Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think children should have their mothers surname

385 replies

Laurendelaney1987 · 05/12/2023 21:50

if the parents are not married. You did the hard work! Why the fuck should the child carry his name?

OP posts:
Tandora · 06/12/2023 16:04

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 15:55

Based on that poster's other contributions in this thread, there is not a chance in hell that what you're saying here was in fact the point. She doesn't like dads having a different name to their DC at all. Read a few posts back!

It's just not helpful for the argument you're making it to try and tie it to a silly claim about double barrels deferring choices.

What you're saying is that you want the framework in which they make the choice to be different. Which isn't the same thing, and additionally, women who are are by definition using their own surnames for their child are not the place to start.

Tbf I didn’t read that posters previous comments, I just saw what (I thought) she meant by that one isolated comment , but maybe I was taking it out of context !

Fairylightfurore · 06/12/2023 16:02

I agree. If the parents aren't married there's no reason for the child to have the fathers surname. I would always assume the mothers surname.

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 15:55

Tandora · 06/12/2023 15:49

double barrelling selfishly defers choice to the next generation

I think the point is that it does in the sense that double barrelling doesn’t address head on the structural imbalance which limits women’s choices. Yes each generation needs to make a choice about names, but the problem is that there isn’t currently a balanced/ equal choice to be had/ made: it’s either dad’s name or hyphenation , if everyone in the family wants the same name. It’s exceptionally rare for men to agree to take their female partner’s name. I suppose it’s still seen as emasculating? It’s selfish to defer addressing this inequality to the next generation- we should be prepared to confront it now.

Edited

Based on that poster's other contributions in this thread, there is not a chance in hell that what you're saying here was in fact the point. She doesn't like dads having a different name to their DC at all. Read a few posts back!

It's just not helpful for the argument you're making it to try and tie it to a silly claim about double barrels deferring choices.

What you're saying is that you want the framework in which they make the choice to be different. Which isn't the same thing, and additionally, women who are are by definition using their own surnames for their child are not the place to start.

Tandora · 06/12/2023 15:49

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 15:44

The post of mine you quoted was in reply to someone claiming that double barrelling selfishly defers choice to the next generation. But there is no naming choice that could prevent deferring choice to the next generation, because parents choose their child's name, and even if they go along with what their parents did, in a free society they'll still have to make a decision. A parent who thinks they can do anything to prevent this deferral is therefore sadly misguided.

In terms of hyphenation, there are entire cultures that use a surname from both parents. Granted, they don't necessarily hyphenate, but the basic principle is the same. This has been going on for some time. It has been sustained.

But the underlying point is that nothing anyone calls their own child means the child doesn't then have a decision to make if they have DC. Sustainability as an argument simply doesn't make sense in this context, because you don't get to pick whether your decisions are sustained down the generations or not. If you want to argue that we should normalise the use of the mother's name only to try and balance the field, by all means do so, but that's a separate point to the now frankly daft trope about hyphenated.

double barrelling selfishly defers choice to the next generation

I think the point is that it does in the sense that double barrelling doesn’t address head on the structural imbalance which limits women’s choices. Yes each generation needs to make a choice about names, but the problem is that there isn’t currently a balanced/ equal choice to be had/ made: it’s either dad’s name or hyphenation , if everyone in the family wants the same name. It’s exceptionally rare for men to agree to take their female partner’s name. I suppose it’s still seen as emasculating? It’s selfish to defer addressing this inequality to the next generation- we should be prepared to confront it now.

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 15:44

Tandora · 06/12/2023 15:34

Anyone who thinks they're in a position to remove a decision from their child is tragically misguided

What does this mean?

hyphenation is no more or less sustainable than any other option

it’s unsustainable in the sense that you can’t keep hyphenating down the generations or you’ll end up with stupidly long names. I suppose one option is the next generation takes one name from mum and one from dad and everyone always has a hyphenated name. But in any case not everyone likes hyphenated names, they can be long, clumsy, not very elegant etc.

I’m not against hyphenating per se - each to their own!, but it should be part of a range of equal choices. Just advocating for hyphenation doesn’t address the structural imbalance in prioritising dad’s name over mums when a choice has to be made, which will always remain until we normalise the expectation that it is equally preferable to just chose mum’s name.

Edited

The post of mine you quoted was in reply to someone claiming that double barrelling selfishly defers choice to the next generation. But there is no naming choice that could prevent deferring choice to the next generation, because parents choose their child's name, and even if they go along with what their parents did, in a free society they'll still have to make a decision. A parent who thinks they can do anything to prevent this deferral is therefore sadly misguided.

In terms of hyphenation, there are entire cultures that use a surname from both parents. Granted, they don't necessarily hyphenate, but the basic principle is the same. This has been going on for some time. It has been sustained.

But the underlying point is that nothing anyone calls their own child means the child doesn't then have a decision to make if they have DC. Sustainability as an argument simply doesn't make sense in this context, because you don't get to pick whether your decisions are sustained down the generations or not. If you want to argue that we should normalise the use of the mother's name only to try and balance the field, by all means do so, but that's a separate point to the now frankly daft trope about hyphenated.

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/12/2023 15:44

Charlie2121 · 06/12/2023 09:15

That is literally the worst option. I cringe every time I see it.

What happens if 2 hyphenated people then meet and want children. Do they have 4 surnames?

They make a decision just like any other couple would and of course it is unlikely they'll have 4 surnames.

They might keep their own names
They might use one each of their names
One might decide to take the others name

It was the best option for us. DC is our child so it makes sense that he has both of our names.

Tandora · 06/12/2023 15:34

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 15:21

Which is fine, but a very different point. Anyone who thinks they're in a position to remove a decision from their child is tragically misguided.

Also, hyphenation is no more or less sustainable than any other option.

Anyone who thinks they're in a position to remove a decision from their child is tragically misguided

What does this mean?

hyphenation is no more or less sustainable than any other option

it’s unsustainable in the sense that you can’t keep hyphenating down the generations or you’ll end up with stupidly long names. I suppose one option is the next generation takes one name from mum and one from dad and everyone always has a hyphenated name. But in any case not everyone likes hyphenated names, they can be long, clumsy, not very elegant etc.

I’m not against hyphenating per se - each to their own!, but it should be part of a range of equal choices. Just advocating for hyphenation doesn’t address the structural imbalance in prioritising dad’s name over mums when a choice has to be made, which will always remain until we normalise the expectation that it is equally preferable to just chose mum’s name.

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 15:21

Tandora · 06/12/2023 15:11

Yes but the point is that the solution of hyphenated names isn’t addressing the real structural imbalance- that the overwhelming norm is dad’s name takes precedence, and if mum doesn’t want to change her name then she puts up with a different name to her children. Hyphenating is a third option which isn’t sustainable. What we need to normalise now is that it becomes just as common for women to give their name to their children and for men to take their female partner’s name in cases where it’s thought desirable for everyone to have a shared name. The latter (where the female partner name is chosen as the sole family name) is so so rare , it is still so hard to negotiate this as a woman imv.

Which is fine, but a very different point. Anyone who thinks they're in a position to remove a decision from their child is tragically misguided.

Also, hyphenation is no more or less sustainable than any other option.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 06/12/2023 15:18

I just don't get the whole 'frenzy' over whether a woman should or should not change their name.
Lots of MNs get their knickers in a twist over how shocking it is for women to make that decision ! Basically it's got F-all to do with anyone else but the woman in question!

Tandora · 06/12/2023 15:11

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 14:26

The choice is with every generation. There isn't a way to make your DC not have a choice about what to call any kids they have.

Yes but the point is that the solution of hyphenated names isn’t addressing the real structural imbalance- that the overwhelming norm is dad’s name takes precedence, and if mum doesn’t want to change her name then she puts up with a different name to her children. Hyphenating is a third option which isn’t sustainable. What we need to normalise now is that it becomes just as common for women to give their name to their children and for men to take their female partner’s name in cases where it’s thought desirable for everyone to have a shared name. The latter (where the female partner name is chosen as the sole family name) is so so rare , it is still so hard to negotiate this as a woman imv.

CurlewKate · 06/12/2023 15:10

@Charlie2121 "On that basis then the people who use hyphenated names are selfishly deferring the choice to the next generation while at the same time burdening their entire family with a ridiculous moniker."

You seem to be starting from the point that hyphenated names are by definition ridiculous.

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 14:26

Charlie2121 · 06/12/2023 14:12

On that basis then the people who use hyphenated names are selfishly deferring the choice to the next generation while at the same time burdening their entire family with a ridiculous moniker.

The choice is with every generation. There isn't a way to make your DC not have a choice about what to call any kids they have.

Charlie2121 · 06/12/2023 14:12

CurlewKate · 06/12/2023 09:41

@BrimfulOfMash "What happens if 2 hyphenated people then meet and want children. Do they have 4 surnames?"

Here's a unique idea. They choose. (Sorry if your mind's blown. Lying down in a darkened room for a bit might help.)

On that basis then the people who use hyphenated names are selfishly deferring the choice to the next generation while at the same time burdening their entire family with a ridiculous moniker.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 06/12/2023 14:10

If you can't agree together as a couple what your baby's name should be then you shouldn't be having a baby together.

Charlie2121 · 06/12/2023 14:08

LusaBatoosa · 06/12/2023 10:58

You appear to have misunderstood. Her examples require the exact same number of name changes as yours. Exact same scenarios, it’s just the men doing the changing, as opposed to the women.

You’ve misunderstood what I wrote.

monsteramunch · 06/12/2023 12:59

@Charlie2121

In current times it feels to me that only those who have low expectations regarding the longevity of their relationship default to the mother’s surname.

Or they have high enough expectations of their relationship that they don't think giving the child the mother's last name instead of the father's last name makes a jot of difference to whether the relationship will work out or not...

Honeychickpea · 06/12/2023 11:18

Charlie2121 · 06/12/2023 09:19

I know about a dozen mainly older first time mothers who are all in stable relationships for a decade or more but have never bothered getting married.

Every single one has given their child the same surname as their father.

In current times it feels to me that only those who have low expectations regarding the longevity of their relationship default to the mother’s surname.

And of course in the other direction there are those who have high hopes that giving a child her "partner's" name will make him stick around. Oddly enough, it does not seem to be a strong glue.

Topseyt123 · 06/12/2023 11:15

I totally agree with this.

That said, I changed my name to DH's when we got married back in 1993. I do like that name and I'm happy with it. However, if I had known then what I know now (that changing my name wasn't really necessary) then I would have retained my maiden name. I'd then probably have given the children (all now in their twenties) my surname. As things stand, they have DH's name.

I might yet make an amendment to add my maiden name back in and ditch one of my middle names. I've regularly mused out loud about it and DH has even hinted that he would be willing to make this change himself if I do, which is rather lovely. 😃 I'd like to do it, but at 57 now I am rather daunted by the sheer number of official documents I would have to change!! For both of us.

BrimfulOfMash · 06/12/2023 11:15

Marriage is not the issue.

Either men or women can change their name to that of a partner (or to any other name) whether or not they are married.
Or not change their name.

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 11:13

pinkyredrose · 06/12/2023 11:06

You need to engage in some critical thinking.

They never do.

Outliers · 06/12/2023 11:11

pinkyredrose · 06/12/2023 11:06

You need to engage in some critical thinking.

Compelling

PallyRoe · 06/12/2023 11:11

DH agreed with me that it was stupid for only me to have to change my name, but we did want to share one and for the dc to have the same names as us.

So we chose a surname we both liked the sound of (not hyphenated, something completely new) and both changed our name to that.

Parents thought it was a great idea and we would be happy for dc to do the same in the future.

pinkyredrose · 06/12/2023 11:06

Outliers · 05/12/2023 23:29

Yes give the kid the name the mother got from her father

You need to engage in some critical thinking.

monsteramunch · 06/12/2023 11:04

@LusaBatoosa

You appear to have misunderstood. Her examples require the exact same number of name changes as yours. Exact same scenarios, it’s just the men doing the changing, as opposed to the women.

Thank you. Exactly this.

monsteramunch · 06/12/2023 11:03

@Charlie2121

I didn’t mention either parent changing their name when the child was born. I was commenting on the situation where parents are unmarried and/or have different surnames.

So was I.

In the instance of unmarried parents naming their child, in order for the family members to all have the same last name, the baby needs to be given the last name of one of the parents and the other parent would need to change their name to the same one (there's no need to be married to change your name).

My question is why in your opinion the chosen shared name should ideally be that of the father and not the mother?

The decision to name the child comes prior to any potential marriage therefore the choice is to give the child one of 2 names.

So why do you think that name should be that if the father rather than the mother?

In your example it would require 2 name changes prior to marriage, the child and one of the parents. That is a very clunky solution when the reality is it is only the child who needs naming.

Take marriage out of the equation. In the case of unmarried parents who don't want to marry at any point, why do you think that the name given to the child should be that if the father rather than the mother when the father can easily change his name to the mothers? The child is still being allocated one of their names and in order to all share a name, one parent has to change theirs too. Why the mother and not the father?