Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Seeking opinions of those with adult children

40 replies

Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 12:04

I’d really like your opinions on how much is reasonable for your adult child to expect of you. I suppose I really mean emotionally but also perhaps with occasional practical help/ support to “give them a break”.

for context I am mid 30s, 2 young children and financially independent and have been for years. My parents live 4 hours away (I moved for my husbands work).

I’ll try and be succinct as it’s very complicated but essentially I feel I’m having a bit of a break down/ crisis due to multiple factors but mainly PTSD following 2 traumatic births and first baby nearly dying, emotional abuse from my husband and marital stress/ difficulties, and other life stress factors. Part of this is when going through all this I feel my mum let me down - I didn’t really have any help from anyone - specifically when physically extremely unwell having to soldier on and deal with all the practicalities of looking after 2 young children.

my dad is an extremely difficult man and she panders to him which I feel dismisses me. They are very much of the ‘suit themselves’ mentality which I find really upsets me - for example saying they will visit and changing the dates/ times short notice - eg now arriving 6 hours later than planned today (no reason) when I’m alone and juggling 2 sick children, I haven’t been able to leave the house in 4 days as kids are both poorly and husband is away. Never breaking their routine which I can’t accommodate with young children - eg wanting to go and sit in a pub every night between 5-7 when kids need dinner/bath. Never visit as often as they say they will.

I used to be so so close with my mum, she was my best friend but I used to fit in exactly around what they wanted all the time. I think I just feel so heart broken as I feel she has chosen his ‘wants’ over my needs.

I know this won’t make much sense but they are arriving later and to be honest I just want to cry and break down when she arrives.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notmetoo · 05/12/2023 16:51

I think it's hard for you all. She probably does want to help but doesn't know how to. Can you help her to help you? Does she know how you feel. What do you practically want from her? And have you told her.
It sounds as though her life with your dad isn't easy either and she may have her own problems.
She is four hours away and it's not as though she is near and can just pop in.
Ultimately though you are an adult in charge of your own life and you can't expect your mum to solve all your problems. That is too much to expect from her.

Catza · 05/12/2023 16:22

Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 15:40

@OkayScooby its more being emotionally available, caring how I feel, being able to talk to her own the phone about important stuff.

The thing is, your mother is essentially a victim of domestic abuse with all the psychological trauma it entails. And while I appreciate your need and want to have some support from her, this may be well beyond her emotional capacity to provide it.
She didn't make a choice to remain with your father. She had her confidence destroyed over many years by an abusive partner which makes her feel like she has no other options but stay. He probably convinced her that she is worthless and that nobody will love her except for him. That's how emotional abuse works.
You may feel that they pushed you into a certain career the same way that your mother feels she has no choice but stay with him. In reality, both of you had a choice - you to go against your parents' wishes, her to break up with your father. But the circumstances did not allow either of you to confidently make that choice.
It may help to see the situation from her perspective because being angry and upset at her will not bring you closer. Both of you need support from each other and a therapy separately to resolve the trauma.
I had similar situation growing up and, luckily my mother was able to escape when I was 11 (only thanks to family members who were there to support). For many years I was angry with her for not leaving the relationship sooner and for failing to talk about it. The truth is, she can't and she will never be able to. Being angry with her wasn't going to change that but once I was able to let go of my own hurt, our relationship improved dramatically.

Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 15:40

@OkayScooby its more being emotionally available, caring how I feel, being able to talk to her own the phone about important stuff.

OP posts:
Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 15:40

@Chiar this is very insightful, thank you. I have read about TA but still don’t much understand it.

I am starting to itch a different counsellor who uses this after Xmas so maybe that will be helpful.

OP posts:
OkayScooby · 05/12/2023 15:21

I'm sorry you're going through hard times and hope it gets easier, but I think yabu about your mum.
How often do you expect her to be there for you, when you have moved 4 hours away?

Apparentlystillchilled · 05/12/2023 14:14

OP, I voted yanbu because I get what it’s like to want your mum’s support when you’ve always supported her and fitted in w her. And not to get it when you’ve clearly been through a horrific time is awful. It feels so lonely when you just want to be mothered. And I remember thinking “but WHEN is it my turn, if not now, when I have small children, just had surgery and husband away?” But like PP have said, my mum has her own stuff. And she’s just not able to parent me the way I’d like to (and that was the when I was a kid too). It’s desperately sad. And it’s reasonable to think she might. But I’ve learned to build my family of choice so that it hurts less when my family of origin let me down once again.

5128gap · 05/12/2023 13:58

Oh and to answer your question, I'm a mother to three adult children and whatever is in my gift or ability is theirs. Whether they will always find it 'enough' I don't know, as even my best, due to my personality and situation, may not always meet their needs.

5128gap · 05/12/2023 13:55

The only 'reasonable' expectation to have of anyone OP is a realistic one based on their behaviour to you in the past. The parent/child relationship doesn't come with a rule book that lists a set of obligations, so people choose how much they give in both directions.
If you're unfortunate enough to be in a situation where what is given is less than you'd like, you have no option but to accept and come to terms with it. Lower your expectations for that person, and you won't be disappointed or hurt.
When you've done that, decide whether what they offer is worth making an effort for. Then look around at the other people in your life. What relationships can you form or develop to help fill the gap?

Chiar · 05/12/2023 13:51

I'm not a parent of an adult child but I do have a very difficult mother.

I wonder if there is a locus of control thing going on here. You don't feel you have much control around your parents. You end up buffeted by them and their agenda which is very stressful for you and puts you in seemingly impossible dilemmas when their demands clash with your children's and your own needs.

You can take back control. You can decide to be less available, you can decide that your parents are welcome to go to the pub between 5 and 7 but you will be at home bathing the children. Your parents won't like it, and it is pretty natural for them to react against it, but that doesn't make it an impossible or unreasonable thing for you to do. At some point going through that friction may be inevitable. Try to focus on what you can control.

Also I would recommend looking up transactional analysis. I think it might be helpful for you to make a point of engaging with your mum in adult - adult ego states. At the moment I wonder if there is a bit too much child - parent interaction still, which is very understandable with your own mum but it can get uncomfortable on both sides once the child has grown up and has family of their own. I'm not calling you childish, I hope you will take this as a constructive idea and not a criticism. I would suggest taking a look at the Wikipedia page for transactional analysis or somesuch, and see if it chimes.

Hatty65 · 05/12/2023 13:46

@Fairyliz Thank you for articulating that, particularly the 'emotional frailty'. I too have adult children, but no grandchildren yet. My DM did little to nothing for me, despite living 3 miles away in the next village. There were plenty of times I could have done with help and she was breezily unavailable.

However, in retrospect she was 68 when my youngest DC was born. I am not yet that age, and my God - the constant tiredness of menopause, full time work and just feeling old is horrendous. I fall into bed by about 8pm most evenings, stressed and shattered. I do not want to be an emotional or physical support to anyone - I can barely cope with my own life, and I feel that my adult DC who are late 20s/early 30s are young, fit and should be sorting their own lives out. Not relying on 'Mummy' who is struggling. I don't want to look after other people's small children. I am desperately worried about covering my own bills with the CoL - I can't afford to financially offer help to anyone else. I can't summon the energy to do much.

I didn't realise in my 30s how tired I would be in my late 50s.

Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 13:32

@Fairyliz thank you - the ‘emotional frailty’ is a good way of describing it.

OP posts:
Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 13:32

@Xoxoxoxoxoxox she did feel abandoned when I moved away - she told me so. But equally they pushed me into a career path which meant that moving away to university was necessary.

OP posts:
Fairyliz · 05/12/2023 13:17

As a mother of adult children (no grandchildren) this is an interesting one.
I have helped my children out lots both financially and emotionally.
However as I get older I am finding it more difficult; I am getting a little annoyed they can’t stand on their own two feet. If you never actually do stuff how do you learn to cope.
I know that sounds harsh but the only way I can describe it as in the same way that I am getting physically more frail, I am also getting emotionally more frail and find it difficult to cope with emotional demands that I could deal with in the past.

autienotnaughty · 05/12/2023 13:09

So you and your mum were close when you fitted into their situation but now you have kids you need more give and take and they are not forthcoming.

You need to create a situation that works for you. Arrange reliable childcare if you need it Ie nursery. There's no point in expecting more from your parents and being perpetually disappointed. Same with your husband, figure out what's best for you and kids and don't rely on flaky people.

cockwomble73 · 05/12/2023 13:07

I have two adult children who live a couple of hours away.

In all honesty I have always been very supportive and have often dropped everything to drive two hours up the motorway when they've been in need of help. I've helped them move house more times than I could count, I've helped them decorate etc.

That said, if either of them have children I have no plans to sign up for childcare on a regular basis like some of my friends have. If they need a weekend away without the dc or back up when they're poorly I'll be there, but I feel like I've done my bit and they're adults now.

In the situation you're in I'd have packed a bag and arrived to help for as long as you needed, because clearly you're struggling.

CalistoNoSolo · 05/12/2023 13:02

Well my mum had a progressive degenerative disease exacerbated by stress by the time I was 20 so I pretty much stopped relying on my parents for anything as I didn't want to make her illness worse. I had a v traumatic miscarriage and an emotionally immature partner late 20's (much wanted baby) and pretty much had to suck that one up on my own.

I'm not unsympathetic OP, but your mother hasn't changed. She's always expected you to work around her so I don't think you should be too suprised or upset that she isn't working around you. I also think anyone expecting a parent to automatically provide childcare is a bit pathetic. You chose to have two children with a man who isn't husband/father material and hard as it can be, you need to own it and grow up a bit.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 05/12/2023 13:00

If your mum is being bullied alot by your dad then maybe she felt a bit abandoned by you when you moved 3 hours away.
Maybe she grieved for the friendship that she had with you but has settled for the life that she now has with your father.

Desecratedcoconut · 05/12/2023 12:57

Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 12:51

@Desecratedcoconut yes it is by some account - he is abusive and controlling. Extremely controlling and extremely difficult. But she is aware of this and has decided she isn’t going to do anything about it. I have been there for her/ supported her even throughout my childhood and teenage years with this, I was the only one she could talk to.

he expects his every wish to be pandered to. And I suppose I feel that when I was really in a bad way (eg nearly dead and in the depths of post natal depression) I should have come first.

im not sure that’s valid or not.

I think it is valid but I don't think it's changeable. It sounds like she made that decision a long time ago, but you are feeling it most now.

Perhaps, she also feels a bit helpless knowing how your dh has let you down and making your life harder but doesn't have a leg to stand on in advising you to put yourself and the dc first?

Octavia64 · 05/12/2023 12:54

Some people cannot cope with emotions.

My mum is like that.

My kids are older but she used to come down and look after them for a week; we went on holiday with them; we have a good relationship.

She cannot cope with anyone crying and being upset. She just needs to leave.
She can't offer emotional support or console anyone or be there for them.

It is who she is.

There are times in my life I have felt very alone as my ExH (we were married for 20 years) did not always step up and I had to deal with work and children alone. My mum didn't want to know.

It's not great.

I tried to build friendships locally through baby and toddler groups, NCT groups, babysitting circles etc. it did help. Having small children is tough.

gotomomo · 05/12/2023 12:53

Grandmothers aren't childcare, they aren't to pick up the pieces. Some do and that's lovely but not to be expected. I've already told my children that we will love our grandchildren but not to expect anything childcare wise. Of course I would help in emergencies but I work and when I stop working it's to have fun

WoolyMammoth55 · 05/12/2023 12:53

OP, I'm really sorry for what you're describing, it sounds like a lot.

My mum died aged 40 so never got the chance to support any of her kids with their own newborns.

It's clearly optimal for every new mum to have good support around her, from both friends and family. It's also clear that many don't get that, for a lot of reasons.

Reading between the lines, my hunch is that your mum is in a toxic marriage of her own. Your dad may be controlling her and limiting her involvement (maybe he was walking in when she hung up on you?) Or maybe all your pain is just too close to the bone for her.

Maybe she's hanging on to her sanity by a thread and doesn't have any more emotional energy to give you.

You might have imprinted what family looks like from this unhealthy dynamic and have chosen a witholding/unkind partner because he's like your dad.

In your shoes I'd get some therapy from someone good, laying all this out upfront.

But in a nutshell, yes, you do need to woman up. She raised you, her job is done. She's coping with her life, she can support you as best she can and that's all she can do. She's human too.

You made your choices as a grown woman, and you still do. You can choose to put up with it, or to confront her, and/or to cut them out. You can choose to stay or leave your marriage. I think it would be unproductive to blame your mum for how you feel when clearly she's got a lot on her own plate to deal with.

Sending you all good things and hope you feel better soon.

Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 12:51

@Desecratedcoconut yes it is by some account - he is abusive and controlling. Extremely controlling and extremely difficult. But she is aware of this and has decided she isn’t going to do anything about it. I have been there for her/ supported her even throughout my childhood and teenage years with this, I was the only one she could talk to.

he expects his every wish to be pandered to. And I suppose I feel that when I was really in a bad way (eg nearly dead and in the depths of post natal depression) I should have come first.

im not sure that’s valid or not.

OP posts:
Neighbours87 · 05/12/2023 12:49

Op I hear you. I’m currently in therapy dealing with how my family treated me at the time of the wedding. I was always there for them and it hurts me that they were not there for me. Like you I was so close to my mum but now I realise it was all me. I’m learning to leave her to it and build my own networks

Desecratedcoconut · 05/12/2023 12:46

Are you sure this increasing gulf between you and your DM isn't being engineered by your Dad?

Give0fecks · 05/12/2023 12:42

I guess 95% of this stems from when I had my first DC, we both nearly died. She didn’t come and help, I had serious health complications and struggled to look after my newborn DC . She didn’t visit for over a month, I needed her help at that time. I needed someone as my husband couldn’t cope. I could barely stand. She hung up on me several times on the phone when I was crying my eyes out (“oh someone is at the door- got to go - bye!) and just seemed to dismiss how ill I was. Every visit since has been changed/ chopped and shortened as they don’t really want to be here. I guess I just want her to spend time with us. I can’t phone and talk to her as my dad is always listening/ involved and I can’t talk about any of it in front of him.

OP posts: