Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the 'Net Contributors' argument is just wrong?

380 replies

Yetmorebeanstocount · 04/12/2023 22:22

Just been reading about "Net Contributors" of tax and how it supposedly is a bad thing that we don't have enough in this country.
i.e. - that most people receive more, in cash benefits, social care, NHS, police, education, roads, bin collections etc. etc. than they will ever pay for via their taxes, so they are 'net recipients' of the system rather than 'net contributors'.

My reaction is - well yes of course. That is how it should be!

Take a very-over-simplified example to illustrate the maths:

Say there are 100 people who earn £1k, and one person who earns £200k. Say the 100 pay no taxes, and the one person pays tax at 50% of £100k.

That tax gets re-distributed to the 100 people in the form of services and benefits and pensions, so that the 100 now have the equivalent of £2k each and the one person still has £100k.
What is supposed to be wrong with this? It is just basic re-distribution of income, which is something that every civilised society should do.

Of course in real life people earn all sorts of amounts and receive different things, so it is not so simple, but the principle is the same - a few at the top are 'net contributors' and the rest are 'net recipients'.

And of course, those at the top still get something back as they drive on roads and have their bins collected, and have the benefit of living in a civilised society which is policed and (mostly) does not have people dying on the streets.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
tttigress · 04/12/2023 22:30

Yeah, but with your example:

"100 people who earn £1k, and one person who earns £200k"

The £200k person must have a good skill set, what if they get totally peed off with the situation, and decide to take their skills and money to a lower tax location?

You probably wouldn't want to advocate for keeping them prisoner and I doubt many people would want the reintroduction of capital controls.

bombastix · 04/12/2023 22:29

I think you might be out of step with even the Labour Party on that one. We are taxing our workers hard and leaving assets alone. Restribution by tax probably only works if your ten percent too contributing class feel, and I use that word carefully, that they too get something out of the system. But the evidence is that these salaried people don't feel that way. And because of the tax system they are choosing to work less.

Both main parties know they need to do something about it, but it remains to be seen what. It has to be something like asset tax but no one will admit it, imo.

cakeorwine · 04/12/2023 22:28

Abolutely.

So people don't get paid much.
They provide essential services to society - which enable those people on higher wages, and often with other income sources, to get their lifestyle and maintain.

If people who were deemed by the rich as not being net contributors decided to stop working, then those who see themselves as net contributors would soon realise that society needs all people to function.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 04/12/2023 22:28

YANBU it is an over simplification that is used by people who agree with the Tory policies of taking from the poor and giving to the rich.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 04/12/2023 22:25

But you still need a decent number of people contributing more money? It needs to support ALL the infrastructure as well as providing benefits.

Not necessarily 1-1 though, you're correct there.

And companies should also be considered net contributors as well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread