Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe that some children in the classroom are acting as if they are three or four years younger than their actual age.

137 replies

Coldcaller · 04/12/2023 19:56

DD 2 is a science teacher in ordinary Comprehensive school where grade 5 in English and Math's hovers around 40% and about 25% of pupils are in receipt of FSM. Therefore, in all probability it is a very average Secondary School. DD 2 is very reticent about continuing to teach at the school or possibly to give up teaching totally. This is down to the behavior of many of the children and DD was continually given the bottom sets to teach in year 7, 8 and 9. because she appeared to the SLT to be the teacher who could mostly engage with them. The behavior never mind any interest in the subject from many of the kids is horrific, swearing fighting refusal to sit down and general anarchy being regular. Despite the appearance DD was getting depressed teaching these groups and was using all her efforts on classroom management and not teaching. A lack of interest in handling the difficult and disengaged kids is shown by members of the SLT. This, means classroom teachers are asked to continue teaching even if swearing is heard as long if it is not aimed at the teacher. There is no point sending a child out, for swearing because SLT will just re admit the child to the class . Isolation is the last resort and would probably require a physical assault to have taken place for it to be in-acted.

DD went to the head of Science and the Headteacher 4 weeks ago saying that she was not enjoying teaching and was thinking of quitting teaching. The truth was she had an interview for a Chemistry teacher for a Co-ed Independent, where the benchmark for GCSE grades are 8 and 9's . Despite having the interview, the head of Science talked her round, convincing her that she would be putting the department in a huge hole if she left. Because DD 2 is nice but naive, she agreed to stay at least until the end of July 2024. This, was on the proviso she would be teaching the top sets in years 9, 10 and 11. The behavior of her current year 10 top set Double Science is currently causing her concern for their immaturity . The kids don't swear or fight but act like 11 year old's. 15 year old girls putting their hands up and telling silly tales, boys laughing at very immature behavior reminiscent of year 6 boys. These kids are expected to get between grades 5 -8 in Double Science in June 2025 and DD says her top pupil is currently in line for a 4 if lucky ! DD is expected to plug the gaps left by the ex teacher in year 10 and these kids are the schools 'Cream'..

OP posts:
Rocksonabeach · 05/12/2023 04:30

justasmalltownmum · 04/12/2023 22:01

If she wants to leave the school, she should leave. She doesn't owe them anything to stay until end of the academic year.

She won’t be leaving a hole they will fill it in. Go to an indie school pick wisely ask about pension, Saturdays etc

did over 20 years in state - 20 years too long!

Devilsmommy · 05/12/2023 04:24

AutismProf · 04/12/2023 23:16

My opinions, for what they are worth:

The rise of smartphones mean parents (especially mums, sorry to say, as they tend to be main carer on mat leave) are not co-regulating with their infants as much or as well. They are looking over baby's shoulder at their phone while feeding, instead of into their eyes. This has a huge impact on emotional regulation and language development. And so it goes on, with parental attention repeatedly drawn away from parent/child interaction, send then very young children given screens to keep them quiet and compounding that loss of interaction.

COVID exacerbated this because young children were sharing space with parents trying to work and having to dismiss their very young children's bids for attention and interaction repeatedly. There was also a loss of opportunities for social growth in baby and toddler groups, nurseries, playdates etc. So vulnerabilities were exacerbated.

With older kids, the impact was more on missing underpinning curricular skills (more than knowledge content) eg missing reception and year 1 has had a big impact on current year 4 and 5 who missed the chance to really consolidate early skill acquisition in literacy and numeracy. Many have caught up of course, but again, pre-existing vulnerabilities are exaggerated. Older kids missed early independence skills - my most impacted kid was about to do GCSEs when COVID struck, his year struggled with A levels exams as hadn't been through the GCSE system, and also limited independence in things like nights out with mates, first trips off camping with friends, etc. he started uni a long way behind, maturity wise, but has made massive progress.

This has all been compounded by a newly challenging "Gove" curriculum which only started a couple of years pre pandemic and which places huge expectations on very young children. With COVID impact many simply haven't been able to reach the incredibly challenging expectations on them academically, and the government has gone very little to help. They certainly haven't stressed play, socialisation, and independence skills which are the fundamental prerequisites really - a little support was offered for knowledge catch up but that was a misunderstanding of the most vital stuff kids missed in lockdown. This means that teachers are trying to get kids to do things that a higher proportion than before COVID are simply not able to attain. These kids by the time they are in year 8 or 9 know they aren't going to pass GCSEs in these subjects, there's no alternative curriculum or qualifications offered in most schools, is it any wonder they don't see the point? And start mucking about, swearing etc? They are exposed to their own inability to meet expectations every day. I think I would get ground down in that situation, too.

Edited

This is excellent articulated

Pacificisolated · 05/12/2023 03:55

I went to a fairly average school in the UK and was in all top sets about 20 years ago. The surrounding catchment area was low income but not horrendous. There was a mix of families in council housing and privately owned and rented homes. Even in top sets there was a lot of disruption, constant chattering, not listening to the teacher and disrespectful behaviour. It got a bit better at GCSE level when we selected our own subjects.
My own sister teaches early primary in a fairly deprived area. Lots of low income and unemployed families, lots of domestic violence and kids with child safety intervention. Her pupils are 5 and yet they scream and swear at each other and the teachers mimicking what they can only have heard at home. There are so many emotionally dysregulated and traumatised kids in her class which makes behaviour management difficult. I can only imagine these are the kids who by secondary school will be punching each other in the bottom sets.
Sadly there is a huge amount of disadvantage and poor behaviour at school is the result.

aliceinanwonderland · 05/12/2023 00:01

IveOnlyEverHeardOutwithONHere · 04/12/2023 22:51

Yes, I think lockdowns have had an effect, but I think we’re getting to the point now where we can’t have that as an excuse anymore. There has been a good 2.5 years now of normality to catch up. I’m sorry but Covid can’t be blamed for the ridiculous number of kids starting reception still in nappies, without language etc. There’s no doubt that interventions such as speech therapy were severely disrupted, but the massive rise in children who need them isn’t just because of lockdowns, and the sooner we stop making excuses and look the issues in the face the better.

But on another thread there will be conversations that one shouldn’t potty train until the child is “ready” even if this is aged 3.5 etc. We were shamed in Spain when we went with my “just” two year old. All other children her age were not in nappies. She was hot and uncomfortable in hers. When home I just “did it “. It took a few days and she was clean and dry even at night. And she was so proud of herself for being a “big girl “. Sometimes we don’t go children justice in keeping them back.

Naptrappedmummy · 04/12/2023 23:29

I’m absolutely mystified by the rise of non verbal children. I can see how a speech delay would be expected because of lockdowns causing a deficit in social interaction, or parents chatting less to their kids due to screens, but to have no language at all?? There have always been neglected children, whose parents would dump them in the high chair and switch TV on, yet I never met a single child growing up who couldn’t speak unless there was a clear reason (ie profound cerebral palsy). It feels like nobody wants to acknowledge there has been a rise in this sort of thing and instead it’s better diagnosis, but these issues are so evident they could never have flown under the radar even 40 years ago. What’s going on?

Woofie7 · 04/12/2023 23:26

Tell her to move schools before she gives up. She sounds a wonderful person.
ignore the school’s comments about leaving them in a hole , they won’t be there for her if she has her life ruined by stress etc.
please tell her to give the other job a go .
from an ex teacher who was In this exact position.
if it doesn’t work out then she can look into something else.

All2Well · 04/12/2023 23:22

I'm another teacher who personally hated school (and have combined type ADHD!) so must be an outlier @MrsTerryPratchett

TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/12/2023 23:19

Teaching is not for everyone - I know for sure I couldn't teach at secondary level, just from my own memories of watching my bored teenage peers playing up our less effective teachers. I know it is harder for schools to exclude pupils now, and I suspect that is not helping at all.

AutismProf · 04/12/2023 23:16

My opinions, for what they are worth:

The rise of smartphones mean parents (especially mums, sorry to say, as they tend to be main carer on mat leave) are not co-regulating with their infants as much or as well. They are looking over baby's shoulder at their phone while feeding, instead of into their eyes. This has a huge impact on emotional regulation and language development. And so it goes on, with parental attention repeatedly drawn away from parent/child interaction, send then very young children given screens to keep them quiet and compounding that loss of interaction.

COVID exacerbated this because young children were sharing space with parents trying to work and having to dismiss their very young children's bids for attention and interaction repeatedly. There was also a loss of opportunities for social growth in baby and toddler groups, nurseries, playdates etc. So vulnerabilities were exacerbated.

With older kids, the impact was more on missing underpinning curricular skills (more than knowledge content) eg missing reception and year 1 has had a big impact on current year 4 and 5 who missed the chance to really consolidate early skill acquisition in literacy and numeracy. Many have caught up of course, but again, pre-existing vulnerabilities are exaggerated. Older kids missed early independence skills - my most impacted kid was about to do GCSEs when COVID struck, his year struggled with A levels exams as hadn't been through the GCSE system, and also limited independence in things like nights out with mates, first trips off camping with friends, etc. he started uni a long way behind, maturity wise, but has made massive progress.

This has all been compounded by a newly challenging "Gove" curriculum which only started a couple of years pre pandemic and which places huge expectations on very young children. With COVID impact many simply haven't been able to reach the incredibly challenging expectations on them academically, and the government has gone very little to help. They certainly haven't stressed play, socialisation, and independence skills which are the fundamental prerequisites really - a little support was offered for knowledge catch up but that was a misunderstanding of the most vital stuff kids missed in lockdown. This means that teachers are trying to get kids to do things that a higher proportion than before COVID are simply not able to attain. These kids by the time they are in year 8 or 9 know they aren't going to pass GCSEs in these subjects, there's no alternative curriculum or qualifications offered in most schools, is it any wonder they don't see the point? And start mucking about, swearing etc? They are exposed to their own inability to meet expectations every day. I think I would get ground down in that situation, too.

Octavia64 · 04/12/2023 23:13

@MrsTerryPratchett
That's really interesting.

At my school a few years ago we were creating a new vision statement in groups. (Vom).

As a group, we talked about why we had become teachers.

It was about an even split between those who had loved school and those who had hated it.

It was a fascinating conversation.

(I hated it.)

wildflowersdontcarewheretheygrow · 04/12/2023 23:05

IveOnlyEverHeardOutwithONHere · 04/12/2023 22:51

Yes, I think lockdowns have had an effect, but I think we’re getting to the point now where we can’t have that as an excuse anymore. There has been a good 2.5 years now of normality to catch up. I’m sorry but Covid can’t be blamed for the ridiculous number of kids starting reception still in nappies, without language etc. There’s no doubt that interventions such as speech therapy were severely disrupted, but the massive rise in children who need them isn’t just because of lockdowns, and the sooner we stop making excuses and look the issues in the face the better.

The kids that have entered primary this year were crawlers / toddlers when Covid hit so the lack of regular socialisation at this point will have impacted them to some extent.
Also, after lockdown I came across lots of people who ' nipped out' from WFH with little ones to attend play groups or the playground. I often wondered what the child was doing for the rest of the day while their parent worked....
What nobody has mentioned so far is that children of all ages are plugged into devices so much that their attention span has and is impacted.
Like every it's ok in small doses but will ultimately have a knock on effect on development especially for the littlest kids watching screens instead of developing fine motor skills.

shearwater2 · 04/12/2023 22:55

Smellslikesummer · 04/12/2023 22:40

Schools have become more massive, bigger classes and more anonymous. There are huge anonymous primary schools as well. It's not education, it's crowd control
But then every time someone asks if they should consider putting their DC into independent they are told there is no point, it won’t make a difference, etc. My DC went from a challenging class of 30 to a class of 14 well behaved children, it did make a world of difference! We went from his teacher telling us he was average academically to him getting amazing results.

Yes, I often wonder if we should have thought about it for DD2. But then nearly all the private schools here are academically selective, and she wouldn't have got in. And as her problem is school avoidance, we might have been paying an awful lot of money for her not to go to school.

IveOnlyEverHeardOutwithONHere · 04/12/2023 22:51

Yes, I think lockdowns have had an effect, but I think we’re getting to the point now where we can’t have that as an excuse anymore. There has been a good 2.5 years now of normality to catch up. I’m sorry but Covid can’t be blamed for the ridiculous number of kids starting reception still in nappies, without language etc. There’s no doubt that interventions such as speech therapy were severely disrupted, but the massive rise in children who need them isn’t just because of lockdowns, and the sooner we stop making excuses and look the issues in the face the better.

Smellslikesummer · 04/12/2023 22:40

Schools have become more massive, bigger classes and more anonymous. There are huge anonymous primary schools as well. It's not education, it's crowd control
But then every time someone asks if they should consider putting their DC into independent they are told there is no point, it won’t make a difference, etc. My DC went from a challenging class of 30 to a class of 14 well behaved children, it did make a world of difference! We went from his teacher telling us he was average academically to him getting amazing results.

shearwater2 · 04/12/2023 22:34

Mariposista · 04/12/2023 22:15

Totally - right across the scale.

Reception kids still in nappies, tantrumming like toddlers and unable to use a knife and fork or speak
7 year olds who look at the floor when spoken to and give one word answers
9 year olds throwing hissy fits when told ‘no’
Year 7 kids unable to organise their own school bags or PE kit
14 year olds throwing paper about in class
16 year olds who can’t take revision seriously
Sixth formers just totally unprepared for life.

unacceptable behavior at all levels, disrupting actual learning. And usually an excuse for each case!

who would be a teacher?

Hasn't changed one bit in 30+ years then since I left school.

redalex261 · 04/12/2023 22:22

Lockdown made a bad situation worse. Attention span of goldfish, whiny and helpless. No inner resilience. Mummies bailing them out of everything, and unwilling to accept their “perfect just as you are” children may have shortcomings. When they can’t progress due to inattention and poor behaviour and general immaturity (or distraction from other bad behaviours) the poor teachers carry the can for bad results.

SalmonWellington · 04/12/2023 22:21

Thanks MrsTerryPratchett.

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/12/2023 22:16

I used to facilitate education (as a classroom guest) for 'challenging' youth. I was very good at it. I think it's a really interesting issue because of one thing.

Typically, teachers are people who broadly liked school, liked education, liked teachers. The kids like them don't need any special skills. Honestly, it's entirely possible they could learn with almost anyone. The kids who hated school, didn't have good relationships with teachers and saw flaws in mainstream education sometimes become youth workers, but they rarely become teachers. And so teachers don't tend towards understanding and empathising with the students with challenges. Many of them complain about student behaviour because of that. T'was ever thus.

I hated school and most teachers. I did well because I was bright but undiagnosed ADHD and school aren't friends. Most teachers hated me because doing well without doing what they told me too wasn't what they wanted. I see the children who do poorly in DD's class and they all have challenges. Crap home lives or ACE or something. But they get blamed, not the adults who fail them.

gooddayruby · 04/12/2023 22:15

Sensibleandboring · 04/12/2023 22:02

does anyone else think emotional growth of children was massively impacted by lockdown, leading them to exhibit behaviour more typical of 2 years younger due to the absence of regular social interactions and developmental experiences?

Yes precisely

Mariposista · 04/12/2023 22:15

Totally - right across the scale.

Reception kids still in nappies, tantrumming like toddlers and unable to use a knife and fork or speak
7 year olds who look at the floor when spoken to and give one word answers
9 year olds throwing hissy fits when told ‘no’
Year 7 kids unable to organise their own school bags or PE kit
14 year olds throwing paper about in class
16 year olds who can’t take revision seriously
Sixth formers just totally unprepared for life.

unacceptable behavior at all levels, disrupting actual learning. And usually an excuse for each case!

who would be a teacher?

shearwater2 · 04/12/2023 22:12

I remember the lads in our class fighting like little kids when I was in Y11 and feeling there was a massive gulf in maturity between me and them - this was in 1992.

Schools have become more massive, bigger classes and more anonymous. There are huge anonymous primary schools as well. It's not education, it's crowd control.

We need small schools, small class sizes and to treat kids as individuals, then behaviour would be much better and special educational and any other individual needs could be better met.

Instead schools have gone back to the Victorian age with draconian rules and one size fits all education, whereas the kids and parents are all very much from a quarter way through the 21st century.

Nowhere else in life is like secondary school. Apart from prisons, perhaps.

parksandrecs · 04/12/2023 22:11

To add, DD has an EHCP and is facing scraping pass grades for 5-6 GCSEs. But not because of the schools teaching, but because of her learning needs

parksandrecs · 04/12/2023 22:09

DD's ordinary secondary school (she is now in year 11) doesn't seem to have these problems. Pretty standard for FSM, Progress 8, levels of SEN

I am sure some schools struggle, and austerity has had an effect.

But not 3-4 years behind

Coldcaller · 04/12/2023 22:06

DD 1's English are all expected to attain grade 7 GCSE at the least . The school requires 57 points from 8 subjects for Sixth Form entry. Even here at sixth Form level there is a bit of immaturity !

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/12/2023 22:03

I think the effects of Covid and kids being at home for a year has a lot to answer for

I've been a teacher for 28 years. Behavioir had already been getting steadily worse for years before Covid, but the lockdowns certainly caused a rise too.