Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all counsellors dealing with their own shitty situations too?

190 replies

Whybeacounsellor · 05/12/2023 23:41

So my DP and I have been noticing a new trend amongst our friends which is that between 45 and 50 they quit professional jobs to retrain as counsellors. Fair enough in a sense that they are of an age to offer some life experience and wisdom because who wants to offload onto a 28 year old?

But what’s striking is that the four people we know are all dealing in their own lives with some mind blowing shit particularly with their families. Person one - son deals drugs and another son was accused of indecent exposure. Husband has been having a very obvious affair but friend won’t accept or admit it. Person two - 3 recent bereavements in a row, one of which was very unexpected. Person three - teenage daughter being brought home by police several times, been expelled, social has got involved. Person four - father caught shoplifting and has brought massive shame on the family because, he’s actually a local solicitor so it’s been very public and in the local paper.

DP isn’t much of a deep thinker and thinks that this is just normal life stuff and has no bearing on a their decision to go into counselling. I on the other hand am more cynical about their motives in changing careers now and think there’s something a bit voyeuristic about wanting to hear about the ‘dirt’ and sad, awful things in other people’s lives. I wonder if they use their job to feel better about their own experiences.

YABU - no of course not, they’re motivated by wanting to help others

YANBU - they are basically driven by a need to know that other people have shitty lives too

OP posts:
Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 20:43

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 18:57

No, a counsellor is also a therapist.

Have you any idea what kind of training is involved to be a qualified counsellor? It’s not something you get qualified in just a few months, or year. It is emotionally shredding and, generally, rigorous.

@benfoldsfivefan, Glad you’ve corrected @Crunched.

It’s quite worrying really when a lot of people are taken in by the difference between a therapist and counsellor and giving my own example earlier when I was unsure re listening therapy, in my defence my DM had me referred by our GP to the NHS listening counsellor/therapist and she just went along with it. When the NHS stopped funding my therapy when I left school as I recall one of DM’s therapists was a psychotherapist with links to a reputable organisation (I can’t recall it at all now) and it was felt by us both that I needed this and DM funded it for me with research from both of us. I paid for this when I worked (full price) but when I went into full time education I found a reduced price therapist which DM then paid for.

If people here are taken in by the definitions then Joe Public of course is quite likely to be taken in by this too! There really needs to be far more strident regulations around these therapists/counsellors, it seems to me.

LittleMissSunshiner · 06/12/2023 20:40

love223 · 06/12/2023 19:04

as a counsellor of many years, who has done long term work with many clients, looking at both conscious and unconscious processes, I can say that there isn't much to separate a "therapist" from a counsellor. Except you'll pay much more to see a psychotherapist and psychologist, obviously!
There's more theory and academia involved on the route to being a psychotherapist or psychologist, but that doesn't necessarily translate to
being good at sitting with people and really supporting and helping them in the midst of their difficulties/trauma. (and I speak both as a counsellor and a client, having seen both counsellors, psychotherapists and psychologists throughout the course
of my life, mostly as part of my training but also on a personal level, as the parent of an autistic child)

Don't forget 'psychoanalysis' in all of this though.

I had a psychoanalyst (truly most sickest person mentally and physically I've ever met in my life) via the NHS once. She had fourteen years training including medical degree, psychiatry degree, PhD, post graduate everything under the sun and all the analytic therapy stuff.

She was abs batshit crazy and said some things that were deeply insane so I had to complain about her. She went off sick and never came back. How odd. She was also very clearly and openly severely physically ill.

LittleMissSunshiner · 06/12/2023 20:34

Crunched · 06/12/2023 18:06

Counsellors and therapists are different.
Counsellors work with conscious processes and thoughts.Therapists work with the conscious, subconscious and unconscious processes and thoughts.
Most importantly therapists have in depth training with a possible area of specialism, including extensive training with personal development
component and psychiatric placements, and are likely to have areas of specialism.
Counselling may help with more surface type difficulties and
current problems. Therapy helps with current and past difficulties which require in depth processing and psyche changes.
Counselling is usually a short to mid term process, therapy is usually a medium to long term process.
It boils my blood when someone sets up as a life coach/counsellor, and some assume they are equivalent to a therapist who is likely to have trained for a minimum of 5 years at university level plus placements in medical settings.

This is absolute rubbish in general, sorry, there's many modalities

Here's some facts

Counsellors, therapists, and psychotherapist
CAN BE
completely unqualified people who are only working on taking your money week in week out and have no training and no process whatsoever.

Or they can have done a couple of short courses or even some part time course or perhaps a whole couple of years training and be fully disinterested in anything whatsoever apart from your money money money and their loft conversion / holidays / kids school fees.

Or they could be highly qualified and still a con artist / rapist

True story: most senior member of staff working at the leading Personality Disorder service in N London with vulnerable young women was sacked on the spot aged 59 for raping female clients IN THEIR SESSIONS AT THE NHS BUILDING. Keith Broadbent. Google him. Don't suppose he suddenly took up his crappy grooming rapey habit at the age of 59 so that would be a forty year career of sexual abuse in the name of being a therapist.

love223 · 06/12/2023 19:13

and yes, I'm not sure where the idea
comes from; that counsellors
work only with short term clients and only on here and now topics. Not true.

love223 · 06/12/2023 19:04

as a counsellor of many years, who has done long term work with many clients, looking at both conscious and unconscious processes, I can say that there isn't much to separate a "therapist" from a counsellor. Except you'll pay much more to see a psychotherapist and psychologist, obviously!
There's more theory and academia involved on the route to being a psychotherapist or psychologist, but that doesn't necessarily translate to
being good at sitting with people and really supporting and helping them in the midst of their difficulties/trauma. (and I speak both as a counsellor and a client, having seen both counsellors, psychotherapists and psychologists throughout the course
of my life, mostly as part of my training but also on a personal level, as the parent of an autistic child)

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 18:57

Crunched · 06/12/2023 18:06

Counsellors and therapists are different.
Counsellors work with conscious processes and thoughts.Therapists work with the conscious, subconscious and unconscious processes and thoughts.
Most importantly therapists have in depth training with a possible area of specialism, including extensive training with personal development
component and psychiatric placements, and are likely to have areas of specialism.
Counselling may help with more surface type difficulties and
current problems. Therapy helps with current and past difficulties which require in depth processing and psyche changes.
Counselling is usually a short to mid term process, therapy is usually a medium to long term process.
It boils my blood when someone sets up as a life coach/counsellor, and some assume they are equivalent to a therapist who is likely to have trained for a minimum of 5 years at university level plus placements in medical settings.

No, a counsellor is also a therapist.

Have you any idea what kind of training is involved to be a qualified counsellor? It’s not something you get qualified in just a few months, or year. It is emotionally shredding and, generally, rigorous.

adventcake · 06/12/2023 18:10

I have watched over years a very disturbed relative insert herself into positions of trust involving vulnerable people who have no choice about the staff around them. It was upsetting to see the way she seemed to revel in badmouthing these people and sharing their private mental health issues etc at family dinners. Completely unprofessional and seemingly done for attention - the more shocking and gory the more she would smile whilst telling despite being told she was totally out of order - shameless.

She has furthered this career by doing a very short "counselling" course run as a sort of evening class via a prestigious uni and then went on to market herself as being a graduate of said uni (not the original college she scraped through).

This is someone utterly shallow who seems to me to be blatantly targeting vulnerable people for personal gain. A manipulative power tripper who lacks the conscience or morals (or intellect) to behave in a professional structured manner in the service of others. A charlatan - ice cold.

I don't think this is unusual in this line of work and I think the numbers increased massively over the pandemic when people were looking about for extra income.

I have dealt with counselling services personally via bereavement and found recently the services on offer are not what they used to be. One person I was referred to only made it 10 minutes into the first session before I had to withdraw, the level of arrogance, presumption and general naivety was unacceptable. When I complained to the service provider nothing was done, it was seen as my issue not theirs, there was no wish to resolve any problem or help me.

Crunched · 06/12/2023 18:06

Counsellors and therapists are different.
Counsellors work with conscious processes and thoughts.Therapists work with the conscious, subconscious and unconscious processes and thoughts.
Most importantly therapists have in depth training with a possible area of specialism, including extensive training with personal development
component and psychiatric placements, and are likely to have areas of specialism.
Counselling may help with more surface type difficulties and
current problems. Therapy helps with current and past difficulties which require in depth processing and psyche changes.
Counselling is usually a short to mid term process, therapy is usually a medium to long term process.
It boils my blood when someone sets up as a life coach/counsellor, and some assume they are equivalent to a therapist who is likely to have trained for a minimum of 5 years at university level plus placements in medical settings.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 17:41

romdowa · 06/12/2023 13:42

It's very common among addiction councillors to either have a history of addiction themselves or in their families. People see how talking therapy helped them and want to help others in the same way

@romdowa physician heal thyself springs to mind.

I think at least 2 of the people I mentioned here had addiction issues though they may not be addiction counsellors. I’m sure one of them goes into that with her clients (her addiction history) if they ask. Like I said some people I don’t trust an inch.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 17:37

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 13:44

You may be thinking of the stereotype of person-centred therapy, which isn’t only about listening skills. There’s no type of therapy about there where the therapist only listens but perhaps some people are out there doing this (and shouldn’t be).

I can’t think of the therapy but I certainly had this as a teenager through the local health authority, I spoke and he made notes, never interacted with me apart from hello and goodbye. The other therapists up til I was 20 were similar but would engage occasionally with me, it was more about listening rather than offering advice. I wish I could recall which area it was maybe psychotherapy? Maybe therapies have moved on since then as this was over 30 years ago!

ConstantRain · 06/12/2023 15:12

I agree that most people don't just want to be listened to and validated. They want help to move on.
I think some of the good counsellors do give 'suggestions' in a roundabout way. The counsellor guides very gently and because they pick up on the client, they're able to guide them along the clients own lines. Well, mostly, the client ends up guiding themself.
I come into contact with a lot of counsellors and the good ones are really good and you can tell.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 13:46

LittleMissSunshiner · 06/12/2023 13:40

Well this is how it would work in a functional and helpful way.

Many counsellors / therapists don't go there. They want to keep you trapped in 'venting'. Venting has been scientifically proven to be addictive. I've read up on this and been to seminars about it.

I saw an excellent speech by Peter Fornagy on the subject a few years ago. Venting meets the same 'satisfaction' neural zones as using an addictive substance and it also now shown to be demonstrably unhelpful and even harmful in therapy to facilitate a client to vent.

Many psychologists and psychiatrists have written on the subject of therapists wanting people trapped in repeat custom, luring them for two sessions a week 'I have to speak to my therapist about this!' and going nowhere and keeping them for multiple years with no end in sight. I had a therapist once who told me she sees her clients all their lives. I was being funded by my local authority to see her. She was rubbish. I dumped her after three years as my mental health had descended into acting on suicide territory. Another one who then got angry and told her I owed her money (I absolutely did not and I even gave her some to shut her up and make her go away). Wow.

Agreed with some counsellors wanting to keep their clients trapped into paying for them forever. I had an ex boyfriend who did this with his counsellor and he’d seen her for years with not much improvement (his words!) and basically just whinged about his pampered life to her. When I suggested maybe she saw his custom as an easy way to make money he got quite shirty with me!

Yaros · 06/12/2023 13:44

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 13:37

Ok other therapists employ listening therapy only. I don’t know the term for that therapy.

Many counsellors / therapists don't go there. They want to keep you trapped in 'venting'. Venting has been scientifically proven to be addictive. I've read up on this and been to seminars about it.

That makes sense get stuck in righteous anger, dopamine hits but it definitely doesn’t qualify as therapeutic.

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 13:44

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 13:37

Ok other therapists employ listening therapy only. I don’t know the term for that therapy.

You may be thinking of the stereotype of person-centred therapy, which isn’t only about listening skills. There’s no type of therapy about there where the therapist only listens but perhaps some people are out there doing this (and shouldn’t be).

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 13:43

Yaros · 06/12/2023 13:32

But they're not allowed to interject with advice or ideas.

I don’t think it is about a counsellor giving their own ideas though, it is about moving the client through the venting stage in a session or how ever many sessions and then moving to the next productive part of the sessions where the client proposes and evaluates their own solutions to the issues. For example my therapist never advised me on anything, he mirrored back my solutions if that makes sense and tried to focus on what was in my control. There are a lot of the “and what do you think might be the possible courses of action you could take“ type comments. Then evaluation of those options, correcting thinking distortions along the way.

Edited

@Yaros what you’ve said actually makes me a bit annoyed and worried about a counsellor’s stages, which I stated I underwent when I was 19/20 and involved her blaming my mother for all my problems when I told her this wasn’t the case, getting me to hit cushions when I didn’t want to do so and then wanting to increase the price of the session after 6 months knowing that I couldn’t afford that and telling me about her own bills and that was why she was increasing the costs. If that’s a good example of moving a client through stages then I’d have to disagree with it all.

Mirroring can be useful with some clients but not all. It can be quite a lazy way to give therapy I find.

Couple Love GIF by JellaCreative
romdowa · 06/12/2023 13:42

It's very common among addiction councillors to either have a history of addiction themselves or in their families. People see how talking therapy helped them and want to help others in the same way

LittleMissSunshiner · 06/12/2023 13:40

Yaros · 06/12/2023 13:32

But they're not allowed to interject with advice or ideas.

I don’t think it is about a counsellor giving their own ideas though, it is about moving the client through the venting stage in a session or how ever many sessions and then moving to the next productive part of the sessions where the client proposes and evaluates their own solutions to the issues. For example my therapist never advised me on anything, he mirrored back my solutions if that makes sense and tried to focus on what was in my control. There are a lot of the “and what do you think might be the possible courses of action you could take“ type comments. Then evaluation of those options, correcting thinking distortions along the way.

Edited

Well this is how it would work in a functional and helpful way.

Many counsellors / therapists don't go there. They want to keep you trapped in 'venting'. Venting has been scientifically proven to be addictive. I've read up on this and been to seminars about it.

I saw an excellent speech by Peter Fornagy on the subject a few years ago. Venting meets the same 'satisfaction' neural zones as using an addictive substance and it also now shown to be demonstrably unhelpful and even harmful in therapy to facilitate a client to vent.

Many psychologists and psychiatrists have written on the subject of therapists wanting people trapped in repeat custom, luring them for two sessions a week 'I have to speak to my therapist about this!' and going nowhere and keeping them for multiple years with no end in sight. I had a therapist once who told me she sees her clients all their lives. I was being funded by my local authority to see her. She was rubbish. I dumped her after three years as my mental health had descended into acting on suicide territory. Another one who then got angry and told her I owed her money (I absolutely did not and I even gave her some to shut her up and make her go away). Wow.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 13:37

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 13:14

some counsellors are there to listen and not to counsel.

Again, nope. All counsellors counsel.

Ok other therapists employ listening therapy only. I don’t know the term for that therapy.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 13:35

wudubelieveit · 06/12/2023 09:11

i think you may have meant this but just to clarify ,the following ARE protected titles: Art psychotherapist ; Art therapist ; Drama therapist ; Music therapist . All of these HAVE to be registered with the HCPC,should be on the register and all have done a significant amount of training and are in clinical supervision. So anyone claiming to be any of these, having done 1 day of training should be reported to the HCPC.
www.hcpc-uk.org/concerns/what-we-investigate/misuse-of-title/

I know personally someone who’s an art therapist and I won’t detail her situation here because it’s very outing. I don’t see her much now as she was more of a childhood and teenage years friend and we lost touch later on in life but her own family background has been very dramatic and has damaged both her and her close family immeasurably. I’m sure she’s a perfectly good art psychotherapist (she’s moved on from art therapy) but knowing her background I’d maybe be slightly wary of engaging her and would require strict controls as to the therapy and anything she says to clients which may be relevant to her own experience.

Someone else also mentioned other types of therapy. Again I know someone from my teenage years and into adult years who’s had a lot of trauma from a young age and on her website considers herself to be a “natural healer”. She loves to talk too but has tried to sign me up for a free session of her therapy which involves life purpose, goals and challenges, this was after I reached out to her giving her forgiveness for bullying me at school. She basically wanted me to pay for her sessions and got quite abusive verbally when I reached out to her at another time to ask her a question and told me she’d “been very busy dealing with clients who pay a high premium for my sought after services”. What’s extremely worrying and dangerous is that someone like this person claims from their own personal experience to be able to cure themselves from a serious illness without medical intervention, which gives the impression to me that she can also do this for her patients.

I know a professional life coach who has her own successful business doing this for careers for a certain business sector so I know what a good life coach/career coach looks like and what a bad one or mediocre one looks like.

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 13:34

Should have said that all counsellors should be counselling. It’s a shit counsellor who only listens to the client. There’s a vast gulf between counselling and listening.

Yaros · 06/12/2023 13:32

But they're not allowed to interject with advice or ideas.

I don’t think it is about a counsellor giving their own ideas though, it is about moving the client through the venting stage in a session or how ever many sessions and then moving to the next productive part of the sessions where the client proposes and evaluates their own solutions to the issues. For example my therapist never advised me on anything, he mirrored back my solutions if that makes sense and tried to focus on what was in my control. There are a lot of the “and what do you think might be the possible courses of action you could take“ type comments. Then evaluation of those options, correcting thinking distortions along the way.

LittleMissSunshiner · 06/12/2023 13:25

benfoldsfivefan · 06/12/2023 13:14

some counsellors are there to listen and not to counsel.

Again, nope. All counsellors counsel.

This isn't true.

There's a very well known two year part time counselling course run by a local community college in C Lon. I can't count the number of people I've known over the years that have taken that course. Thanks be to god most of them don't and have never worked as counsellors. It must be quite a good course also a quite a lot of them get 'failed' or told to take time out because they can't progress to stage 2 due to their own personal issues, which is a healthy thing.

But I've heard it time after time them saying about they're there to listen and basically they learn little phrases to repeat and affirm what the person has said 'so, you feel angry with your husband?'. The typical 'and how do you feel about that?' type counsellors.

But they're not allowed to interject with advice or ideas. I've had this kind of counselling myself, it's infuriating. I don't want to be listened to and parroted, I want suggestion, advice, ideas, solutions, points of view, that are coming from outside of my own (sick) thinking. But they're not allowed to do that.

One friend who trained like this and works told me when a person directly asks 'what should I do?' or 'what do you think?' she's trained to say back 'what do you think you should do?' or 'it's not what I think that matters it's what you think'. UGhhhh talk about someone keeping you stuck in the bell jar.

She charges £80 p/h for what it's worth.

Yaros · 06/12/2023 13:24

@Yaros , some counsellors are there to listen and not to counsel. In fact the definition of counsellor is:- “a person trained to give guidance on personal or psychological problems”.

From my reading of that definition it suggests that counselling involves actual counselling. I would suggest that actually it is more there are good and bad counsellors out there.

giftofporridge · 06/12/2023 13:22

I think many people go into the profession having experienced difficulties or poor mental health which they've been able to overcome or heal from due to having therapy themselves. Counsellor training involves doing a lot of work on yourself to understand why you are the way you. You examine your childhood, your relationships, your responses to others and uncover your own bias/prejudices. The aim being to grow your own self awareness, improve your relationships and enable you to better deal with your own challenges. No one should be a counsellor supporting others through this process before having been through this process of change it themselves. It involves being really honest with yourself, being open to honest feedback from others, and really examining why you may be responding in certain ways and doing lots of regular therapy. Any good counselling course will put students through a rigorous training process.

Ascubudr · 06/12/2023 13:21

There was a mum at DC's primary school who quite frankly I wouldn't have trusted with my pet rabbit ( borderline alcoholic, very odd and disordered relationship with the father of her single child whom she had at 43). She was employed by the local secondary school where some of the children had very significant issues. Really I should have reported my concerns. Her own daughter is about 14 now and totally fucked up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread