Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two girls vs One of each

118 replies

Morningcoffeewithcookies · 05/12/2023 10:50

I have seen in many posts recently that Mumsnet people tend to favour having girls instead of boys, which puzzles me given that so many people can't even have children!

I am really curious if this is a trend or if I got it wrong hence the thread!

So, of course health and to have children comes first, but then what about the gender? What would you ideally prefer in a perfect world?

AIBU - Two girls
AINBU - One of each

OP posts:
CoalCraft · 05/12/2023 12:35

I wanted at least one boy and knew I wanted two children, so top choice would have been one of each, second two boys, and third two girls.

I have two girls. Wouldn't change a thing.

ActDottie · 05/12/2023 12:32

I always wanted a girl. I think because I have a brother and he barely sees my parents and I see them regularly.

My husband is the same in that he barely sees his parents, so in my head this is what boys do and I would hate it if they were adults and didn’t want to see me much. There’s obviously no guarantee having girls will guarantee this either and I know that.

Obviously this is all completely skewed by my own experiences. But I always said I’d have two children, but if I had two boys I’d try for a third but that would be it.

Currently pregnant with our first and she’s a girl! So we’ll likely have two children and it takes the pressure off baby 2 being a girl.

Obviously my reasoning is all completely emotional and I’m sure if I had ended up with all boys I ultimately wouldn’t care.

I do think there’s a thing about wanting a mini you as well. I know plenty of husbands who were relieved to find out they were having boys rather than girls.

My friend who is a nanny wanted two boys because she said they’re so much easier than girls! She’s currently got one girl. But just an example of a woman wanting boys.

Suchardchoccy · 05/12/2023 12:31

@TheBirdintheCave oh really, I hope that's not the case with girls clothes! 2-3 so far so good.
TBF I haven't actively gone to look at the boys clothes obviously I've just seen them briefly near the girls clothes so I could be wrong!

Livingoncaffeine · 05/12/2023 12:31

I always thought I wanted one of each but got two boys and I couldn’t be happier! If we had a third I’d secretly prefer another boy (though of course be happy with a girl too!)

PerspiringElizabeth · 05/12/2023 12:23

Why are those the only options 😵‍💫 if I had to pick I guess I’d prefer to have one of each than 2 girls. 2 boys was epic though but I am very much in that world as weirdly me and ALL my friends (honestly!) had 2 boys. So I’d go for one of each but that is not my choice in real life 😄 I know lots of brother/sister sets who are very close, and just as many same-sex siblings who aren’t close at all.

I have 2 boys and a girl and it’s 👌🏻👌🏻 would have been delighted with a 3rd boy, they’re so loving and easy! Adore DD too of course, she is loving too and very rough and tumble and hilarious!

Pluvia · 05/12/2023 12:22

You talk about gender, OP, when you actually mean sex. Your children are born either male or female. It's biology.

Gender is a social construct, it changes over time and varies in different societies. It's based on feelings and beliefs, not on physical reality.

Cheeseywheel · 05/12/2023 12:21

I have got 2 girls. Absolutely wouldn’t change that for the world - I expect (hope!) I would say the same whichever gender they are. However I did have a teeny preference for a girl only because I have the lived experience of being a female and felt more comfortable bringing one up! Both girls have their father’s (confident, outgoing) personality though, rather than my shy, reserved nature so I’m not sure what use my words of wisdom will be in their teenage years!

Andywarholswig · 05/12/2023 12:20

2 girls as that what I have and I wouldn’t wish for anything else

SignoraItaliana · 05/12/2023 12:16

I have two of each and I love having sons and daughters. I know I am lucky to have four healthy children. I think I would have been a tiny bit disappointed if my third baby had been another boy.

GoingOffOnATangent · 05/12/2023 12:10

I only wanted children who didn't have bad personality clash, and could hopefully stand a chance of getting on ok. Sex irrelevant to that imo.
I got two quite different characters, and I also invested a lot of time teaching them both relationship skills, so happily my kids have a far healthier relationship than I ever did with my sibling (personality clash, zero helpful relationship skills taught, dysfunctional family dynamic).
I'm delighted.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 05/12/2023 12:09

I didn't mind but I grew up with a sister and loved it and still do so part of me wanted the same for my children. I did have two girls and very happy but sure I would be whatever we had! They are close in age and get on very well almost all the time!

theprincessthepea · 05/12/2023 12:09

I’ve noticed this trend. I have a girl. The only reason I preferred a girl was because I haven’t been around men much in my life - parents divorce, lone parent, even work has been female dominated for me. That was it really. I felt if I had a boy I wouldn’t have any experience to pull from to help. I also think it is naive to think that gender does not play any role in upbringing - even if it is just external influences.

Also I don’t think it’s right to make women feel bad for preferring a gender just because they should be “happy as some cannot have children” - I don’t want to be insensitive but we have a high rate of termination too and I don’t see this argument being used there. I am pro choice but I don’t think it’s fair to point this out as everyone’s circumstances are different. We all have been raised differently and our thinking is not the same.

I also think sadly we live in a world where the “wrong doings” of men are amplified in a way that it never was before (e.g. me too , toxic feminism, toxic masculinity etc) and I really feel for the good men that cannot get a word in sideways because of this but my theory is that this culture in society might be feeding into this.

With that being said a few years ago most people would have preferred boys - Most of my friends would and that is because they think girls are brats or will steal their beauty and limelight (again equally dumb shallow reasons) - not long ago we had a culture of “wanting a male heir and continuing family legacy” etc which I bet some cultures or some of our grandparents might have believed! In the west females have a more equal playing field.

Sorry for being all academic about it but we are allowed opinions and feelings.

EmpressSoleil · 05/12/2023 12:09

I wanted one of each and that's what I had. 2 (or more) sisters can be difficult, I say that as someone who has a sister! It was rough on me (the older one) as I was always expected to play with her and rough on her as she always got my second hand clothes etc. As adults we had some terrible arguments too. I just can't see I'd have had those arguments with a brother.

Mine are adults so they don't really "hang out" together although we do still do family stuff. But they are fiercely protective of one another and would always be there if the other needed them.

Rosecutting · 05/12/2023 12:07

I would have thought 2 healthy children would be the only option, for someone that wants 2.
Can’t understand these gender preferences.

Hattie89 · 05/12/2023 12:06

I’m not religious but surprisingly quite spiritual when it comes to my belief that we get what we’re meant to have in terms of the sex of our kids. So no preference.

BebbanburgIsMine · 05/12/2023 12:05

I wanted two girls, and I got two girls.

I've never felt any desire for a boy, my elder brother could be vicious and cruel when we were growing up.

He's still a bully and I have nothing to do with him.

janfebmarchapril · 05/12/2023 12:05

Equally If I had a boy first I'd want another boy. Ive always wanted the same sex children

janfebmarchapril · 05/12/2023 12:04

Two girls

AmazingSnakeHead · 05/12/2023 12:01

I don't have a preference. When I was pregnant first time I genuinely had no deep preference at all, but if asked to choose I would have chosen a boy for the shallow reason that all my friends had just given birth to boys and I just thought it would be fun to refer to "our boys". I got a wonderful little boy. I would not have any preferences if I were to have another, I've learned enough to know that all children are their own people, and having another boy would not be like having two of my existing boy.

Hapagirl48 · 05/12/2023 12:00

I wasn't that bothered which when I was pregnant with my first but I did want the same sex. I thought it would be easier both in a financial sense (hand me downs) and in a social sense. So when DD1 was a girl, I just thought it would be nice if the next one was a girl. As it is, I now have 3 teen DDs and they are always sharing stuff (and arguing about it). When we go on holiday, we now need two rooms and the girls have their own room and they wander around in their bras and knickers stealing each other's make up etc. That would be difficult with different sex siblings but I don't know anything else because I am one of two girls too.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 05/12/2023 12:00

The sex preference topic comes up.on MN at least once a week.

I had two very difficult pregnancies, involving multiple hospital admissions. I am incredibly grateful fir my two beautiful healthy sons.

NotYeti · 05/12/2023 11:57

I can't vote because I'd love two boys. I have one and he's utterly lush. ❤️ But really I wouldn't give a flying fig about the sex.

gertren · 05/12/2023 11:56

Around here, the trophy family is one of each, 1-2 years apart. Ideally September born. Then each parent can have their mini-me and put them in all the same activities and have nice days out because the dcs will be similar ages, and when they grow up, the dad can play football with his son and go to the pub and the mum can do afternoon tea and spa days with the daughter. And they will be super bright and top of the class because they are the eldest.

I have 2 girls around 4 years apart and I'm happy with it. They definitely seem to be less boisterous and better at quiet activities than my nephews and other boys who are sons of close friends. Bigger age gap allowed me to give more one to one time to each of them throughout the baby and toddler years and treat them as individuals.

Sconehenge · 05/12/2023 11:56

I think I’d genuinely be happy with any combo except for 3 of 1 and 1 of the other, as it’s so clear that family was trying for the other gender on #3 and failed and kept going until #4 😂

I would probably have less “what ifs?” If I had only girls, where if I had only boys I would probably wonder what it would have been like to have a daughter. But I think I would be happy to be an all boy mum too.

Prelapsarianhag · 05/12/2023 11:56

Both. I am lucky enough to have birthed a baby girl who has transitioned in adulthood so I have had the best of both worlds.