Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all counsellors dealing with their own shitty situations too?

190 replies

Whybeacounsellor · 05/12/2023 23:41

So my DP and I have been noticing a new trend amongst our friends which is that between 45 and 50 they quit professional jobs to retrain as counsellors. Fair enough in a sense that they are of an age to offer some life experience and wisdom because who wants to offload onto a 28 year old?

But what’s striking is that the four people we know are all dealing in their own lives with some mind blowing shit particularly with their families. Person one - son deals drugs and another son was accused of indecent exposure. Husband has been having a very obvious affair but friend won’t accept or admit it. Person two - 3 recent bereavements in a row, one of which was very unexpected. Person three - teenage daughter being brought home by police several times, been expelled, social has got involved. Person four - father caught shoplifting and has brought massive shame on the family because, he’s actually a local solicitor so it’s been very public and in the local paper.

DP isn’t much of a deep thinker and thinks that this is just normal life stuff and has no bearing on a their decision to go into counselling. I on the other hand am more cynical about their motives in changing careers now and think there’s something a bit voyeuristic about wanting to hear about the ‘dirt’ and sad, awful things in other people’s lives. I wonder if they use their job to feel better about their own experiences.

YABU - no of course not, they’re motivated by wanting to help others

YANBU - they are basically driven by a need to know that other people have shitty lives too

OP posts:
Ficklebricks · 06/12/2023 08:20

I knew someone with bipolar who refused to take medication despite obviously struggling with it. She wasn't in a good place mentally, lots of black and white extreme thinking, snap judgements and out of character, risky behaviours. She decided it was the perfect time to train as a counsellor.

It did give me some very serious concerns as I thought she wasn't able to make rational decisions on her own life at the time, let alone advise someone else. I asked her for advice on some rather difficult personal issues and her responses were very odd. If I'd taken her advice I would be in a very different, much worse situation in my life right now. When she was medicated and supported she was an entirely different person with much more balance to her advice.

People who train to counsel others should be screened for more severe mental health issues. Conditions that can impact your interpretation of events and interpersonal relationships should be well managed and under control before they are allowed to guide patients. In the case of more severe conditions, a yearly mental health medical might be in order. Patients are very much at risk and vulnerable, and this is something we lose sight of in our pursuit to be inclusive.

bakedbeansontoastfortea · 06/12/2023 08:18

I know someone who is training to be a marriage counsellor but is openly verbally abusive toward her husband. She berates him in front of others, slags him off all the time and the poor guy looks permanently defeated.

When she shared her plans to retrain with a few of us, there was this stunned, awkward silence. Grin

FrillyGoatFluff · 06/12/2023 08:17

I did the initial counsellor training a few years ago, not to actually do it as a career, but because my stepchildren were dealing with some unimaginable shit that will be ongoing for years and years and I wanted to know how to better support them (as the services they were offered were frankly fucking awful).

The first stage was really helpful in learning listening skills, encouraging people to lead conversations etc, but I can see how (if anyone had known I was doing it) it would have appeared I was jumping career off the back of a trauma.

Maybe some of your friends are using it as a coping mechanism/won't actually go into the job? It's a bit commitment, both emotionally and financially, and frankly, not one id be prepared to make with the hangovers I have from our family circumstances. I think you need to go in with a relatively clean slate in order to not get dragged down.

RainbowRuby · 06/12/2023 08:15

I know 3 girls- aged 30-35 who have refrained as counsellors. 1. Is self absorbed and can’t even clean up after herself and literally sits around backbiting about her MIL who gives 100% of free childcare to her daughter. 2. Selfish and self cantered 3. Batshit crazy

wiseoldcat · 06/12/2023 08:13

Nothingbuttheglory · 06/12/2023 08:03

Most people are going through crap in their life, it is good when people can use those experiences to help other people.

Hm. Counsellors should absolutely not be using their own experiences to help other people though. When in the therapy room it is only about the client, not the counsellor. This is why counsellors have to have their own therapy and supervision - to process and deal with all the trauma that is an inevitable part of living, so that they don't bring their own issues in to their client's therapy.

A few people have mentioned counsellors giving advice - counselling is meant to be more about helping people reach their own decisions, not telling them what to do.

I am not a counsellor but have worked in MH and have had therapy. I chose a therapist with a string of serious qualifications from reputable universities and decades of NHS experience. Expensive but paid for itself in the end. If that/NHS is not an option, I'd strongly recommend looking for therapists/counsellors through reputable organisations like MIND.

It's not about counsellors using their experiences directly or bringing them into the room - it's more about the process they've been through as a result of dealing with their own issues.

Understanding what it is like to feel a certain way or go through a difficult time gives you a perspective and a type of empathy.

Of course they should not bring their own issues into the room. But that doesn't mean they aren't using their own experiences to help others. Our experiences give us perspective and make us who we are - without them, we are nothing .

Experience gives us the ability to relate and understand, and that impacts the relationship and their ability to empathise.

It doesn't mean you need to have had awful life experiences to be a counsellor - nor does it mean you'll automatically be a good counsellor if you have.

But what it can mean is that you have an ability to empathise and understand, and have been though the process yourself, so through your own experience, you have some idea of how the client may be feeling.

daffodilandtulip · 06/12/2023 08:10

It's not limited to unregulated services either. I've worked with two registered mental health nurses with current diagnoses of personality disorder who are being treated while they work, and many many more with other mental health issues. I know a high percentage of the population has mental health issues at any one time, but you have to wonder which came first, and if it's appropriate to be treating people.

mosaicqueen · 06/12/2023 08:07

Nothingbuttheglory · 06/12/2023 08:03

Most people are going through crap in their life, it is good when people can use those experiences to help other people.

Hm. Counsellors should absolutely not be using their own experiences to help other people though. When in the therapy room it is only about the client, not the counsellor. This is why counsellors have to have their own therapy and supervision - to process and deal with all the trauma that is an inevitable part of living, so that they don't bring their own issues in to their client's therapy.

A few people have mentioned counsellors giving advice - counselling is meant to be more about helping people reach their own decisions, not telling them what to do.

I am not a counsellor but have worked in MH and have had therapy. I chose a therapist with a string of serious qualifications from reputable universities and decades of NHS experience. Expensive but paid for itself in the end. If that/NHS is not an option, I'd strongly recommend looking for therapists/counsellors through reputable organisations like MIND.

Yes, it's very important to recognise that just because you have had a similar experience, even the very same experience at the same time, you might have experienced it very differently, so you can't impose your own experience on the other person. This is why proper training is so important.

wildwestpioneer · 06/12/2023 08:06

It's a case of 'do as I say, not as I do'

Nothingbuttheglory · 06/12/2023 08:03

Most people are going through crap in their life, it is good when people can use those experiences to help other people.

Hm. Counsellors should absolutely not be using their own experiences to help other people though. When in the therapy room it is only about the client, not the counsellor. This is why counsellors have to have their own therapy and supervision - to process and deal with all the trauma that is an inevitable part of living, so that they don't bring their own issues in to their client's therapy.

A few people have mentioned counsellors giving advice - counselling is meant to be more about helping people reach their own decisions, not telling them what to do.

I am not a counsellor but have worked in MH and have had therapy. I chose a therapist with a string of serious qualifications from reputable universities and decades of NHS experience. Expensive but paid for itself in the end. If that/NHS is not an option, I'd strongly recommend looking for therapists/counsellors through reputable organisations like MIND.

mosaicqueen · 06/12/2023 08:03

wiseoldcat · 06/12/2023 07:56

I think almost all adult humans are troubled with unresolved issues, and if you start asking them to open up they will.

Counselling training makes you explore your issues and your relationships with yourself and others. That will bring things up for anyone and everyone.

No one is going to sit there in a counselling role play and say 'I'm fine today - no issues, thanks'.

I agree and I have found (professionally and personally) that if you really start talking to people, everyone has something going on in some way.

WickWood · 06/12/2023 08:01

I'm a 28 year old Psychologist, I work for the NHS in a specialist service (think schizophrenia) and have no issues working with people of all ages, from 14 to 65. I've worked in MH all my life, I don't have lived experience, but nor do I pretend to, and I am still able to relate and empathise with my service users.

As above, counselling psychologists are regulated, it requires a doctorate etc, whereas anyone can do a 'counselling course' and technically call themselves a counsellor.

All the psychologists I know via the NHS are lovely, lovely people.

mosaicqueen · 06/12/2023 08:00

CharlotteRumpling · 06/12/2023 07:50

Most counsellors I know have been very fragile themselves and with a incredible number of issues. I have ended up having zero confidence in them. Maybe I have had bad luck.

At one time I was enrolled in a Masters of Counselling. A highly competitive course with very careful selection. I've known a lot of counsellors. I didn't finish as I decided to go off in a tangent direction. All the counsellors I've known were just standard everyday people, some with challenges in life, some less so. Some I would have felt more confident talking to than others. Many were doing it because of their current career and wanting to develop counselling skills, not because they wanted to become counsellors but because they wanted to be better at supporting those they already worked with.

I did it because I seemed to be good at it, I found it really satisfying to see people do well through it, and I genuinely cared.

I don't plan to work directly as a counsellor but I wouldn't hesitate to seek out one if I needed it.

PinkTeaForMe · 06/12/2023 07:58

*Do you know who make really good counsellors? People who don't judge other people based on what's happening in their lives/ their income/ their past.

*Exactly this. I can't believe how judgemental this post is. As far as I'm concerned I would much rather talk to someone who has had their own lived experience and can empathise when someone is struggling with their mental health.

wiseoldcat · 06/12/2023 07:56

nonsensicalmess · 06/12/2023 07:49

I started training years ago but didn't see it through. The class was full of people with serious issues themselves who obviously saw it as some sort of outlet (we had counselling role play sessions as part of the training so a LOT came up). It was really startling - I think a lot of troubled individuals with unresolved issues are drawn to it.

I think almost all adult humans are troubled with unresolved issues, and if you start asking them to open up they will.

Counselling training makes you explore your issues and your relationships with yourself and others. That will bring things up for anyone and everyone.

No one is going to sit there in a counselling role play and say 'I'm fine today - no issues, thanks'.

Yaros · 06/12/2023 07:56

I think having your own shit can really help as a therapist for insight and empathy. My personal experience brought me a therapist who was the right combination of Gabor Mate and Jordan Peterson. He was completely empathetic and gave you an ass kick every session. You need to be pretty together to carry that off no matter what your background, this guy was more together than either Mate or Peterson.

CharlotteRumpling · 06/12/2023 07:55

I dont think they are voyeuristic. I think a great many counsellors and life coaches are narcissistic and have very little life experience.

I have just got to the stage in my life where I am distrustful of a lot of therapy speak and the enabling of victimhood. I recognise the need for empathy but so many family members have reported the same thing, and found it far more helpful to take up a sport or hobby.

Unicorndoorstopper · 06/12/2023 07:55

I’m a psychotherapist and I agree with the PP saying many people training are back door clients.
A good robust training will last 3 years or more and you will be required to have a minimum or around 35 hours per year of your own personal therapy. The rational for this is, your clients can only go as far as you have gone. If you are still holding onto unprocessed issues it may cause a blind spot and you can’t support your client.

The idea of a wounded healer, that someone who has suffered pain is well placed to support others, is common in the field. However, the person can only do so when they have fully recovered and processed their wounds.
I am registered with the UKCP a voluntary registration body, but it really gets my goat when I see unqualified and unprofessional people running things such as ‘womb therapy’ or birth trauma circles, when their biggest skill set seems to be marketing.
As for the person above saying it’s a way to get rich, I wish! According to BACP 71% of their members are earning under £30,000.

baroqueandblue · 06/12/2023 07:54

mosaicqueen · 06/12/2023 07:45

Not the poster you're replying to but it is considered unethical to counsel someone you have a relationship with or know. It's called a dual relationship. Just as doctors don't treat family members, a counsellor can't operate dual relationships. There are a lot of issues with this.

Agree that counsellors are required to consider the potential implications of dual relationships, but that term isn't supposed to be applied to the nth degree. If it were, we would have lots of highly trained effective counsellors who aren't allowed to use their skills to help others in varying levels of distress outwith rigid 'professional' contexts and fee-paying arrangements. Such deprivation of liberty would be unethical. The previous poster described their counsellor as an acquaintance, which is a very different thing to family or friendship.

oldcrinkle · 06/12/2023 07:52

Should add that the 'retraining' was in the evenings and weekends and I never did paid work it was all voluntary on top of my full time job.

wiseoldcat · 06/12/2023 07:52

CharlotteRumpling · 06/12/2023 07:50

Most counsellors I know have been very fragile themselves and with a incredible number of issues. I have ended up having zero confidence in them. Maybe I have had bad luck.

If you know about your counsellor's issues then they are failing as counsellors.

So yes, I think you have had bad luck.

oldcrinkle · 06/12/2023 07:51

I trained to be a counsellor 15 years ago in my 30s. I did it because I'd had a shit time in the past and counselling helped me.

It's not about wanting to know other peoples' shit. In fact that was that put me off after a couple of years so much self indulgent twaddle - though obviously there was serious stuff too.

You have to have counselling yourself when you're training and practicing.

wiseoldcat · 06/12/2023 07:50

I think your use of the word 'voyeuristic' in this context is unreasonable.

You are right that people go into counselling for all sorts of reasons and sometimes (even often) they have had difficult life experiences themselves.

This isn't mutually exclusive with wanting to help others.

Going through difficult things gives us a life experience, perspective and empathy. All very useful things when thinking about helping others.

Perhaps some individuals are 'voyeuristic' - you know these individual friends - but as a general rule one thing does not lead to the other.

CharlotteRumpling · 06/12/2023 07:50

Most counsellors I know have been very fragile themselves and with a incredible number of issues. I have ended up having zero confidence in them. Maybe I have had bad luck.

nonsensicalmess · 06/12/2023 07:49

I started training years ago but didn't see it through. The class was full of people with serious issues themselves who obviously saw it as some sort of outlet (we had counselling role play sessions as part of the training so a LOT came up). It was really startling - I think a lot of troubled individuals with unresolved issues are drawn to it.

mosaicqueen · 06/12/2023 07:49

FaiIureToLunch · 06/12/2023 07:47

I’ve never known a psychologist who has been completely balanced. Every single one I know has deep seated issues.

But that’s not to say it’s not
motivated by altruism. It’s a tough job and they have my respect.

I've never known a human being who is completely balanced and who doesn't have some sort of issue. The older they get, the more likely they are to have some sort of serious trauma. Psychologists and counsellors are no exception to the human condition.

Swipe left for the next trending thread