Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think spending £400 on a 4 year old at Christmas is too much?

217 replies

user6776 · 04/12/2023 20:55

Not a bragging post before I begin and I appreciate we are lucky to have the money to spend.

We've already bought DS an iPad which cost £180. This was the "main" present and he will get his use out of it, as he's ASD and it helps to regulate him so I didn't mind forking out for that.

Anyway, I was thinking of then setting a remaining budget of £100 for some other bits that he can open - toys, clothes etc. DH was shocked and thought I was being "tight" and suggested we increase the budget to at least £200. He's of the opinion that whatever we see that we think DS might like, that we should buy it and not really have a budget. I told him that's ridiculous and there's no need to buy so much for such a small child!

AIBU to think this is too much?

OP posts:
Luxell934 · 06/12/2023 18:32

If money isn’t an issue for you I’d just consider buying 2/3 presents for him to open, whether they cost £100 each or £30
each just buy stuff you know he will like/use. He doesn’t need 20 things to open, it’s too overwhelming and he won’t truly appreciate it. I assume he will he given presents by family too?

00100001 · 06/12/2023 18:31

I agree.

But I disagree with the PP who implied you can't get anything for £150... That's all...

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 18:16

00100001 · 06/12/2023 18:14

She could have bought one of the golf things... probably 2 for the £150...?

Again so what if a 8yo wants a PS5? Doesn't mean you have to buy it... They can have plenty of other decent gifts.

Also plenty of kids don't demand high priced items.

Since when was a Christmas list a list of demands instead of an ideas list?

Soed what you like, makes no difference to me. But £150 buys a child plenty.

🤦‍♀️

If they want it, and you can afford it, it’s fine to buy it. Other people couldn’t or wouldn’t, that’s fine too… you don’t have moral superiority because you spend less. It’s literally a matter of personal taste!

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 18:14

Ragwort · 06/12/2023 17:52

Parents who spend large amounts on presents ... do you also put money into your DC's savings accounts? A young relative of mine used to get the 'whole room full of presents' ... literally a sea of plastic tat toys, Barbie house, toy prams, dolls, dressing up clothes etc etc ... you could not move in the room. However her DPs put no money aside 'for the future'. They seemed obsessed with the 'magic' of the experience. We gave our DS nice - but modest - gifts, he is into sport so using the example of the teenager who was interested in golf we would give one item eg: a golf bag. We put money aside for our DS and also encouraged him to save financial gifts he was given.
Both DC reached their late teens ... my DS had enough to pay half the cost of his first car, 'extras' at Uni, decent travel, lap top etc etc ... the other DC has nothing ..
yes, the memory of all the toys but nothing to help to them into adult life ...

We all make choices about how we spend our money but £400 on a four year old seems completely OTT (in my opinion).

Yes we put money into savings specifically for him every month and he also saves from his pocket money each week. His grandparents also save for him.

We also give to charity each month, donate food to the food bank, buy the big issue and donate toys at Christmas.

We aren’t devoid of good sense or a sense of duty to the community or environment (we don’t buy a lot of plastic stuff that gets chucked out, money goes on good quality things that will last and be valued)- we just enjoy ‘spoiling’ our son.

00100001 · 06/12/2023 18:14

She could have bought one of the golf things... probably 2 for the £150...?

Again so what if a 8yo wants a PS5? Doesn't mean you have to buy it... They can have plenty of other decent gifts.

Also plenty of kids don't demand high priced items.

Since when was a Christmas list a list of demands instead of an ideas list?

Soed what you like, makes no difference to me. But £150 buys a child plenty.

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 18:04

00100001 · 06/12/2023 17:42

I mean that no-one is compelled to spend £400+ on stuff just because the kid wants it. Whether it's one thing or 3. Child might want a new iPad... doesn't mean he's getting it.
I was just showing how there's plenty of other things that can be bought for £150 that he might like as well.

If people want to spend £400+ its nothing to do with me, no skin off my nose. but to imply that you can't get kids anything for £150 just isn't true and leans into the idea that Christmas must be expensive because "everyone spends £400" and "what can you even get for £150?" It just puts pressure on this people who can't find huge sums of money and perhaps makes them feel guilty for not being able to.. or worse getting in to debt so their kids have a massive pile of presents/latest tech etc because "that's what everyone else is getting".

Edited

If the child wants it, and the parents can afford it, why shouldn’t they buy it? Yes, I could have bought a kindle for my son instead of a top of the range iPad, but he didn’t want a kindle and couldn’t use it for a whole load of stuff that he can use the iPad for.

I don’t see the need to say no for the sake of it.

Yes, obviously you can buy things for £150. You could buy 1500 penny sweets for example. But you couldn’t buy the golf things the previous poster was talking about, or a ps5 or millions of other things that children ask for- that’s what they mean, they presume you realise that they are talking within the context of high street prices and children’s wish lists.

Comedycook · 06/12/2023 18:02

somewhereovertherain · 06/12/2023 17:54

Never spent more than £100 on our kids - it's one bloody day - it just gets madder and madder every year.

Agree....I consider us reasonably well off and I've never spent hundreds and hundreds. One year my ds asked for an Xbox ..we got it for him but apart from his stocking gifts from Santa, the Xbox was his only gift from us. I explained it was an expensive present so that would be it. He was perfectly happy. I'm amazed when I hear of kids getting iPads and bikes and phones...my kids would only get one big present.

somewhereovertherain · 06/12/2023 17:54

Never spent more than £100 on our kids - it's one bloody day - it just gets madder and madder every year.

Ragwort · 06/12/2023 17:52

Parents who spend large amounts on presents ... do you also put money into your DC's savings accounts? A young relative of mine used to get the 'whole room full of presents' ... literally a sea of plastic tat toys, Barbie house, toy prams, dolls, dressing up clothes etc etc ... you could not move in the room. However her DPs put no money aside 'for the future'. They seemed obsessed with the 'magic' of the experience. We gave our DS nice - but modest - gifts, he is into sport so using the example of the teenager who was interested in golf we would give one item eg: a golf bag. We put money aside for our DS and also encouraged him to save financial gifts he was given.
Both DC reached their late teens ... my DS had enough to pay half the cost of his first car, 'extras' at Uni, decent travel, lap top etc etc ... the other DC has nothing ..
yes, the memory of all the toys but nothing to help to them into adult life ...

We all make choices about how we spend our money but £400 on a four year old seems completely OTT (in my opinion).

00100001 · 06/12/2023 17:46

This reply has been deleted

This is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

But surely they won't "love" every item that's piled under the tree? You're just buying them stuff you think they'll like and that's fine... but let's not pretend all those gifts will be treasured items to them, and not just another toy in the pile of consumerism under your tree.

00100001 · 06/12/2023 17:42

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 17:18

obviously you mean those lists as an example, but I still don’t see the sense in knowing what your children want and will use, and buying something else just because it’s cheaper.

Obviously you have to work to the budget you have, but if the kid asks for 3 sensible things for his hobby, and you can afford them and know he will use and value them I don’t see the sense in buying 6 other things instead because it’s a bit cheaper.

I mean that no-one is compelled to spend £400+ on stuff just because the kid wants it. Whether it's one thing or 3. Child might want a new iPad... doesn't mean he's getting it.
I was just showing how there's plenty of other things that can be bought for £150 that he might like as well.

If people want to spend £400+ its nothing to do with me, no skin off my nose. but to imply that you can't get kids anything for £150 just isn't true and leans into the idea that Christmas must be expensive because "everyone spends £400" and "what can you even get for £150?" It just puts pressure on this people who can't find huge sums of money and perhaps makes them feel guilty for not being able to.. or worse getting in to debt so their kids have a massive pile of presents/latest tech etc because "that's what everyone else is getting".

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 17:27

ginandtonicwithlimes · 06/12/2023 12:47

Don't have you have hand me downs? My son will get the Duplo my daughter was given. He has the dolls she was given and plays with a pram that I bought for her. Each to their own but at three she won't be bothered yet. Is there big age gaps?

Surely hand me down toys are just there in the house? Not hidden to be wrapped up and re gifted to younger kids… who would be like “oh there’s older sisters doll that I’ve played with a load of times before, why is it wrapped up like a present?”.

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 17:18

00100001 · 06/12/2023 11:24

Again.... the lists were just examples in response to "what does £150 even get you these days?" as if you couldn't get a good amount of decent presents for that much - when you can.

And also - the golf thing, again, I was just saying there's nothing mandating that the PP absolutely had to buy all three things...

obviously you mean those lists as an example, but I still don’t see the sense in knowing what your children want and will use, and buying something else just because it’s cheaper.

Obviously you have to work to the budget you have, but if the kid asks for 3 sensible things for his hobby, and you can afford them and know he will use and value them I don’t see the sense in buying 6 other things instead because it’s a bit cheaper.

PastelHouses · 06/12/2023 14:10

This reply has been deleted

This is a goady troll so we've removed their posts.

toddlermam · 06/12/2023 14:05

I've probably spent around that on my 3 year old tbh. I don't think it's excessive

ginandtonicwithlimes · 06/12/2023 13:09

Derdiedasdie · 06/12/2023 12:58

Jeez how depressing. I’m one of 5 from a not wealthy family and we never got hand me down gifts from older siblings. We always got something new for Christmas that was our own.

You have just presumed I never buy anything new for my youngest. I am one of seven and at times my mum starved herself to give us food. I imagine I wouldn't have noticed if a present wasn't new at the age of the child we are talking about. I would have been grateful. My one year old is getting some new things but if everything I got for him was second hand or hand me downs I don't see that as any issue? Good for the environment and my bank account. They don't care.

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 13:09

00100001 · 06/12/2023 13:03

Ok calm down. It's just seemed unlikely they don't receive a single toy, big or small throughout the year. Because people who know kids (aunts uncles, parents of friends etc) usually buy children toys for birthdays or special occasions or whatever.

So,.if you meant "we don't buy them toys" then fine... It wasn't clear.

We dont buy toys.

Grans and papas, aunts and uncles defo buy at birthdays. The older girls dont have toys anymore.

We dont do Easter toys or any other "events" in the year that would warrant presents

We defo go to sofplay/trampoline parks days out.

But physical toys or Christmas stuff type buys are purely at xmas

I think it was the way i was brought up, mum and dad were the same, large pile of presents at christmas and just the essentials/what was needed throughout the year.

00100001 · 06/12/2023 13:03

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:38

LOOK AT WHAT I POSTED

There is no toys throughout the year only essential purchases like clothes etc, Birthdays we maybe spend around £60 on them so christmas we go all out because we want to

Ok calm down. It's just seemed unlikely they don't receive a single toy, big or small throughout the year. Because people who know kids (aunts uncles, parents of friends etc) usually buy children toys for birthdays or special occasions or whatever.

So,.if you meant "we don't buy them toys" then fine... It wasn't clear.

Derdiedasdie · 06/12/2023 12:58

ginandtonicwithlimes · 06/12/2023 12:47

Don't have you have hand me downs? My son will get the Duplo my daughter was given. He has the dolls she was given and plays with a pram that I bought for her. Each to their own but at three she won't be bothered yet. Is there big age gaps?

Jeez how depressing. I’m one of 5 from a not wealthy family and we never got hand me down gifts from older siblings. We always got something new for Christmas that was our own.

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:56

Pipistrellus · 06/12/2023 12:45

Is all the stuff from last Christmas too young and passed on/sold now? Does she not get plenty of hand me downs from the two older girls? Just struggling to understand if this is normal for Christmas x3 children what happens to it all?

Oldest is 11, middle is 9 so quite a big difference now in age. Ive kept load of clothes to be fair. The dolls house is a hand me down as is the bike.

My next door neighbors daughter is 7 so she gets alot of things as she is closer in age.

Ive kept all the barbie stuff from my middle child packed away for my youngest Christmas so absolutely most big things have been kept but alot of "smaller/cheaper" items were given to my neighbor or charity.

She was a surprise (but over the moon) 3rd baby 😊

ChristmasSugarplumFairy · 06/12/2023 12:53

It's the volume of gifts rather than the volume of pounds that's the main decider on whether it is "too much" IMHO.
I could spend that quite easily on my 4 year old and it only be a few gifts because I like to choose gifts with a bit of a longer life span and the family will pick up things related to the latest obsession.
DS hasn't the foggiest whether I spent £20 or £2000 - he's 4. He's just happy playing with his new toys.
I don't like massive "piles" as they are stressful to deal with and it's no fun when kids don't have space to actually play.

Jellybean85 · 06/12/2023 12:52

@Pipistrellus does t have to be normal at all if you're considering three. We have three and that list seems excessive tk me! Lots of wasted and plastic it seems if they all get loads like that! And yes ours passed toys down. One boy two girls.

elrider · 06/12/2023 12:51

That's a huge amount to me, and I've never spent that much on either child. If I was giving a big thing like an iPad, then I'd give it with a stocking and that would be it, on the basis that (like yours) they get other toys and things from family anyway so it's not like they are sitting in an empty house devoid of all toys. They just get overwhelmed with lots to open and most of it gets played with a few times then never again - I hate the waste so I try to very carefully pick things that will last and be loved, and environmentally, I look to buy second hand where possible. Spending on all sorts of toys they "might like" (and that also other people might have got them) is just a waste and will quickly clutter up your house and cause overwhelm for both the adults and children. Less is more, just chosen very carefully!

ginandtonicwithlimes · 06/12/2023 12:47

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:39

3 Girls with 11 years of parenting experience and Christmases, im well versed thankyou.

Don't have you have hand me downs? My son will get the Duplo my daughter was given. He has the dolls she was given and plays with a pram that I bought for her. Each to their own but at three she won't be bothered yet. Is there big age gaps?

Pipistrellus · 06/12/2023 12:45

Littlecatonthefence · 06/12/2023 12:39

3 Girls with 11 years of parenting experience and Christmases, im well versed thankyou.

Is all the stuff from last Christmas too young and passed on/sold now? Does she not get plenty of hand me downs from the two older girls? Just struggling to understand if this is normal for Christmas x3 children what happens to it all?