Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think spending £400 on a 4 year old at Christmas is too much?

217 replies

user6776 · 04/12/2023 20:55

Not a bragging post before I begin and I appreciate we are lucky to have the money to spend.

We've already bought DS an iPad which cost £180. This was the "main" present and he will get his use out of it, as he's ASD and it helps to regulate him so I didn't mind forking out for that.

Anyway, I was thinking of then setting a remaining budget of £100 for some other bits that he can open - toys, clothes etc. DH was shocked and thought I was being "tight" and suggested we increase the budget to at least £200. He's of the opinion that whatever we see that we think DS might like, that we should buy it and not really have a budget. I told him that's ridiculous and there's no need to buy so much for such a small child!

AIBU to think this is too much?

OP posts:
Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:39

ginandtonicwithlimes · 06/12/2023 12:36

Being honest I think at least half of that won't be played with at all. Just words of experience.

3 Girls with 11 years of parenting experience and Christmases, im well versed thankyou.

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:38

00100001 · 06/12/2023 12:16

oh...so they do receive stuff throughout the year then....

LOOK AT WHAT I POSTED

There is no toys throughout the year only essential purchases like clothes etc, Birthdays we maybe spend around £60 on them so christmas we go all out because we want to

ginandtonicwithlimes · 06/12/2023 12:36

Littlecatonthefence · 05/12/2023 14:47

Well.

We have 3 DCs and it varies what we spend each year but at christmas we spoil with what we can affor and never get into debt, we save all year round.

There is no toys throughout the year only essential purchases like clothes etc, Birthdays we maybe spend around £60 on them so christmas we go all out because we want to.

But my 3.5 year old is currently sitting at £460 and thats with some FREE/Hand me down things.

Stuff is expensive, and this is her list for anyone thats interested, and no its not a brag its giving full context to my statement.

DISNEY MERMAID £26.99
MISSY KISSY DOLL £29.99
EASEL £29.99
MAGIC MIXES GENIE £45
MEGAPHONE £4.99
CUTIE CUTS £15
DOLLS PRAM £27.50
KITCHEN £79
DOGGITO £7
SQUIHMALLOW £35
KITCHEN £80
BIKE FREE
LITTLE LIVE MY PUPPY £35
Magic MIXES couldren £18.00
DOLLS HOUSE FREE
DOLLS HOUSE PEOPLE £11
BUCKAROO £16

Being honest I think at least half of that won't be played with at all. Just words of experience.

00100001 · 06/12/2023 12:16

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:14

So yes for their birthdays it will maybe be overall a cost of about £60-£100, could be some lip glosses, jammies, a gymnastics leo or somethings like that.

When we go on holiday there gran and papas will give them some money so they would use that to buy something

oh...so they do receive stuff throughout the year then....

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:14

00100001 · 06/12/2023 12:11

don't they get anything for their birthday?

or any gifts/trinkets/toys at all from holidays/days out/summer fetes/fairgrounds etc?

So yes for their birthdays it will maybe be overall a cost of about £60-£100, could be some lip glosses, jammies, a gymnastics leo or somethings like that.

When we go on holiday there gran and papas will give them some money so they would use that to buy something

00100001 · 06/12/2023 12:14

Blankscreen · 06/12/2023 11:49

We obviously don't have to buy all 3 golf things but it is his hobby and they will be used loads.

I also don't think a £15-£25 hoodie or a pair of Vans are Christmas presents. Surely they are just basic clothing items that they need?

Anyway each to their own, we all have different budgets and different ideas as to what is appropriate and our children don't know any different.

Loads of people give clothes as presents? Some people even give pyjamas.

Plus things like nice/branded items like a pair of Vans would be an acceptable gift too? Sure, not school shoes or whatever.... but a nicer/coveted pair of football boots / hoodrich hoodie ? That's absolutely fine as a gift.

00100001 · 06/12/2023 12:11

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 11:59

Mainly because i want to but also they dont need it, xmas toys covers them throughout the year apart from books we get them books and clothes throughout the year.

don't they get anything for their birthday?

or any gifts/trinkets/toys at all from holidays/days out/summer fetes/fairgrounds etc?

SJM1988 · 06/12/2023 12:05

We do the 5 present rule thing for Christmas - something you need, something you want, something to read, something to wear and something extra special. It helps to highlight not just getting presents for the sake of it and that would go to waste.

Some years we spend alot but others we spend not so much. Sometimes it comes down to what they 'need/want' that year. This year we are replacing my eldest's kindle for a newer version so that is £180 but last year he got a skateboard for under £20. My youngest tends to end up with re-gifted items. This year her main present is a new doll but I am giving her all the dolls clothes I had as a child.

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:01

Livinginanotherworld · 06/12/2023 00:15

A three year old doesn’t need that many toys in one go, it’s very overwhelming for them. The less toys they have the more play value they get out of them if they are chosen carefully.

Maybe pop a couple of those in the salvation army collection for kids with no toys.
and sorry IPads for that age group is just ridiculous and very harmful to developing brains.

You literally have just assumed we dont do any charity Christmas collections.

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 11:59

00100001 · 05/12/2023 23:14

Why do you not give them anything during the year? I don't really understand the need to keep it all until Christmas and then go overboard?

Mainly because i want to but also they dont need it, xmas toys covers them throughout the year apart from books we get them books and clothes throughout the year.

Blankscreen · 06/12/2023 11:49

We obviously don't have to buy all 3 golf things but it is his hobby and they will be used loads.

I also don't think a £15-£25 hoodie or a pair of Vans are Christmas presents. Surely they are just basic clothing items that they need?

Anyway each to their own, we all have different budgets and different ideas as to what is appropriate and our children don't know any different.

00100001 · 06/12/2023 11:24

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 11:06

But what’s the point of spending a load of money on stuff they don’t really want or need? I’d rather spend more but have it be stuff that will last and be used loads.

Again.... the lists were just examples in response to "what does £150 even get you these days?" as if you couldn't get a good amount of decent presents for that much - when you can.

And also - the golf thing, again, I was just saying there's nothing mandating that the PP absolutely had to buy all three things...

00100001 · 06/12/2023 11:23

Sugarfree23 · 06/12/2023 11:06

Why buy a bundle of other stuff which may become cupboard clutter if what the kid really wants a new golf bag?

this was in response to "what does £150 even get you these days?" as if you couldn't get a good amount of decent presents for that much - when you can

And also - the golf thing, again, I was just saying there's nothing mandating that the PP absolutely had to buy all three things...

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 11:06

00100001 · 06/12/2023 10:27

Bit there's nothing compelling you to buy him the new golf bag, club and the other golf thing is there?

You could have just bought one of those....

For ~£150 for a 13yo you could buy them;

Mini drone £40
Wireless headphones £30-40
Card game like exploding kittens £10-15
Air hammock £10
Chocolate £5
Multi tool/ swiss army knife/ swiss army card £10
Hoodie £15-25
Rubik's cube or similar £10

Or ...

Computer game £50
Power bank £30
Vans £50
Various sweets and treats £20

All perfectly acceptable gifts for a 13yo lad, and plenty to show for it 🤷‍♀️

But what’s the point of spending a load of money on stuff they don’t really want or need? I’d rather spend more but have it be stuff that will last and be used loads.

Sugarfree23 · 06/12/2023 11:06

00100001 · 06/12/2023 10:27

Bit there's nothing compelling you to buy him the new golf bag, club and the other golf thing is there?

You could have just bought one of those....

For ~£150 for a 13yo you could buy them;

Mini drone £40
Wireless headphones £30-40
Card game like exploding kittens £10-15
Air hammock £10
Chocolate £5
Multi tool/ swiss army knife/ swiss army card £10
Hoodie £15-25
Rubik's cube or similar £10

Or ...

Computer game £50
Power bank £30
Vans £50
Various sweets and treats £20

All perfectly acceptable gifts for a 13yo lad, and plenty to show for it 🤷‍♀️

Why buy a bundle of other stuff which may become cupboard clutter if what the kid really wants a new golf bag?

TheGoogleMum · 06/12/2023 10:30

Your budget of 280 (since the ipad was 180) is more than I would spend on a 4 yr old

00100001 · 06/12/2023 10:27

Blankscreen · 06/12/2023 09:47

I'm surprised at how little some people spend.

When children are little is is easier to spend less but as they grow up the things they want become more and more expensive so it is hard to stick to a lower amount.

For example DS is 13 and has asked for anew golf bag - £170, a new golf club £60 and some other golf thing which is £70. So that's £300 on just 3 presents.

Then he needs stocking presents and other bits.

I reckon it will be £450.

With inflation the cost of presents has massively gone up. If you spend £150 what can you actually buy them?

Bit there's nothing compelling you to buy him the new golf bag, club and the other golf thing is there?

You could have just bought one of those....

For ~£150 for a 13yo you could buy them;

Mini drone £40
Wireless headphones £30-40
Card game like exploding kittens £10-15
Air hammock £10
Chocolate £5
Multi tool/ swiss army knife/ swiss army card £10
Hoodie £15-25
Rubik's cube or similar £10

Or ...

Computer game £50
Power bank £30
Vans £50
Various sweets and treats £20

All perfectly acceptable gifts for a 13yo lad, and plenty to show for it 🤷‍♀️

Blankscreen · 06/12/2023 09:47

I'm surprised at how little some people spend.

When children are little is is easier to spend less but as they grow up the things they want become more and more expensive so it is hard to stick to a lower amount.

For example DS is 13 and has asked for anew golf bag - £170, a new golf club £60 and some other golf thing which is £70. So that's £300 on just 3 presents.

Then he needs stocking presents and other bits.

I reckon it will be £450.

With inflation the cost of presents has massively gone up. If you spend £150 what can you actually buy them?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/12/2023 09:24

I’d have thought that even half that would be plenty. And if you’ve got the other £200 to spare, put it in a savings a/c for him, or a junior S&S ISA.

At that age they can often be just as pleased with something that cost a fiver, as with ditto for £50.

Sugarfree23 · 06/12/2023 08:59

user6776 · 06/12/2023 08:05

@DoorPath Nope, I'm under 30 so wasn't that long ago

I often think budgets are impossible to compare. Some families big ticket items like consoles will be the only gift. Some it will be split between two or more children. Some big ticket items are birthday gifts rather than Christmas. I've even come across Grandparents doing the big ticket stuff and parents doing smaller things.

Some families include clothes and sports lessons as Christmas gifts to others they are monthly spends.

People have different income levels, family sizes and budget sizes.
But budgets are impossible to compare.

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 08:37

Arthursmom · 06/12/2023 03:49

Feels excessive but depends on the child I suppose. And when their birthday is/what you are planning to do on the day. The cost of the iPad skews things and I’d say that’s worth considering as it seems that it is a toy as much as a learning tool?

DS is 3 and has a birthday near Xmas. He is well loved (spoiled) by us and family alike. He is the ‘bonus baby’ that no one thought was coming 😂 It was a lot on his birthday so I kept things back and will us at Christmas or when he’s off nursery ill etc. I thinks it’s fine to do that to stop them getting overwhelmed-the Xmas holidays are long!! I also have asked specifically for things he needs and wants so he is getting lots but from different places / people etc but in a more controlled and planned way that also includes pyjamas and socks and pants alongside very specific toys and no tat. I hate the random extra bits that end up broken or in the bin so ask for what he actually wants and will play with-no extras so no extra expense. I’d rather the money was spent on 1 amazing toy that will last than many random daft things that break and can’t be passed on.

I may be in the minority but I do enjoy spoiling DS and also enjoy playing with him and his new toys. What I would say is that he genuinely plays with and cares for all his toys so perhaps what’s needed is more intentional choosing ? I have this conversation a lot with my mum friends who’s children always want to come over and never want to leave. They feel my DS lives in a toy palace and they couldn’t spoil their child like that. My response is that I have chosen and designed his room and playroom. He is never bored and looks after each and every toy. He loves playing at home! 💯 worth the money if they are used, liked and propagate fun and appropriate play. Don’t regret a single penny.

I suppose what I’m saying is, it’s fine to spoil them but there’s different ways to do it-check what he’s getting elsewhere first, spread out the toy giving, don’t buy ‘fillers’, focus on what he’ll love. I find this cheaper in the long run and the toys give me peace over the holidays.

I’m with you- I put a lot of energy into choosing the right things- I never buy stuff just because it’s cheap or on offer.

At the moment my son is obsessed with rubix cubes- if he goes into hyper focus he can easily spend 4 hours doing nothing else (especially since he is home educated), so people might not think he needs the 10 different ones he has for Christmas, but they won’t be played with for 5 minutes and forgotten, he will play with them for hours, for days at a time. They will then go away and be revisited in a few weeks when his focus goes back to puzzles and logic games.

He has a lot of presents, but they are all chosen based on what is going to help his development as well as be fun. Pokemon cards for example (outrageously expensive) but he will a) be overjoyed and b) use them to actually socialise with other children at Pokemon club.

Mummyofanonly · 06/12/2023 08:27

Has DS actually asked for anything else?

user6776 · 06/12/2023 08:26

gotomomo · 06/12/2023 08:10

I'm with you though I also wouldn't buy an iPad either, 4 year olds with autism don't need them to regulate!!! My dd was diagnosed at 3 before they had been invented, she was screen obsessed, the last thing she needed was her own screen

Surely you should realise not every autistic child is the same. What works for one, doesn't work for another so please don't judge.

OP posts:
Mummyofanonly · 06/12/2023 08:26

I think we’ve all agreed that every child/ family/ financial situation is different. OP, if I were you, if DS hasn’t asked for anything else then I would take your husband to Smyths and ask him what he thinks DS would like. If you can have a quick conversation about whether he will or not in Smyths then get what you both agree on and be done with it. The iPad by your own admission is something that helps him and if he ‘needed’ it in April would you wait til Christmas? I can’t remember whether you’ve said he gets overwhelmed but if so then just split them up over a few days, we’ve had to do that before, it’s fine! Rotate toys if you need to, have a declutter and sell if you want to recoup some money. Only you and your husband know what kind of Christmas DS would like.

999caffeineplease · 06/12/2023 08:24

I agree with @DoorPath, if your parents spent £200 on you 20 years ago (give or take), that would be more like £350 in today’s money due to inflation, which is closer to what your husband is suggesting. That’ll be why you remember feeling like it was plenty.