Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think kids media should ease up on the representations of snow

208 replies

someladdersandsnakes · 06/12/2023 07:57

Trying to be lighthearted here but this is bugging me
CBeebies has wall-to-wall snow right now, in all the Christmas episodes and in-between segments, anything to do with Christmas or winter = SNOW SNOW SNOW
Except for Bluey which represents Australian December accurately.
Also books from the library, British ones, it's snowing at Christmas and anything about the seasons is like "in winter it snows bla bla bla"
Well my DD has never seen snow in all of her 5 years and she asks every day when it's going to start snowing, and getting disappointed that it isn't snowing yet.
AIBU to want to see Christmas or winter represented without snow occasionally so it's accurate to our actual lives?

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 07/12/2023 02:57

So much of kids worlds is make-believe as in the books and TV they read, there is talking animals, fairies, dinosaurs and humans living together, trains that talk etc.

And kids brains can cope with all this yet seeing snow on cards/books/tv etc. Yet not seeing snow when they go to nursery or school as much

Al this and the same kids don't understand snow is not always around?

I give kids more credit than that

ToWhitToWhoo · 07/12/2023 02:26

Flandango · 06/12/2023 22:44

I agree with you OP. Christmas cards should feature mud, relentlessly grey weather and the hopeless misery of the English winter. It is pointless trying to bring any joy into our children's lives

But snow gives some people far less joy and more misery than 'relentlessly grey weather'. I don't mind the greyness that much; it's seasonal; I prefer summer, but greyness doesn't make me miserable. But icy paths and pavements do!

I don't think children should be deprived of fairy tales about The Snow Queen, or Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer pulling Santa's sleigh. But I think that programmes that are supposed to be about real life should not always imply that snow is a key part of Christmas everywhere.

ToWhitToWhoo · 07/12/2023 02:17

Agree. Partly because I hate it when it does snow, as I have disabilities that are manageable most of the time, but confine me to the house worse than lockdown when we get slippery icy snow. I don't WANT a white Christmas! And am very glad that we don't usually have one in southern England. If people like snow, fine; but I hate it being represented as a special part of Christmas.

someladdersandsnakes · 07/12/2023 00:13

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/12/2023 22:50

I did intend this as a light hearted post but I'm getting a lot of shaming now for not giving my daughter specific life experiences that I either couldn't access or still can't access.

The point isn't you are being unreasonable not to drive your dd to where there are ducks and snow. The point is that you're being utterly ridiculous to expect kids' tv to tweak or remove things that are perfectly fine, just because they don't happen to be part of your dd's everyday life!

That would be a totally fair point if that was the only thing people were disagreeing with me about, but I've also had a lot of replies berating me for not taking my daughter to see ducks/snow!

@Sparkledr Queen's Park is an hour and a half walk from my house. @Rouleur Stanmer Park is two and a half hours walk. Is that your idea of walking distance for a day out with a toddler? I honestly can't tell whether I'm being trolled with comments like this.

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 06/12/2023 22:50

I did intend this as a light hearted post but I'm getting a lot of shaming now for not giving my daughter specific life experiences that I either couldn't access or still can't access.

The point isn't you are being unreasonable not to drive your dd to where there are ducks and snow. The point is that you're being utterly ridiculous to expect kids' tv to tweak or remove things that are perfectly fine, just because they don't happen to be part of your dd's everyday life!

Flandango · 06/12/2023 22:44

I agree with you OP. Christmas cards should feature mud, relentlessly grey weather and the hopeless misery of the English winter. It is pointless trying to bring any joy into our children's lives

Rouleur · 06/12/2023 22:38

someladdersandsnakes · 06/12/2023 12:10

JFC
I don't live in central Brighton. I live in Brighton, on the coast. Not central Brighton and nowhere near Queen's Park which was one of the parks mentioned. Another mentioned was in Lancing which is also nowhere near me though we did go there this year once. And Stanmer was mentioned which is far inland and again nowhere near me. There are 4 parks in easy walking distance of my house - 1 is on the beach, 1 has a little forest area but no fresh water, 2 are rec grounds with a playground. During covid we rotated those 4 parks and the beach and went out to one of them every day or twice a day. There were a couple of other parks we would go to for a change, which are a longer walk or very short bus journey, one has a forest and horses and trees but no water. One has a lovely sand area and cafe but no water. Anywhere else was too far away to bother with when we have so many nice outdoor spaces locally that don't take two buses to get to. And no ducks in a single one of them. I'm sorry my local area lacks ducks. Do you still not believe me?

You have a very strange definition of “nowhere near”. Brighton is hardly some vast metropolis, it’s tiny, only about 3 miles across. You can walk from one end to the other in 40 minutes. Stanmer is not “far inland”, it’s 4 miles from the coast.

Sparkledr · 06/12/2023 22:09

If you live near the coast in Brighton you can easily walk to Queens Park. I live in Brighton. Even if you lived on the coast in Hove Actually you could still walk to Queens Park. What 5 parks are you near?
Has she met a squirrel at St Ann's well yet?

Moanyoldmoan · 06/12/2023 20:08

I’m with you. My kids think Christmas Day means 5ft of lovely thick snow and can’t grasp when I explain it’ll probably be raining. We are also South coast

Abbyant · 06/12/2023 19:36

where is this snowless place you live? I hate the snow and being by the coast it turns mushy straight away

beanii · 06/12/2023 19:29

Does she also think that people go around singing and animals talk?

No. You just explain that TV programmes and stories don't have to be realistic.

DemBonesDemBones · 06/12/2023 15:59

There's snow here 🤷‍♀️

Ponoka7 · 06/12/2023 15:43

Floatlikeafeather2 · 06/12/2023 09:40

Snow sticking or not is absolutely nothing to do with "salt in the air". I live on the coast in Cumbria and we had a few days of complete whiteout last weekend, even on the beach. We can see Blackpool from our beach too.

That's what was said a few times by locals. The weekends we've been there when it's been frosty everywhere else on the way to Liverpool, it's been clear in Blackpool. I know in Liverpool a lot of the extreme weather misses us because of where we are placed.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 06/12/2023 14:45

The Lighthouse Keepers Lunch is all about sea gulls.

someladdersandsnakes · 06/12/2023 14:41

JamieKnows · 06/12/2023 13:50

"This is a RTFT issue, I've been going further than walking distance from my house on a regular basis the last two years and DD has seen ducks lots of times. I was talking about 2020/21."

No it isn't, I read the full thread. As I said, it sounds like you're in walking distance of Valley Ponds where there are ducks. There were ducks in 2020/21 there also 🦆

I had to look up valley ponds because I'd never heard of it, apparently it's in Newhaven. I said I lived in Brighton, on the seafront. Newhaven and Brighton are MILES from each other even if I lived on the East side of it, which I don't. Why the f* are you so confident you know exactly where I live???

OP posts:
JamieKnows · 06/12/2023 13:50

"This is a RTFT issue, I've been going further than walking distance from my house on a regular basis the last two years and DD has seen ducks lots of times. I was talking about 2020/21."

No it isn't, I read the full thread. As I said, it sounds like you're in walking distance of Valley Ponds where there are ducks. There were ducks in 2020/21 there also 🦆

someladdersandsnakes · 06/12/2023 13:32

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 06/12/2023 12:40

OP I couldn't agree with you more re the snow. This was a big issue for years in my house, eldest was constantly disappointed about it at Christmas, despite me telling him repeatedly that it was never going to happen. When Storm Emma arrived in 2018 he was saying 'about time' but still moaned that it wasn't there for Christmas. I

As for those telling OP 'but it snows where I live' really what is the point of that? Surely OP's point is that 100% of Christmas representations include snow, when only some parts of the UK get snow. If it was any other issue there would be changes to be inclusive.

What particularly pissed me off was a Christmas ad was filmed in my city a few years ago showing it snow covered (literally never seen it like this other than 2018 and apparently once in 1994, but I didn't live here) which required fake snow for filming obviously, and shows recognisable landmarks. The ad says its Christmas eve and shows kids making snowmen and throwing snowballs. My kids always used to ask why did we not go to the city that day, how come it used to snow at Christmas etc etc. Do parents not have enough to worry about without this BS.

Exactly! I wasn't saying snow should not feature in anything, just that snow is totally omnipresent in these things and I find it silly because even if you live in a part of the country where you occasionally get snow, most of winter still isn't snowy, Christmas day is hardly ever snowy, and lots of places in the UK hardly get any snow ever.

OP posts:
JanetandRita · 06/12/2023 13:30

Ducks are overrated. They can be really mean and I much prefer swans.

Gulls rock.

I was so disappointed as a child visiting a pebble beach for the first time. I asked mum where the sand was, which was the only type of beach I'd seen in books and on TV. I was inconsolable when mum said this beach does not have sand.

someladdersandsnakes · 06/12/2023 13:29

JamieKnows · 06/12/2023 12:26

Valley Ponds has ducks also and by the sounds of it isn't too far from you. But I think the main issue is probably that you'll always have a small world if you stay within walking distance of your house!

Covid did teach us that but it was a tiny snapshot of time. Your dd must've been 18 months old by then and the last 2 years have been fine too.

This is a RTFT issue, I've been going further than walking distance from my house on a regular basis the last two years and DD has seen ducks lots of times. I was talking about 2020/21.

OP posts:
Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 06/12/2023 12:40

OP I couldn't agree with you more re the snow. This was a big issue for years in my house, eldest was constantly disappointed about it at Christmas, despite me telling him repeatedly that it was never going to happen. When Storm Emma arrived in 2018 he was saying 'about time' but still moaned that it wasn't there for Christmas. I

As for those telling OP 'but it snows where I live' really what is the point of that? Surely OP's point is that 100% of Christmas representations include snow, when only some parts of the UK get snow. If it was any other issue there would be changes to be inclusive.

What particularly pissed me off was a Christmas ad was filmed in my city a few years ago showing it snow covered (literally never seen it like this other than 2018 and apparently once in 1994, but I didn't live here) which required fake snow for filming obviously, and shows recognisable landmarks. The ad says its Christmas eve and shows kids making snowmen and throwing snowballs. My kids always used to ask why did we not go to the city that day, how come it used to snow at Christmas etc etc. Do parents not have enough to worry about without this BS.

CaptainMyCaptain · 06/12/2023 12:34

I still don't see the problem. My child saw plenty of ducks at that age but no lions, tigers, elephants etc. She only saw them in books but would have recognised one if she saw it. Surely extending a child's world outside their immediate experience is one of the reasons we have books.

JamieKnows · 06/12/2023 12:26

Valley Ponds has ducks also and by the sounds of it isn't too far from you. But I think the main issue is probably that you'll always have a small world if you stay within walking distance of your house!

Covid did teach us that but it was a tiny snapshot of time. Your dd must've been 18 months old by then and the last 2 years have been fine too.

BarnacleBeasley · 06/12/2023 12:12

I believe you OP about the ducks - I live in a seaside village and we have eider ducks in the harbour but no mallards.

someladdersandsnakes · 06/12/2023 12:10

Rollawaythestone · 06/12/2023 11:51

I stand by the comment. The OP lives in Brighton and very centrally, by the sounds of it. Other people have pointed out that there are parks with ducks in Brighton. People were encouraged to get out of the house during lockdown and have a walk.

JFC
I don't live in central Brighton. I live in Brighton, on the coast. Not central Brighton and nowhere near Queen's Park which was one of the parks mentioned. Another mentioned was in Lancing which is also nowhere near me though we did go there this year once. And Stanmer was mentioned which is far inland and again nowhere near me. There are 4 parks in easy walking distance of my house - 1 is on the beach, 1 has a little forest area but no fresh water, 2 are rec grounds with a playground. During covid we rotated those 4 parks and the beach and went out to one of them every day or twice a day. There were a couple of other parks we would go to for a change, which are a longer walk or very short bus journey, one has a forest and horses and trees but no water. One has a lovely sand area and cafe but no water. Anywhere else was too far away to bother with when we have so many nice outdoor spaces locally that don't take two buses to get to. And no ducks in a single one of them. I'm sorry my local area lacks ducks. Do you still not believe me?

OP posts: