Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the 'Net Contributors' argument is just wrong?

380 replies

Yetmorebeanstocount · 04/12/2023 22:22

Just been reading about "Net Contributors" of tax and how it supposedly is a bad thing that we don't have enough in this country.
i.e. - that most people receive more, in cash benefits, social care, NHS, police, education, roads, bin collections etc. etc. than they will ever pay for via their taxes, so they are 'net recipients' of the system rather than 'net contributors'.

My reaction is - well yes of course. That is how it should be!

Take a very-over-simplified example to illustrate the maths:

Say there are 100 people who earn £1k, and one person who earns £200k. Say the 100 pay no taxes, and the one person pays tax at 50% of £100k.

That tax gets re-distributed to the 100 people in the form of services and benefits and pensions, so that the 100 now have the equivalent of £2k each and the one person still has £100k.
What is supposed to be wrong with this? It is just basic re-distribution of income, which is something that every civilised society should do.

Of course in real life people earn all sorts of amounts and receive different things, so it is not so simple, but the principle is the same - a few at the top are 'net contributors' and the rest are 'net recipients'.

And of course, those at the top still get something back as they drive on roads and have their bins collected, and have the benefit of living in a civilised society which is policed and (mostly) does not have people dying on the streets.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
BIossomtoes · 07/12/2023 16:58

How nice it would be if these threads didn’t turn into personal slanging matches.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 07/12/2023 15:07

Princessandthepea0 · 07/12/2023 14:05

On a lunch break and here you are being horribly abusive on the internet again. Serious question. Have you thought about being less angry and making your situation better?

I’m not being angry or abusive at all. You seem like someone who is used to holding forth with absolute nonsense regularly and who is unused to being challenged on it. Have you ever considered checking your facts - you might be less triggered by people pointing out errors if you bothered to do a cursory investigation before spouting crap.

Statementdress · 07/12/2023 14:59

Camerasforinthehouse · 06/12/2023 08:39

Calling people illiterate is rude.

I think most people grasp that if we take more from the pot than we put in then debt and bankruptcy ensue and public services fail.

Where there is disagreement is what to do about this. This is the complex issue and the answers are not clear cut.

@lkwhjis you are also forgetting corporate tax. The country isn’t run purely from individual’s pockets.

Perhaps if the government cut benefits to working people and made private companies actually pay employees a living wage, there would be more cash swilling about.

The Uk effectively subsidises companies who underpay their workers.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 07/12/2023 14:36

Or even work from home policies/flexible working policies. Yet companies still want you to come to the office a few days a week , forcing a lot of people having to live in cities.

Princessandthepea0 · 07/12/2023 14:05

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 07/12/2023 12:48

I didn’t say I was happy with anything - I was just responding to a post that was incorrectly trying to frame the tax concessions given to Olympic athletes as some concoction of a Labour government when it wasn’t.

Of course some rich people like J K Rowling are decent so they don’t just fuck off to wherever is cheapest like cunts.

On a lunch break and here you are being horribly abusive on the internet again. Serious question. Have you thought about being less angry and making your situation better?

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 07/12/2023 12:48

user1497207191 · 07/12/2023 11:13

It proves the point about "movable" rich people. Tax them too much and they'll just stay in their tax havens!

So you're happy for "rich" athletes (and pop stars, movie stars etc who are mobile) to avoid paying tax, but want to hit "rich" landowners, entreprenneurs, etc who can't as easily relocate?

Edited

I didn’t say I was happy with anything - I was just responding to a post that was incorrectly trying to frame the tax concessions given to Olympic athletes as some concoction of a Labour government when it wasn’t.

Of course some rich people like J K Rowling are decent so they don’t just fuck off to wherever is cheapest like cunts.

user1497207191 · 07/12/2023 11:13

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 21:00

The tax exemption wasn’t some deal cooked up by Labour. It’s a standard IOC requirement and applies wherever the games are held.

It proves the point about "movable" rich people. Tax them too much and they'll just stay in their tax havens!

So you're happy for "rich" athletes (and pop stars, movie stars etc who are mobile) to avoid paying tax, but want to hit "rich" landowners, entreprenneurs, etc who can't as easily relocate?

verdantverdure · 07/12/2023 09:46

Switcher · 04/12/2023 22:43

Yeah only I don't get anything back at all. I can't even book a GP appointment for my kids. And I can't go private because the referral has to be from GP for certain things. The roads are potholed, the trains are so bad my commute has turned into a nightmare, but despite being a net contributor for over ten years, I can't really afford to buy a house in London. You can't just endlessly squeeze the top earners, otherwise what's the point of earning more? It just gets taken away. There are some very serious macro issues facing the UK, principally driven by the lack of growth over the last decade. And no, not driven by "rich people".

If you can afford to give birth privately, vaccinate and educate your children privately, see a private GP, have your own private police force, army, fire brigade, emergency department, and and ambulance on standby and travel everywhere by helicopter not using the national infrastructure of road and rail then surely you can afford property?

verdantverdure · 07/12/2023 09:40

tttigress · 04/12/2023 22:30

Yeah, but with your example:

"100 people who earn £1k, and one person who earns £200k"

The £200k person must have a good skill set, what if they get totally peed off with the situation, and decide to take their skills and money to a lower tax location?

You probably wouldn't want to advocate for keeping them prisoner and I doubt many people would want the reintroduction of capital controls.

I'd wave them bye bye and hire someone else.

verdantverdure · 07/12/2023 09:35

honoldbrist · 06/12/2023 10:54

Plenty of tax is collected in this country. Its just wasted.

It is.

During the pandemic the U.K. government paid over the odds for PPE from 3 week old companies, paid over the odds to store it when most of it was found to be substandard and unusable, and then paid to burn it.

It's a similar story with the Nightingales, with Test and Trace, with the asylum system...

Papyrophile · 06/12/2023 21:58

And, face it, property prices are a factor. I have seen a house I like, in the Dorgogne, for 330,000 euros. Anything similar in the UK is about £700K. I can chat away in (bad) french about most things.

Papyrophile · 06/12/2023 21:48

Left to me, I'd be trying to choose between the Welsh marches and the Dordogne. My french is pretty good. Healthcare: France ticks the box -- Welsh healthcare is very threadbare, I am told by friends who live in Wales. So a tick for France. But being a 60 minute drive from my sister and ageing mum, both of whom I adore, needs taking into consideration too. I care a great deal about this choice and I want to get it right for the long term.

Papyrophile · 06/12/2023 21:36

I see both sets of compromises, and I don't like either. Frankly.

Papyrophile · 06/12/2023 21:32

Threads like this, about really important subjects, always end up in fights. I/We at 67 are in the process of deciding where we'd like to live in retirement (it definitely won't be where we live now, simply because we are so far from our widely distributed group of friends, who are mainly at least three hours away by road). We have a zone, but we also like the idea of living somewhere sunnier. In another language, albeit in a country where English is well taught as a second language. It's in Europe, but we can meet the income requirements, property costs less and we don't want anything huge or swanky. My sister thinks its a bad idea; DH loves the idea of something new and sunny.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 21:08

As the cliche has it - you are entitled to your own opinions but not to make up your own facts.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 21:07

The ONS has already stated that tax system in this country is reducing tax take
Demonstrably untrue.

Princessandthepea0 · 06/12/2023 21:05

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 21:02

Stop posting lies and bollocks and you won’t be challenged on them, there’s nothing wrong with my comprehension - you’re just upset you got called out on a simple falsehood.

If that’s what makes you feel better. Maybe if you were less angry on the internet you may feel life was fairer. You have a wonderful evening in that world of yours.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 21:02

Princessandthepea0 · 06/12/2023 21:00

Reading comprehension is appalling; answered the question in my my prior post though. Good old MN 🤣

Stop posting lies and bollocks and you won’t be challenged on them, there’s nothing wrong with my comprehension - you’re just upset you got called out on a simple falsehood.

Princessandthepea0 · 06/12/2023 21:00

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 20:53

Indeed I can use Google although I didn’t need that to know its bollocks to claim the tax take is falling. It’s pretty hilarious that working is supposed to be an excuse for telling lies about what the ONS says.

Reading comprehension is appalling; answered the question in my my prior post though. Good old MN 🤣

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 21:00

user1497207191 · 06/12/2023 10:35

Exactly, hence the "Sweetheart" deals that were struck under Labour in the noughties and the sweetheart deals with Olympic athletes for the London Olympics. All on the grounds that something is better than nothing and that the "bigger picture" was more important than following the laws when it came to tax. I.e. some top Olympic athletes were given tax exemptions so that they would avoid paying tax in the UK whilst they were here for the Olympics after they threatened to boycott the games!!

The tax exemption wasn’t some deal cooked up by Labour. It’s a standard IOC requirement and applies wherever the games are held.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 20:53

Princessandthepea0 · 06/12/2023 20:36

Of course it is. If that makes you feel better. Unfortunately I work so I don’t have time to be getting angry and demanding more taxpayers money all day on the internet. The statistics and reports are actually out there. I presume you can use Google?

Bollocks indeed.

Indeed I can use Google although I didn’t need that to know its bollocks to claim the tax take is falling. It’s pretty hilarious that working is supposed to be an excuse for telling lies about what the ONS says.

Princessandthepea0 · 06/12/2023 20:36

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 18:41

So tax take is increasing but you claim the ONS says it isn’t because reasons….OK then.

Then you just reassert the claim about dependency - that’s all fine if you just expect me to take your word for everything as some kind of random oracle, but I don’t.

I did think of posting that your claims were just bollocks but it wasn’t immediately clear, however it is now.

Of course it is. If that makes you feel better. Unfortunately I work so I don’t have time to be getting angry and demanding more taxpayers money all day on the internet. The statistics and reports are actually out there. I presume you can use Google?

Bollocks indeed.

NeelyOHara1 · 06/12/2023 18:42

A Land Tax might help.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 06/12/2023 18:41

So tax take is increasing but you claim the ONS says it isn’t because reasons….OK then.

Then you just reassert the claim about dependency - that’s all fine if you just expect me to take your word for everything as some kind of random oracle, but I don’t.

I did think of posting that your claims were just bollocks but it wasn’t immediately clear, however it is now.