Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this name calling? Am I being too sensitive

58 replies

Bigskies · 05/12/2023 22:31

I’d like to understand if I’m BU in being upset over this. I said something jokey to my partner and he got cross and began, in my view, mocking me and then called me neurotic (because I avoid the sun on holiday, he also called me a vampire for same reason which sounds ridiculous writing it down but felt aggressive) and some other things. He went on and on about the same points. I have apologised for my comment but it was not personal to him whereas his attack on me was and about something I’m already self-conscious about it. Do you count being called ‘neurotic’ as name calling? AIBU to be upset?

Then he declared he was ‘wanting to state that he was feeling angry’ (this doesn’t come across as threatening, more like trying to put therapy tactics into practice) which I don’t know what I’m meant to do with.

When I was unwell a few weeks ago he mimicked me being out of breath and fatigued (I had long covid badly and some symptoms came back for a few days when I got a virus) - just the once and I pulled him up on it but I was shocked. He is normally kind, gentle, mature and great at communication. So these things are so out of character but they feel belittling . Similarly when he made a rude comment about my stomach - though he was v apologetic after. I don’t profess to be perfect - I know when stressed I can snap and be stressy and he has rightly pulled me up on this and said it’s not acceptable. We’ve been together 1 year and live together.

I feel exhausted by this and work so said I needed some space this evening and had a bath and am sleeping in spare room (though I would have anyway due to his early start) he has respected this though I think is annoyed. We’re meant to be starting a family but I’m concerned by this. I don’t know if I’m being way too sensitive given he is genuinely a very nice guy (and son and friend).

Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Snowdogsmitten · 06/12/2023 18:41

He’s said all these horrible things to you and you’ve only been together one year? Christ. He’s mocked you for being ill, been cruel about your stomach (what the fuck would he say if you were pregnant?!) and has attacked parts of your personality.

You’d be mad to tie yourself to him forever by way of a child. Don’t subject a kid to a dad who will mock them when they’re down.

Catsmere · 06/12/2023 08:56

Dear God, don't go off and live with this man overseas! You'd be totally isolated from everyone you know and unable to get help - and you would end up needing help to escape him. The more you describe him, the worse he sounds. He's not remotely good and kind. He's a piece of shit whose mask is slipping off.

Do. Not. Get. Pregnant. By. This. Man.

Get. Away. From. Him.

TomatoSandwiches · 06/12/2023 08:49

Imagine how much worse he will be after you bring a baby home who has colic and neither of you sleep more than 2hr stretches, you have stitches in places you didn't know you had and are leaking fluids from nearly every orifice and are uncomfortable or in pain for weeks whilst you recover from birth.
Is he going to mock you waddling and gingerly sitting down?

You've made a mistake, this man is not the one.

Outwiththenorm · 06/12/2023 08:39

Bigskies · 06/12/2023 06:57

Thank you for taking the time to comment. Some very valid points. I acknowledge I hit a nerve clearly. What I found difficult was that we both made these comments which offended the other, I then said I was exhausted so would have a bath (I didn’t storm off, ignore him or anything, I just said I needed some time out as I’d had a crazy work day). He then followed me a few mins later to the bathroom and then kept going on and on at me. I wasn’t saying much as I was exhausted and was hurt (it was late) and it was after he’d walked away he called out from next room he was angry. It wasn’t threatening - it felt more like telling me so it became my responsibility.

I agree with everyone who says warned on pausing thinking about a family. Unfortunately I think we moved too fast down to circumstances (I was between properties, age etc) and have taken on too much (a big move). If I could go back to start I would not have done either so soon.

I’ll chat with him tonight and see where we get to.

Ignore this, he was clearly looking for a fight / to insult you. Do you really want to be with a man who can’t take a lighthearted joke about Morris Dancing for dog’s sake? I’ve been with DH for over 20 years and he has NEVER made a negative joke about my personal appearance.

But your partner reminds me of an insecure, needy ex-boyfriend from my teens. We were watching a film and I said something innocuous about how the lead guy’s haircut would suit him. He immediately snapped and said ‘why don’t you get a boob reduction as the lead actress’s boobs would suit you’. This was not the first or last time.

billy1966 · 06/12/2023 08:28

You know you moved in far too quickly with someone you didn't know.

You are getting to know him.
His mask is slipping and he isn't very nice.

This is the point that you will look back and regret not paying attention to red flags.

Calling someone names is not normal.
Many people have normal relationships for years, in my case 35 and we haven't ever name called.

He followed you and went on and on. Awful behaviour.

You would want to be out of your mind to rush into having a child with someone you clearly don't know and has shown you he has a nasty streak.

LC is a dose and so debilitating.

I have friends suffering from it whose taste and smell hasn't returned and for whom energy levels haven't returned and suffer with persistent brain fog.

They get on with life but it is very very hard.

You have made a mistake with your haste, do not repent at leisure.

I think you should be looking for your own home.

junebirthdaygirl · 06/12/2023 08:26

I think we become more able and willing to look after and care for a partner with an illness when we have had a good long stretch of wellness, happiness and good times together. Our tank is full so we move quickly into the caring part quite willingly. But he is in a new relationship and maybe has taken on more than he had reckoned for as signs of your long Covid re-emerge. There is definitely a situation here of moving too quickly and then becoming unaccepting of difficulties. So he has a new gf, all is great and then suddenly he sees a different side of you when ye holiday together and then a different side when you are ill. He doesn't know you well enough to be living with you and he may feel now he has taken on too much.
As long Covid is horrendous and has a big impact you might benefit from some therapy and l think you would both benefit from slowing things down.

Babyboomtastic · 06/12/2023 08:23

Bigskies · 06/12/2023 08:15

No not at all 😆! I’ve totally given wrong impression in that case. This was about how I was on a hot holiday in a country we will spend a lot more time in in the future due to his work. The reason it came up is because we will be there for long periods in the future. I don’t act differently to anyone else in UK or abroad if it’s not that hot. I still go in the sea, go on hikes, walk around cities - I just don’t want to be in the midday sun IF very very hot and I can feel unwell since being ill if it gets very hot etc (if low/mid twenties no problem) . I think someone else wouldn’t even say their behaviour was odd, just being sensible. I am quick to judge myself so am probably being a lot more critical and calling myself anxious too much. I wouldn’t choose normally to live in a very hot country.

That sounds totally normal!

I was imagining a giant hat, spf clothing and only going out in the dark in November, not perfectly normal behaviour in a hot country.

Bigskies · 06/12/2023 08:15

Babyboomtastic · 06/12/2023 08:02

If it were just the sun comment, I would think he was being tactless, but it wouldn't raise too much if a red flag in the circumstances. But coupled with everything else this isn't tactlessness, but cruel. You don't need that in your life.

As this thread is going on, it's becoming increasingly obvious that you do have significant anxiety issues over sunlight. Given this is an argument you've been having in darkest darkest December, am I right in thinking your reluctance to go out in the sun/wearing spf clothing is a year round thing, rather than just a hot summer day thing? Not going out in the midday sun and wearing a hat when its 35 degrees = sensible. Taking the same sort of approach on a drizzly autumn day would indicate mental health issues regarding sun.

That doesn't excuse calling you neurotic though, it's not goirather

No not at all 😆! I’ve totally given wrong impression in that case. This was about how I was on a hot holiday in a country we will spend a lot more time in in the future due to his work. The reason it came up is because we will be there for long periods in the future. I don’t act differently to anyone else in UK or abroad if it’s not that hot. I still go in the sea, go on hikes, walk around cities - I just don’t want to be in the midday sun IF very very hot and I can feel unwell since being ill if it gets very hot etc (if low/mid twenties no problem) . I think someone else wouldn’t even say their behaviour was odd, just being sensible. I am quick to judge myself so am probably being a lot more critical and calling myself anxious too much. I wouldn’t choose normally to live in a very hot country.

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 06/12/2023 08:02

If it were just the sun comment, I would think he was being tactless, but it wouldn't raise too much if a red flag in the circumstances. But coupled with everything else this isn't tactlessness, but cruel. You don't need that in your life.

As this thread is going on, it's becoming increasingly obvious that you do have significant anxiety issues over sunlight. Given this is an argument you've been having in darkest darkest December, am I right in thinking your reluctance to go out in the sun/wearing spf clothing is a year round thing, rather than just a hot summer day thing? Not going out in the midday sun and wearing a hat when its 35 degrees = sensible. Taking the same sort of approach on a drizzly autumn day would indicate mental health issues regarding sun.

That doesn't excuse calling you neurotic though, it's not goirather

ButterBastardBeans · 06/12/2023 07:59

OP seriously, you have to reconsider this.

My DH has had cancer three times now and is being investigated for it again. I have nursed him through all of it and am hoping to learn to do home dialysis with him as it would benefit him so much

I had botched surgery and was in bed for almost five years. DH has cared for me in his turn. I am about to have further surgery to try and put it all right.

Luckily we have not both been ill at the same time but I think that is about to happen.

Can you imagine if either of us had the attitude that your 'D'P has? He sees you as a commodity from your latest posts.

The marriage vows are there for your protection. So you have help if you are ill and all the rest of it too. He does not have your back. He does NOT have your back and the mimicking? - Christ preserve us! It's the worst sort of mockery.

You deserve so much better than this person who has vital parts missing.

Nicole1111 · 06/12/2023 07:50

Given how you’ve described yourself in the sun and your anxieties around health in relation to the sun have you considered the possibility that in that one area you could be seen as neurotic? If the answer is yes and he wasn’t calling you neurotic in general, which it doesn’t sound he like was, then I wouldn’t view this as abusive name calling, more of a bluntly outlined observation.
Taking the mick out of your presentation when ill is a worry though, as it shows a complete lack of care for your welfare.

avenue1 · 06/12/2023 07:44

He's got a nasty streak that he's good at hiding most of the time.

Bigskies · 06/12/2023 07:38

MyEyesMyThighs · 06/12/2023 07:22

I think it's different to make an off the cuff comment within a conversation about a topic (like morris dancing) and to drag up something unrelated the person is sensitive about. The latter, that he did, is like bearing a grudge or storing up things that hurt you. It's a bad sign. I also suspect he's someone who can dish it out but not take it. Your comment was meant to make him laugh or smile, his was only intended to hurt.

I also have long Covid, how long have you had it, is it most of this relationship? I'd be careful you aren't feeling grateful or lowering your standards because you feel a bit shit.

That is how it feels - things get stored up and brought out if we have a disagreement. I try to keep arguments to the one thing at hand. I had long covid very badly for 18m (bed-ridden for lots of it, off work for 8m). I was mostly back to normal when we met aside from getting some symptoms again if I overdo it, do cardio (fine with weights), or get a virus. I didn’t find him sympathetic when I got a virus and it triggered it - he was asking why I wasn’t 100% again after a week as he was and said this wasn’t normal. He said he was worried about what happens if I get long covid again especially if we have a family - that is a valid concern but it felt unsupportive to say it when I was in bed feeling crap. I was calm and said I wasn’t concerned about that, lots of people take more than a week to get over a virus etc.

im sorry that you and @flowerchild2000 have had LC too. It was a very bleak time at points. Looking back, I can’t believe how ill I was.

OP posts:
Kittenkitty · 06/12/2023 07:34

My experience is when people say things like this they stay with you and chip away at your confidence. You’ll remember every word he said in this argument - in a week he’ll have forgotten what you said. People saying hurtful things in arguments is a major problem for relationships.

Bigskies · 06/12/2023 07:28

PippyLongTits · 05/12/2023 23:39

The neurotic thing depends on the context surely?! If you were saying something "jokey"/borderline insulting to him and he responded in kind, perhaps he thought you were both just bantering/lightheartedly teasing each other. It sounds like you set the tone.

Are you particularly sensitive about all comments or just about sun/vampire comments? If you are sensitive to everything then yabu because it is exhausting treading on eggshells around someone and not knowing what might set them off. If you are just sensitive about the SPF/sun/vampire thing, then he is being unreasonable and he should know not to joke about things that so easily upset you.

The mocking when you were ill thing and comments on your stomach are both totally out of order.

No I don’t get sensitive about all comments - he says other things about me regularly (that I’m always in a rush so am clumsy, that I’m ‘particular’, that I’m stressy) which I don’t get sensitive about (albeit sometimes annoyed if he says it a lot!). Though if I’m honest. I don’t love being told I’m stressy/particular but I let it go as I accept I can be. The sun thing is only recently in last 2 years - in this time sibling had melanoma (they are fine, but runs in family) and I can’t tolerate heat since being ill. The two things seem to have triggered anxiety around it, as well as hating having freckles and not wanting more!

OP posts:
MyEyesMyThighs · 06/12/2023 07:22

I think it's different to make an off the cuff comment within a conversation about a topic (like morris dancing) and to drag up something unrelated the person is sensitive about. The latter, that he did, is like bearing a grudge or storing up things that hurt you. It's a bad sign. I also suspect he's someone who can dish it out but not take it. Your comment was meant to make him laugh or smile, his was only intended to hurt.

I also have long Covid, how long have you had it, is it most of this relationship? I'd be careful you aren't feeling grateful or lowering your standards because you feel a bit shit.

flowerchild2000 · 06/12/2023 06:58

I have Long Covid and my ex used to gaslight me about it. It's very serious, my nerves were damaged so my stomach doesn't really work, I lost a lot of weight when I was already slender, I get fatigued easily, trouble breathing, horrible pain, etc. He would constantly accuse me of having an eating disorder, when I used my inhaler he said I didn't need it, he would constantly say there's nothing wrong with you, etc etc. It actually made me feel horrible and took me a long time after breaking up with him to be okay again. I would tell him off for mansplaining my body to me, but his words still affected me deeply. Being accused of being neurotic is worse than just a name call. You'll see what I mean when/if you leave him. It will be hard to shake that feeling of being gaslit, even though you didn't fall for it. Men like that are insecure and try to minimize people to make themselves feel bigger. It's a damaging situation to be in and I hope you find your way out.

Bigskies · 06/12/2023 06:57

sandyhappypeople · 06/12/2023 01:15

It's a slippery slope to take the piss out of your partner in that way, they should be your safe space, and it's not really up to you what was 'personal' to him, he obviously took your first comment personally, he sounds self conscious about whatever it was you inferred with your comment to take it so badly, so you should have paid attention to that fact and not just immediately dismissed his feelings as irrelevant.

I think the him 'stating he was angry line' is quite telling, he's told you immediately that he didn't like what you said, and compared it to if he said 'this' to you, to which, instead of understanding the analogy and realising at that point that whatever it was has actually upset him, as his comment would no doubt upset you, you've doubled down and tried to justify why you're allowed to say hurtful things, but he isn't allowed to, you're also saying he's not allowed to get angry at you about it because yours was 'just a joke'... but he IS allowed to feel however he feels, it's not up to you to tell him how to feel, it's complete double standards and I think that's the point he's trying to prove, you're just not listening, no wonder it escalated into an argument.

A joke is only a joke if both people are in on it. If I thought I'd hurt my partners feelings, with a 'joke', then I'd back down straight away, as he has done with you previously when you've said he's upset you.

It doesn't sound like you have a great relationship to be fair, you're taking out your stress on him by being snappy and stressy with him for seemingly no reason, which he has to pull you up on, and making jokes about him and he's making snide comment at your expense, which you have to pull him up on, you don't sound like you're making each other happy at all, I'd question at a year in if you've got a future together.

Thank you for taking the time to comment. Some very valid points. I acknowledge I hit a nerve clearly. What I found difficult was that we both made these comments which offended the other, I then said I was exhausted so would have a bath (I didn’t storm off, ignore him or anything, I just said I needed some time out as I’d had a crazy work day). He then followed me a few mins later to the bathroom and then kept going on and on at me. I wasn’t saying much as I was exhausted and was hurt (it was late) and it was after he’d walked away he called out from next room he was angry. It wasn’t threatening - it felt more like telling me so it became my responsibility.

I agree with everyone who says warned on pausing thinking about a family. Unfortunately I think we moved too fast down to circumstances (I was between properties, age etc) and have taken on too much (a big move). If I could go back to start I would not have done either so soon.

I’ll chat with him tonight and see where we get to.

OP posts:
wite · 06/12/2023 06:53

I need to stare I'm feeling angry. Major ick

How long have you lived together for?

ButterBastardBeans · 06/12/2023 06:50

I use the yardstick of if they wouldn't speak to another man like it, they are not getting away with it with me.

ButterBastardBeans · 06/12/2023 06:49

Bobsyouraunty · 05/12/2023 23:47

No relationship is perfect 🙄

It hurt your feelings - so tell him op. No one can tell you whether you’re being over sensitive because the situation hasn’t really been explained clearly.. we don’t know what you said.

Agree with everyone that you shouldn’t have moved in together.

You can eyeroll at this all you like but the OP is having prior warning of how this man is prepared to put her down and it always starts out in a low key way and with a variety of excuses. This trait and his excuses for it, will worsen once he is married and you have kids.

1% raw sewage can kill you.

This isn't evidence of a not perfect relationship, it's him trying to be dominant and an asshole.
I've been married 22 years and my DH would never even consider calling me neurotic or any other cod psycho/misogynist term designed to unbalance and upset me.
OP , your gut is telling you his mask is slipping and honestly, the best thing to do is to see this as the end. If you are considering staying with him, you need to experience genuine troubles before you get married. It's under pressure that these types reveal themselves. Please don't ignore red flags. I have done that in the past as have a massive number of MNetters no doubt. Not one of us is glad we ignored red flags or our gut feeling - ever.

Banana1979 · 06/12/2023 01:29

It’s that horrible thing, where women are labelled as neurotic and mad for having genuine fears or issues / opinions about something, you have only been with him a year. One year is definitely not enough to know a person properly as in the first year you have the honeymoon period -getting to know each other and then that settles down but people don’t usually show their true colours that soon - during the year two and three people start to show real colours . He is showing you Glimpses into your future - by year two and three when you he will definitely be name calling you and making you feel crap about yourself . After just one year I would not expect a partner to make a nasty comment about my appearance and I’m not sure why you have defended this by saying he has a lot on
I would reconsider with this man if I were you
I will definitely not have a family with him either - even if he was perfect one year is too soon
I have been with my partner for three years and he has never ever called me a name , shamed me or implied I was neurotic mad or something wrong with me.

sandyhappypeople · 06/12/2023 01:15

It's a slippery slope to take the piss out of your partner in that way, they should be your safe space, and it's not really up to you what was 'personal' to him, he obviously took your first comment personally, he sounds self conscious about whatever it was you inferred with your comment to take it so badly, so you should have paid attention to that fact and not just immediately dismissed his feelings as irrelevant.

I think the him 'stating he was angry line' is quite telling, he's told you immediately that he didn't like what you said, and compared it to if he said 'this' to you, to which, instead of understanding the analogy and realising at that point that whatever it was has actually upset him, as his comment would no doubt upset you, you've doubled down and tried to justify why you're allowed to say hurtful things, but he isn't allowed to, you're also saying he's not allowed to get angry at you about it because yours was 'just a joke'... but he IS allowed to feel however he feels, it's not up to you to tell him how to feel, it's complete double standards and I think that's the point he's trying to prove, you're just not listening, no wonder it escalated into an argument.

A joke is only a joke if both people are in on it. If I thought I'd hurt my partners feelings, with a 'joke', then I'd back down straight away, as he has done with you previously when you've said he's upset you.

It doesn't sound like you have a great relationship to be fair, you're taking out your stress on him by being snappy and stressy with him for seemingly no reason, which he has to pull you up on, and making jokes about him and he's making snide comment at your expense, which you have to pull him up on, you don't sound like you're making each other happy at all, I'd question at a year in if you've got a future together.

Katej82 · 06/12/2023 00:19

Nagado · 06/12/2023 00:03

I wrote out a big long reply responding to all of your comments then lost it, and can’t remember it all now, so this is a bit more basic and possibly a bit blunter than intended!

  • Would you call your best friend neurotic about something that was important to her? If not, why not?

  • Would you make a spiteful comment about your partner’s physical appearance? If not, why not?

  • He is not kind. He is not gentle. He is not mature. He is not great at communicating. People who are those things don’t call their loved ones names or make spiteful comments about their physical appearance.

  • If he’s like this when he’s just stressing about a job move, then what’s it going to be like when you’ve got a baby stressing him out? Or money worries? Or health worries? Or all of those things at once?

  • Are you aware that by saying you’ve probably added too many details and distracted from the issue, you sound like you’re trying to justify his behaviour and take the blame for making it seem worse than it is?

I think your inner voice is currently niggling away at the back of your brain and you’re doing your very best to ignore it.

Also, the ‘therapy sounding’ phrasing about him stating that he feels angry - has he had anger management therapy previously? Have you done a Claire’s law request for this man?

completely agree with you 💯 OP please really think about all of the points Nagado makes here.

Katej82 · 06/12/2023 00:16

This is not ok. Calling you neurotic, deflecting because he's taken your joke as an offence or in the wrong context. Your questioning yourself yet he is sensitive if you can't joke without being name called....Mocking your illness your body . No this is not acceptable at all. You say he's normally really kind but it sounds like the vampire thing happened on holiday when was that? Think back to previous comments etc. No loving partner would make such comments and in fact he's sounds a bit narcissistic/ controlling because he's loved you up now knocking or trying to knock your confidence. Who's idea was it to start a family? Was it his? Sorry OP but I don't think you should even consider it. This man needs the bin