Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my friend is using the single parent reason for things that affect all of us?

121 replies

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:00

I don’t know if I am being sensitive but I supported my friend through a horrific break up when her baby was only a few months old. It was awful for her and I was there for her every step of the way. She has emerged from it with her ex partner paying her mortgage (over 1k a month, they weren’t married) and landed a job paying over 50k for 3.5 days a week. When I helped her with relocating we worked out she had around 1,500 spare for food and fun stuff. I was obviously pleased for her as she has been through hell and this makes life easier.

Anyway, here’s the bit I’m struggling with. It’s a year on and her ex sees his child once a month. My friend understandably says looking after dc is a lot etc and she doesn’t have much help apart from when she’s in nursery and she’s working which I know isn’t actually a break. But… I’m about to have ivf alone as I am still single at 37. I know this probably plays into why I am so sensitive but every time we talk she says what a stretch it is to put her daughter into nursery an extra day here and there to mean she has spare time. She will say how alone she feels even though her daughter’s dad does buy things (I know it’s not the same as being an active parent day to day), but he’s also paying her mortgage!! It’s making me feel really scared about doing it alone when I will have no support in any way shape or form from anyone and with the cost of living crisis it’s stressful talking to her when I’m thinking well you have 1,500 SPARE a month!! I know it probably sounds like I am jealous and I really really do understand the stress of being a single parent but I am finding it so hard to be in her life while going through this process. I have spoken to her about it and she said I didn’t understand the stress of single parenthood and ‘all single parents struggle.’ Apparently because I am choosing this alone I don’t warrant the same understanding. I don’t want to lose her friendship but I feel so upset and conflicted about it all and it’s really driven a wedge between us at a time I need support myself. Am I being harsh to her? Am I mad for doing this alone?

OP posts:
Jinglingallthewaytochristmas · 05/12/2023 10:37

Saggypants · 05/12/2023 09:09

I really really do understand the stress of being a single parent

You really don't.

It's not just about money.* *

I agree with this. You can’t fully understand the stress of a parent unless your one or perhaps if your a carer of older person would be similar. The exhaustion is a major issues and then you a constant mental load of a whole other person.

I’m not a single parent. I can emphasise but it’s not something that I can fully understand.

sunnydayhereandnow · 05/12/2023 10:32

Single mum by choice here :) I think the dynamic between single mums and our single-with-no-kids friends can be a bit weird, and I would try not to read too much into her comments. It can just be hard to see your friends "footloose and fancy free" when you have so much on your plate, so comments can come out the wrong way.

Previous posters are right in saying that being a single mum by choice is totally different to being someone who has broken up with their partner and been left with the kids. As a SMBC you expect things to be hard work from the start but you're willing to go for it.

Bringing up a kid on your own isn't all about the money, but money gives you more options to pay for things that can make your life more convenient (babysitting, the odd takeaway when you're tired...). However, having a supportive community around you is REALLY important. You need a couple of numbers in your phone that you can call when you are ill/the kid is ill and you need something from the pharmacy - or just so that your kid has a relationship with adults other than yourself. I found I got a lot of support from friends a little older than me whose kids have already left home but aren't yet grandparents.

Good luck with it. It's very full on but immensely gratifying :)

ginandtonicwithlimes · 05/12/2023 10:32

I have a supportive and quite hands on DH. We have no family nearby and childcare is very expensive. We are both finding it exhausting looking after two kids. We don't have much money. Still that rather than be a single parent. It must be hard.

Dahliasrule · 05/12/2023 10:31

My DD went down the same route as you, OP, IVF that resulted in beautiful twins. However, she made sure she had a good support network around her, close friends and we live a few doors away. However, there is no doubt it has been hard for her. Twins are now teenagers, and most of her close friends have moved away so I think she does get lonely at times. Would she make a different decision knowing what she knows? Never.

TheWetBandits · 05/12/2023 10:30

I echo other posters here that I don't think you get it and you seem fixated on the money

I am with my DH, we have 2 DC and between us earn £100k. We have enough to put aside savings each month. BUT we still umm and err about extra days in nursery, how much to spend on presents, whether to get new or second hand bike.

This year alone we've had to replace our car, the boiler broke, had a leak in our bathroom needing new shower and flooring... That money gets used up very quickly. And each time we use it, it's a little less for DCs education fund etc

And even in a 2 parent family, it is tiring, I am tired ALL THE TIME. I come down with viruses the kids get ALL THE TIME. Sometimes at the weekend I just want to scream into a pillow as it is so relentless. And that is with an extra parent. The money does nothing to ease that and your friend is doing it alone

If you're undergoing IVF presumably you've budgeted for maternity, childcare when you're back at work, thought about a support network etc. And if you've thought all this through and done the work then whatever your friend says shouldn't put you off. But she's not wrong in what she's saying

hydriotaphia · 05/12/2023 10:27

I feel like you are worried about what the reality of having a child will be for you if the IVF is successful. I actually agree that money makes a significant difference to how easy many things are. I would try to separate out your concern about this from your friend's situation (which is not really relevant). I would try to think in advance about how you will live in the early years. Eg will you be able to afford childcare or will you need to quit your job, how will you afford other outgoings, what benefits will you be entitled to and will they cover your expenses etc. There's no point being surprised by this stuff so you may as well go in with your eyes open. Good luck.

Nowherenew · 05/12/2023 10:23

I’m a single parent and money would absolutely make things easier but that’s not the hardest part of being a single parent.

It’s carrying the mental load 100% all of the time.
Even choosing a nursery or school is so much easier when you can have a quick discussion with someone about it.

You could probably afford a cleaner but it does mean everything else is 100% your responsibility.
So when you’re poorly and can barely get out of bed you still need to cook, clean, change nappies, make bottles etc.

Whenever there are posts about women getting pregnant with a ONS or man who’s left her, I am always honest about my experiences because I don’t believe in lying about something like this.

Nowherenew · 05/12/2023 10:19

YABU

And you’re being very selfish by planning to have a baby with no father.

Your friend is a single parent and is living what you will be living - she is telling you how difficult it is, even though she only works PT and has lots of money.

I don’t understand why you wouldn’t listen to what she’s saying.

Children raised in single parent households are proven to be at a disadvantage.
You are choosing to have a child knowing they will be put at a disadvantage.

You have a decent income but it’s still not the same as having 2 incomes.

You say you have no support, so it’s going to be even harder for you and your child.
What happens if you die or become seriously ill?

A child needs to know that they are loved by both parents (even if one is a complete waste of space, not involved at all or dead).

Choosing to have a baby this way is very selfish.
Just get a cat.

Saz12 · 05/12/2023 10:18

But OP, only you honestly know your energy levels, your ability to deal with the lonliness, confidence to make decisions for your cchld day in day out - and your freind had your support initially: she wont be able to offer you the same level of support because she has dc who she is solely responsible for.

You see her doing well and she's worried that you dont see all the other times when she's at thevend of her tether.

TrashyP · 05/12/2023 10:16

No problem happy to share but not sure if it'll help. Second is six months old and big sibling is five so lots of conversations to come I know.
The big one accepts the little one doesn't have a daddy but a man&doctor helped mummy grow them. - I'm using the language advised by Donor Conception Network.
I'm hoping a strong sense of mutual family and honesty will give allow us to discuss and so neither feels lacking but also I accept every child thinks the grass is greener. At some point the older will feel jealous youngest gets to stay in one home with mum, and the younger will wish he had a known father figure. I can mitigate as best I can but it will happen.
I rationalized if I met someone then kids would have different dads and experiences, this way I at least can control the youngest child's experience more than a new relationship.
Eldest hates going to his dad's and adores baby.

betterangels · 05/12/2023 10:16

I think your friend is trying to warn you, I know you feel unsupported but we should tell our friends the truth and thats what she’s doing. it would be no good if she told you it’s great and it’s a breeze if it’s not the truth, you would later wonder why she didn’t tell you

This is what I thought. More people should probably be honest about the reality of parenthood.

Allaboutthepeople · 05/12/2023 10:16

Do you have family support OP?

If you don’t, you really need to think if you are prepared for how lonely it will be not been able to go out till your child is in their mid teens.

Money does make things easier, it does. For a single parent, your friend does have a lot of advantages. Affluent, working part time.

I think you are reacting to your friend as she is making you face up to how hard it will be for you to be a single parent. And yes it will be harder for you. You need to stop focusing on your feelungs about your friend, and start focusing on if your life as a single parent is one you really want.

KCSIE · 05/12/2023 10:14

QueenBean22 · 05/12/2023 09:16

Kindly, You are being unreasonable. The loneliness of parenting alone and lack of childfree time when not working is so hard.

im sorry for your situation, it must be hard having to undergo IVF alone but this isn’t your friends fault. You sound like a very good friend, hopefully she can return the favour for you and support you if and when you need it.

Hugs

Beautifully put.

Orangeandgold · 05/12/2023 10:14

Jeuggy · 05/12/2023 09:08

@Dishwashersaurous i know that but I supported her non stop and I feel now she is not supporting me but making out she is struggling with even an extra day of nursery when she has the funds for it…all I take from that is it would be impossible for me

@Jeuggy what did your support look like?

what do you want support from her to look like?

I say this because I have had many people support me over the years, some more than others. Some would consider their support highly valuable. Was it that you were there for her? Babysat? Helped financially?

And then what do you feel you need from her? To be sensitive whilst you go through this? To not judge? To be there when you become a single parent?

I hope you can have an honest convo about that.

(just wanted to add this)

fairymary87 · 05/12/2023 10:14

You'll never understand being a good parent until you are one. And it's so hard she's just being very honest with you. Stop being jealous. Also yes you don't earn enough. It's gonna be very tight. Also even with two you can still feel very alone. Me and the dad feel like passing ships as he works week days and I work weekends to make things work. So stop acting like you know everything when you haven't experienced. Just because you sat on the side lines watching someone struggling doesn't mean you get it. As someone raised by a single parent on little money, I admire my mother so much as I find it so hard now and I can't possibly understand how she got through it. You're being a bit of a tit if I'm honest

anon20 · 05/12/2023 10:11

I meant to say discusses with the ex. I know having an ex is sometimes a nightmare but I'd like think there are some parents male and female still want what's best for their child

Ontheperiphery79 · 05/12/2023 10:11

Respectfully, you don't understand what it is to be a parent, single or otherwise, as you don't have a child.@

anon20 · 05/12/2023 10:09

Hi OP...I think you have to see it that she is telling you how hard it is. It really is, no question. Of course there are amazing times and I love my child to bits but it is bloody hard. She finds it hard I'm spite of all the help she gets. But you're two different people so it may be a breeze for you. I had IVF, completely alone, at a similar age. The circumstances were slightly different. It has been highs and lows all the way, I won't lie. You are responsible for absolutely everything and I mean everything. I assume your friend discusses things about their child plus she doesn't have the money worries. I would really really really think about it carefully which I'm sure you have done. As I say Id do anything for my child but if I'm honest, knowing what I know no, I'm not sure I would have gone ahead. Good luck x

Hadjab · 05/12/2023 10:09

Fabellini · 05/12/2023 09:25

You seem to think that all the problems a single parent faces are gone if they are comfortable financially. Which tells me that actually you really really don’t understand the stress of being a single parent.
I was widowed when my children were very young - the circumstances meant we were left pretty well off, but I was exhausted.
No one there to share worries with, no one to attend parents evening with, no one to back me up when an irate 7 year old refused to go to bed, no one to let me have a lie in on a weekend, no one to take over when I was ill, and no one on the planet who loved my children as much as I did.
I read something a while back about how you should be prepared as a parent to spend the rest of your life worried, and I think there’s some truth in that - harder too when there’s no one there at 3 in the morning to share your worries, or tell you that you’re being daft and everything’s fine.
My children are amazing, wonderful, young adults now, and I am often told they are a credit to me, which is lovely obviously, but it was fucking hard getting to this point.

This!!

My husband died 5 years ago. Whilst my kids were older when it happened, that in no way negates how hard it's been being on my own. Their mental health has been shot to pieces, especially the youngest, and covid compounded that. Not having that support to get through it has been soul destroying. House stuff, work stuff, you name it - when you're having to make all of those decisions alone, and not through choice, no amount of money can compensate.

swuahies · 05/12/2023 10:08

Saggypants · 05/12/2023 09:09

I really really do understand the stress of being a single parent

You really don't.

It's not just about money.* *

Exactly this.

I'm a single parent, not doing bad financially (but need to work full time). And it's so so so so fucking hard. It's relentless and can be draining at times.

But it's always the most amazing thing in the whole world. I've never known love and contentment like it. But. It. Is. Hard.

Many 2 parent families struggle with having time, personal space, childcare.....imagine having that doubled! I've lost track of the amount of my married friends/relatives with v supportive husbands who have said "why did you never tell me it'd this hard?"

As a single parent the hardest part for me isn't the money or the practical stuff. It's the mental load, the not being part of a team when you've had a really shit day and feeling the worlds worst parent - there's no one there to reassure you're doing your best and support and to have your back! It can be very very lonely regardless of how many great friendships you have - it's no where near having someone who is actively co-parenting in a loving relationship.

People don't want to hear it before having a baby, then moan they weren't told after.

Your friend is realistic and looking out for you. Would it be better if she told you it was all rainbows and sunshine until your baby is here?

YaWeeFurryBastard · 05/12/2023 10:08

Apparently because I am choosing this alone I don’t warrant the same understanding.

Well to be blunt, she chose to have a baby without being married to the father so the odds of him sticking around were much lower and she’s lucky he’s doing the decent thing and financially providing.

(When I say lucky, of course the father should be contributing but sadly many do not, so she is luckier than others in that respect).

Sunshineandflipflops · 05/12/2023 10:05

Op, it sounds like you have been a good friend.

I am a single parent, earning similar to you, who receives maintenance from her exdh, he has them EOW and a night in the week and we do all major child-related things together.

Compared to many single parents I probably 'have it easy', but this is my reality and I can't compare my life to anyone else's as this is the one I am living. It's hard. Not just financially, knowing I have no fall back, but my dc are teenagers now so every bad day falls on me because this is their home and where they return to every day, even on the days they go to their dad's. They know I make time for them when their dad doesn't. He can go away for a few days/a week without thinking about anyone else...the most time I get on my own is 2 days in a row. Even if I were rich, that wouldn't change.

Like your friend, I never planned or expected to be a single parent. My life is not what I imagined it would be before my ex had an affair. I know people have it worse but I am still allowed to mourn or be angry about what I thought MY life would be sometimes.

Yes, your friend is better off than many single parents financially but it doesn't make it easier for her to live her life.

Being comfortable financially doesn't mean your life is easy.

Best of luck with your ivf - I'm sure your friend will be there for you. Remember, comparison is the thief of joy x

headcheffer · 05/12/2023 09:58

Dishwashersaurous · 05/12/2023 09:07

She's giving realistic picture of the fact that having children is really, really hard.

It's really hard emotionally, physically qnd financially.

It's really hard with two committed parents in a stable relationship.

It's hard if you have pots of cash.

It's hard.

And lots of people don't go into it understanding that.

You can make any life choices you wish and doing so on the most realistic understanding of what it may actually be like is important.

Exactly this

PippyLongTits · 05/12/2023 09:56

It is difficult to be a single parent, but that is no reason not to do it. Good luck to you!

Yes, your friend is in a fortunate position financially and many people have an income lower than £1500/mo from which they need to pay all bills, mortgage, food, car and other expenses, so to have £1500/mo fun money is a very enviable position.

That said, she didn't sign up to do everything on her own, so she will have a lot of feelings of rejection, resentment and other emotions related to being left holding the baby. I feel that whatever your situation ends up being, you will know that it was the result of YOUR choices whereas she cannot say the same.

There are lots of things about being a single parent that it is impossible to fully understand until you are in that situation though. It is relentless and gruelling, and you will constantly be told that other people understand what it's like, but they really don't.

Weekends are lonely because most of your/your kid's friends are having "family time" with both parents. The housework is never done because there just aren't enough hours in the day compared to having one person putting the kids to bed while the other one tidies up. You may have to reduce your working hours to fit around childcare (income, career progression, pension pot all take a hit). When the kids are ill you have to take time off work and that isn't shared with another person (so work/career can suffer). You can't just pop out if you run out of milk - you have to take everyone to and around the shop. You can't see your friends as much because you have noone to watch the child(ren) and babysitters are expensive. If you are feeling rotten, you can't rest up in bed, you still have to get up and do everything. Everything takes a lot longer because it is only you doing it.

And yes, financially it is hard too. Not many single parents are able to find a job paying £50k for 3 days, and it is hard having to tell your children "no" when they want what their friends have or seeing all the extracurricular activities that their friends are able to do that are simply not affordable on (most) part-time wages.

But it is also very rewarding, and I am so, so glad I have my amazing, wonderful children in my life.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 05/12/2023 09:56

TrashyP · 05/12/2023 09:50

Apologies if I'm replying wrongly, I've made an account to reply to this as usually I just lurk.
I've been both you and your friend, and I don't think your friend is being very supportive.
I also think a lot of the other replys are treating you like a naive teenager wanting a baby doll.

You've supported her enough for her to share finances you know how hard the parenting graft is. It could be she's got stuck in a "woe is me" mentality when actually she's got a going for her. But it is different going into it knowing your alone to being left.
Budget, be sensible and ask her for emotional support. Try and not focus on the financial disparity.

(I write after being left with a one year old, relocating, new job, custody and choosing to have my second as a solo mum.)

That's really interesting - sorry to derail, but can I ask a personal question- how do you deal with one child having a dad and not the other? I wondered about having a second via ivf but that's a big fear of mine