Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the 'Net Contributors' argument is just wrong?

380 replies

Yetmorebeanstocount · 04/12/2023 22:22

Just been reading about "Net Contributors" of tax and how it supposedly is a bad thing that we don't have enough in this country.
i.e. - that most people receive more, in cash benefits, social care, NHS, police, education, roads, bin collections etc. etc. than they will ever pay for via their taxes, so they are 'net recipients' of the system rather than 'net contributors'.

My reaction is - well yes of course. That is how it should be!

Take a very-over-simplified example to illustrate the maths:

Say there are 100 people who earn £1k, and one person who earns £200k. Say the 100 pay no taxes, and the one person pays tax at 50% of £100k.

That tax gets re-distributed to the 100 people in the form of services and benefits and pensions, so that the 100 now have the equivalent of £2k each and the one person still has £100k.
What is supposed to be wrong with this? It is just basic re-distribution of income, which is something that every civilised society should do.

Of course in real life people earn all sorts of amounts and receive different things, so it is not so simple, but the principle is the same - a few at the top are 'net contributors' and the rest are 'net recipients'.

And of course, those at the top still get something back as they drive on roads and have their bins collected, and have the benefit of living in a civilised society which is policed and (mostly) does not have people dying on the streets.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
110APiccadilly · 06/12/2023 07:16

Statementdress · 05/12/2023 18:02

I think you’re the perfect example of how someone who does a lot for society is considered to ‘cost’ the government.

It also sounds like you cost less than the average person- but that’s an average. If you have a complicated illness, possibly medivaced to hospital, have to spend time in intensive care, then you could easily ‘cost’ the government millions of pounds in healthcare costs. An amount you’d never pay back in your lifetime.

The big costs for government are the NHS and Defence. You may only bother the Doctor with a cough, but you could easily get seriously ill at any given time. The gvt has to plan for X amount of people needing treatment.

The 41k is the amount being quoted in media. ( probably ONS figure, but can’t remember)

There’s also the huge cost of the armed forces who are there to defend the country- could you imagine if we had to pay for that directly?

Defence is only 6%. It's less than the interest on government debt. Also less than education or welfare, as well as health. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_United_Kingdom

Government spending in the United Kingdom - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending_in_the_United_Kingdom

lkwhjis · 06/12/2023 07:02

MN is a great demonstration of enonomic illiteracy in this country. It shows you why our economy is in so much trouble.

Net contribution is such a simple concept, yet there are sorts of weird contortions being performed on this thread. If you have more people who take that those who pay in on a net basis, what happens? Greece happens. You run out of money. You go bankrupt. Up the creek, without a paddle. Call it what you will.

The number of net contributors in this country is shrinking fast, now down at 47%. More than half take more than they pay into the system. To the hard of thinking, what is a low enough number of net contributors that you think is acceptable? 0%? Fear not, we are heading that way, since reducing the number of net contributors has a spiral effect. More and more people either reduce their earnings to reduce tax, leave for countries with lower tax or impacted in some other way by a weaker economy - which itself is weaker due to the initial reduction in net contributors.

So if you ever wonder why the roads look shabby, why you can’t get healthcare. Or the police won’t attend a burglary. The root cause is that we have too many people taking and not enough paying into the system. But then again, the poor knowledge of basic economics in this country shouldn’t surprise anyone that this is the case.

Princessandthepea0 · 06/12/2023 06:40

There are multiple problems here. We have one of the highest state dependencies and economically inactive populations in the developed world. A messed up tax system which means that people pay marginals of 70%-100% here. The highest tax payers on PAYE are already paying their fare share when compared to the rest of the world. Other (basic rate) payers are not when you look at scandi models for example - 30%.

The ONS has already stated that tax system in this country is reducing tax take which society needs to pay for itself. We are already in debt and have to borrow every month to fund the state. Put simply not enough people are paying in. It’s also led to a brain drain and people like consultants and dentists dropping hours to stay under 100k. That’s why the pensions changed. Even Labour knows this is all a crisis hence backtracking on targeting high earners on PAYE.

auberginefortea · 06/12/2023 06:04

Cattenberg · 05/12/2023 02:12

I’m trying to imagine a present day General Strike. Let’s say that all the “net takers” stopped working for a few days.

People with young children or elderly relatives would have to care for them themselves 24/7. There would be no care workers or nursery nurses to help. Needless to say, many people wouldn’t be able to work during the strike.

Supermarkets would have to close. Owners of small family-owned stores might be able to open, but they would soon run out of perishable goods.

Crops would rot in the fields.

You could order items online, but you wouldn’t receive them.

Rubbish would start to pile up in the streets, causing a health hazard. Public toilets would soon be in a grim state.

Thousands of medical appointments would have to be cancelled.

Primary schools might have to close. Those that stayed open would have to forget their lesson plans and focus on basic childcare and crowd control.

If you had an urgent issue and needed to speak to a Customer Services department, then tough luck - no one would take your call.

Brilliant post

mantyzer · 06/12/2023 02:01

@Papyrophile you would not need 3 clinicians in the UK to rebandage a wound that has already been treated. A nurse would do it in the UK if necessary - the Dr would tell you to book another appointment with the nurse for this.

distrussful · 06/12/2023 01:41

Sorry to say this, but what happens when we inevitably have contributor drain? Unfortunately, those who pay the highest taxes are often the most geographically mobile and can do things like head to Hong Kong (10%), or the Middle East, and even though life might be more expensive for them, they'll have a better disposable income and a better way of life. We are heading to disaster with our continual
Hate of high earners.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 22:18

The late husband of a friend, a French resident for many years, was treated in France for a difficult life-threatening combination of health conditions in his last 18 months. The French system did much, much more to treat him than the UK system did to treat my DH (same age) with a similar condition. One lived, the other died.

ChatBFP · 05/12/2023 22:11

@mantyzer

Agreed that the French healthcare system is better funded than the NHS. It is not twice as well funded and it is multiple times better.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 22:04

No France doesn't spend more on healthcare. France's citizens spend more. There's a huge difference,

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 22:02

But the assessment process in France does not appear to require three clinicians to declare that it is necessary. The nurse can look, decide and treat in a single 5-15 minute whether to re-bandage a wound or leave it uncovered, or to say go back to the doctor for further advice.

mantyzer · 05/12/2023 21:59

@Papyrophile France spends more on healthcare than the UK.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 21:58

And France manages to deliver exceptional health care with good results, for the vast majority of the population. At a cost that appears very cheap compared to the bureaucracy that dogs the NHS.

mantyzer · 05/12/2023 21:57

@Papyrophile there is assessment. A qualified nurse has to assess the wound before dressing it. It may not take long, but it still has to happen.
There is admin for private providers to claim money back from the government. Juts because you can't see the admin does not mean it is not there.
Frances healthcare is judged independently to be top notch. They also pay more for healthcare than people in the UK do.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/236541/per-capita-health-expenditure-by-country/

Per capita health spending by country 2022 | Statista

The U.S. had the highest per capita healthcare costs in 2022. Per capita health costs in several high-income nations were half or less of what the U.S. spent.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/236541/per-capita-health-expenditure-by-country

ChatBFP · 05/12/2023 21:51

Agreed @Papyrophile

Also, France doesn't have a NHS - if you are entitled to treatment for something, you book your operation, down to the anaesthetist. Think of the admin cost saved!!

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 21:48

I think these are self standing businesses; there may be a government subsidy, but I don't know how the finances work. But it probably helps that you only visit to have a specific service. There's no diagnostic work because you'd be sent elsewhere to get tests (another private service covered by state or insurance). France has a national hospital service, but not a national health service, as most providers/doctors etc work for themselves and vy for patients. From the outside, it seems to work very smoothly.

ChatBFP · 05/12/2023 21:45

In France I mean

ChatBFP · 05/12/2023 21:45

Yes @Papyrophile

Lots of nurses with childcare responsibilities also do care in the community (elderly regular care, wound checking, removal of stitches after discharge etc) and phlebotomy roles (taking blood - you can get someone come to you!). They travel, often work just school hours and are sometimes paid time spent on job on a flexible basis.

mantyzer · 05/12/2023 21:39

@Papyrophile but it must be subsidised by the government? There is no way 5 euros covers the cost of assessment and treatment by a qualified nurse.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 21:36

And in all the places that I've needed a walk in consultation in France, I have only ever walked into the surgery (unregistered without an address -- because we were on holiday) and given a brief description of the symptoms. Been seen, paid the consultation fee, examined, and treated. Usually a private Rx, for which the cost has mostly been less than the NHS Rx fee.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 21:29

I don't disagree @Cattenberg . Nurses are among the most valuable members of society. But I was suggesting there are ways of utilising nursing skills and knowledge that may be more appealing to nurses who don't want to be at the beck and call of NHS rotas during child care years but who need to keep earning. France has "invented" the nursing office... so nurses keep their skills current and when their family commitments allow, go back to full on hospital work. I've consulted a few GPs in France, just walked in with ear infections mostly, and there has never been a nurse on the premises of a GP... only a receptionist to tell you your number and take your £10/15 euro consultation charge.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 05/12/2023 21:22

We are individualist here, Denmark and the other progressive countries have much more cohesive norms
Not everyone in the UK is a fuck you individualist - some of us still believe in society and don’t consider ourselves Thatcher’s children.

Schooldinner2 · 05/12/2023 21:19

Even low earners are paying hugely more tax than pre covid
Council tax up
Food prices
Gas electric
Fuel
And everything else.

Basically now spending whole wages so whatever the tax rate is on what is bought.
Even £1k now just to get 1 kid to secondary school.
So in terms of the initial tax and ni maybe not huge but when you see the say 1.5k council tax which just covers black bins (every 2w and weekly recycling)
If you think what products you have bought maybe a car so what that would be vefore tax and a phone.

However as a society growing too high population but as all layers too get more into spending on luxuries for themself keeping up with the jones the 'higher earners' rather than thinking how lucky they are (as most is just luck and no better at a job) try to avoid tax.
Personally i would cap the difference between to top earners in a company (except owners) often they are just constantly in meetings with those on the (non contributing?) 20-30k doing all the work

Cattenberg · 05/12/2023 21:02

@Papyrophile , I was addressing the beginning of your post.

But good marketing people make their employers money. Nurses are a cost:

MidnightMeltdown · 05/12/2023 20:53

I think part of the issue is that you don't need to be a high earner to be a net contributor. A quick google tells me that it's 41k

Given the cost of housing etc, 41k isn't a massive amount to live on. A family could easily be struggling on that, and yet are expected to fund others through the tax system.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 20:52

Not quite my point. Paying a few euros to have your injury properly checked, dressed and re-bandaged (I recall a charge of about 5 euros) on your schedule and within walking distance seems worth the modest charge to me. I admit my privilege freely, but I also don't want to freeload on the state provision. MN is split on whether I am doing the right thing by queuing for three weeks, or taking the Mick by paying and not troubling the system.