Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all counsellors dealing with their own shitty situations too?

190 replies

Whybeacounsellor · 05/12/2023 23:41

So my DP and I have been noticing a new trend amongst our friends which is that between 45 and 50 they quit professional jobs to retrain as counsellors. Fair enough in a sense that they are of an age to offer some life experience and wisdom because who wants to offload onto a 28 year old?

But what’s striking is that the four people we know are all dealing in their own lives with some mind blowing shit particularly with their families. Person one - son deals drugs and another son was accused of indecent exposure. Husband has been having a very obvious affair but friend won’t accept or admit it. Person two - 3 recent bereavements in a row, one of which was very unexpected. Person three - teenage daughter being brought home by police several times, been expelled, social has got involved. Person four - father caught shoplifting and has brought massive shame on the family because, he’s actually a local solicitor so it’s been very public and in the local paper.

DP isn’t much of a deep thinker and thinks that this is just normal life stuff and has no bearing on a their decision to go into counselling. I on the other hand am more cynical about their motives in changing careers now and think there’s something a bit voyeuristic about wanting to hear about the ‘dirt’ and sad, awful things in other people’s lives. I wonder if they use their job to feel better about their own experiences.

YABU - no of course not, they’re motivated by wanting to help others

YANBU - they are basically driven by a need to know that other people have shitty lives too

OP posts:
Whybeacounsellor · 06/12/2023 09:04

@BrunhildefromDusseldorf are you going to report this man? That’s a very sickening thought that he has contact with children through his job.

OP posts:
Whybeacounsellor · 06/12/2023 09:02

Foxblue · 06/12/2023 08:58

I actually agree with your husband in that 'everyone has shit'

I think some people are just better at hiding it than others, or choose not to publicise their experiences/mental health issues/mistakes.

All the 'lovely' people around you will have also gone through awful shit, or done awful things, because that is the nature of being human - we are complex.

So while yes, I understand completely being concerned about certain people because of what you know, and I might feel the same, I am quick to remind myself that what I don't know about other people is infinite, so the most suitable, perfect person could have all sorts of skeletons.

It's an interesting one for sure! If I was depressed, I think id prefer a counsellor who had been through it? Or if I was going through a divorce etc.

Yes ofc most people go through awful times at periods in their lives but my point is that the people I know decided to retrain mid-life having only recently gotten through a horrible time or while still getting through it, I’m thinking particularly of the poor bereaved friend.

OP posts:
BrunhildefromDusseldorf · 06/12/2023 09:02

I would hope it's more a case that they have experienced difficulties so feel able to empathise with and help others. I know two people who retrained as counsellors.

  1. Nice woman. Crunchy, hippie. Tended to talk about herself A LOT .
  1. Relative. His listening skills are appalling and he seems to lack sensitivity. He cheated on his wife recently with prostitutes in Thailand. He is a children's counsellor. Oh and he displayed such greed over his claim on the spoils of my dead parent's estate. Am dreading seeing him at Xmas.

Make of that what you will!

Toddlerteaplease · 06/12/2023 09:01

A friend of mine who is special guardian for her great nephews and nieces, has also done this. All three of the kids have massive behavioural issues. Partly nature, but also nurture.

Whybeacounsellor · 06/12/2023 08:59

Gorjus · 06/12/2023 08:40

This reminds me of the wounded healer archetype.

Yes, this is my point. Great label, wounded healer.

OP posts:
Foxblue · 06/12/2023 08:58

I actually agree with your husband in that 'everyone has shit'

I think some people are just better at hiding it than others, or choose not to publicise their experiences/mental health issues/mistakes.

All the 'lovely' people around you will have also gone through awful shit, or done awful things, because that is the nature of being human - we are complex.

So while yes, I understand completely being concerned about certain people because of what you know, and I might feel the same, I am quick to remind myself that what I don't know about other people is infinite, so the most suitable, perfect person could have all sorts of skeletons.

It's an interesting one for sure! If I was depressed, I think id prefer a counsellor who had been through it? Or if I was going through a divorce etc.

cornflakesandtea · 06/12/2023 08:58

I know 4 people who have retrained as a counsellor / therapist / life coach and I wouldn't take advice from any of them for the same reasons as you, OP. Obviously it's better if you don't know your counsellor because they could be great if you don't know their background and how shitty their own lives are.

Whybeacounsellor · 06/12/2023 08:58

nonsensicalmess · 06/12/2023 07:49

I started training years ago but didn't see it through. The class was full of people with serious issues themselves who obviously saw it as some sort of outlet (we had counselling role play sessions as part of the training so a LOT came up). It was really startling - I think a lot of troubled individuals with unresolved issues are drawn to it.

Yes, this is what I am seeing. It’s very interesting to read the replies here, there must be a wider discussion to be had about the training and motivation of the people who decide to enter this profession. Funny a few of you mentioned life coaching as an ex work colleague is doing this now, god knows why as she was awful at the job but I think having a wealthy husband must help!

What does someone who calls themselves a counsellor and who may or may not be registered, earn? Is it worth giving up a job for?

OP posts:
Worried2000 · 06/12/2023 08:55

WickWood · 06/12/2023 08:01

I'm a 28 year old Psychologist, I work for the NHS in a specialist service (think schizophrenia) and have no issues working with people of all ages, from 14 to 65. I've worked in MH all my life, I don't have lived experience, but nor do I pretend to, and I am still able to relate and empathise with my service users.

As above, counselling psychologists are regulated, it requires a doctorate etc, whereas anyone can do a 'counselling course' and technically call themselves a counsellor.

All the psychologists I know via the NHS are lovely, lovely people.

All BACP & NCPS registered counsellors have been trained to a certain standard ( Level 4 Diploma and above) they will be insured and registered with the ICO if working in private practice. It's not a case of just doing any old counselling course. You are being rather dismissive to be honest and don't know your facts.

Iwishmynamewassheilah · 06/12/2023 08:40

easilydistracted1 · 06/12/2023 00:26

@Whybeacounsellor neither counsellor nor therapist is a protected title. Or play therapist. Or I think even psychotherapist. There are people who call themselves play therapists or art therapists who have done a one day course where as my training is 3-4 years. As @Lavender14 says a reputable counsellor will register with a voluntary regulatory body but its not a legal requirement. Social workers, drs, nurses need to be registered. Counsellor and therapy is much less regulated

The psychotherapist title is an interesting example. AFAIK "registered psychotherapist" is protected but plain old psychotherapist is not. It really is a case of buyer beware.

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 08:39

Ascubudr · 06/12/2023 07:41

That is deeply unethical.

Yes, very unethical, not just in terms of dual relationship, but also a lack of boundaries.

I can’t see this going well for the counsellor if they’re registered with a counselling organisation and the acquaintance makes a complaint.

mosaicqueen · 06/12/2023 08:33

Clarinet1 · 06/12/2023 08:31

I agree that there are a lot of unregulated and poorly trained counsellors and therapists out there - it is very much a case of caveat emptor and, of course, vulnerable, fragile potential clients may well not be in a headspace to make a good choice.
However a good counsellor or therapist can
help enormously. In terms of whether they are going through or have gone through “stuff” themselves, well they almost certainly have. It is OK for this to inform their work “in the background” but what is not OK is for them to be telling clients “Oh yes, I’ve been divorced three times” or “I’m terrified I’ve got cancer” or whatever.
In terms of the risk of dual relationship, I think is is totally unacceptable for a professional to give a friend formal counselling or therapy but, obviously, when a friend comes to them with an issue, their professional experience and training is going to influence what they say and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that.

Edited

Agree. I've agreed to meet people I know for coffee to discuss things with them but I've made it very clear that I am meeting them as a friend, not as a professional.

ALightOverThere · 06/12/2023 08:33

Counselling psychologists have supervisors who they can talk to to deal with the mental stress of listening to other people’s problems- this includes where something a client is talking about triggers something for the psychologist. There are also clear ethical rules about how to act (or not act) when this happens.

I wouldn’t see anyone who was not qualified. Reminds me of when Jeremy became a life coach in Peep Show.

WomanFromTheNorth · 06/12/2023 08:33

I started a counselling course at college; well, I went along with a friend who wanted to do it but didn't want to go alone. What I hadn't realised is that when you train to be a counselor, most of the "training" is focused on you. So you have to really explore yourself and open up to others and talk about yourself etc. Lots of the people there had "issues" that they were working around. So I suppose that the truth is that we all have issues and to be a good counsellor you need to identify and deal with your own shit first - which is kind of what they do in training. I guess that then some people feel that they want to use that to help others? I don't know. I didn't last long on the course; I'm far too English to sit around in a circle sharing my feelings and crying. I just couldn't do it. But I think it's a good thing.

Clarinet1 · 06/12/2023 08:31

I agree that there are a lot of unregulated and poorly trained counsellors and therapists out there - it is very much a case of caveat emptor and, of course, vulnerable, fragile potential clients may well not be in a headspace to make a good choice.
However a good counsellor or therapist can
help enormously. In terms of whether they are going through or have gone through “stuff” themselves, well they almost certainly have. It is OK for this to inform their work “in the background” but what is not OK is for them to be telling clients “Oh yes, I’ve been divorced three times” or “I’m terrified I’ve got cancer” or whatever.
In terms of the risk of dual relationship, I think is is totally unacceptable for a professional to give a friend formal counselling or therapy but, obviously, when a friend comes to them with an issue, their professional experience and training is going to influence what they say and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that.

Koalatreats · 06/12/2023 08:30

Counselling regulations in the U.K. are shocking. A relative showed me a text from his counsellor - a very misogynistic text (saying he won’t counsel feminists) that wouldn’t have been out of place in an incel forum.

Scarily this ‘counsellor’ does relationship counselling and sees women alone in his office. I doubt they know his real views.

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 08:30

Do you know who make really good counsellors? People who don't judge other people based on what's happening in their lives/ their income/ their past.

I agree with this but do think that having personal counselling should be mandatory on all qualifying counselling or psychotherapy courses, as it was on mine (a post grad course). The very best therapy helps you become more self-aware and that’s something you need if you’re going to be a truly effective therapist. From what I understand, on Levels 4 and 5 courses you do in FE colleges, personal therapy is generally encouraged but it’s not mandatory.

mosaicqueen · 06/12/2023 08:29

TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/12/2023 08:24

I studied psychology at university and have various friends who went on to be clinical or educational psychologists. They are totally normal people with the usual ups and downs - they work hard with some very difficult situations, because that is what professionally qualified psychologists in the NHS do.

Over the years I have also seen half a dozen people I know change direction and become life coaches, counsellors etc. Their qualifications are variable and I would have to say the change came from problems in their own life, and I would not take advice from any one of them. BUT I believe their motives are good - it is not that they want to be privy to other people's problems, it is just that they want to give others the support they have found helpful.

I don't think it's about giving the support they found helpful. I entered professional training without a single day of counselling or professional support of any kind under my belt.

wishingiwas20something · 06/12/2023 08:28

Your friends sound very interesting, no dullards on your watch. Sounds like all of you have some very valuable life experiences with which to guide others.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 08:26

I can counsellors in my teenage years, when I was being bullied in later life at work and then briefly over lockdown.

I can honestly say hand on heart there are only 2 out of those counsellors who were any good. The rest were very questionable including one who tried to put it into my head at 20 that all my issues stemmed from my DM (they didn’t and I told her so!) and then wanted me to punch cushions to let out my anger (didn’t want to do either of those) and when we finished our sessions completely asked me to choose a small ornament from her “shrine” to help me, I felt awkward and did it but it meant nothing to me! Comparing her to a counsellor I had before who was lovely and listened (and gave feedback) and I felt after our sessions that a weight had been lifted off my shoulders.

Training of counsellors helps a lot too though. And also life experiences.

thedukeofbuckinghamshire · 06/12/2023 08:24

It does seem to be a bit of thing - I have two friends who have retrained as counsellors, from professional roles, but they are both extremely intelligent and lovely, lovely generous people.

CurlewKate · 06/12/2023 08:24

Proper training and supervision will help them decide whether it's the career for them.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 06/12/2023 08:24

I studied psychology at university and have various friends who went on to be clinical or educational psychologists. They are totally normal people with the usual ups and downs - they work hard with some very difficult situations, because that is what professionally qualified psychologists in the NHS do.

Over the years I have also seen half a dozen people I know change direction and become life coaches, counsellors etc. Their qualifications are variable and I would have to say the change came from problems in their own life, and I would not take advice from any one of them. BUT I believe their motives are good - it is not that they want to be privy to other people's problems, it is just that they want to give others the support they have found helpful.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 06/12/2023 08:21

I think it’s somewhere between the two, possibly? Or perhaps that they want to help others but also want to be able to solve something. I’ve often wondered this but more in the context of friends who had MH problems and anorexia and go in to professional jobs involved with those straight away. I think there may also be an element there of wanting to stay in a world where they feel comfortable.