Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are all counsellors dealing with their own shitty situations too?

190 replies

Whybeacounsellor · 05/12/2023 23:41

So my DP and I have been noticing a new trend amongst our friends which is that between 45 and 50 they quit professional jobs to retrain as counsellors. Fair enough in a sense that they are of an age to offer some life experience and wisdom because who wants to offload onto a 28 year old?

But what’s striking is that the four people we know are all dealing in their own lives with some mind blowing shit particularly with their families. Person one - son deals drugs and another son was accused of indecent exposure. Husband has been having a very obvious affair but friend won’t accept or admit it. Person two - 3 recent bereavements in a row, one of which was very unexpected. Person three - teenage daughter being brought home by police several times, been expelled, social has got involved. Person four - father caught shoplifting and has brought massive shame on the family because, he’s actually a local solicitor so it’s been very public and in the local paper.

DP isn’t much of a deep thinker and thinks that this is just normal life stuff and has no bearing on a their decision to go into counselling. I on the other hand am more cynical about their motives in changing careers now and think there’s something a bit voyeuristic about wanting to hear about the ‘dirt’ and sad, awful things in other people’s lives. I wonder if they use their job to feel better about their own experiences.

YABU - no of course not, they’re motivated by wanting to help others

YANBU - they are basically driven by a need to know that other people have shitty lives too

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Enko · 10/12/2023 00:36

@HamBone no they can still be a counsellor it is not a protected title however it is also about how it is done.

So, for example, I may ask a client "Have you considered mindfulness?" and they will go " What's that then?" so I will do a brief explanation. Some may ask can we try some breathing techniques" so we go through that if that is something that may benefit. So in practice I would have " taught" them something. However, I would have given a brief idea of what it was about. Not full training so it is more signposting towards what can occur and happen.

A large part of counselling is supporting the client to work out what will be good for them. So say you say "Well some like colouring for mindfulness, others prefer listening to music. Some want to be in a silent room" it is all about what makes you feel like you can switch off for a short time and just have space for you... "oh so could I dance for a bit i like that?" Yes that sounds like a good idea why don't you try and see if it works?

So signposting towards techniques.
In the case of your sons counsellor, I would say they likely specialised in this and used it as their way of practice. That doesn't mean they were not a counsellor.

I kept this very general as well I don't want anyone wondering if I am talking of a client (no I wasn't)

Lastly many will tell you that their counsellor have told them x or suggested Y.

An example "My counsellor thinks I may be autistic" speaks a bit further and what it turned out was the counsellor had asked. "Do you think you may be autistic?" As it happens said person does think this and undergoes tests and yes is autistic. However, the counsellor may not have thought this at all they may have simply asked the question to allow the client to decide if they wanted to explore this further. We wont know unless we speak to the counsellor.

So be careful with what you say your counsellor "said" as many times they did not say that they asked you something you reflected further on and drew your own conclusion to. So actually did their job as a counsellor.

Ilikepinacoladass · 07/12/2023 19:26

Does it really matter - as long as they're providing a good service to their clients? Therapist's tend not to 'give advice' anyway, that would be more of a life coach. Hairdressers don't always have good hair doesn't mean they aren't good at their job..

HamBone · 07/12/2023 18:51

ChocolateYuleLog · 07/12/2023 17:22

@Whybeacounsellor Counsellors are supposed to have counselling/ therapy themselves as part of their training, if it's with a reputable training organisation.

That's why it can take 4 years or more as they have to invest in their own therapy to unpack stuff.

I knew a counsellor who was bereaved and although she had offered bereavement counselling before, she made a decision not to offer it for a good while when her DH died because she knew she would not be as emotionally detached as she ought to be.

For the record, counsellors never give advice (someone upthread said they would not take advice from X person because of their own life.)

Counsellors are supposed to ask questions so the client finds their own answers by digging deep into their own emotions.

@ChocolateYuleLog So would someone who gives guidance on alleviating anxiety such as relaxation techniques, for example, definitely not be a counsellor?

We always referred to DS’s “counsellor” but he did have a PhD in Clinical Psychology. I think perhaps the doctor was perhaps being careful not to frighten DS by saying that he needed to see a psychologist.

ExTheCheater · 07/12/2023 18:35

My friend is a one and has the most messed up life out of everyone I know. Severe mental health issues bless her. She loves her job but I just don't get it.

dressedforcomfort · 07/12/2023 17:25

I did a short, entry course in counselling years ago. Realised fairly early on that I'd made a mistake and I would be a terrible counsellor, but kept up the course for a few months because the skills learnt were very useful in my day job.

There were definitely some people on that course who had major issues and shouldn't have been allowed within 10 miles of a vulnerable person. (Including 1 person who basically used the triad time as their own personal marriage counselling session, and a couple of other people who clearly hadn't come to terms with some fairly substantial past trauma.) I think there's a definite 'physician heal thyself' thing going on with counselling courses. People have a difficult life period and decide they want to help others and become a counsellor regardless of whether they are suited to it. IMO, counselling requires a very specific skill set and temperament - and the idea that anyone with life experience can train to be a counsellor is as nonsensical as saying anyone with hands can train to be a surgeon. Some people simply don't have the right qualities to do it well (myself included.)

ChocolateYuleLog · 07/12/2023 17:22

@Whybeacounsellor Counsellors are supposed to have counselling/ therapy themselves as part of their training, if it's with a reputable training organisation.

That's why it can take 4 years or more as they have to invest in their own therapy to unpack stuff.

I knew a counsellor who was bereaved and although she had offered bereavement counselling before, she made a decision not to offer it for a good while when her DH died because she knew she would not be as emotionally detached as she ought to be.

For the record, counsellors never give advice (someone upthread said they would not take advice from X person because of their own life.)

Counsellors are supposed to ask questions so the client finds their own answers by digging deep into their own emotions.

OnionOnionH · 07/12/2023 16:54

I think the problem with counselling, outside of it not being a protected title, but that can easily be resolved by only using counsellors registered with BACP.
I did a couple of accredited counselling courses at a local college a few years ago and was unaware how many different types of counselling there and some of it works for some and not for others. You need to research what therapy you’re getting and ask questions before just diving into it.
Counsellors are also just human and have differing personalities and as in real life, some people we gel with and others we don’t, you need to shop around to find one that fits.
Lastly, proper counselling training is very rigorous and you have to have your own therapy. I’m sure some wrong ‘uns sneak through, the same within any profession, but on the whole the process will weed out anyone not suitable to the role.

HamBone · 07/12/2023 14:37

*Counselling isn't about giving advice is it?

I thought counselling was about listening and validating, about helping the person articulate their pain or grief and feel heard.... not telling someone what to do???*

@SlothOfDespair I think there’s sometimes a fine line between counselling and therapy. My DS (15) suffers from anxiety and when he was 10, his doctor referred us to an excellent counsellor who listened to him, but also taught him techniques such as deep breathing and mediation to help him control the anxiety. He also discussed DS’s tendency to catastrophise and helped him to recognize when his thoughts were spiraling-and make suggestions on how to rationalize/redirect his thoughts. Sometimes people need guidance on how to manage their situations-telling someone about them is a relief, but it may not help you cope any better, iyswim.

This counsellor had a PhD in Clinical Psychology and also worked as a counsellor at a local school. He really helped DS, who can manage his anxiety much better now.

Of course, seeing a highly qualified counsellor privately wasn’t cheap but it was worth every penny for how much he helped DS.

SlothOfDespair · 07/12/2023 13:22

Counselling isn't about giving advice is it?

I thought counselling was about listening and validating, about helping the person articulate their pain or grief and feel heard.... not telling someone what to do???

I remember a few years back when lots of people were re-inventing themselves as 'life coaches'. These were probably unregulated and more about giving advice.

LittleMissSunshiner · 07/12/2023 13:12

TorroFerney · 07/12/2023 11:46

That’s interesting as I stopped my sessions (which were very useful initially) as I felt that it had become just that and I’d exhausted the usefulness . Counsellor was good and in conjunction with the work I’d done myself reading etc I am in a better place and, I’ll go back again should I need it. It’s a bit like to me when people get into a negative complaining spiral at work and it makes you feel worse.

Exactly this - it was actually the tools of a 12 Step Prog that broke me out of my negative loop of venting and getting nowhere.

For me I was feeling frustrated by situations, criticising the people in them, complaining to anyone who would listen to get them on board and in order to feel validated (which is easy enough as often situations are bonkers and people do often behaved poorly), demonising or at least heavily critiquing / bitching about the frustrating people involved behind their backs, and then drinking off the back of the tension within me. That's not what caused my alcoholism but it was a part of one of my processes that fuelled it. Toxic.

Now I know different - I have the serenity prayer 'accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference'. I also learned over time that when a person is difficult to accept that's how they are and work around it, have kindness for them if they're struggling, and think how I can help them do better. Or decide to walk away. I usually don't need to discuss my situations with another person - it's between me and my conscience / higher power to discern the right thing / action to do. I usually know what the right thing is now and act immediately on it. The programme taught me all of this and more. No therapy I've had (and there's been a LOT) even began to address these type of issues.

More so, therapists proactively wanted me to be running off to them to rant about silly things - how a server in a coffee shop gave me the wrong drink and then we had an argument and they refused to replace it and the security came over and blah blah on and on. Therapist would want to ask what is it within me that felt triggered when I got the wrong drink and if this relates to anything that's happened to me before and then before I knew it I started banking every incidents under the sun til the next time saw therapist so I could naval gaze.

Now, were the exact same incident to occur, I wouldn't even remember it as I'd have dealt with it at the time appropriately and it would be forgotten. I went into end of life alcoholism and nearly died under my therapist who I was seeing twice a week wanted me addicted to venting. It nearly killed me. I saved my own life by dumping her. I dumped her after I saw Peter Fornagy's talk. He set it out clearly if your therapist is doing x, y, z, this is not therapy this is them addicting you to venting and taking your money. Notable this therapist came to my home demanding money - I didn't owe a penny.

berksandbeyond · 07/12/2023 12:44

Those who can’t do (life), teach (others how to do life)

OctogenarianDecathlete · 07/12/2023 12:37

I know someone who trained as a counsellor, and on completing their course was immediately recruited to teach counselling. I've always wondered about the Dunning-Kruger aspect of this and other counsellors. It's counselling, not psychiatry.

I think this person does have a bit of a voyeuristic streak, now that you mention it. They like to read fiction and non-fiction about abuse and other horrors.

This person, I know, is doing it all in good faith. And we are proud of them and all they've achieved.

But maybe PPs are right about keeping people coming.

The person I know is convinced everyone should have a therapist.

I think that too much navel gazing can be catastrophic. I think a lot of people just need to take more responsibility for their lives and develop some grit. The person I know has been kind enough not to take me to task on my unreasonable attitude!

Whybeacounsellor · 07/12/2023 12:25

GasPanic · 07/12/2023 11:31

I know a few accountants whose financial affairs are a bit or have been a bit, how shall we say, poorly managed.

I don't think it's exclusive to counsellors.

Yes. Or overweight doctors who drink too much. There are a few at my local surgery.

OP posts:
TorroFerney · 07/12/2023 11:46

LittleMissSunshiner · 06/12/2023 13:40

Well this is how it would work in a functional and helpful way.

Many counsellors / therapists don't go there. They want to keep you trapped in 'venting'. Venting has been scientifically proven to be addictive. I've read up on this and been to seminars about it.

I saw an excellent speech by Peter Fornagy on the subject a few years ago. Venting meets the same 'satisfaction' neural zones as using an addictive substance and it also now shown to be demonstrably unhelpful and even harmful in therapy to facilitate a client to vent.

Many psychologists and psychiatrists have written on the subject of therapists wanting people trapped in repeat custom, luring them for two sessions a week 'I have to speak to my therapist about this!' and going nowhere and keeping them for multiple years with no end in sight. I had a therapist once who told me she sees her clients all their lives. I was being funded by my local authority to see her. She was rubbish. I dumped her after three years as my mental health had descended into acting on suicide territory. Another one who then got angry and told her I owed her money (I absolutely did not and I even gave her some to shut her up and make her go away). Wow.

That’s interesting as I stopped my sessions (which were very useful initially) as I felt that it had become just that and I’d exhausted the usefulness . Counsellor was good and in conjunction with the work I’d done myself reading etc I am in a better place and, I’ll go back again should I need it. It’s a bit like to me when people get into a negative complaining spiral at work and it makes you feel worse.

GasPanic · 07/12/2023 11:31

I know a few accountants whose financial affairs are a bit or have been a bit, how shall we say, poorly managed.

I don't think it's exclusive to counsellors.

Lavender14 · 07/12/2023 11:27

Something that really jumps out at me on this thread is that there seems to be a bit of a double standard in terms of expectations of people in a counselling role. There's plenty of doctors, social workers, teachers etc who have shit going on in their personal life but in not sure anyone is saying that means they can't go to work and put their professional hat on and do their job effectively. So many people saying they wouldn't want to be counselled by a person they know- you know them personally not in a professional capacity and have no idea what they're like in that role. The opinions I have, feelings, worries etc I need to leave at the door on my way into work and I use supervision to help me do that. I don't need to do that in my personal life. This is in part why people don't counsel people they know personally. A counsellor should be as neutral a space as possible in human form. Also there's nothing to stop someone from becoming a counsellor and then something awful happening in their personal life unexpectedly. Like most other people, financially it's unlikely they'll be able to come out of work until that's resolved especially as some things are unresolvable so they'll have to go for their own counselling and use their supervisions for it. Counsellors are human too at the end of the day. But I do agree that there should be more diligence on the part of those bodies issuing qualifications to identify and manage someone's reasons for wanting to become a counsellor. The lack of this is why it's so important for prospective clients to do their research on who they ask to take them on.

Enko · 07/12/2023 06:54

@MrsSpoon79 noone can tell you how long you should continue to see her. What I will say is one say you will know you have reached your end or she will guide you towards it realising you have.

As a counsellor myself I've taken 3 years with of personal counselling even without a lot of trauma /issues its fascinating to work on your own parmtterns of behaviour.

Enko · 07/12/2023 06:50

I'm a level 4 qualified counsellor. I'm not able to vote as I didn't train for either of your reasons.

I find human behavior fascinating. I find the theories within counselling fascinating. That was what motivated me. Wheb I trained my life was in a pretty good place and I didn't have anything major going on.

During our training I got to know several of the people I trained with well. Some had stuff going on. One had been supported through counselling herself to realise she was able to get herself past a trauma. (Severe trauma) that motivated her to train. One simply wanted to learn and had no intention of practicing as a counsellor (and still doesnt) one was a priest and wanted to use it in his way his parisioners)

As for stuff yourself. We'll I mostly deal with bereavement. I recently and unexpectedly lost a very close friend. I took the day after her funeral off. As I knew I was unlikely to concentrate on what my clients may bring especially if they were wanting to talk about their loved ones funeral.

If you have gone through a good programme you will have had to have a lot of counselling yourself. You have worked a lot on your shit and you have learned to compartmentalise it. You bring it in your own counselling or your supervision.

So on a way your dh is right. Everyone has their own shit. If your friends have trained in some reputable establishments they will have been taught how to reflect and work on their own shit outside of their clients counselling sessions.

MrsSpoon79 · 07/12/2023 06:40

As a parent of SEN children, I started seeing a counsellor to help me cope with the challenges of our life and to help me process my children's diagnoses/conditions and to help me reframe my view of family life now we know what we know.

I think she has/had a child with medical needs at some point in his life (possibly still does) and her experience navigating that led her to wanting to help other parents in similar situations.

She has been wonderful for me. I get a fortnightly opportunity to reflect on what's going on in my life and this always teaches me something, I have identified my core values which I found very helpful because I like to check my choices and behaviours align with my values (when they do I almost always feel most comfortable) and she has introduced me to a number of techniques that help me process emotions (really helpful as I need to do this for myself in order to help my children regulate their own emotions too).

She charges £50/55. For those in the know, how long should I be seeing someone like her? I feel like I want to continue for at least another 3 months (fortnightly sessions) and now see it as a very important part of my coping strategies.

LittleMissSunshiner · 06/12/2023 22:52

I can understand the type of counsellor who is one with lived experience as I'm informed that many rehab centres and such deploy people with LE.

As someone who has long since recovered from my own substance addiction & alcoholism and used a wide variety of tools to get myself out of the gutter and release my own sick thinking, I genuinely believe I'd be useful / helpful and a really good addiction counsellor one day. I've got pressing physical health issues to deal with right now.

I would never want to do it without professional training and a framework / network of peers and superiors. It wouldn't be because I'm trying to figure myself out or being a wounded healer it would literally be OK let me show you the way out of this living hell using the tools that work so you too can be free.

I do help friends and people I meet on a local level if they ask me to, I chat around the subject and we have in depth conversations about if they'd like to change and how they could but I never ask them to get back to me on how they're going or lean on them or have them feel they can start leaning on me because I'm really good with boundaries.

I can see that if I was a sick minded person, I could just set up clinic as an 'alcohol counsellor' and charge really really vulnerable people to come desperately chat with me. That would be so predatory and there's so many people actually doing exactly that. (not that many addicts are wanting to spend their time or money on counsellors tbh, thankfully!)

Whybeacounsellor · 06/12/2023 22:24

Some very interesting things here to reflect on, especially the post from @hettie I had no idea about this.

OP posts:
DeeCeeCherry · 06/12/2023 21:57

I am very cynical about Counsellors. I know they cant all be bad, but still. I'm thinking of 3 I know well:

One is an Andrew Tate disciple and thinks its fine to talk about 'body count'. Unmarried, can't maintain relationships. Also too much (judgmental bullshit) to say about women who are 20 years younger than him and way out of his league.

The other has family issues and flatly refuses to see why his sister is upset by their narcissistic parent, who treated her differently whilst he was 'God'.

& one who goes to work and home, no social life, still lives with her parents (she's late 30s), has been with her boyfriend for a decade with no progress. She's retrained as a Life Coach and is now looking into going for Counselling qualifications

Essentially anyone who's done the training, gains the qualifications, looks and sounds the part, is on a roll.

Again Im sure they're not all bad but the ones I know have put me off ever going to a Counsellor

Ladybughello · 06/12/2023 21:52

Lavender14 · 05/12/2023 23:52

Do you not think it's more likely that they have received counselling due to said shitty situations and found it beneficial and therefore wanted to pass on what they found helpful to others in similar situations?

I work in a similar role and I often find that some of the best social workers/ youth workers/counsellors are those who have been through the process themselves and really "get it".

In a way its probably also helpful for them to feel they're enacting something positive out of an otherwise difficult situation and I don't think that's a bad thing provided they're in control and aware of that and manage it through the counselling and supervision they'll receive as part of their role.

Exactly. I know a few people who have followed this kind of path. Sorry OP but it seems quite bitchy to think they “are basically driven by a need to know that other people have shitty lives too” 😬🤦🏻‍♀️

hettie · 06/12/2023 21:46

In answer to your original question. No not all counsellors are using the work to deal with their own shit (consciously or unconsciously) but many are. As others have referenced there is a whole research area on this 'the wounded healer' and reputable training organisations will cover this in training.
It's an interesting debate and one that most members of the public are unaware of.
The issue is that anybody can call themselves a counsellor or therapist or psychotherapist and can list some impressive sounding qualifications that are actually piss all guarantee of anything. And many people who do a years part time counselling course think they are equipped to do all sorts with no real insight into their own motivation, use of self in the work or limits of competent practice. The area that really pisses me off the most is when people claim they can do couples therapy after a two day training on top of their counselling certificate. Couples and family work is specialist and missteps are easy (control, DV, gender dynamics, developmental differences). Then people who have a poor experience think all therapy is shit
It's so underegulated.
There are only a few protected titles that people can't use unless they are registered (well they could but face consequences it's like calling yourself a Dr medicine). It's much more of a guarantee but not a fail safe, I've met some 'interesting' psychologists in my time but generally a small minority. The training is long and rigorous and the governance, CPD and supervision requirements help to weed out the worst.
Protected titles

  • Art psychotherapist
  • Art therapist
  • Dramatherapist
  • Music therapist
  • Clinical psychologist
  • Forensic psychologist
  • Counselling psychologist
  • Health psychologist
  • Educational psychologist
  • Occupational psychologist
  • Sport and exercise psychologist
BeatrizViter · 06/12/2023 21:06

Although the industry definition of counsellor vs psychotherapist is a counsellor as being someone who works with conscious process and a psychotherapist someone who works with unconscious process, as neither are protected titles- like general therapist- it is extremely difficult to assess someone's competence or expertise by what they call themselves. Also psychologist is not a protected title in the UK- clinical psychologist and counselling psychologist are protected titles, but anyone can call themselves a psychologist, leading to new guidance in the family courts. https://www.milnerslaw.co.uk/psychologists-in-family-law-courts-the-new-guidance-explained#:~:text=A%20psychologist's%20report%20can%20influence,alienated%22%20them%20from%20their%20father.

The idea that many people in the helping professions are themselves vulnerable in some way goes back to at least Jung and 'the wounded healer'. Someone who has undergone rigorous training will have undergone personal therapy and supervision which should be encouraging the therapist to identify their own mental processes and separate that from the clients. Unfortunately, I would say even going through that training does not mean that people who are insightful/plausible/articulate- yet badly intentioned - stop getting through. See Warner Interviews- used to be a standard safeguard for trying to weed out potential child abusers from positions with children, by asking lot of personal and ethical questions. However it transpired paedophiles did really well at Warner interviews as they were able to demonstrate great verbal empathy with children.

Neither does it preclude people having a major life crisis themselves later down the line and becoming unfit to offer therapy- if you are self employed as a therapist, there is very little oversight even if registered with BACP or UKCP.

Psychologists in family law courts: the new guidance explained

New guidance seeks to curb the use of unregulated psychologists as expert witnesses in family law cases. Learn about the issue in our 5-minute read.

https://www.milnerslaw.co.uk/psychologists-in-family-law-courts-the-new-guidance-explained#:~:text=A%20psychologist's%20report%20can%20influence,alienated%22%20them%20from%20their%20father.