Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas party awards - humiliating or harmless fun?

94 replies

TippyToes123 · 06/12/2023 09:32

Our office Christmas party takes place in a couple of weeks and an email has been sent to all staff by the organiser asking us to nominate our colleagues for an alternative awards ceremony.

The categories include things like 'worst tea maker', 'office clown', 'always chatting' and so on. There is also an award for the person who loves to drink but can't handle it.

For context, my employer is a national firm which prides itself on looking after their staff and having a culture of respect. But our local office is more 'laid back' and has a heavy drinking culture.

Since I joined, there have been many staff events, which have included lots of free alcohol. I have witnessed colleagues getting very drunk, being sick, saying and doing things they have regretted afterwards. Usually, it is the newer trainees who are swept along with the free alcohol and encouraged to knock back shots. I think that making anyone get up in front of their colleagues to accept an award for not being able to handle their drink is humiliating. If it was me, I would be mortified. (For the record, I've been tee-total since joining and am not expecting to be nominated!)

I know that if I was to express my feelings on this (which I won't), I would be accused of missing the point and trying to spoil everyone else's fun. In fact, the email even stated that these awards are to be taken in the good nature and spirit that they are intended, a bit of fun.

So I'm interested to know...AIBU?

Yes...it's just a bit of harmless fun, which promotes team bonding.
No...it is potentially humiliating and adds nothing to the Christmas celebrations.

OP posts:
HamstersAreMyLife · 06/12/2023 13:18

Allergictoironing · 06/12/2023 10:04

I've worked in places that do Christmas "awards", but only ones that aren't cruel or humiliating. Things like most chatty, best tea maker, most likely to go over and above, that kind of thing. I think the closest to being cruel was the "most likely to have biscuits/chocolate available" type thing which was created especially for me as I always had a stockpile in my drawer that others could borrow from then replace - often late nights there meeting deadlines on projects etc, when a chocolate bar or Jaffa Cakes could keep people going.

I agree. I don't like enforced fun but we do have lots who do so we organise a range of things and would contemplate positive awards if this came up. The culture of humiliation is a bad one and I wouldn't engage with it at all.

user1492757084 · 06/12/2023 13:15

Harmless fun and any adult who accepted too many of the free beers has already humiliated themselves, to be fair.

ALightOverThere · 06/12/2023 13:11

Sounds like an employment tribunal waiting to happen. The drinking culture also sounds awful.

Hamburgler666 · 06/12/2023 13:10

About 20 years ago I worked in an office full of middle aged nasty bitches (I was only young at the time)

Anyway, one Xmas we went out for the office Xmas meal and everyone had done secret Santa. There was a lady who was rather overweight and not well liked for some reason. Somebody had bought a fat, ugly troll as her Xmas gift.

She was utterly humiliated but tried to laugh along, bless her. The rest of them howled with laughter (I didn't join in).

So yeah, any form of public humiliation is not ok in my book!

DinoDays · 06/12/2023 13:06

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/12/2023 11:02

Justfinking · Today 09:35
**
I think harmless fun, but I have a good sense of humour and can take a joke. I have been to two occasions when someone couldn't and ended up being quite (unreasonably) offended which put a dampener on things”

Mocking people in public doesn’t equate to a “good sense of humour” at all.

Exactly!!!

How do you know you have a good sense of humour? I always think people who say that are in the same category as the "I'm mad, I am!!".

Who are always not funny but irritating as hell!

Spinet · 06/12/2023 12:57

And the award for best magically knowing everybody else's intentions and braying loudly about it goes to @AngelAurora

PuttingDownRoots · 06/12/2023 12:52

There can be a fine line between banter and bullying. As I tell my kids... a joke is only funny if everyone is laughing.

TippyToes123 · 06/12/2023 12:35

AngelAurora · 06/12/2023 11:07

Take it in the context it's meant to be taken in and lighten up. You sound like a right miserable party pooper. If you do not want to participate, then don't, but stop spoiling everyone else's fun.

How am I spoiling everyone's "fun" by posting for opinions on here? I said in my post that I wasn't going to try and stop it. I just wanted to see if anyone else thought it was inappropriate, in a work environment, to celebrate people getting really drunk. It just seems to go against everything that the firm as a whole stands for.

OP posts:
TippyToes123 · 06/12/2023 12:28

Thanks for all the comments. It's interesting to get others' thoughts as I would be shot down in flames if I uttered any kind of disapproval at work. I'm pleased to see that most agree.

I'm not against the idea of an awards ceremony and some of the awards are for how helpful, happy, entertaining, and so on, people are. The worst cup of tea award is just plain daft and I doubt anyone would get too upset about that.

It's just the drinking one that really oversteps the mark. Who would want to be reminded of how drunk they got? Especially in front of all their colleagues at a Christmas party. I don't get any pleasure from seeing other people being embarrassed.

OP posts:
Stephisaur · 06/12/2023 11:11

I like the idea of the awards, but agree that some of those you have mentioned are incredibly poor taste.

I would nominate for the fun awards (like worst tea maker - is there also an option for best tea maker?) but I would decline for the alcohol related awards.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/12/2023 11:11

AngelAurora · Today 11:09
**
God what a bunch of miserable people you all are. Well they do say misery loves company”

Not miserable at all. Just not spiteful.

AngelAurora · 06/12/2023 11:09

God what a bunch of miserable people you all are. Well they do say misery loves company. Biscuit

PippyLongTits · 06/12/2023 11:08

Making a bad cup of tea is one thing, but anything to do with alcohol should not be included. You don't know what people are dealing with at home. Someone could've gone overboard at a work event following bereavement or depression or a bad medical diagnosis and not want the incident brought to the attention of the whole office to be laughed about.

AngelAurora · 06/12/2023 11:07

Take it in the context it's meant to be taken in and lighten up. You sound like a right miserable party pooper. If you do not want to participate, then don't, but stop spoiling everyone else's fun.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/12/2023 11:02

Justfinking · Today 09:35
**
I think harmless fun, but I have a good sense of humour and can take a joke. I have been to two occasions when someone couldn't and ended up being quite (unreasonably) offended which put a dampener on things”

Mocking people in public doesn’t equate to a “good sense of humour” at all.

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/12/2023 11:00

Feels very 1980s and deeply inappropriate.

Catlord · 06/12/2023 10:58

It's interesting how dated the drinking culture and shots o clock stuff sounds to me when that would have been normal just a few years ago. Drinking isn't the thing it was anymore so I don't think it's right pushing the young starters into it, who probably think they must participate.

Awards can be done in a well meant way but that is so hard to gauge and someone who comes across as having the thickest skin can be one of the most sensitive. A young man on my course who was a loud character was voted for many things including 'most likely to be convicted'. He was actually very hurt by that as it was quite an unsettling thing to be accused of in our line of work even in jest.

I mean I don't think it's all terrible but maybe a 'keep it lighthearted and include seniors' request to avoid punching down and personal comments? Someone could be really mortified at going too far on a work drinks.

Haydenn · 06/12/2023 10:40

Hate shit like this. Tedious

bluelavender · 06/12/2023 10:39

This is the sort of thing that ends up being cited in employment tribunals as evidence of harassment or unfair work environments- any manager signing off on this is not good on strategic risk/ workplace culture

Keepinmovin · 06/12/2023 10:39

We have alternative awards but the categories are very harmless. Mostly likely to send a gif on teams chat or most energetic in the afternoon sort of thing.

So alternative awards are fun but these categories are absolutely not appropriate!

RealBigBarbie · 06/12/2023 10:39

I think it sounds awful and really embarrassing

LlynTegid · 06/12/2023 10:37

The drinking culture you describe is far worse than a few awards.

EvilElsa · 06/12/2023 10:37

I wouldn't care personally about being nominated for anything BUT I think it's a stupid idea as there are always people who get hurt -even the complimentary side can be problematic with people going off in a huff as they've not won anything (yes, I have experience in this area having worked as HR manager for a big firm and dealing with the fall out!).
I'd always advise managers to just steer clear of this kind of thing. It may seem fun on paper, but it rarely turns out that way.

TeenLifeMum · 06/12/2023 10:30

We had office awards but they were all complimentary… even then, I was overthinking and wondering if there was an undertone to mine (big toxic history). I hate them. Ours were done nicely but even then, someone may have been upset.

Swipe left for the next trending thread