Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my friend is using the single parent reason for things that affect all of us?

121 replies

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:00

I don’t know if I am being sensitive but I supported my friend through a horrific break up when her baby was only a few months old. It was awful for her and I was there for her every step of the way. She has emerged from it with her ex partner paying her mortgage (over 1k a month, they weren’t married) and landed a job paying over 50k for 3.5 days a week. When I helped her with relocating we worked out she had around 1,500 spare for food and fun stuff. I was obviously pleased for her as she has been through hell and this makes life easier.

Anyway, here’s the bit I’m struggling with. It’s a year on and her ex sees his child once a month. My friend understandably says looking after dc is a lot etc and she doesn’t have much help apart from when she’s in nursery and she’s working which I know isn’t actually a break. But… I’m about to have ivf alone as I am still single at 37. I know this probably plays into why I am so sensitive but every time we talk she says what a stretch it is to put her daughter into nursery an extra day here and there to mean she has spare time. She will say how alone she feels even though her daughter’s dad does buy things (I know it’s not the same as being an active parent day to day), but he’s also paying her mortgage!! It’s making me feel really scared about doing it alone when I will have no support in any way shape or form from anyone and with the cost of living crisis it’s stressful talking to her when I’m thinking well you have 1,500 SPARE a month!! I know it probably sounds like I am jealous and I really really do understand the stress of being a single parent but I am finding it so hard to be in her life while going through this process. I have spoken to her about it and she said I didn’t understand the stress of single parenthood and ‘all single parents struggle.’ Apparently because I am choosing this alone I don’t warrant the same understanding. I don’t want to lose her friendship but I feel so upset and conflicted about it all and it’s really driven a wedge between us at a time I need support myself. Am I being harsh to her? Am I mad for doing this alone?

OP posts:
WowOK · 05/12/2023 09:55

You think she is making out she is struggling but SHE IS STRUGGLING. How she feels is how she feels it isn't about you. She has a job and some bills paid but that isn't the same as an actual coparent.

If you want to be a mum and your ready then go for it but don't project your fear onto your friend. It's a YOU problem.

Being a parent is hard. I'm a SAHM to 2 under 5. It's hard with a partner. I'm sure it's even harder without one. Things change and situations change. I have a partner now I might not have one later. We role with the punches and adapt.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 05/12/2023 09:55

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:07

@Daisies12 my situation will be so different though. I earn 35k a year and so will have nowhere near the sort of income she has and it has really scared me.

You'll have access to universal credit and child benefit if you rent you'll get even more.

A single parent with a mortgage earning
60k has less monthly spending money than
A
Single parents on 12k renting on universal credit. According to 'mothers at home matter'

TrashyP · 05/12/2023 09:50

Apologies if I'm replying wrongly, I've made an account to reply to this as usually I just lurk.
I've been both you and your friend, and I don't think your friend is being very supportive.
I also think a lot of the other replys are treating you like a naive teenager wanting a baby doll.

You've supported her enough for her to share finances you know how hard the parenting graft is. It could be she's got stuck in a "woe is me" mentality when actually she's got a going for her. But it is different going into it knowing your alone to being left.
Budget, be sensible and ask her for emotional support. Try and not focus on the financial disparity.

(I write after being left with a one year old, relocating, new job, custody and choosing to have my second as a solo mum.)

Keeva2017 · 05/12/2023 09:50

You don’t get it at all. That fact that you think you do just means you are in for a rude awakening.

Headband · 05/12/2023 09:49

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:07

@Daisies12 my situation will be so different though. I earn 35k a year and so will have nowhere near the sort of income she has and it has really scared me.

Sometimes it's not the money, it's the worry and mental load. It's also not a competition. Maybe, as she's finding it so hard (and it is , being a single parent nearly broke me at times) she's trying to make you aware and make sure you really know what you are doing.

Yaros · 05/12/2023 09:48

I’m a parent but not a single parent. I have zero comprehension of what the daily trials of being a single parent are even though I know what it is to be a parent and I am friends with single parents too.

I think her reality is confronting for you because your reality is likely to be even more difficult. That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t do it, she is just giving you a more realistic perspective about what being a single parent is like.

NerrSnerr · 05/12/2023 09:45

Having a decent income helps but it doesn't take away a lot of the struggles of being a single parent. I think the biggest one is just the huge responsibility of doing it alone. Your child has chicken pox so needs a week off school/ nursery and there is no one to share the load. You've been up all night with a child who doesn't sleep and there's no one to give you an hour to yourself etc.

Would I choose to have a child with no family support? Absolutely not, I'm in a couple with no extended family and it's bloody exhausting (and expensive). You'll need the finances for extra support at some point I imagine if there's no one else and get plans in place if there's any reason you can't care for your child (illness/ accident)

ManchesterGirl2 · 05/12/2023 09:45

I think you are jealous, and I also think that's okay.

To be considering going it alone on £35k is a really tricky position. If you had, effectively, a sperm donor who paid you £1k per month, you'd be in a much better position.

I think maybe the friendship needs a shake up. Things are difficult for both of you in different ways, so it can't be a one-way provision of support any more.

ExcitingRicotta · 05/12/2023 09:45

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:08

@Dishwashersaurous i know that but I supported her non stop and I feel now she is not supporting me but making out she is struggling with even an extra day of nursery when she has the funds for it…all I take from that is it would be impossible for me

”all I take from that is it would be impossible for me”
there will always be people out there who are in a better and a worse position that you are. All you can do is be confident in your own choices. Going into single parenthood alone won’t be easy and if you’re struggling financial it will be 10x harder. Do you have a financial plan for childcare etc? If you have confidence in your own plan it shouldn’t matter what other people are doing.

I don’t agree with everyone giving you a hard time, or those saying ‘she is doing uou a favour’, from what you’ve described it doesn’t sound like she’s at all sensitive to your position. But if your friend having a higher disposable income than you is so unsettling I think you need to review your own options and make sure you are comfortable with your choices.

Justfinking · 05/12/2023 09:43

Sorry to disappoint OP but even with a partner it is so, so hard. If you have no support network then you will need to buy it which might not be possible if you have a low income. It is really important that you realise you know what you're getting yourself into

Orangeandgold · 05/12/2023 09:43

If I am being honest I find that nobody understands parenting until they become a parent. Even people that raised their siblings, people that love children, teachers.

There is nothing that prepares you for being a parent - if there is, someone please show me. So when I have a rant about my life in regards to parenting I know that the people that truly understand are those that are going through it.

This isn’t a dig at you but parenting, whether single or not is hard - I have married friends that rant at me and I almost want to say “but I don’t have a person at home” but I cannot invalidate their experience - and so I listen and accept that they are struggling too. However for those of us that are genuinely happy about being parents, we also see that it’s such an amazing experience.

She probably isn’t doing it on purpose but often as parents we rant about our children, parenting. Getting our children to school is a daily time consuming task and also her baby dad seeing the child once a month isn’t actually regular.

Anyway if you are doing it alone I would advise having someone. Friends - you might find that she is that friend, I have a beautiful friendship group of single mums (sadly not by choice) and we get each other and help eachother out. I also have family that I would see as my daughters guardians who help me particularly with work and having a small life outside parenting.

The reality is that for those of us parents that are hands on, our children take over our lives and we have to find ways to Carve out space for ourselves.

You will be fine as a single mum - many do it. But we all need support. I would never advise anyone to have a child all on their own. Yes you can be a single parent but who else is there? Family? Friend? Aunt? One of the most undervalued quotes is “it takes a village”.

LetsGoDoDoDo · 05/12/2023 09:39

I think some PPs are being a little harsh to the OP here.

I was a single parent to my DD from when she was 15mo to 9 years. Yes, it can be really hard emotionally and at times feels isolating but oh my goodness it is so worth it! I'm so close to my 12 yo DD now! To be honest, I feel like I'm reaping the rewards from that hard slog!

OP you know yourself well, if this is something that you really want and you believe you have the strength of character (as alluded to above) to handle this journey on your own then don't let your friend steer you off course.

It's useful to have some insight into being a single parent as this will enable you to think and plan out how you will curate a support network, which will benefit both you and your DC. (It takes a village!)

Good luck!

SmokySilverShine · 05/12/2023 09:38

User2346522 · 05/12/2023 09:19

Agree. Parenting is soul crushing in a way that doesn't boil down to just money (and 1500 is not even that much tbh). I know plenty of couples who have endless funds for nursery, nannies, cleaners, toys, entertainment and it's still extremely difficult. Being a single parent even more so. Small kids get sick, you get sick, work needs to be down, you never get any downtime let alone a night off and only get a few hours of broken sleep every single night. All of that you can't buy or fix with cash. Contrary to what many think, extra nursery time, a nanny or au pair doesn't mean you swan around in leisure time. Most people earning enough to afford that will need to spend every free minute working or commuting, so it works out to nothing in the end.

Money doesn't insulate you from loneliness either. There's nothing more lonely than being left alone with a small child and having to put on a cheery face even though you get screamed and cried at all day. You have virtually no adult conversation for days and no time to build up meaningful friendships or relationships.

Edited

Blimey £1500 is a lot to me.
Your friend is in a very good place financially, but it is daunting to be raising a child, mostly by herself

In your position, I would distance myself. She is not going to give you the support you need

I would also reconsider going through IVF yourself.
I am a mother, and I wouldn’t chose to do it alone, or at all given a second chance at life.

DinkyDonkey2018 · 05/12/2023 09:37

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:08

@Dishwashersaurous i know that but I supported her non stop and I feel now she is not supporting me but making out she is struggling with even an extra day of nursery when she has the funds for it…all I take from that is it would be impossible for me

Come on, OP, you must see how ridiculous this is? She's doing you a favour, giving you a taste of what the reality is - it's hard and even harder for single parents regardless of money. You're deciding to go into this and become a single parent, so if you don't like the dose of reality she's giving you, don't do it. It's not her responsibility to make you feel comfortable with YOUR choices.

Seeline · 05/12/2023 09:37

It's not the money. It will help if you're not wondering whether the mortgage will be paid, can you put the heating on and have you enough food, but it's so much more

Tiny newborn, straight after a long and difficult birth. Needs feeding at least every 2hours, and changing, and won't sleep unless held. You haven't had more than 90 mins sleep for days, you need to cook and eat too. No-one else to hold the baby while you sleep.

Baby appears to be ill - but how ill? Do you give Calpol, get a GP appointment, A&E or ambulance. No one to discuss it with - it's all down to you.

Tantrums, teething, vaccinations, which school, discipline, accidents, illnesses - it's all down to you.

NoNoNadaNo · 05/12/2023 09:36

There's several points here that I have different opinions about.

The fact she's complaining about being a single parent; she is absolutely reasonable to do this, she didn't expect to be a single parent and sounds like baby's dad is hardly involved. So, aswell as holding down what is probably a high responsibility career (given the salary), she's having to do all the night wakings, illnesses, teething, different stages of development, figuring out why baby/toddler is crying this time etc, by herself. This is hard when there's two of you, can't imagine doing it all yourself with no breaks from your partner. Nursery is not a break from this, nursery does not make a dent in the sleepless nights.

The fact she's complaining about the finances of all this; she is being unreasonable. She knows you know her circumstances and how much she has to spare, so she's being a bit dense. You say she doesn't know how much you earn, maybe she has assumed you earn more than her and is trying a sympathy vote? Maybe next time she brings this up, you drop in to conversation your salary and let that sink in for her a bit?
Depending on where you live and your housing situation (do you own or rent? How much does this cost you?), I would say it's more than doable to live a comfortable life with one child on your income. You should be entitled to help with nursery fees.

The fact that she knows you want a child and will have to go through IVF to do this, I would say she's being completely insensitive to you and rude, seeing how much you supported her in the past. She sounds a bit like one of those friends who wants to be your bestie when it advantages them, but when you need the support they get defensive and suddenly still have all these 'issues', so couldn't possibly support you at this time.

When you have to take an alternative route to have children because things haven't gone to 'plan' for you, it's heart breaking. It's one thing to have a hard time financially/time wise, but still having the family you wanted around you. It's another thing completely to yearn for children so much and not being able to have them naturally. It's literally our biological purpose on this planet to procreate, so it hurts beyond words to not be able to do so. If she were a real friend, she'd be sensitive to that and not make everything about her all the time.

Thesearmsofmine · 05/12/2023 09:32

YABU she chose to have a baby presumably thinking her and her partner would be sharing the load. Things have changed for her and it’s hard. You don’t understand how hard it is for her, it’s not about money, it’s the mental load, the relentlessness and responsibility of looking after a small child with nobody to hand over too at the end of a long day when they have cried non stop or have been sick all over you and you just want to wash.

You are choosing to have IVF and go it alone. It will be hard. Should she pretend it’s all cute outfits and fun days out?

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 05/12/2023 09:32

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:11

@Saggypants i do as I have seen my friend in that situation. But there is no doubt the finances have made it easier for her by a long way and I feel she is rubbing that in my face a bit.

Believe me, you don't. My best friend was a single parent and I spent a lot of time with her and the kids. I still didn't properly comprehend the stress and mental strain of being a single parent - until i was one myself. It's one thing that I genuinely think you can't understand unless you've actually been there, done it.

ElevenSeven · 05/12/2023 09:29

Choosing to do it alone is very different to unexpectedly ending up alone. You’ve made the choice.

Financially, it’s going to be extra hard. That doesn’t mean your friend can’t then complain about her circumstances, it’s all relative.

RudolphsFriend · 05/12/2023 09:28

You don’t understand what it’s like to be a single parent, sorry but you don’t.

I am financially stable but I find it incredibly hard. It must be harder when you’re struggling with money but it’s just hard.

There is no way I would ever encourage someone I knew well to voluntarily go it alone, knowing what I now know.

nutbrownhare15 · 05/12/2023 09:28

It sounds like you are comparing your future self to her and feeling jealous. This is illogical and ultimately not something we should be doing with friends. She is having a hard time, yes she has some privileges but also some hardships. As do we all. Support her as best you can bearing in mind you are also going through a hard time. Stop comparing and seek support elsewhere if she's not able to provide it.

EarringsandLipstick · 05/12/2023 09:25

I agree with PP, you don't get it - because you can't. (Single parent, 3 DC)

You need to separate it out - what your friend does, or her circumstances, are irrelevant to you.

You do need to practically think about how you plan to afford IVF and possibly bring up a baby alone, and how that will impact you financially - and emotionally. Bluntly, yes, it will be tough on £35k. Yes many two parent families only have that - but when you are on your own, everything falls to you, and that's the part that makes it hard.

Fabellini · 05/12/2023 09:25

You seem to think that all the problems a single parent faces are gone if they are comfortable financially. Which tells me that actually you really really don’t understand the stress of being a single parent.
I was widowed when my children were very young - the circumstances meant we were left pretty well off, but I was exhausted.
No one there to share worries with, no one to attend parents evening with, no one to back me up when an irate 7 year old refused to go to bed, no one to let me have a lie in on a weekend, no one to take over when I was ill, and no one on the planet who loved my children as much as I did.
I read something a while back about how you should be prepared as a parent to spend the rest of your life worried, and I think there’s some truth in that - harder too when there’s no one there at 3 in the morning to share your worries, or tell you that you’re being daft and everything’s fine.
My children are amazing, wonderful, young adults now, and I am often told they are a credit to me, which is lovely obviously, but it was fucking hard getting to this point.

SonwflakesAreForWimps · 05/12/2023 09:24

She's being a good friend by giving you a window into how hard it is both financially and emotionally. Having a little human wholly dependent on you for everything is not something to do lightly even if you really want it.

Have you considered whether you can actually afford to be a single parent? There's an overwhelming biological urge to be a parent but it's not enough to get you through the grinding misery that parenting can be if you don't have enough money and/ or support to make it work.

Haveyouanyjam · 05/12/2023 09:22

She might be unaware that your financial
situation is not the same as hers, especially given you only know hers for a specific reason. Everyone’s perspective is limited in some way. Are you self-funding the IVF as that also may be skewing her view?

I agree that it’s reasonable she is sharing her struggles as you do need to be prepared that it will be tough.

If you are close then I would just say to her - why don’t you cut back elsewhere and put your child in nursery an extra day? If she comes up with reasons why she can’t/doesn’t want to then maybe she will bring it up less. You can also say to her that whilst you value her honesty, you have made the decision to pursue a child as a single parent and whilst you appreciate that the reality is tough you also don’t currently feel able to cope with hearing about it all the time. It’s similar to discussing the challenges of labour or child rearing whilst someone is pregnant. You want to be honest but you don’t want to scare monger when someone has already made the decision.