Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist we review all outgoings before cutting cleaner’s hours?

189 replies

Rainallnight · 05/12/2023 14:36

We are very fortunate to be comfortably off and I realise this whole post is a first world problem.

Our cleaner comes twice a week. DP and I agreed this when I returned to work after DC, on the grounds that she simply doesn’t see stuff that needs to be done and it would fall automatically to me.

DP works full time, is the higher earner. I work slightly less than full time and am with DC when not in work.

Our outgoings are too high, and DP wants to reduce the cleaner to once a week.

I think the cleaner looks like the ‘easy’ thing to cut whereas there are hidden costs that could equally be reduced. For example, DP is supposed to be in charge of dinners (planning them if not actually making them) and the planning and shopping is often bad, which means we end up with a lot of expensive M&S convenience food, and Deliveroo.

That’s just an example to show what I mean.

I’m worried that cutting the cleaner will add more drudgery to my life, and want us to do a proper review of outgoing first.

AIBU?

DP is very dogmatic about things and finds it difficult to have a reasonable conversation about stuff like this so it would be good for my thought process to hear others’ points of view.

OP posts:
MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 06/12/2023 09:18

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 08:19

@Sunshineandflipflops I’m a bit staggered too! When DM was younger and a single parent with a child with chronic asthma (downstairs rooms were non carpeted and needed to be vacuumed and mopped regularly) and she managed to do all her own cleaning, washing and shopping too as well as working full time as a teacher. And that was also in a large Victorian house, no tumble dryer as too expensive (she did have one when we were little but then a rat got into it when it wasn’t used…and my stepdad set fire to it in the snow outside, another story!). For years me and DB hoovered our own rooms and helped with housework and my nana (DM’s DM) offered to buy DM a dishwasher as we always squabbled over doing the washing up
but DM said no and refused this! We only got one when we were early teenagers.

But why the fuck should they clear up after another functioning adult?

Cleaning takes your time away- why your mother martyred herself and why you see refusing the help of a dishwasher as something to be proud of is beyond me.

Op, it is always easiest to cut back on things that don't affect you- yanbu to challenge this.

Viviennemary · 06/12/2023 09:14

Just get a better paid job if you Can't afford a cleaner twice a week or cut back on other stuff. Can't be a lot of other cleaning if you have a cleaner twice a week.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2023 09:12

@Rainallnight how do you feel about the pp on this thread calling your dp lazy, a bully, etc. Is that a sentiment you share?

FWIW none of the lazy partners that I’ve ever come across do any of the cooking, meal planning and shopping, while holding down a full time job. And I would guess she does a bit more than that.

justasking111 · 06/12/2023 08:51

OH you really need a comprehensive spreadsheet of all outgoings.

Mortgage, energy, council tax, water rates, cars, fuel, food, cleaner, Netflix etc That will give you a base line for basics. Then child costs,

all the above are joint payments

Hobbies, beauty, clothes etc and other fripperies come down to individual choice so are from your fun fund which is yours alone.

Mikimoto · 06/12/2023 08:47

Switch to Octopus - savings done in one fell swoop.

Pelham678 · 06/12/2023 08:40

The single parent argument is both a race to the bottom and also doesn't take into account that a messy/slobby adult can create more mess than a tidy/clean one. It's much less stressful to clean up after yourself and your children than after a lazy partner, and causes less resentment.

RosesAndHellebores · 06/12/2023 08:39

@Sunshineandflipflops because DH and I work 9/10 hour days - sometimes out of the house for 12 hours, the house is 3,500 Square feet. The cleaner cleans for three hours one day: mopping hard floors, vacuuming carpets, cleans bogs and bathrooms and does an hour of ironing; the other day she dusts and wipes paintwork and does more ironing. 7 hours a week.

Also, we like living in a clean and tidy house and we don't like cleaning and don't have time to do it. We are early 60s and when I retire, I might cut it down and do the ironing. There is still the garden, cooking, laundry, shopping, maintenance bits to do.

I would ask @Rainallnight how big the house is and whether they have a spreadsheet not only of outgoings but of each other's time spent on jobs/domestic responsibilities. They need to be added to the working hours and the overall time time rendered needs to be equal. DH always worked a lot more than me when the dc were little (from 0 to 18) but our input as a team was equal.

Pipsquiggle · 06/12/2023 08:35

There are loads of things I would cut back on before I reduced my cleaner's hours - because she make my life so much easier & better

I actually think the deliveroo and the meal planning are great examples.
The mark up on uber eats / deliveroo is insane (I work in grocery) and I honestly don't know how people can afford.
After years (decades) of trying to meal plan, I have finally cracked it over the last couple of months, I am truly staggered by the amount I am saving and my food waste is significantly reduced.

By the sounds of it, you are doing all the grunt work already so why should you just capitulate over the cleaner.
Definitely look at other expenditure before looking at reducing the cleaning hours.

Zanatdy · 06/12/2023 08:32

It does seem the obvious choice as twice a week is definitely a luxury. I have my friend clean once a fortnight and I really look forward to clean day so I can see why you’re hesitant to give it up. When you work and have young kids it’s tough to find the time. I voted you’re not unreasonable as I do think you need to review all outgoings and not just something that’s going to impact you. Agree hairdressers, food budget. Or look at what the cleaner drops, get her to focus on the jobs you dislike most. Twice a week is a lot, unless you have a huge house

Victoria3010 · 06/12/2023 08:32

We did a spreadsheet of our outgoings (we are also well off/lucky) and it surprised me how much nonsense was on there. Coffees/little shop trips was costing maybe £100 a month (I know that sounds mad, but it was actually only 1 or 2 trips a week), same for takeaways, lunches out etc. I had a bad Amazon habit and started getting kids clothes on vinted instead of expensive shops (same brands half the price), I also had loads of subscriptions I didn't use much (looking at your Paramount). It all added up to more than I thought. Equally I've never had (or even thought of) a cleaner more than once a week - this does seem a lot. Could you also write down all the jobs you each do, I know you said she doesn't "see" stuff, but could she just always do one/two jobs once a week like a cleaning rota. Also could you move the cleaners hours to get max benefit? Fridays are always best for me to get the benefit over the weekend, mid week I care less, maybe then once a week would do?

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 06/12/2023 08:19

Sunshineandflipflops · 05/12/2023 15:12

I am just amazed that people have a cleaner twice a week!

I am a full-time working single mum of two and manage to do my own cleaning, washing, shopping and cooking.

Sorry, that doesn't answer your question but I am struggling to relate to potentially 'only' having a cleaner once a week.

@Sunshineandflipflops I’m a bit staggered too! When DM was younger and a single parent with a child with chronic asthma (downstairs rooms were non carpeted and needed to be vacuumed and mopped regularly) and she managed to do all her own cleaning, washing and shopping too as well as working full time as a teacher. And that was also in a large Victorian house, no tumble dryer as too expensive (she did have one when we were little but then a rat got into it when it wasn’t used…and my stepdad set fire to it in the snow outside, another story!). For years me and DB hoovered our own rooms and helped with housework and my nana (DM’s DM) offered to buy DM a dishwasher as we always squabbled over doing the washing up
but DM said no and refused this! We only got one when we were early teenagers.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2023 08:18

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 08:00

The difficulty with cooking together as a solution is that it's concentrating parental resources. It only works if both parents have finished work and neither is needed for anything else like looking after a DC young enough to need supervision still or taking an older one to clubs. So it may be practicality more than preference. It might work sometimes, but from what OP has said, it isn't likely to solve the issue.

That’s a fair point. I’m a single parent and have gotten used figuring out how to supervise young children while cooking, grocery shopping etc.

However, I also suggested to take it in turns. The Op has made it clear that they think that their Dp is not doing the meal planning, shopping and cooking well enough. It makes sense to help them out with that. When you are a couple, you help each other out and work as a team.

There are posts on MN where the partner who works longer hours does absolutely no household chores whatsoever. Which is not ok. That is not the case here.

CherryBlossom321 · 06/12/2023 08:17

You have less of a financial problem, and more of mutually respectful, equitable relationship problem. That needs addressing more urgently.

MandyFriend · 06/12/2023 08:15

I would suggest doing an audit of your last three month's spending. You can import most bank and credit card statements into Excel these days which should speed things up a bit. Break it down into the basics, Food, Fuel, Takeaways, Subscriptions, the cleaner, etc to get to the bottom of where you're overspending and take things from there. We've done this a few times and it can be quite surprising where you're spending all your money!

PS. I've been married for 27 years and cleaning rotas don't work and just cause arguments!

JoanOfAllTrades · 06/12/2023 08:14

DP is being very unreasonable!

You do the life admin, work almost full time, do the childcare when you’re not working, do the laundry and goodness know what else!

@Rainallnight, if you don’t want to lose the cleaner, you need to be strategic.

Make a list of all the household/family tasks that you do, solely!

Make a list of all the household/family tasks that DP does solely and also any that you have to help her with, such as the meal planning/shopping, which is a huge waste of money if it’s all convenience food.

Then make a list of every single task that needs to be done in the house, so it looks like this:

BEDROOM

Tidying
High dusting
Low dusting
Vacuuming
Launder bedding
Polish furniture
Wipe down skirting board
Clean window sill and inside of windows
Dust lampshades
Clean pictures and picture frames
Clean mirrors

EN-SUITE

List all the tasks, high dusting, windows, shower, etc.

I hope that your cleaner is doing all that, and I’m sure they probably are, as cleaning is easy, if you keep on top of it!

Once you’ve made your list, and included meal planning, shopping and meal prep to be done on Sunday!, then you can put names next to each job! Include laundry, washing out the bin, everything!

If you require help to make a list, please message me, I’ll be happy to send you a complete list! Also, make it clear to DP, that if she wants a clean home, rather than just a tidy one, and don’t move the ornaments 😉, then she has to be prepared for the housework to take up about 6 hours per week, with you doing the other 6 hours (I’m including laundry in that as well).

Then the meal planning, shopping and meal prep, is going to be quite a few hours initially, until DP sets up a good system, and evening meals should be able to be lunches for the next day, to make things easier and save money, if you’re currently paying for lunch. Doing this will save heaps of money!

Then allocate which life admin tasks that you are responsible for and which one's are DP’s!

Make sure you allocate childcare tasks as well. Since you do the majority of care whilst DP works, then she should take the reins after she’s cooked dinner and cleaned the kitchen, loaded the dishwasher/washed the dishes, etc.

Hopefully by doing this, you will open her eyes to the reality of being working parents and juggling it all between you.

Can it be done? Of course it can, I did it, as do millions of parents, but if you don’t have to do it, then why would you?

I would also make the point that in this current COL crisis, does DP really want to fire the cleaner? Surely cutting back on takeaway coffees/paying for lunches/dyeing your own hair, is better than firing the cleaner?

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 08:12

Fwiw, I think DP sounds more disorganised than lazy.

Panic ringing Deliveroo for meals they can't really afford probably uses up more mental energy than buying some frozen pizza for banana skin nights and putting it in the oven. It's one of the ironies about planning, not doing it often makes your life harder overall.

EveWinter · 06/12/2023 08:09

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2023 08:00

@TrashedSofa I was responding to what you wrote, not what the Op wrote. ‘I would guess it’s because DP doesn't actually do the cleaning, even when supposed to.’

Having a cleaner once a week should be making it a great deal easier than for many of us who don’t have a cleaner at all. I really don’t think that twice a week should be necessary.

I do all the housework. No cleaner to vacuum, mop, clean the bathroom, toilet, sinks, wipe the kitchen benches. I do all that.

Apart from cleaning up after ourselves it only needs to be done once a week.

With a cleaner (even if they only came once a week) what other housework would Op need to do other than laundry, loading the dishwasher, tidying up after the kids? It’s not a lot really.

I do all the housework, cooking, meal planning, shopping, laundry and mowing the lawns.

The Op’s partner (who works longer hours) is doing the grocery shopping, meal planning and cooking but just not up to the standard that Op expects. And whether or not the Op is male or female, I don’t think that’s being reasonable. Op’s Dp is making a significant contribution to the household chores yet is being made out to be lazy.

I’m baffled by posts like this. How do you know that the OP doesn’t need a cleaner twice a week? A PP said ⬆️ that it’s always a race to the bottom on these threads and she was right.

I’d have my cleaner more than once a week if she’d do it, she hasn’t got room. Second visit would be changing the beds amongst other things. I can afford to outsource as much as I want to.

I can’t buy extra free time but I can choose to make it. That extra couple of hours, taking my teen out for a walk/lunch, nine holes, swim, extra yoga class. You done have to justify farming it out.

Pelham678 · 06/12/2023 08:09

I think I'd say that I will personally pay for the extra cleaning day and DP can personally pay for any deliveroo/ready meals. How can she argue with that and you'll more than likely do better on the deal?

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 08:08

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2023 08:00

@TrashedSofa I was responding to what you wrote, not what the Op wrote. ‘I would guess it’s because DP doesn't actually do the cleaning, even when supposed to.’

Having a cleaner once a week should be making it a great deal easier than for many of us who don’t have a cleaner at all. I really don’t think that twice a week should be necessary.

I do all the housework. No cleaner to vacuum, mop, clean the bathroom, toilet, sinks, wipe the kitchen benches. I do all that.

Apart from cleaning up after ourselves it only needs to be done once a week.

With a cleaner (even if they only came once a week) what other housework would Op need to do other than laundry, loading the dishwasher, tidying up after the kids? It’s not a lot really.

I do all the housework, cooking, meal planning, shopping, laundry and mowing the lawns.

The Op’s partner (who works longer hours) is doing the grocery shopping, meal planning and cooking but just not up to the standard that Op expects. And whether or not the Op is male or female, I don’t think that’s being reasonable. Op’s Dp is making a significant contribution to the household chores yet is being made out to be lazy.

Then why did you write 'Since when does the partner who works longer hours be expected to do more of the housework than the partner who works less hours?'. Because nobody has said that at all.

Neither does the laundry comparison make sense in that context. Even if you want to argue that the meal planning and cooking as DP currently does it is a bigger job than the laundry, you still left all the rest of the housework out of it entirely, and you're only minimising the amount of work it involves now it's been pointed out to you what OP actually said. With no information about the size of the house, the age of the DC and how much time they spend in it, you can't decide it isn't a lot.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2023 08:06

@spriots I tried ordering online (I am not in the UK) and every time it was delivered I would have items that were somehow unavailable and substituted with something completely different, smashed/damaged produce and one time (the last time and never again) fresh produce covered in leaked cleaning fluid and had to be thrown away. So, I prefer to do it myself.

limefrog · 06/12/2023 08:04

A cleaner twice a week does seem like a lot. How many children do you have?

We have a cleaner once a fortnight and it's really not difficult to keep on top of things in between.

Does it really need to be cleaned twice a week?

Readingineading · 06/12/2023 08:03

When we were both working full time and the kids were small ( DH is retired now) we used to do a 3 month review on who was doing what, if it worked and see what we help we could reasonably buy in.
Would your DW be up for a discussion like that @Rainallnight ?

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 08:00

The difficulty with cooking together as a solution is that it's concentrating parental resources. It only works if both parents have finished work and neither is needed for anything else like looking after a DC young enough to need supervision still or taking an older one to clubs. So it may be practicality more than preference. It might work sometimes, but from what OP has said, it isn't likely to solve the issue.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2023 08:00

@TrashedSofa I was responding to what you wrote, not what the Op wrote. ‘I would guess it’s because DP doesn't actually do the cleaning, even when supposed to.’

Having a cleaner once a week should be making it a great deal easier than for many of us who don’t have a cleaner at all. I really don’t think that twice a week should be necessary.

I do all the housework. No cleaner to vacuum, mop, clean the bathroom, toilet, sinks, wipe the kitchen benches. I do all that.

Apart from cleaning up after ourselves it only needs to be done once a week.

With a cleaner (even if they only came once a week) what other housework would Op need to do other than laundry, loading the dishwasher, tidying up after the kids? It’s not a lot really.

I do all the housework, cooking, meal planning, shopping, laundry and mowing the lawns.

The Op’s partner (who works longer hours) is doing the grocery shopping, meal planning and cooking but just not up to the standard that Op expects. And whether or not the Op is male or female, I don’t think that’s being reasonable. Op’s Dp is making a significant contribution to the household chores yet is being made out to be lazy.

spriots · 06/12/2023 08:00

As for grocery shopping: Crowded supermarket, searching for items that have yet again been relocated in the store, having to scan all my groceries, loading them in the car, carrying heavy shopping bags up the stairs, putting groceries away is not very enjoyable.

That does sound a bit rubbish but we just order online!