Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the 'Net Contributors' argument is just wrong?

380 replies

Yetmorebeanstocount · 04/12/2023 22:22

Just been reading about "Net Contributors" of tax and how it supposedly is a bad thing that we don't have enough in this country.
i.e. - that most people receive more, in cash benefits, social care, NHS, police, education, roads, bin collections etc. etc. than they will ever pay for via their taxes, so they are 'net recipients' of the system rather than 'net contributors'.

My reaction is - well yes of course. That is how it should be!

Take a very-over-simplified example to illustrate the maths:

Say there are 100 people who earn £1k, and one person who earns £200k. Say the 100 pay no taxes, and the one person pays tax at 50% of £100k.

That tax gets re-distributed to the 100 people in the form of services and benefits and pensions, so that the 100 now have the equivalent of £2k each and the one person still has £100k.
What is supposed to be wrong with this? It is just basic re-distribution of income, which is something that every civilised society should do.

Of course in real life people earn all sorts of amounts and receive different things, so it is not so simple, but the principle is the same - a few at the top are 'net contributors' and the rest are 'net recipients'.

And of course, those at the top still get something back as they drive on roads and have their bins collected, and have the benefit of living in a civilised society which is policed and (mostly) does not have people dying on the streets.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Yetmorebeanstocount · 04/12/2023 23:33

mateysmum · 04/12/2023 22:58

Also the top 10% of tax payers pay 60% of all income tax. How much further you could push this is debatable.

But what is the % each person pays? Yes they will collectively pay 60% of all income tax, because they are earning more.

If each person is taxed under the same system of tax bands and rates, of course the top X% will pay more than Y% of all income tax. That's how the maths is supposed to work.

OP posts:
jesterdourt · 04/12/2023 23:33

“the average rate of tax paid by people who received one million pounds in taxable income and gains was just 35 per cent: the same as someone earning £100,000. But one in four of these paid 45 per cent – close to the top rate – whilst another quarter paid less than 30 per cent overall. One in ten paid just 11 per cent—the same as someone earning £15,000. The rich, it seems, are not all in it together.”

WillowCraft · 04/12/2023 23:31

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 04/12/2023 23:12

Denmark - population: 5.857 million
UK - population: 67.33 million

More people live in London than in Denmark.

What have the relative populations got to do with it?

mantyzer · 04/12/2023 23:31

The issue is lack of productivity. UK firms have not invested in technology and the government has done little to encourage this. We are lagging behind. It is why wages have fallen in real terms.

Yetmorebeanstocount · 04/12/2023 23:29

mateysmum · 04/12/2023 22:54

But if you tax dividends at the same rate as income, why would anybody invest in shares, and provide investment to business? Why take the risk?
Also a land tax is not easy to keep collecting because it is a pretty illiquid asset. If my house is a small run down cottage that happens to sit on an acre plot which has no value other than as garden, and I am a modest earner, where will the cash come from to pay a land tax?

But if you tax dividends at the same rate as income, why would anybody invest in shares, and provide investment to business? Why take the risk?

Because you would still likely get more than stashing it in a bank savings account.

There is an argument that if one small cottage is sitting on an acre, that is not good use of land, and is a luxury for which the occupant should pay. If they can't afford it, they can move out and several homes can be built on the land instead. Better to do that than develop housing on green fields.

OP posts:
baroqueandblue · 04/12/2023 23:28

roarrfeckingroar · 04/12/2023 23:18

Well no. It's shit. The tax burden shouldn't fall on a small proportion of people while most just take.

Deliberately completely misses the point of the thread Hmm

mateysmum · 04/12/2023 23:28

jesterdourt · 04/12/2023 23:25

The super wealthy will have more complex tax arrangements but you only need to earn 59k to be in the top 10%.

But the super wealthy aren’t on paye

My point is there are a lot of people on modest incomes paying a huge slice of the tax take. The numbers of truly super rich are relatively small and their wealth more mobile.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 04/12/2023 23:27

Of course there are many types of tax but income tax is a decent illustrative measure and one of the hardest to avoid.
It’s a piece of piss to avoid income tax if you have a stack of wealth.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 04/12/2023 23:25

jesterdourt · 04/12/2023 23:25

The super wealthy will have more complex tax arrangements but you only need to earn 59k to be in the top 10%.

But the super wealthy aren’t on paye

Exactly - in many cases their money isn’t even here (UK) they just live here.

jesterdourt · 04/12/2023 23:25

The super wealthy will have more complex tax arrangements but you only need to earn 59k to be in the top 10%.

But the super wealthy aren’t on paye

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 04/12/2023 23:25

mateysmum · 04/12/2023 23:17

If most of the real wealthy pay little income.tax how come the top 1% pay 34% of income tax?
Of course there are many types of tax but income tax is a decent illustrative measure and one of the hardest to avoid. The super wealthy will have more complex tax arrangements but you only need to earn 59k to be in the top 10%. People at this level would not consider themselves wealthy or have complex tax affairs.

You have answered your own question really - only wage slaves are unable to dodge income tax. If most of your wealth doesn’t come from working you don’t pay much income tax. Rishi pays about 20% overall, but he’ll be paying at the top rate on his PM salary.

Signal72 · 04/12/2023 23:24

Doesn’t matter what you earn in Warrington , your bins won’t be collected. Lazy bastards are sat on their arses all day being funded by the Union.

Yetmorebeanstocount · 04/12/2023 23:24

Q2C4 · 04/12/2023 22:54

@Yetmorebeanstocount I know full well what the original quote was. I put it deliberately the wrong way round, as others more eloquent than me have done, to make the point that if people do not (economically) contribute to society there is a risk that people may feel disenfranchised by it.

Are you really suggesting that if people don't pay taxes because of their low income then they somehow won't feel part of society?

A strange way to look at the relationship between people and their society.

OP posts:
jesterdourt · 04/12/2023 23:22

There are some very serious macro issues facing the UK, principally driven by the lack of growth over the last decade

yes & I think things are only going to get worse

mantyzer · 04/12/2023 23:20

@LaurieStrode if you had ever been unemployed as I have you would know you get pushed into any job already.

2weeks · 04/12/2023 23:20

Edinburgh during the bin strike. Dire! Gross 🤮 Really made me appreciate how fragile society is.

roarrfeckingroar · 04/12/2023 23:19

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 04/12/2023 22:28

YANBU it is an over simplification that is used by people who agree with the Tory policies of taking from the poor and giving to the rich.

Or just not vilifying the people who support most of the country

LaurieStrode · 04/12/2023 23:19

Q2C4 · 04/12/2023 23:01

... And their reward is a government pushing them to take the jobs left vacant by EU migrants with the threat of removal of benefits if they remain unemployed.

As it should be. Everyone who physically can work should be doing so, not turning up their noses at basic jobs. Or go hungry, I couldn't care less. But not be rewarded by picking the pockets of actual workers.

roarrfeckingroar · 04/12/2023 23:18

Well no. It's shit. The tax burden shouldn't fall on a small proportion of people while most just take.

jesterdourt · 04/12/2023 23:18

The issue is more the ageing population & the shrinking working one plus tax is weighted quite heavily on income eg paye then other vehicles or assets which is making it hard to build wealth not to mention yrs of stagnant wage growth.

mateysmum · 04/12/2023 23:17

If most of the real wealthy pay little income.tax how come the top 1% pay 34% of income tax?
Of course there are many types of tax but income tax is a decent illustrative measure and one of the hardest to avoid. The super wealthy will have more complex tax arrangements but you only need to earn 59k to be in the top 10%. People at this level would not consider themselves wealthy or have complex tax affairs.

cakeorwine · 04/12/2023 23:17

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 04/12/2023 23:09

Most of the really wealthy pay little or no income tax. There is such a lot more to taxation than income tax.

You mean 10% of income tax payers pay 60% of income tax.
Other taxes are available.

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 04/12/2023 23:12

Octavia64 · 04/12/2023 23:08

Personally I think we should be more Denmark.

Working welfare state, decent healthcare, and everyone is pretty happy to pay taxes because they get a decent service.

Denmark - population: 5.857 million
UK - population: 67.33 million

More people live in London than in Denmark.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 04/12/2023 23:09

mateysmum · 04/12/2023 22:58

Also the top 10% of tax payers pay 60% of all income tax. How much further you could push this is debatable.

Most of the really wealthy pay little or no income tax. There is such a lot more to taxation than income tax.

Swipe left for the next trending thread