Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Managers focus on soft skills feels like discrimination

66 replies

Hicorky · 05/12/2023 16:14

Hi,
I work in a loosely marketing job, really it's more brand management. I had to attend a networking event as part of work last week, I've been to hundreds now and know the ropes. I was asked to take two girls we have with us on "year in Industry" placements from university. Not a problem, they are working between marketing and brand management so I don't know them great but thought it would be fun,
In meetings I've been in where their progress has come up it's been clear at every level above one girl is liked much much more than the other. Our company sells expensive products that I imagine many 20/21 year olds haven't had a lot of real engagement with. However one of the girls has, due to a much wealthier background. The other girl doesn't have that experience, she is also autistic and has ADHD.
The networking event was a couple of speeches then drinks and light buffet. After the speeches I said they could either stick with me, I'd introduce them to people or if they felt confident they could go off and work the room.
The girl who is seemingly loved by all went off and worked the room the other stayed by me. The first girl was a natural, not surprising since based on her instagram she's a member of various private members clubs, so I assume she's quite used to networking.
I'd say she did all of it with more ease than I did. The other girl was really shy, stuck to my side and even when I'd directly include her in conversation struggled. I'll assume this is part of her autism.
When I got back I asked them both to just write up a report on it all, summary of the speeches and anything we could action or bring up at the next team meeting off the back of it, I planned to pass it along to my manager.
Yesterday they both gave me them and well girl 1 did much better than girl 2. She had managed to speak to each of the speakers after and ask lots of questions, got access to more resources etc. Just had a look and she's linked with two of them on LinkedIn now! The other girl was very much bullet points of the presentations.
My manager had a look at them and asked how I felt they did. I was honest and said girl
1 was definitely more comfortable but they both learned a lot. My manager now thinks that girl 2s lack of soft skills are extremely concerning. We've had other issues with her, persistent absence, poor quality of work even when being hand held through it. In comparison to her class mate they are worlds apart. Her classmate is very good at taking initiative, getting started on a task then asking questions as she goes. Girl 2 just sort of sits if she isn't 100% sure until someone approaches her.
We will be doing a review for them in then next couple of weeks and feeding back to the coordinator at their university.
My manager has expressed she is considering suggesting to the university they find a different placement for the last 2/3 of the year as she isn't thriving here or making any attempt to.
She listed her reasons as

  • Poor work quality
  • Persistent absence
  • Lack of initiative
  • Poor soft skills

I'm concerned the last two could be seen as discrimination considering she has autism? And I'd like to point it out to my manager before she goes ahead and uses those as reasons.
AIBU for thinking those reasons are discrimination?

OP posts:
egowise · 05/12/2023 17:53

Quite a lot of people seem to have zero idea about what employers have to do in regards to disabilities.

www.gov.uk/reasonable-adjustments-for-disabled-workers

It's a requirement to offer reasonable adjustments.

Keepinmovin · 05/12/2023 17:48

Hicorky · 05/12/2023 16:14

Hi,
I work in a loosely marketing job, really it's more brand management. I had to attend a networking event as part of work last week, I've been to hundreds now and know the ropes. I was asked to take two girls we have with us on "year in Industry" placements from university. Not a problem, they are working between marketing and brand management so I don't know them great but thought it would be fun,
In meetings I've been in where their progress has come up it's been clear at every level above one girl is liked much much more than the other. Our company sells expensive products that I imagine many 20/21 year olds haven't had a lot of real engagement with. However one of the girls has, due to a much wealthier background. The other girl doesn't have that experience, she is also autistic and has ADHD.
The networking event was a couple of speeches then drinks and light buffet. After the speeches I said they could either stick with me, I'd introduce them to people or if they felt confident they could go off and work the room.
The girl who is seemingly loved by all went off and worked the room the other stayed by me. The first girl was a natural, not surprising since based on her instagram she's a member of various private members clubs, so I assume she's quite used to networking.
I'd say she did all of it with more ease than I did. The other girl was really shy, stuck to my side and even when I'd directly include her in conversation struggled. I'll assume this is part of her autism.
When I got back I asked them both to just write up a report on it all, summary of the speeches and anything we could action or bring up at the next team meeting off the back of it, I planned to pass it along to my manager.
Yesterday they both gave me them and well girl 1 did much better than girl 2. She had managed to speak to each of the speakers after and ask lots of questions, got access to more resources etc. Just had a look and she's linked with two of them on LinkedIn now! The other girl was very much bullet points of the presentations.
My manager had a look at them and asked how I felt they did. I was honest and said girl
1 was definitely more comfortable but they both learned a lot. My manager now thinks that girl 2s lack of soft skills are extremely concerning. We've had other issues with her, persistent absence, poor quality of work even when being hand held through it. In comparison to her class mate they are worlds apart. Her classmate is very good at taking initiative, getting started on a task then asking questions as she goes. Girl 2 just sort of sits if she isn't 100% sure until someone approaches her.
We will be doing a review for them in then next couple of weeks and feeding back to the coordinator at their university.
My manager has expressed she is considering suggesting to the university they find a different placement for the last 2/3 of the year as she isn't thriving here or making any attempt to.
She listed her reasons as

  • Poor work quality
  • Persistent absence
  • Lack of initiative
  • Poor soft skills

I'm concerned the last two could be seen as discrimination considering she has autism? And I'd like to point it out to my manager before she goes ahead and uses those as reasons.
AIBU for thinking those reasons are discrimination?

I think you'd be sensible to suggest to your manager that the feedback concentrates on areas for development and things like "soft skills" can be presented as an area for development without that needing to be discrimination. If those skills are indeed needed for the job. So ability to meet new people absolutely can be a requirement for a job, but I'd say they need to try not to compare with the other person as I'd say a lot of students may struggle in that sort of situation.
So if the manager suggests that some work is required in these areas in order to be successful then that's very reasonable. I'd suggest to them probably better not to lead with "find another placement" but perhaps talk to uni about how they can support this girl in developing these areas and if she doesn't want to then look for another placement

theduchessofspork · 05/12/2023 17:48

Catza · 05/12/2023 17:42

Every time I had issues with my student, I was asked by placement coordinator to provide documentation as above. Which is completely fair. If university does not require it, they are a shit university.
When I was a student, some of my colleagues went through a placement thinking they did a great job just to get a D at the end of it. If no relevant documentation was provided from the placement educator, the organisation was removed from the next cohort allocation list as they were deemed poor placement provider.
I am sure it is not a norm with every uni and every industry but it really should be. The students are there to learn, not to plug holes in the rota.

They do require paperwork, but if it’s not working out, they often do whatever it is they do to push that through based on a quick conv with the company. If it’s an in demand company, no university is going to want to piss them off.

I think there is a middle way myself, so I am not advocating this, but it’s absolutely what happens

Katbum · 05/12/2023 17:46

I’m a lecturer in a similar management subject, and our students do years in industry. IMO this is a learning experience and if I were the tutor my preference would be working with the student and industry partner to address the issues outlined so she can complete her year placement. When you take on students in placements such as these you are agreeing to assist in their education - as any teacher will tell you there are wildly different levels of intelligence, motivation, engagement and so on with any set of students, and teaching needs to be differentiated to their needs. That means yes, reasonable adjustments for disabilities (I agree the last two could be seen as discrimination), but also ‘scaffolding’ the learning so those with greater needs don’t fall off the edge. It would be quite a blow to lose a prestigious placement, so anything that you can do to give her a chance to address the behaviour that is not working for your company would be best practice I think. You can make it clear absence and so on is a problem, while working with her and her tutors to help her get the most out of the placement.

user628468523532453 · 05/12/2023 17:43

Why do people insist on giving their "answer" on threads like this when they clearly have zero knowledge of the law in question.

Catza · 05/12/2023 17:42

theduchessofspork · 05/12/2023 17:37

TBF it often doesn’t work like that IMO

But anyway it’s the OP’s manager’s problem

Every time I had issues with my student, I was asked by placement coordinator to provide documentation as above. Which is completely fair. If university does not require it, they are a shit university.
When I was a student, some of my colleagues went through a placement thinking they did a great job just to get a D at the end of it. If no relevant documentation was provided from the placement educator, the organisation was removed from the next cohort allocation list as they were deemed poor placement provider.
I am sure it is not a norm with every uni and every industry but it really should be. The students are there to learn, not to plug holes in the rota.

Getthethrowonthesofa · 05/12/2023 17:40

I’m not sure how it qualifies as discrimination. Discrimination is effectively treating one employee less favourably than another. Stating the young woman lacks certain skills is not discrimation, it is a statement of fact.

mids2019 · 05/12/2023 17:39

@Zamzamzamdeedah

A lot of wise words there

Universities that are heavily marketed themselves are not going to turn away money and their courses nay not be to the benefit of the student

The inclusive environment of universities and the 'being your whole self' to work attitude is creating unrealistic expectations in an unsympathetic world.

I wish schools and universities could have the hard conversations and not pass the buck to employers when it may be more difficult to reappraise career choices.

SawX · 05/12/2023 17:37

Are initiative and soft skills required to do the job? Can she do them adequately with reasonable adjustments?

If yes and no then you can discriminate. I'm disabled and some jobs simply aren't suitable for me.

theduchessofspork · 05/12/2023 17:37

Catza · 05/12/2023 17:35

Also to add, you cannot just suggest to the university that they find alternative placement. I take on placement students and when issues arise you need to demonstrate that the student is aware of the issues with their performance (i.e. documented minutes from the weekly review where these issues were raised), you put a collaborative action plan for improvement which details additional support provided, deadline by which you expect improvement and specific outcome measures you propose to track improvements etc. Only after the clear plan has been put in place and the student failed to follow through despite additional support, you can have a discussion with placement coordinator about terminating the placement.
These are your basic responsibilities as practice placement educator/supervisor.

Edited

TBF it often doesn’t work like that IMO

But anyway it’s the OP’s manager’s problem

theduchessofspork · 05/12/2023 17:36

I’m not an expert but if you lack soft skills that’s just a statement of fact - it’s not a direct criticism, just an expression of an area of weakness (which we all have)

I don’t see lack of initiative really comes into it, unless her manifestation of autism is such that she isn’t picking up cues to do things that an NT person would.

I wouldn’t worry about policing your manager and this gig seems absolutely wrong for her, so it’s in everyone’s interests her university finds something that works better

Catza · 05/12/2023 17:35

Also to add, you cannot just suggest to the university that they find alternative placement. I take on placement students and when issues arise you need to demonstrate that the student is aware of the issues with their performance (i.e. documented minutes from the weekly review where these issues were raised), you put a collaborative action plan for improvement which details additional support provided, deadline by which you expect improvement and specific outcome measures you propose to track improvements etc. Only after the clear plan has been put in place and the student failed to follow through despite additional support, you can have a discussion with placement coordinator about terminating the placement.
These are your basic responsibilities as practice placement educator/supervisor.

user628468523532453 · 05/12/2023 17:35

Failure to make reasonable adjustments is automatically unlawful discrimination.

Have reasonable adjustments been made?

Zamzamzamdeedah · 05/12/2023 17:34

@BadSkiingMum it wasn't her. It was them

CornishPorsche · 05/12/2023 17:34

Unfortunately, if you're not a good fit for a job, you're not a good fit for a job.

Sadly whilst it might legally be discrimination, it's also a reality that not every person is right for every job.

If this doesn't work for girl 2, it's as well she works out now what suits her best and not in a few years when she's in a job she hates and makes her ill.

mids2019 · 05/12/2023 17:34

@Sportycustard

I am sorry to hear about your DD and graduate training schemes can be stressful and there is cometition for them. Also some companies are just bad employers and many pay lip service to inclusivity programs.

It may be that your daughter finds the right type of employer eventually 🙂

Zamzamzamdeedah · 05/12/2023 17:33

mids2019 · 05/12/2023 17:27

@Sparthan

I agree but isn't it up to universities as well to maybe suggest a course isnt suitable as the work placements necessitate a certain skill set?

The university probably has quite happily take tuition fees with the promise that the degree and all its components are inclusive.

The university can quite easily and is duty bound to make accomodations meaning the company boss is then the bad guy.

I think it's colleges. I saw them do that "of course you can do it if you want to!" encouragement in absolutely not suitable situations.

While reasonable adjustments at work help, sometimes they simply are not enough. As said, sometimes we cannot do the job we would love to. Some people manage later to have it on a side or as a hobby, but such is kife whether it's because of disability or lack of certain talent or skills.

Being realistic with people, while still encouraging, so making sure they know what the problems might be and what other maybe better suitable options they have, would make lots of young people's lives easier. Same goes for pushing people for uni when they are practical rather than academic (like writing essays) and then they end up absolutely miserable for 3 years and end with 2.2 while they could have thrived in different environment.

BadSkiingMum · 05/12/2023 17:31

I remember a programme about social mobility made by Amol Rajan, all about graduates getting into top jobs. He compared the progress of a young man from a very advantaged background (Dulwich College etc) with another graduate with equivalent qualifications but from a disadvantaged background. It was fascinating; sadly no longer on iplayer, although a second programme he made on the topic is still available I think. Both were trying to get internships etc.

A lot of social mobility interventions appear to be based on the idea of employers accessing untapped pools of talent, which of course is quite likely to be the case. But half the problem in this programme seemed to be that the privileged young man was also very likeable, hardworking and had great soft skills. It would have been hard for any employer to argue against hiring him, whereas an employer would have had to look a bit harder to see that in the other graduate. From what I remember those characteristics were probably there, but just at a much earlier stage of development.

I am not sure what the solution is, but surely girl 2 needs more time to develop rather than having her placement ended abruptly?

Sportycustard · 05/12/2023 17:28

Thank you for not just writing off the second girl. Last year my DD was the second girl also on a placement year. She was dropped in at the deep end with a company expecting to use a placement student to cover a product owner on maternity leave. My DD struggled, probably 50% her fault ( probably autistic, awaiting diagnosis) and 50% the company's unreasonable expectations.

The way they handled it was very poor and has resulted in my DD believing all grad schemes to be beyond her capability, her degree to be of no use now and me trying to shore up her self confidence to get her through her final year.

If you do let this girl go please, please, please give her feedback on some strengths so she has something positive to focus on.

mids2019 · 05/12/2023 17:27

@Sparthan

I agree but isn't it up to universities as well to maybe suggest a course isnt suitable as the work placements necessitate a certain skill set?

The university probably has quite happily take tuition fees with the promise that the degree and all its components are inclusive.

The university can quite easily and is duty bound to make accomodations meaning the company boss is then the bad guy.

HFJ · 05/12/2023 17:25

This is a real shame. We expect the finished article. Some people need more guidance and support, but then do even better once they’ve found their way. Many young people, regardless of a diagnosis, would struggl to ‘work the room’. In this respect, I also think there is discrimination - against the less confident, young men, autistic women.

Sparthan · 05/12/2023 17:23

If you need to be comfortable and confident networking to be a brand manager apprentice, then its not discriminating to say she can't do the job, whatever the reason for her discomfort and lack of confidence
I agree, but it’s a bit late in the day for OP’s boss to decide this is an essential aspect of the role. If these are vital skills for the job then they shouldn’t have accepted a placement candidate with autism and ADHD, who clearly isn’t going to have those skills.

mids2019 · 05/12/2023 17:21

The problem is she may actually doing well at university as neurological disorder is viewed compassionately. It is much easier for a university to accommodate the symptoms than a 'real life' company.

I think this may be a warning to the many autistic/ADHD children that at some point in life there will be real challenges that inclusive policies can't take account of.

I also think the positive stories of ADHD/autistic children 'thriving' can sadly be disingenuous but no body admits this in public

We then come down to the fact that advocates often say people should be open about disability but it is debatable how much this helps

thing47 · 05/12/2023 17:19

I think it would be really mean not to let her complete the placement, surely she could be found work in other areas of the business, as PPs have suggested.

But I'm not sure the last two reasons amount to discrimination - I imagine people without autism or ADHD would also be let go if it was felt that their skillset was not suited to the role.

Sparthan · 05/12/2023 17:19

How does her autism stop her writing a good report on what she heard?
Well for example, OP said she asked for a summary of the speeches and action points. So I presume the autistic girl took the instructions literally and produced exactly that. Whereas the other girl included other things that OP didn’t ask for. To an autistic person that would be outside of their remit since they were specifically asked only for summaries and action points. OP also said she liked the other girl’s report better because she networked with the speakers, which the girl with autism was unable to do due to her disability.

I’m not sure that persistent absence is linked to her autism either
I have autism. I’ve been known to quit jobs because the train journey was noisy and overwhelming and strangers kept touching me. Some days I called in sick because I just couldn’t cope with it. Also OP hasn’t said what adjustments were put in place for the girl’s disability, so perhaps the office environment was intolerable for her too. So yes, autism can be linked with absence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread