Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tv and babies

39 replies

Ambn1 · 06/12/2023 08:52

My DD is 5 months old. We don’t use screens to entertain her and would like to hold off on introducing them until she is older.

When I get up with her in the morning, we go downstairs and I give her tummy time and time to play on her play mat and with her toys. During this time I don’t put the tv on, because I feel like this will draw her attention (and mine!) away from play.

My DH and other family members think I’m being overly harsh on myself and should allow myself to put the tv or radio on in the background to entertain myself while the baby plays.

IBU- it’s fine to have tv on in the background while baby plays.

INBU- having the tv on in the background is detrimental to the baby.

OP posts:
hjytrjulykuyh · 06/12/2023 10:21

SleepingStandingUp · 06/12/2023 09:06

When people say it worked for them, can I ask at what age you started to see that your children were developing ahead of their peers / had better socialisation etc compared to babies who would be let watch TV? And do you think this advantage has held up now their older in terms of who they are

I don't know of any evidence that being screen-free increases the likelihood of higher attainment later on, however I can say anecdotally that we read a TONNE of books when DC was little, from being a baby onwards, they were absolutely in love with reading and we would often get through 30-40 across the day (some re-reads obviously... many, many re-reads...). Now that they're almost four they're doing well, can read three or four letter words, can tell you what most three letter words spell when you say them out loud, can often read things out and about (he read 'crispy fries' on the wall of our local takeaway haha) and has a massive passion for words, letters, numbers, and learning. Of course now they have screen time they love watching stuff on the TV too (no tablets or phones). But I wonder if there's any correlation between spending the first 2-3yr without screens and how they are with literacy now. My common sense suggests that a small child would prefer a screen to a book as one is more passive and one more active, but who knows? There are smart kids raised both ways. My kid wasn't early with any milestones (speaking, walking etc.) just average, but they're pretty advanced now they're approaching school age.

Weatherwax134 · 06/12/2023 10:18

It's a tough one- I worried obsessively about screen time with my first child and then was much more relaxed with my twins. Now that they're older I don't think there is any difference between their attitudes to media, each other etc. Ultimately, I think I worried a lot and it didn't matter either way.

Daisies12 · 06/12/2023 10:07

What's the issue with a radio? You literally have a silent house? that's ridiculous. A bit of TV is fine to.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 06/12/2023 10:03

@Ambn1

Ahhh it feels like Mumsnet of old, stressing about screen time.

Not wading in on that one this morning.

but what's your issue with the radio??

ColleenDonaghy · 06/12/2023 09:54

There's no reasonable or unreasonable here - it's fine to have it on, and it won't matter either if it's off.

I had it on all day during maternity leave, more or less, for my own sake. The babies weren't particularly interested or not! It was only once they became toddlers that we became more careful with it.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 06/12/2023 09:26

DS watched a bit of tv as a baby - he found cricket very soothing for some reason, which was helpful after vaccinations etc. I never felt the occasional 15 minutes would do him any harm.

Richie23 · 06/12/2023 09:16

My son is 9 months and wasn’t interested in the TV until very recently. When we are getting ready in the morning we put some Nursery Rhymes on YouTube and he enjoys that and it’s handy to keep him still for a few minutes. But that’s the only TV time he has. It’s totally Ok to have the radio on in the background - singing and music are super encouraged to help with speech development so if you want to have some music playing whilst you’re doing tummy time then that will have absolutely no detrimental effect. Singing is such a good way to help babies learn how speech works and they love the repetitive nature of songs.
I follow a child speech therapist on socials who was saying that TV time is fine in small doses, but it’s best to do it with your input. So if watching something then make comments like wow look at that bear, or singing along to the songs etc, rather than just letting them sit for ages on their own watching stuff.

HippeePrincess · 06/12/2023 09:12

I often put the radio on, don’t always think about putting tv on on the background as I grew up without a TV for a lot of the time, and when my older two were little I didn’t have a TV for about 4 years as I couldn’t afford to buy one and the license, neither did the have anything with a screen. They are no more or less advanced than their peers currently, though when one was in preschool or reception can’t recall which, there was a comment in their development portfolio that they did not know how to use a computer mouse or touch screen and this was seen as a negative thing.

SleepingStandingUp · 06/12/2023 09:06

When people say it worked for them, can I ask at what age you started to see that your children were developing ahead of their peers / had better socialisation etc compared to babies who would be let watch TV? And do you think this advantage has held up now their older in terms of who they are

DuploTrain · 06/12/2023 09:06

To be honest when my DS was that age he wasn’t interested in the TV at all, he just ignored it so I used have it on for myself.

Once he started being glued to it, (much later, around age 2) that’s when I started to limit to 1 or 2 episodes of teletubbies while I cooked dinner.

MyDogCalledMax · 06/12/2023 09:03

YANBU. I give 30 mins of Miss Rachel in the morning so that I can shower, sort breakfast etc. My 7.5mo is a contact napper so I don’t get that time while she’s asleep 🙄
And then it’s off all day usually because we’re out and about or playing. I will sometimes put it on in the evening because I like watching Pointless 😂😂 but it depends what else is going on.

It does mean my Netflix watch list is backing up a bit though!!

Makkacakka · 06/12/2023 09:03

Neither.

It isn't detrimental to the baby to have the TV on in the background. At the same time, if you don't feel you need or want it on then that's also fine. My toddler got gradual screen time from about a year old. Some days I've banned it completely as I felt he was getting too much (more recently) and other times he'll have it more than I'd like (we've both been poorly recently so we had it on for hours!).

When they do get to an age they might watch a bit, it is more about what they are watching. My nearly 2 year old watches YouTube videos with me about animals. He names them with me. We stay away from overstimulating things like Cocomelon!

Z1hun · 06/12/2023 08:57

My toddler who is 16m very rarely gets the TV on and shows no interest when it is on. She plays perfectly fine without it. We put it on once she's gone to bed. You are not being unreasonable.

hjytrjulykuyh · 06/12/2023 08:56

Of course YANBU. People managed without screens for millennia lol. We did the same and chose not to use any screens at all until our child was 2.5yr. It worked really well for us and looking back I'm definitely glad we did it, even though it wasn't always the easiest time.

Of course, if you feel like it would be the better option in some scenarios (you have a work call, you're sick with nobody to help, you are struggling mentally and need a break) it's not the worst thing in the world, but there's certainly no assumption you should be using screens or that it's wrong if you don't.

I must admit I came across this attitude quite a bit, I never outright told anyone we were screen-free as there was no need to and I didn't want it to seem braggy, but when people found out through conversation (happened a couple times) they would be quite judgey and taken aback as if our screen free decision meant we were criticising them. But that's par for the course with every parenting decision tbh.

You will def get people criticising you for being 'pfb' but do what works for you and your child. I think it's a wonderful thing to be able to do for your child if you want to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread