Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist we review all outgoings before cutting cleaner’s hours?

189 replies

Rainallnight · 05/12/2023 14:36

We are very fortunate to be comfortably off and I realise this whole post is a first world problem.

Our cleaner comes twice a week. DP and I agreed this when I returned to work after DC, on the grounds that she simply doesn’t see stuff that needs to be done and it would fall automatically to me.

DP works full time, is the higher earner. I work slightly less than full time and am with DC when not in work.

Our outgoings are too high, and DP wants to reduce the cleaner to once a week.

I think the cleaner looks like the ‘easy’ thing to cut whereas there are hidden costs that could equally be reduced. For example, DP is supposed to be in charge of dinners (planning them if not actually making them) and the planning and shopping is often bad, which means we end up with a lot of expensive M&S convenience food, and Deliveroo.

That’s just an example to show what I mean.

I’m worried that cutting the cleaner will add more drudgery to my life, and want us to do a proper review of outgoing first.

AIBU?

DP is very dogmatic about things and finds it difficult to have a reasonable conversation about stuff like this so it would be good for my thought process to hear others’ points of view.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nantescalling · 09/12/2023 23:40

TomatoSandwiches · 05/12/2023 14:49

I think a cleaner twice a week is excessive, if op wants to keep it then looking at where each of them play to their strengths could help finance it.
I didn't say op would have to do it all, perhaps they could do the planning and get a shopping delivery which would help save time and deciding what is to cook for each day.

How can you possibl
y judge how much time it takes to clean a flat/house without actually knowing a bit about size, contents etc,

angelfacecuti75 · 08/12/2023 17:30

I wluld have words to the effect of for hubby
...
"You might earn more money but you are only able to do this because I take on the majority of the household chores. You are equally responsible for this , yet you feel money trumps time and makes your time more 'worthy" than mine....how? Did you somehow forget that if one day I was not here all these tasks would fall to you whether you worked or not? So no, hubby of mine ...you can learn to plan , budget and not spend stupid amounts on overpriced food from m& s & deliveroo or you can do half the housework , and actually do it, or i won't be. I am not a get out of jail free card. I am your equal. So i very much doubt given past experience you will actually do even half of what is needed to run a household well. So we shall review the budget , and you have 2 choices in my eyes 1. Spend less and plan better (e.g. do online shopping by consultation with me & the cupboards...at somewhere cheaper) food so we aren't overspending 2. Do it all yourself .
I think 2 is a better idea!
Or similar.

Islandgirl68 · 08/12/2023 08:24

Definitely look at the cost of food first, as that is an expensive way to buy food. Ready meals are expensive and takeaway. I would do that before cleaner.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 07/12/2023 22:14

ohdamnitjanet · 05/12/2023 15:09

And will impact on the cleaner, although not @Rainallnight‘s problem, the cleaner is still a human who needs to work.

@ohdamnitjanet

yes, but it's not up to the OP to run the cleaners business. She's not compelled to keep the cleaner on if her finances don't allow for it.

Good cleaners are in high demand everywhere, I'm sure the OP's hours would be easily made up for.

@Rainallnight

your partner needs to be on board with checking all your outgoings & see where you can cut back. As you say, cutting back on the cleaner is 'easy'. I think you need to fix the food/takeaway budget first! The money that's been overspent there would likely cover the cleaners second day, so screw that.

Teenagehorrorbag · 07/12/2023 21:57

Did she used to be married to my friend? If so she is a control freak and YANBU......

Yourcatisnotsorry · 07/12/2023 21:52

How many hours does your cleaner do? Twice a week does seem excessive but without all the info it’s hard to say.

TeamGeriatric · 07/12/2023 20:37

I am pretty rubbish at domestic chores, I am good with laundry and a hoover, but that's about it. We have a weekly meal plan to avoid food waste and it works pretty efficiently, fridge usually pretty much empty by Friday night for a fresh shop on a Saturday morning. I know it takes away the spontaneity but on a weekend can you not jointly meal plan for the week and get her to shop/online order for the entire week, so you are both on the same page and you have all the necessary ingredients in the house. Also love our rice cooker, wash rice add right ratio of water to rice and without fail perfect rice approx 20 mins later. Perfect accompaniment for chilli and curry and other things bulk cooked and being reheated from frozen.

Dammitthisisshit · 07/12/2023 20:35

I voted YANBU because it needs to be a conversation.
however, IMO the meal planning, shopping and cooking is massive - much bigger than any other job. Personally I like home cooked food so I’d much rather spend 2 hours cooking than cleaning. So I’d opt to save money on takeaways and keep the cleaner (we have one once a week - twice would be amazing!). But some people prefer eating takeaway to home cooked food and if that’s your DP then you need to align expectations on what works for both of you.

Mostlyoblivious · 07/12/2023 20:05

Absolutely review the spending on paper and then present it to here so she can see what is going where.

If she persists in being dogmatic then I would pay the cleaner for a holiday one day a week for a fortnight (I understand it sounds insane to pay for something you’re not getting) and then see if your partner keeps on top of the chores - if they don’t as you anticipate then you’ve not lost your in demand cleaner and have also proved how vital they are.

It sounds like a convo about work load in and out of house perhaps needs to be had and it might not all be about the cleaners costs?

Sillyname63 · 07/12/2023 19:57

I would sit down together and go through you outgoings, silly things like phone contracts, can you buy your phone's and get a cheap contract, Tesco and Gif Gaff both do them for under a £10. Do you want to take over the online delivery shop, so that meal planning and shopping to hand in hand. Do you both use things you have monthly contracts on Gym, Sky, Netflix, Disney + is there an evening you are both busy that you can't cook, make sure you have something there ready, either in the slow cooker prepped the night before and switched on in the morning before you leave or something like a pizza that can be cooked from frozen in under 15 mins and eaten with a salad. You have got to take a little control over something's to get what you want in the long run, i.e the cleaner twice a week.

ThinWomansBrain · 07/12/2023 19:47

I totally get that, but I do most of the rest of the planning and general housework. I do all laundry, for example

Duur - so that is why it would make sense to review who does what.

Zerosleep · 07/12/2023 19:43

it would help if you could plan meals better. We were doing Deliveroo a lot at one point and it cost a fortune. We cut it out apart from once in a blue moon and we have saved so much money.

pollymere · 07/12/2023 19:16

No... You need to have takeout once a fortnight and menu plan with a proper weekly shop. I spent £65 this week in the supermarket for my weekly shop which wouldn't go far on takeouts etc. It's amazing how many meals you can get from one large chicken or the half price joints of meat on offer at the moment.

I suspect the cost of the cleaner is very little compared to the money "wasted" on ready meals and takeout.

FindingNeverland28 · 07/12/2023 19:15

Could you take on the planning and cooking of meals to reduce outgoings there and then ask DP to do the extra clean if you were to reduce your cleaners hours.
would it be also worth signing up with one of those meal kit subscriptions like hello fresh?

celia5678 · 07/12/2023 18:50

Poor cleaner
presumably he/she cleans because the money is needed?
so by dropping his/ her hours their family will have less income they may need to drop you and get a new job with more money xx

ellyeth · 07/12/2023 18:44

I don't see why the OP should be questioned as to why she has a cleaner 2 days a week. She obviously feels she needs it.

If unnecessary and extravagant amounts of money are spent on take aways and expensive ready meals, I think this is where cuts could be made.

Also, I don't know how long you have had the cleaner and how much you value her but I would be thinking about the effect on her as well, especially at these very difficult times.

CatMummyOf3 · 07/12/2023 18:13

I haven't read all the posts yet, so this may have already been said...
Whenever costs start to exceed income I do a cost summary of everything we spend, over 3, 6 or 12 months, depending on how much time I have (or how much we need to cut back). From that it is easier to see where money could be saved, rather than just picking an "easy" target.
Certain costs may stand out, that you don't necessarily expect, and can then potentially be reduced.
I don't think you would be unreasonable to suggest looking into alternatives for savings.

OhmygodDont · 07/12/2023 17:32

I’m guessing if they are always out it’s a good clean like all the skirting boards and a proper scrub of the toilet and such.

I used to as a child if sick off school
help a family member go to cleaning jobs and some of the houses though it was like they didn’t touch anything at all inbetween cleans. So they had to tidy before the cleaning could even start and these where big houses expecting full on cleans on the inside of the fridge / oven and everything every week. But wouldn’t even put a bowl of cereal in their own sinks.

AchillesHeelys · 07/12/2023 17:03

What does the cleaner actually do OP that means you need her twice a week? I feel like if my cleaner came twice a week then she would just end up cleaning the same things that don’t really need doing again but perhaps you have a massive house (or are really filthy 😅)

runsmidgeOMG · 07/12/2023 16:45

I clicked the wrong button 😣
YANBU

spriots · 07/12/2023 16:00

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I think a lot depends on your standards and preferences.

We have a cleaner and don't clean between her visits (except for surface wiping and sweeping)

I would love it if meal planning and cooking was my only chore, I would 100% think I had got the best of the bargain.

Laundry - the putting away in particular - takes bloody ages and I hate chores that are less routiney like gardening and admin like topping up the tax-free childcare acc etc

Bertiesmum3 · 07/12/2023 15:54

Rainallnight · 05/12/2023 14:42

I totally get that, but I do most of the rest of the planning and general housework. I do all laundry, for example

So why have a cleaner if you do general housework and laundry?

Sadandhurt23 · 07/12/2023 07:52

Sounds like you need a new cleaner that is proactive. If she comes twice a week, she does half the house throughly one day and the other half the next. How big is your house that she needs to come twice a week. Genuine question.

KK05 · 06/12/2023 22:10

We had a similar issue with our outgoing costs.
What I found worked for us was over a month we tallied up all outgoings this included everything from mortgage payments to coffee on the go to a chocolate bar. I’m not going to lie it was a nightmare keeping receipts etc.
We were both shocked at how much we were spending on snacks, top up shops (convenience stores), take aways etc.
From there we then decided meal planning together (what he can cook and what I’ll cook varies greatly) and do an online shop once weekly. This includes ready meals and or frozen food, plus snacks etc. We have a take away once a week with the occasional extra. If we need a top up shop we now go to a supermarket over a local store and take our coffee with us from home rather than a Starbucks or Costa drive through.

We managed to cut back nearly £600 every month. This now goes to savings for holidays etc.

My DH sounds a bit like your DP but when he seen what we saving he was a bit more on board. Now instead of take aways he’ll stick a ready meal in the microwave or oven. If I’m cooking from scratch I make extra to freeze that can then easily be reheated.

yeah we have to be a bit more organised with lunches etc but overall the outcome has been positive. We do still have the occasional extra take away or bought lunch.

would something like this work for you guys? It’s just the basic everyday things but very quickly adds up. Obviously some months we save a bit less some months slightly more but overall been a great way to save but also open both our eyes to where our money is going. It also made us realise what was more important to us as a couple which was extra money for breaks away. Plus we didn’t have to cut back on what was making our lives easier or more enjoyable.

ImustLearn2Cook · 06/12/2023 21:16

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I absolutely agree with you. I think that you are being perfectly reasonable. Especially with what you said here:

As I see it, the one with the more demanding job seems to be responsible for the domestic work that - for me, at least - is by far the most onerous. At the moment, she is cutting corners so it doesn't involve that much work, but the OP is suggesting that her DP should approach this differently - ie take on more work in this area - in order to cut costs. The DP is suggesting that the OP takes on more work instead by reducing the cleaner's hours. Obviously, they need to negotiate what is fair between them, and ideally, both of them should take on a bit more in order to be fair.