Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe that some children in the classroom are acting as if they are three or four years younger than their actual age.

137 replies

Coldcaller · 04/12/2023 19:56

DD 2 is a science teacher in ordinary Comprehensive school where grade 5 in English and Math's hovers around 40% and about 25% of pupils are in receipt of FSM. Therefore, in all probability it is a very average Secondary School. DD 2 is very reticent about continuing to teach at the school or possibly to give up teaching totally. This is down to the behavior of many of the children and DD was continually given the bottom sets to teach in year 7, 8 and 9. because she appeared to the SLT to be the teacher who could mostly engage with them. The behavior never mind any interest in the subject from many of the kids is horrific, swearing fighting refusal to sit down and general anarchy being regular. Despite the appearance DD was getting depressed teaching these groups and was using all her efforts on classroom management and not teaching. A lack of interest in handling the difficult and disengaged kids is shown by members of the SLT. This, means classroom teachers are asked to continue teaching even if swearing is heard as long if it is not aimed at the teacher. There is no point sending a child out, for swearing because SLT will just re admit the child to the class . Isolation is the last resort and would probably require a physical assault to have taken place for it to be in-acted.

DD went to the head of Science and the Headteacher 4 weeks ago saying that she was not enjoying teaching and was thinking of quitting teaching. The truth was she had an interview for a Chemistry teacher for a Co-ed Independent, where the benchmark for GCSE grades are 8 and 9's . Despite having the interview, the head of Science talked her round, convincing her that she would be putting the department in a huge hole if she left. Because DD 2 is nice but naive, she agreed to stay at least until the end of July 2024. This, was on the proviso she would be teaching the top sets in years 9, 10 and 11. The behavior of her current year 10 top set Double Science is currently causing her concern for their immaturity . The kids don't swear or fight but act like 11 year old's. 15 year old girls putting their hands up and telling silly tales, boys laughing at very immature behavior reminiscent of year 6 boys. These kids are expected to get between grades 5 -8 in Double Science in June 2025 and DD says her top pupil is currently in line for a 4 if lucky ! DD is expected to plug the gaps left by the ex teacher in year 10 and these kids are the schools 'Cream'..

OP posts:
lollo8 · 05/12/2023 07:25

So many threads on here from people terrified to leave their 15-year-olds in the house alone, or furious at teachers for suggesting that little Timmy is not a perfect angel, or appalled by any suggestion that a 23-year-old should get a job and leave home.

Yes it's covid, and too much screentime, but it's also that parents have become wildly overprotective and coddling, and unwilling to let children develop any sense of confidence, ability to judge risk or self-sufficiency.

They're not allowed to socialise in person and learn social skills like kids used to. They don't work Saturday/summer jobs or do paper rounds. They're not even trusted to get on the bus alone. So they continue to act like toddlers.

Ejismyf · 05/12/2023 07:23

I think covids defo delayed some children maturing. My niece is about to turn 9 and honestly still acts like a 4 year old. There's quite a few I know who seem very immature compared to their age.

QueenBean22 · 05/12/2023 07:21

It sounds awful. I quit teaching 13 years ago for similar reasons. I loved my subject just didn’t love the constant management of absolute dickheads. And in practical subjects like science the safety is compromised with such immaturity and bad behaviour.

I was very fortunate to be able to retrain in another profession with funding available.

x2boys · 05/12/2023 07:18

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 05/12/2023 07:09

Those people who are saying it hasn’t changed since they were at school 30 yrs ago are talking absolute nonsense. Of course it’s changed. Society is unrecognisable from 30 years ago and schools have been hugely impacted.

I do think we need to stop blaming covid though - I think it’s a mixture of parenting (where parents refuse to say no or teach any discipline or boundaries) and social media which encourages this sense of entitlement. It’s a dangerous mix and teachers are paying a heavy price. I left the profession last year and nothing would tempt me back.

I agree schools have changed massivly since i was at school, i left in 1990
But society has changed too
When i was at school was w were given far more independence from.a much younger age and when i left school at 16 whilst i went to college many of my pees went straight into a job

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 05/12/2023 07:15

If your daughter is unhappy at the school she should leave. It's not her fault there is a massive teacher shortage and they'll find it difficult to replace her.

However, she shouldn't lie to her HoD if she is going for a job in a different school - ultimately they'll find out if she gets it, if not sooner if asked for a reference etc, and that sort of thing has the potential to really burn bridges.

But she shouldn't let herself be talked into staying.

That said there are downsides to private too and she should ask careful questions about pay, pensions and evening commitments

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 05/12/2023 07:09

Those people who are saying it hasn’t changed since they were at school 30 yrs ago are talking absolute nonsense. Of course it’s changed. Society is unrecognisable from 30 years ago and schools have been hugely impacted.

I do think we need to stop blaming covid though - I think it’s a mixture of parenting (where parents refuse to say no or teach any discipline or boundaries) and social media which encourages this sense of entitlement. It’s a dangerous mix and teachers are paying a heavy price. I left the profession last year and nothing would tempt me back.

x2boys · 05/12/2023 07:08

Naptrappedmummy · 04/12/2023 23:29

I’m absolutely mystified by the rise of non verbal children. I can see how a speech delay would be expected because of lockdowns causing a deficit in social interaction, or parents chatting less to their kids due to screens, but to have no language at all?? There have always been neglected children, whose parents would dump them in the high chair and switch TV on, yet I never met a single child growing up who couldn’t speak unless there was a clear reason (ie profound cerebral palsy). It feels like nobody wants to acknowledge there has been a rise in this sort of thing and instead it’s better diagnosis, but these issues are so evident they could never have flown under the radar even 40 years ago. What’s going on?

They used to be locked up in years gone byi have a non verbal 13 year old
Children that remain non verbal do so becsuse of complex disabillitues
Some children will have speech delay
But thats not the same as non verbal

PartTimePartyPooper · 05/12/2023 07:03

lockdown and screen addiction, I agree these are the huge problems for a traditional education. Why learn anything when everything is so easy online?

My eldest daughter is doing fine- she’s hugely addicted to her screen but also loves art and sport and her pets. She has switched on at school but she’s aa fairly rare exception - her primary peers suffered hugely from lockdown, the boys who behaved badly got much rose.

My little boy is about two years behind where he should be. I am actually quitting work to try and help him. It’s been so hard - lockdown was a terrible thing to do to our kids.

x2boys · 05/12/2023 07:02

How long can we keep blaming covid for everything?
Yes we had a very disrupted year between march 2020,and march 2021
But thats nearly 3 years ago now
Not all, kids in the bottom sets are disruptive some just are not very academic
I have a non academic nearly 17 year old ,you couldnt meet nicer ,kind young man and its not just me who says that lets not write bottom set kids off becsuse they cant acheive a string of 8,s and 9,s at GCSE,s

ExpressCheckout · 05/12/2023 07:00

Agree with most of the above. So, what's the solution for parents' behaviors? I have no idea where we should start with this, but would be interested to hear some ideas ...

BelindaOkra · 05/12/2023 06:59

I work with kids who are out of school - primary and secondary. There are growing numbers of children and young people who cannot cope with school. There used to be a bit more choice in school style - my youngest went to a free school with quite a different approach for example. First names for teachers, project based learning etc. it suited him. He did well with that, was always an anxious child and that very human approach built his confidence and worked well with him.

Schools now pretty much have to be bootcamp, The govt loves the Michaela style or slogan shouting style schools. My youngest son’s school is now bootcamp. And there are whole bunch of kids who can’t cope with that style of school, and a whole bunch who don’t care & fight against it. But there is little room for schools to do anything except be very very directive & disciplined and imo it doesn’t work with kids who are not able to regulate well. And they end up out of school.

Immature uni kids are interesting - these are people who have reached a certain standard & won’t be the huge disrupters.. But again in an education system & exam system that does not support thinking for yourself. Which of course is what they should be doing at university.

NonanteNeuf · 05/12/2023 06:57

My DH is a neurologist and he said that this is 100% down to screens, addictive games and the “slot machine like” infinite scrolling.

They've done FMRIs on 9 years to 17 year olds for their current research and he said they have the same brains as drug addicts. All the same places lighting up.

Covid just made a bad situation worse.

Tumbleweed101 · 05/12/2023 06:56

Even our preschool cohorts the last couple years are seeing much worse behaviour and lower attainment for speech and communication, social skills etc.

AutismProf · 05/12/2023 06:52

Galiana · 05/12/2023 05:30

@AutismProf

This is not excellently articulated. This is giving up on young people before they have even had a chance because of preconceived notions.

I refuse to believe that young people don't have a chance.

Yeah, you can write them off, and it's both easy and difficult.

And @Coldcaller your daughter's job is fuck all to do with you really.

Where is this giving up on young people? Understanding or theorising about *why" something is happening gives you the curiosity and drive to try to find solutions and the clues as to what the solutions might be.

I vehemently object to you suggesting that perceiving reasons for observed behaviours is the same as writing off those young people or claiming they don't have a chance.

There are loads of solutions: more information on coregulation in infancy and on phone use. More advice on when to use screens. Prioritisation of play and book sharing in the early years; later introduction of reading and formal numeracy as in Scandi countries. Adjustment of the national curriculum to include a national qualifications scheme for those who are not going to get 10 GCSE passes whatever anyone does, and change in Ofsted so schools are not penalised for offering alternative qualifications. Specifically, a core offer of a maths and English curriculum that actually measures basic numeracy and literacy alongside the GCSE spec.

My entire career has been around not giving up on kids who struggle.

Heartfullofcheese · 05/12/2023 06:52

Pandemic.
Screen time.
Pressure of Instagram etc.
Massive rise in parents who intervene to prevent any tiny moment of discomfort for their child.
Insane curriculum expectations in primary meaning there is no time to nurture, discuss, deal with anything.
Big rise in parents who don’t want to take any responsibility (but know their rights).

All this and probably more.

wiseoldcat · 05/12/2023 06:49

Longwhiskers · 05/12/2023 06:36

Have there been any studies done recently that connect (or not) screen time/games/YouTube use with poor behaviour in school? I wonder if we’re blaming a lot of stuff on the pandemic but it went hand in hand with increased screen time?

I really don't think so.

Screen time is an issue, of course, and some kids stay up until the early hours playing XBox or whatever. But this was just as much of an issue before the pandemic.

There has definitely been an impact of Covid and teenagers' social skills have regressed or just not developed as they normally would.

Screen time/ games/ social media are a separate issue which do have an impact but were already there even a decade ago. It has got worse over the last 3 years since Covid.

wiseoldcat · 05/12/2023 06:46

Behaviour in schools has always been an issue. Even back in the 90's when I was at school we had these problems of disrespect, backchat, even violence in the classroom and there not being much that teachers could do.

I do agree though that Covid has had a big impact on this generation of young people and things like the putting their hands up and telling silly tales show the lack of social development.

Really I can't feel anything but sorry for these young people who have missed so much important development, and I don't know what the answer is.

everybluesock · 05/12/2023 06:46

Everyone blames the pandemic but the truth is endless screen time means they haven't developed key social skills.
Every time your child is spending an evening gaming or messaging on their phone - they're not actually socialising with other teenagers face to face. Previous generations would have hung out, got into trouble, done stupid things together but that's part of learning and growing. Technology has taken these key experiences from young people and they simply don't grow up in the way they should.

3Tunes · 05/12/2023 06:45

@Galiana Your final sentence was rude and uncalled for.

Longwhiskers · 05/12/2023 06:36

Have there been any studies done recently that connect (or not) screen time/games/YouTube use with poor behaviour in school? I wonder if we’re blaming a lot of stuff on the pandemic but it went hand in hand with increased screen time?

sashh · 05/12/2023 05:48

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/12/2023 22:16

I used to facilitate education (as a classroom guest) for 'challenging' youth. I was very good at it. I think it's a really interesting issue because of one thing.

Typically, teachers are people who broadly liked school, liked education, liked teachers. The kids like them don't need any special skills. Honestly, it's entirely possible they could learn with almost anyone. The kids who hated school, didn't have good relationships with teachers and saw flaws in mainstream education sometimes become youth workers, but they rarely become teachers. And so teachers don't tend towards understanding and empathising with the students with challenges. Many of them complain about student behaviour because of that. T'was ever thus.

I hated school and most teachers. I did well because I was bright but undiagnosed ADHD and school aren't friends. Most teachers hated me because doing well without doing what they told me too wasn't what they wanted. I see the children who do poorly in DD's class and they all have challenges. Crap home lives or ACE or something. But they get blamed, not the adults who fail them.

I agree with this.

I also hated school and sort of fell in to teaching.

OP

I did a lot of supply, including in some very challenging schools.

One thing I did that helped me cope was to call the parents of the children who are behaving. Just to say there is a a lot of disruption and I might not get a chance to acknowledge your child but I have noticed them, I know they are working and I appreciate it.

Also I agree with a lot that @Devilsmommy said.

Galiana · 05/12/2023 05:30

@AutismProf

This is not excellently articulated. This is giving up on young people before they have even had a chance because of preconceived notions.

I refuse to believe that young people don't have a chance.

Yeah, you can write them off, and it's both easy and difficult.

And @Coldcaller your daughter's job is fuck all to do with you really.

WandaWonder · 05/12/2023 05:11

Of the teachers I know it is the parents that are the issue, they don't want to believe it

Reugny · 05/12/2023 05:06

aliceinanwonderland · 05/12/2023 00:01

But on another thread there will be conversations that one shouldn’t potty train until the child is “ready” even if this is aged 3.5 etc. We were shamed in Spain when we went with my “just” two year old. All other children her age were not in nappies. She was hot and uncomfortable in hers. When home I just “did it “. It took a few days and she was clean and dry even at night. And she was so proud of herself for being a “big girl “. Sometimes we don’t go children justice in keeping them back.

You have actually explained in your post why kids in another country end up being potty trained younger - hot weather.