife. We have posters in our hospital asking people to consider whether they might be a bully! And I'm sorry you've been led to think you wouldn't cope in a corporate environment. My friends are nearly all in the private sector. There's nothing magical about the other side.

OP posts:
BadSkiingMum · 06/12/2023 16:28

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 15:39

@Salacia, I so so agree with you that medicine has lost its status and doctors skills, intelligence, dedication and commitment is just not respected to it's true value.

The general public has no idea what the job entails, physically, mentally and psychologically. The number of paperwork and bureaucracy is mad. This is why though I am in support of freeing their time and commitment to do what is more complex and are trained for rather than focusing on the mundane every common tasks.

A new patient is referred with symptoms of MS. Never ever appropriate to be seen at first appointment by a PA. Consultants only or Junior Doctor whose specialised. 2 years down the line, the patients is seen every 6 months to check on progression of the disease, symptoms, side effects of medication, or discuss social issues such as finances, social care and need to be sign posted to the right agency...that would be a waste of consultant appointment and a PA review is totally appropriate. If the patient has deteriorated beyond expectation, suddenly don't do so well on their meds, is experiencing new symptoms or has now co-morbidies, they should then be reviewed by a doctor.

The problem is that this is how it starts out. It started out exactly the same way in education i.e. the alternative practitioner ‘freeing up’ the professional. But it doesn’t stay that way once that helpful new person is in the building and there’s a sudden bout of sickness, a bereavement, a resignation or someone’s suspended from duty. They aren’t just a theoretical PA whom no-one trusts; they’re Jane, who is always so cooperative and patients really seem to like her…

See my posts upthread for what has happened in teaching, with HLTA and cover supervisors being used to cover classes once the legal requirement for qualified teachers to teach classes had been removed. Thinking about it, it definitely contributed to me leaving the profession because when I later wanted to return to work after maternity leave those flexible cover roles (most primary schools previously had several cover teachers) were much more sparse than they had been before - even in London. They were still out there, but there certainly wasn’t the same high demand for qualified teachers to do these roles.

Hey ho, it’s all in the past for me now. I thought the unions were wrong and overreacting at the time but oh how wrong I was!

Ascubudr · 06/12/2023 16:27

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 15:33

Women absolutely do NOT have the option of putting children on hold in the same way that men do. A man can father a child at 40, a woman may very well struggle over 35. If you want to have more than one child then you’re really pushing your luck as a woman to wait until consultancy.

I would support a male doctor who is the main care giver to their children in exactly the same way as I would support a female doctor. Can you clarify what you mean re: female doctors getting preferential treatment?

This most of my collegues tried to get as much of their registrar training under their belts before motherhood as they could of these who had children whilst in training I guessttimate 50% stayed in training, the others couldn't make it work and took SAS jobs or locumed . Of those who took the gamble of waiting till consultancy I would say 50% had some sort of fertility difficulties.

So those of us who managed it ( children and CCT) are the lucky few. Most of us have had massive amounts of support from our families and our partners. There is usually a fair dose of good luck in there ( straightforward pregnancies, healthy children) and an enormous dose of determination and the men we went to medical school with still outearn us.😥

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:27

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:25

Not a race to the bottom. Most doctors are very privileged, I'd never deny that. I always, always advocate for the rights of nurses and AHPs. Their shift pattern is far more random than ours, it must be really hard to find childcare. Unsure how that's at all relevant to my AIBU though? If a nurse managed to get a community 9-5 job that worked for their family and then was replaced by someone less qualified, less experienced, less skilled and who earned more than them, I bet they'd feel like I do. Also, nurses aren't as beholden to one trust as we are ... I know plenty of nurses who have moved from hospital to community, or who do solely bank shifts. It's really not a race to the bottom. I'd never deny that I'm in an incredibly privileged position to be able to choose to leave if the job becomes too unfavourable.

It's not relevant to your AIBU, I agreed earlier YANBU, but the thread has moved on

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:26

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:23

so why do PAs get to do 9-5 on band 7 starting? On AFC I think a newly qualified F1 would be at least band 8, if you want to compare like for like.

I have no idea, some daft government initiative made up by managers who couldn't cope with a patient-facing role I assume, as I said upthread.

I think an F1 would probably be more of a band 6 though, not an 8

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:25

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:21

@PlusThyme how much would someone have to pay you to work random 12h days, one week of nights a month and 1 in 2 or 3 weekends?

A huge % of the NHS workforce do this for a band 5 though. Look I do agree medicine has gone to shit, but between this and OP's latest post it makes doctors look a bit privileged

Not a race to the bottom. Most doctors are very privileged, I'd never deny that. I always, always advocate for the rights of nurses and AHPs. Their shift pattern is far more random than ours, it must be really hard to find childcare. Unsure how that's at all relevant to my AIBU though? If a nurse managed to get a community 9-5 job that worked for their family and then was replaced by someone less qualified, less experienced, less skilled and who earned more than them, I bet they'd feel like I do. Also, nurses aren't as beholden to one trust as we are ... I know plenty of nurses who have moved from hospital to community, or who do solely bank shifts. It's really not a race to the bottom. I'd never deny that I'm in an incredibly privileged position to be able to choose to leave if the job becomes too unfavourable.

OP posts:
PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:23

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:21

@PlusThyme how much would someone have to pay you to work random 12h days, one week of nights a month and 1 in 2 or 3 weekends?

A huge % of the NHS workforce do this for a band 5 though. Look I do agree medicine has gone to shit, but between this and OP's latest post it makes doctors look a bit privileged

so why do PAs get to do 9-5 on band 7 starting? On AFC I think a newly qualified F1 would be at least band 8, if you want to compare like for like.

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:23

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:16

I wonder in general if non-medics on this thread realise how reliant we are on good relations with our consultants and the MDT in general to get adequate feedback and pass our rotations. We move into new teams frequently and the onus is on us to get on with people. Have you ever seen #tipsfornewdoctors on twitter in August? Imagine starting a new job and being told you must make the established team tea and biscuits so they'll be nice to you! Happens every August. I mentioned my first weekend as an F1 upthread. That weekend I stayed hours late because the nurses insisted they couldn't help me with some physical tasks. Once I knew them better, they admitted they actually could but they like to 'lay down the law' to new doctors. Imagine that on your first days! Life can be very, very difficult if you complain. I've seen it again and again. It's generally easier to just accept staying late and getting rotas late, keep your head down, get signed off and moved on. Part of the reason I adore this job is because I've been accepted into a team. Work is so so much easier when you always know what you're doing, where you're going, who you need to talk to to get something done, and when you have working relations with the nurses (who themselves have to quickly size up new junior doctors and adapt to their styles - rotational training is difficult for all!)

This is just... having a job? Getting on with colleagues and doing the grunt work when you're new. I'm NHS myself, but lots of us would not be able to cope in a corporate environment.

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:21

SawX · 06/12/2023 16:18

Plus, how are junior doctors going to be able to learn basic skills if PAs are playing doctor with all the easy cases? You can't go straight from med school to taking on the most complex patients.

PAs aren't the answer to anything except Tory ideology.

Totally agree. There’s hardly enough training to go round as it is. What I would have given to be in clinic with a consultant debriefing me before and after my patients! Or in theatre assisting. Instead I was stuck on the wards doing discharge summaries and blood forms, prescribing for the PAs.

Possimpible · 06/12/2023 16:21

@PlusThyme how much would someone have to pay you to work random 12h days, one week of nights a month and 1 in 2 or 3 weekends?

A huge % of the NHS workforce do this for a band 5 though. Look I do agree medicine has gone to shit, but between this and OP's latest post it makes doctors look a bit privileged

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:21

SawX · 06/12/2023 16:18

Plus, how are junior doctors going to be able to learn basic skills if PAs are playing doctor with all the easy cases? You can't go straight from med school to taking on the most complex patients.

PAs aren't the answer to anything except Tory ideology.

Exactly. We need simpler cases. It's really depressing how some consultants seem to resent having to train juniors, particularly due to our rotations. I know this will be down to their own workload but it really stings. We are doctors in training.

OP posts:
SawX · 06/12/2023 16:18

PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 13:21

@prawncocktailskips totally agree. People are deluded if they think doctors will be willing to work mostly OOH and weekends for £14-20 per hour in order to take on only the “most complex” patients and 100% of the clinically responsibility for patients they have never seen or reviewed.

@JennieTheZebra as I understand it almost all nurses are trained in these things at university, but each trust requires them to attend training at their individual trust post qualification (and these courses are massively oversubscribed) so in practice they mostly are unable.

Plus, how are junior doctors going to be able to learn basic skills if PAs are playing doctor with all the easy cases? You can't go straight from med school to taking on the most complex patients.

PAs aren't the answer to anything except Tory ideology.

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:16

I wonder in general if non-medics on this thread realise how reliant we are on good relations with our consultants and the MDT in general to get adequate feedback and pass our rotations. We move into new teams frequently and the onus is on us to get on with people. Have you ever seen #tipsfornewdoctors on twitter in August? Imagine starting a new job and being told you must make the established team tea and biscuits so they'll be nice to you! Happens every August. I mentioned my first weekend as an F1 upthread. That weekend I stayed hours late because the nurses insisted they couldn't help me with some physical tasks. Once I knew them better, they admitted they actually could but they like to 'lay down the law' to new doctors. Imagine that on your first days! Life can be very, very difficult if you complain. I've seen it again and again. It's generally easier to just accept staying late and getting rotas late, keep your head down, get signed off and moved on. Part of the reason I adore this job is because I've been accepted into a team. Work is so so much easier when you always know what you're doing, where you're going, who you need to talk to to get something done, and when you have working relations with the nurses (who themselves have to quickly size up new junior doctors and adapt to their styles - rotational training is difficult for all!)

OP posts:
prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 16:11

Yes, like @PlusThyme said, it's a combination of factors. Realistically I don't enjoy OOH and often get migraines following nights but I accept that. We'd all find OOH less stressful if we were better supported for a start. Then agree about affordable childcare. Adding in the randomness of rotations, moving away from support networks or just meaning the commute is much longer so more childcare must be found etc. Again, add in getting rotas last minute (I can make this job work with DH's travel just fine because I know my hours and can request AL long in advance, unlike previous jobs I did where AL requests were ignored and rotas were given out weeks in advance and changed frequently without warning - yes, in theory this shouldn't happen and I think(?) one can refuse to work a shift but this does not go down well with consultants - the same consultants who we need to sign us off as competent )... Add in again frequently leaving late because someone hasn't come to relieve you on time and you're the only doctor. There are a lot of factors that make it really hard. I'm not opposed to hard work and OOH in general. I wouldn't have survived med school and foundation if so and, even as a naive 17 year old, I didn't expect to never work a weekend or to have every christmas off with my children.

OP posts:
PlusThyme · 06/12/2023 16:07

Spacecowboys · 06/12/2023 16:02

I think it’s a tricky one regarding out of hours generally. A previous poster stated that she can’t do shift work or weekends and how inflexible the nhs is. But, allowing some staff members to do 9-5 Monday to Friday would only mean someone else having to take on additional unsocial hours. And it would probably be a staff member who also has children. Having to do extra unsocial hours to accommodate someone else’s family, at the expense of your own isn’t really on. Of the female medics I know, some continued their training on reduced hours ( so it took longer) and others only had children when they achieved consultant level - so in their 30’s. It’s a difficult decision to make.

Edited

I think most women would be happy to do more OOH if they got paid enough to cover the childcare for it. That is the crux of the matter. Doctors used to be paid enough to have full time nannies- those days are sadly long gone. I’ve never understood why we don’t get a significant uplift for OOH - then those who are willing to take those shifts (and some people love them!) get paid their worth for them.

how much would someone have to pay you to work random 12h days, one week of nights a month and 1 in 2 or 3 weekends?

Spacecowboys · 06/12/2023 16:02

I think it’s a tricky one regarding out of hours generally. A previous poster stated that she can’t do shift work or weekends and how inflexible the nhs is. But, allowing some staff members to do 9-5 Monday to Friday would only mean someone else having to take on additional unsocial hours. And it would probably be a staff member who also has children. Having to do extra unsocial hours to accommodate someone else’s family, at the expense of your own isn’t really on. Of the female medics I know, some continued their training on reduced hours ( so it took longer) and others only had children when they achieved consultant level - so in their 30’s. It’s a difficult decision to make.

JennieTheZebra · 06/12/2023 15:50

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 15:39

@Salacia, I so so agree with you that medicine has lost its status and doctors skills, intelligence, dedication and commitment is just not respected to it's true value.

The general public has no idea what the job entails, physically, mentally and psychologically. The number of paperwork and bureaucracy is mad. This is why though I am in support of freeing their time and commitment to do what is more complex and are trained for rather than focusing on the mundane every common tasks.

A new patient is referred with symptoms of MS. Never ever appropriate to be seen at first appointment by a PA. Consultants only or Junior Doctor whose specialised. 2 years down the line, the patients is seen every 6 months to check on progression of the disease, symptoms, side effects of medication, or discuss social issues such as finances, social care and need to be sign posted to the right agency...that would be a waste of consultant appointment and a PA review is totally appropriate. If the patient has deteriorated beyond expectation, suddenly don't do so well on their meds, is experiencing new symptoms or has now co-morbidies, they should then be reviewed by a doctor.

@vivainsomnia why is that person being seen by a PA at all? Why not a specialist nurse with a 3 year nursing degree, potentially decades of experience and a masters degree in clinical neuroscience? It feels to me that PAs are taking work away not just from junior doctors, but also from specialist nurses who have eons more knowledge and experience than your average PA.

Leafysuburb · 06/12/2023 15:48

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 15:44

So when you choose who has to stay home on parental leave and who does the pick ups and drop offs then most couples will be financially sensible and choose the higher paid person i.e. the man
Or the opposite...maybe women are choosing to work fewer hours, are not as keen to progress etc..egg and chicken effect.

No it's adjusted for hours.

The 'lean in' argument is postfeminist twaddle.

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 15:44

So when you choose who has to stay home on parental leave and who does the pick ups and drop offs then most couples will be financially sensible and choose the higher paid person i.e. the man
Or the opposite...maybe women are choosing to work fewer hours, are not as keen to progress etc..egg and chicken effect.

Leafysuburb · 06/12/2023 15:43

It is an adjusted gap based on a comparison of full time equivalent mean pay. The unadjusted is 24.4%

vivainsomnia · 06/12/2023 15:42

Because we are the ones who carry and birth the children (and possibly feed them). So we certainly need to be considered above men at least during the pregnancy
No one mentioned during pregnancy. No reason afterwards why leave can't be shared. The NHS offers one of the best shared care package.

The bma pay gap report for 2020 says that there is 18.9% pay gap between male and female hospital doctors
Does it total hours in considerations, grades etc...it means nothing alone when not knowing which factors have been or not taken into account.

prawncocktailskips · 06/12/2023 15:41

@Salacia I'm also being very pessimistic I'm afraid! I know there are ways for me to stay in medicine if I want to. I just feel like the balance is being tipped further and further towards leaving and this particular episode has really made me want to go far away from the NHS to lick my wounds!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread