Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a strange way to do Secret Santa?

343 replies

Fancylike · 05/12/2023 10:44

My office has announced a Secret Santa but has set a minimum price of £40. There’s no maximum but you have to spend over £40 on a single gift. I’m new to the company but every SS I’ve done previously had a maximum spend, not a minimum and it’s always been £5-10.

This just seems like a lot of money to spend on coworkers you may not know well (I work in a different department to the name I pulled so have to research them) and also having a minimum doesn’t sit well with me given the disparity in salaries across the office. I’m new so I don’t want to rock the boat by asking if the organiser got mixed up but it’s also been made clear we all need to participate.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
EvilElsa · 11/12/2023 14:26

A presentation -for secret santa?! I'd be "sick" that day. What utter bullshit. On top of the £40 bombshell I'd be actively looking for a new job.

willWillSmithsmith · 11/12/2023 14:23

Fancylike · 11/12/2023 11:12

Thanks for all the thoughts and I feel like I’m not being as unreasonable in thinking it’s a lot.

Update from this morning. I nosed into a water cooler conversation where other people were complaining that it should be a lower maximum spend instead of this high minimum. Yes it is definitely £40. No we are not making well paid salaries (before Covid I made double but have struggled to find work after losing that job) but live in a high cost of living area.
Also it appears the different teams are quite separate and don’t mix much (I haven’t been here long enough to work this out yet) so people have pulled names they aren’t even personally familiar with.

Another message went out saying each gift needs to be given out with a little presentation on why the gift is perfect for the receiver. So not so secret. Feeling quite anxious now not so much about spending, but how on earth will I know what a random guy I’ve never even met will like and have to talk about it.

Good Lord what nonsense is this! Who on earth does this company think it is!

I’d not have a thing to do with this utter nonsense.

TheCatfordCat · 11/12/2023 14:19

Fuck that noise. I'd be looking for a job in the New Year. It says a lot about the culture of the company OP works for, I think.

Our SS was £15 max. I spent about £10-15 on each child in my circle. It's enough.

OVienna · 11/12/2023 14:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OVienna · 11/12/2023 14:03

Fancylike · 11/12/2023 11:12

Thanks for all the thoughts and I feel like I’m not being as unreasonable in thinking it’s a lot.

Update from this morning. I nosed into a water cooler conversation where other people were complaining that it should be a lower maximum spend instead of this high minimum. Yes it is definitely £40. No we are not making well paid salaries (before Covid I made double but have struggled to find work after losing that job) but live in a high cost of living area.
Also it appears the different teams are quite separate and don’t mix much (I haven’t been here long enough to work this out yet) so people have pulled names they aren’t even personally familiar with.

Another message went out saying each gift needs to be given out with a little presentation on why the gift is perfect for the receiver. So not so secret. Feeling quite anxious now not so much about spending, but how on earth will I know what a random guy I’ve never even met will like and have to talk about it.

This is all absolutely ridiculous. Whoever set this up is some sort of sadist.

theDudesmummy · 11/12/2023 13:47

If this is true (and I have my doubts) then I would certainly be refusing. They can't enforce that you have a social interaction with someone you don't even know (or, for all they know, you may know and have reason to dislike).

RampantIvy · 11/12/2023 13:43

Feeling quite anxious now not so much about spending, but how on earth will I know what a random guy I’ve never even met will like and have to talk about it.

But then it isn't a secret Santa. It is enforced gift giving to a stranger.

"I'm new here. I hope you like my gift."

Or pull a sickie. This is utterly ridiculous. If other people are complaining they should make a stand.

Calliopespa · 11/12/2023 13:34

Fancylike · 11/12/2023 11:12

Thanks for all the thoughts and I feel like I’m not being as unreasonable in thinking it’s a lot.

Update from this morning. I nosed into a water cooler conversation where other people were complaining that it should be a lower maximum spend instead of this high minimum. Yes it is definitely £40. No we are not making well paid salaries (before Covid I made double but have struggled to find work after losing that job) but live in a high cost of living area.
Also it appears the different teams are quite separate and don’t mix much (I haven’t been here long enough to work this out yet) so people have pulled names they aren’t even personally familiar with.

Another message went out saying each gift needs to be given out with a little presentation on why the gift is perfect for the receiver. So not so secret. Feeling quite anxious now not so much about spending, but how on earth will I know what a random guy I’ve never even met will like and have to talk about it.

😳 It gets more and more bonkers!! At least you can say you are new. And if you said “ I have no idea as we’ve never met “ you will probably be echoing the thoughts of many others ! Good luck!

Headband · 11/12/2023 12:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Jackfrostnippingatmynose · 11/12/2023 12:30

Saw your last update OP - the organiser of this is absolutely bonkers!
Tell the organiser that you're sadly unable to comply.

flyingant · 11/12/2023 12:04

Oh, come on, after the latest additional rule, this has got to be a wind-up!

McrWife · 11/12/2023 11:19

That’s ridiculous.

PrimitivePerson · 11/12/2023 11:15

Someone needs to be brave enough to stand up and say "sorry, this is ridiculous, I'm out". Appreciate it's far from easy to be that person, though.

It's really stupid and crass.

Fancylike · 11/12/2023 11:12

Thanks for all the thoughts and I feel like I’m not being as unreasonable in thinking it’s a lot.

Update from this morning. I nosed into a water cooler conversation where other people were complaining that it should be a lower maximum spend instead of this high minimum. Yes it is definitely £40. No we are not making well paid salaries (before Covid I made double but have struggled to find work after losing that job) but live in a high cost of living area.
Also it appears the different teams are quite separate and don’t mix much (I haven’t been here long enough to work this out yet) so people have pulled names they aren’t even personally familiar with.

Another message went out saying each gift needs to be given out with a little presentation on why the gift is perfect for the receiver. So not so secret. Feeling quite anxious now not so much about spending, but how on earth will I know what a random guy I’ve never even met will like and have to talk about it.

OP posts:
Luckypom · 11/12/2023 04:44

Never heard such nonsense (unless you’re all millionaires??) £5 - 10 max and you didn’t need to spend that either. It’s hard because you are new to the company but I have never heard of this! Maybe on housewives of (fill in the city)

Kirstk · 11/12/2023 04:25

I dont even spend £40 on nieces and nephews we all have a £20 limit.

Calliopespa · 10/12/2023 22:44

scottishGirl · 10/12/2023 21:34

To clarify , I think £40 spent on anyone you don't know is madness, no matter what it is purchased! The donation idea was just an idea of something that could be purchased that would hopefully do some good for a charity rather than buying something not wanted since the OP doesn't know the recipient.
I fully agree this whole £40 situation is bizarre.

Sorry yes, didn’t mean to imply you agreed with the 40! I think we are all aghast! And I get the donation idea as an offshoot of that absurdity. I just worried OP might hit the wrong recipient .

scottishGirl · 10/12/2023 21:34

Calliopespa · 10/12/2023 18:54

Yes I wouldn’t mind myself. But I just wondered if some might mutter a bit if it happened to them. It’s just too much for someone you don’t know full stop.

To clarify , I think £40 spent on anyone you don't know is madness, no matter what it is purchased! The donation idea was just an idea of something that could be purchased that would hopefully do some good for a charity rather than buying something not wanted since the OP doesn't know the recipient.
I fully agree this whole £40 situation is bizarre.

Calliopespa · 10/12/2023 18:54

scottishGirl · 10/12/2023 14:15

Perhaps. For me, If I was the recipient of one of those charity donation things I would maybe just think that the person who was allocated to me barely knows me and that's probably why they have chosen to do that, rather than buy something they don't know if I would want. I would personally prefer that and welcome it as a 'gift' but completely appreciate that yeah, maybe some people would like an actual gift since they have given a gift.
Each to their own I guess!

Yes I wouldn’t mind myself. But I just wondered if some might mutter a bit if it happened to them. It’s just too much for someone you don’t know full stop.

scottishGirl · 10/12/2023 14:15

Calliopespa · 10/12/2023 00:01

I think the charity donations are a good idea except don’t they work better/ are really designed for when the recipient says no gifts for me, do a charity donation instead? It’s a bit weird to say oh you were hoping for a gift but I went over your head and sanctimoniously gave it to charity in lieu.

Perhaps. For me, If I was the recipient of one of those charity donation things I would maybe just think that the person who was allocated to me barely knows me and that's probably why they have chosen to do that, rather than buy something they don't know if I would want. I would personally prefer that and welcome it as a 'gift' but completely appreciate that yeah, maybe some people would like an actual gift since they have given a gift.
Each to their own I guess!

Calliopespa · 10/12/2023 00:01

scottishGirl · 06/12/2023 08:40

Agree that is not a normal amount to spend on secret Santa. I would definitely ask your colleagues what they think. I hope you don't have to go ahead.

If you feel you have to go ahead, I would buy one of those Christmas donations a lot of charities do. Eg your donation has paid for books for children in a school in X country. I'd print out confirmation and put in an envelope. Or you could spend £30 on that and then buy something small to go with it eg chocolate.

Edited

I think the charity donations are a good idea except don’t they work better/ are really designed for when the recipient says no gifts for me, do a charity donation instead? It’s a bit weird to say oh you were hoping for a gift but I went over your head and sanctimoniously gave it to charity in lieu.

Ilovecleaning · 09/12/2023 21:45

Might be worth contacting ACAS and asking their opinion?

smithsinarazz · 09/12/2023 00:09

I can't imagine that, legally, they have a leg to stand on if they say you have to participate. I also can't imagine you're the only person feeling this way.
There's a whole chapter in "The Ragged-Trousered Philanthropists" in which the cast of underpaid decorators are taken out on an excursion by their boss...which, actually, they have to pay for themselves. It's presented as a tool of control - making people think "good old So-and-So", when he's nothing of the sort - and also as an extortion mechanism, because, after all, who's organised the charabanc and who's collecting the fares?
If the staff in an office organise a cheap and jokey Secret Santa, it's churlish (but permissible) not to join in. If the management instruct you to spend proper money (most of the price of a day's childcare, or enough shopping for a few days) then it's essentially a deduction from your pay.

CleaningAngel · 08/12/2023 07:03

Buy something off vinted, with labels on, it may retail at £40 but on vinted you will pay less than half.

Call me tigh but that's what I've done for all my Xmas shopping, named clothing unworn with labels much much less than rrp.

Thorntons1710 · 07/12/2023 20:22

As an American who lived in Victoria, British Columbia as a child and spends time in the UK, Yankee candles, and other smelly kitsch is something some Americans like, but many of us would rather skip that sort of thing. I personally purchase items that are of quality. For example, my mother loved (as do I) Liberty of London fabrics, etc.

It amuses me how Americans have a reputation for liking loud, cheap rubbish, yet that is of a sort not like many of us.

For the gift exchange, I’d buy something that is unclassifiable as far as worth (such as a leather good or a nice silk or wool scarf that is not as high as listed here in OP’s post) and of lesser amount, and simply gift it without stating cost.