Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret Santa gate

36 replies

JBright · 05/12/2023 09:55

Okay first world problem here, so we have a secret Santa set up at work. Limit is £5 and as I don’t know the person I’ve been selected for very well, I bought them some lovely biscuits (who doesn’t like nice biscuits?) which cost £7, being generous lol. So AFTER I bought the biscuits, I get an email saying they have added a “wish list”. Who on earth makes a wish list for secret Santa?! I click and they have added a specific link to a specific candle they want on Etsy. £6.00. So, I’m not buying it for them, I already paid for the biscuits. Really though its the principle, it feels so presumptuous of them. Plus doesn’t a wish list suck out all the (albeit minimal) joy of secret Santa. Am I being unreasonable? This is someone who never answers my emails by the way!

OP posts:
Dee1224 · 05/12/2023 10:36

We’ve got one at work and this year the organiser has used a site which actually suggests a wish list and links to items. It’s quite impressive but it is causing a bit of confusion as to whether or not it’s ‘rude’ to put something on the wish list.

I haven’t, because most others have ignored it. However, I just know that whatever I get will be absolutely dreadful and of no use to me, so it is a good idea imo, but only if everyone does it.

sweetpickle23 · 05/12/2023 10:28

My family and I do secret santa and we always do wish lists, as now there are brothers and sisters in-law etc who don't necessarily know everyone that well. The function is built into the name drawing website we use.

It's just a guide to help someone out incase they don't know what to get you, it's actually quite thoughtful.

But it's not a demand it's just a suggestion! The biscuits are fine.

Whinge · 05/12/2023 10:26

Who on earth makes a wish list for secret Santa?

A wish list seems like a sensible idea, especially if you work with lots of people and don't know their likes / dislikes.

I would buy a candle (it doesn't have to be the one linked in the wishlist) and eat / donate the biscuits.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/12/2023 10:24

They’ve put one specific item without having been invited to post a wish list, and that item is over budget? That is cheeky (even though you chose to go over budget anyway).

They might as well not bother with SS and just go shopping if they’re going to do that.

SnaccidentsHappen · 05/12/2023 10:21

Also to add, there shouldn't be anything over budget on the gift list. That should be your choice to spend more

SnaccidentsHappen · 05/12/2023 10:20

We do a family secret Santa and have the option to add a wish list - I always do but have around 4/5 things on it at or close to the budget set so - a) I should get something I want & b) the person who picked me doesn't have to guess.

The annoying thing is not everyone adds a gift list and some people struggle just to access the link to pick a name lol.

I like the gift list but it only works if people add to it and use it for ideas.

PippyLongTits · 05/12/2023 10:06

Give the biscuits. The candle is only a suggestion.

BaronessBomburst · 05/12/2023 10:04

The wish list is a great idea as lots of people will be stuck and not know what to get.
Eat the biscuits yourself.
Buy the candle.
Then they get something that they really want, but from an unknown giver, which is the fun and joy behind a proper Secret Santa.

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/12/2023 10:01

I think it makes a lot of sense: if you’re buying for somebody you don’t know and don’t want to completely waste your money on unwanted tat, a suggestion list is helpful. You’ve bought a gift already, so all good. Biscuits are fine.

Jackfrostnippingatmynose · 05/12/2023 10:00

YANBU especially as she had the cheek to send a round robin email to all in the secret santa but never answers your emails. She can suck it up buttercup!

mondaytosunday · 05/12/2023 10:00

The specific person has added a wish list or has the office done it (Susan would like a mug; Harold a certain chocolate; Mary a candle...)?
Yes it does suck the joy out of it. The challenge to buy something that won't instantly be thrown in the bin for £5, that might actually be appreciated is half the fun (or agony).
If it's just the individual very cheeky for sure.