Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think this is a total over reaction

187 replies

titsgigglesandshits · 05/12/2023 19:55

I had three dates with a guy who was really lovely. Absolutely perfect and we got on really well, but after the 3rd date I knew he wanted to take it to the next level and I just wasn't ready so I finished it and said I liked him, he was perfect, but it was missing the chemistry. I had just come out of a short relationship and was quite upset about that, so I probably wasn't in the best place.

That was a few weeks ago and I have a lovely friend and she has younger children and although has her parents' support struggles juggling children, finances, work and time for herself. I would love to see someone sweep her off her feet and look after her, she's beautiful and kind.

I told her about the guy I'd briefly dated and asked if she wanted me to give him her number etc. She said yes so I got in touch and sent him her photos.

He said she was lovely and asked to meet me to find out more about her. I did expect him to just ask for her number, so when he asked to see me i wondered if it was a ploy to see me again. I told my friend and she said it sounded like he still liked me.

Anyway, I agreed to meet him and I was weirdly really looking forward to seeing him. He said he was disappointed that I'd ended it and I explained that I can be fickle and I wasn't ready for things to evolve or even if I wanted it to. He suggested that perhaps we just see each other as friends and if things evolved so be it. He said he's quite happy single, enjoys my company, so happy to go with the flow - no pressure. He said he liked I was independent job-wise and that our children were older. which isn't the case with my friend, but I wouldn't tell her this.

I spoke with my friend today, i was going to speak with her face to face, but she asked me over text and I explained what had happened. She's absolutely furious with me, she said I'm sly and underhand, i spend too much time on dating apps, jumping from one man to another, that I didn't need to meet him and if I were her friend I wouldn't have been so selfish. I'm really shocked by her reaction and feel really guilty as the last thing I wanted to do was upset her.

I feel guilty, because I probably will run from this relationship, and I didn't need to involve her to begin with, she didn't ask. I've apologised and agreed I was thinking about myself and the last thing I wanted to do was hurt her, but she won't have any of it. She's fuming.
WWYD

OP posts:
ChristmasFluff · 06/12/2023 07:01

It seems you are that person who shits all over people and then when they get upset says 'but I told you what I was like right from the start! This was YOUR choice!'

MargotBlobby · 06/12/2023 07:01

Also, if she’s still a friend in a week or two, you’ve kinda torpedoed the possibility of them ever meeting if you do become a couple with this guy. That would be so shite for the friend.

margotrose · 06/12/2023 06:52

You describe your friend as “lovely” and this man as “perfect” but yet you still seem to quite happy to shit on both them to try and boost your own ego.

I’m not surprised your friend is angry - that’s how “mean girls” behave.

MargotBlobby · 06/12/2023 06:51

I actually don’t think it’s weird you tried to set them up. When I was doing OLD I set a friend up with a guy I went on a date with. But it was after one date, nice guy, zero chemistry and he was just far more on her wavelength. They went out about a dozen times.

What’s weird is that you met up with him again after suggesting your friend. If I was the friend I would feel a bit used, although I do think she’s gone a bit OTT. But I think you get that now.

TryAgainWithFeeling · 06/12/2023 06:41

It’s weird that you attempted to set them up at all. It’s shitty to set them up then meet him.

And for gods sake, unless you’re 16 lose the “I warned him, I’m so fickle” act. Either it’s an act so he gets reeled in to “fix” you or you’re someone who doesn’t care that you treat people like shit, or maybe you’re protecting yourself because you’ve been treated badly. Whatever the reason, if you know that you treat them like shit, stop dating until you’ve worked on yourself. You won’t change because he is so nice - because he is not the problem, you are.

Yes, your friend overreacted to the particular situation. But I don’t blame her, because we’ve all known people like you who string other people along then dump them, and sometimes their behaviour pisses you off for ages until you can’t stand it any more. Her reaction isn’t about this one incident.

Honestly OP, you’ve got a chance here with a guy who sounds decent and a friendship in the balance. Don’t chuck it all away.

saffronsoup · 06/12/2023 06:38

Seems like you see both men and friends as toys to mess around with and play games with in order to get your own needs met. You will lose both in the end if you keep treating them like this.

I am going to hope you are still just a new adults and it is your youth and lack of life experience that is leading you to treat people this way.

Sleeplessnightssss · 06/12/2023 06:38

Wtf am i reading? I've never in my life heard of anything like it

stayathomer · 06/12/2023 06:33

I find it so weird that you even tried to fix them up in the first place!!!!!!

StayingUpSleepingIn · 06/12/2023 06:30

🙄

titsgigglesandshits · 06/12/2023 06:29

My mistake was I should never have mentioned him to my friend. I should have sat with that thought and processed my feelings.

It’s not really a straightforward case of him choosing me and preferring me over her because they’ve never met each other.

I had told my friend he’d asked to see me. It was only 3 weeks ago when I saw him last and we'd said we'd keep in touch.

Looking at my text messages my friend had said “it sounds like he still likes you as there’s not much to say in person that you can’t say over the phone, if that’s the case let it be. I don’t want to meet someone If they still like someone else” she also mentions that I should probably take some time out for a bit.

I think that’s why I didn’t give it more thought , as I didn’t think she was that invested.

I’m always protective and loyal towards my friends, which is why I’m upset that I’ve hurt her.
She won’t accept my apologies. I will tell her if she calms down about him saying she's at the wrong stage in life.

Never ever have I, would I flirt with my friend’s partners.

By cathartic I mean it's made me look at my behaviour, because you don't always see it until someone calls you out. it's good to hear the opinions on here, I needed to hear it.
We make mistakes, we learn we grow - it's life!

OP posts:
ErmWhatever · 06/12/2023 05:58

"This has actually been very cathartic"

Well that makes it ok then 🤨

You sound very self involved.

thishasnotmyweek · 06/12/2023 05:56

Your friend is angry because you’ve played with her feelings and don’t seem to care / understand that what you did was wrong.

Why suggest they get together if you had any interest at all. That was a really stupid move - what if they met and liked each other then you’d have got jealous and it would have been a recipe for disaster.

Ridiculous idea. He also should have been honest about why he wanted to meet you and just said ‘I’m not interested in your friend because I’m interested in you’

PubicZirconia · 06/12/2023 05:53

Yeah...you've messed up.Why you are treating your 'kind and beautiful' friend and 'perfect' guy like this is beyond me.Stop with the faux innocence,you know exactly what you're doing.

WandaWonder · 06/12/2023 05:21

So in short you need a man, you don't care how as long as you can claim one and get attention?

Pancakeorcrepe · 06/12/2023 05:20

You are playing some very weird games. Just leave these two people alone until you mature and stop being so manipulative.

Random30 · 06/12/2023 05:18

You haven’t been much of a friend though.

As you say - you’re fickle, and obviously wanted to put your friend back in her box.

You weren’t a friend and I’d imagine this is just another example.

HeraSyndulla · 06/12/2023 05:13

I think you need to leave this guy alone.

Zanatdy · 06/12/2023 05:11

You should have told your friend about the young kids issue as assume that means he wasn’t interested anyway. I can see why your friend is hurt

LadyOfTheCanyon · 06/12/2023 05:10

"I know I'm fickle and I always sabotage or run"

This isn't some kind of badge of honour. If you know this about yourself you should be working on why, not using it in an "OMG, I'm so deep and insightful, but also a sexy hot mess" way to reel in men, who mostly fall for that shit.

Women, on the other hand, see right through you.

ANightingale · 06/12/2023 05:05

This does sound a bit like something that would happen amongst 12 year olds. "My mate really likes you" type thing.

He said he liked I was independent job-wise and that our children were older. which isn't the case with my friend, but I wouldn't tell her this.

It might be less hurtful to your friend if you did tell her - if she's at the wrong life-stage for him that's more of a neutral message than him liking you better than her.

LAMPS1 · 06/12/2023 04:48

You offered your cast off to your lovely friend as a sort of gift to make up for her struggling. She enthusiastically agreed but then you withdrew the gift because you suddenly got excited about seeing him again.
That is two people’s lives you are messing with.
No wonder your lovely friend is upset.

What do you plan to do with him next OP ?

momonpurpose · 06/12/2023 02:44

tachycardigan · 05/12/2023 21:49

You only want him because she likes the sound of him. She’s not the spiteful one.

With friendsike these who needs enemies

Museum10662 · 06/12/2023 02:13

titsgigglesandshits · 05/12/2023 21:47

My initial intention did come from a good place. I didn’t expect him to ask to see me, that threw me and made me reflect. He is lovely. he’s emotionally available, he’s local, he’s not needy, he’s kind , he’s perfect and then I thought why do I not want perfect?

I was honest with him. I said I’m fickle and I always sabotage or run he said no pressure. Let’s see what happens He’s happy to go with the flow he’s very chilled.

It has made me reflect about dating apps and my ego though. There's truth in that but I genuinely didn’t expect her to be so upset.
She also said she bet I’d slept with him .. which I absolutely didn’t and was why I ran before as didn’t want to take it to the next level. I think that was quite spiteful and made me feel less sorry tbh.

I was selfish and I take that on board, but you’d think I’d killed her cat and shoved it through the letter box by her reaction. I don’t think what I did was that bad

Some people don't always understand the differences of levels of bad, they just see as has happened that what you did was bad,

Ellamaelucyolivia · 06/12/2023 02:11

I don't understand how you don't realise you've done a shit thing. You got her hopes up. She was excited and happy. Then you kept him yourself. I know why she is so angry. I think you lack awareness, OP, and you're playing around with people's feelings.

StayingUpSleepingIn · 06/12/2023 02:09

**She wanted to know HE thought she was better than her friend.