Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe that some children in the classroom are acting as if they are three or four years younger than their actual age.

137 replies

Coldcaller · 04/12/2023 19:56

DD 2 is a science teacher in ordinary Comprehensive school where grade 5 in English and Math's hovers around 40% and about 25% of pupils are in receipt of FSM. Therefore, in all probability it is a very average Secondary School. DD 2 is very reticent about continuing to teach at the school or possibly to give up teaching totally. This is down to the behavior of many of the children and DD was continually given the bottom sets to teach in year 7, 8 and 9. because she appeared to the SLT to be the teacher who could mostly engage with them. The behavior never mind any interest in the subject from many of the kids is horrific, swearing fighting refusal to sit down and general anarchy being regular. Despite the appearance DD was getting depressed teaching these groups and was using all her efforts on classroom management and not teaching. A lack of interest in handling the difficult and disengaged kids is shown by members of the SLT. This, means classroom teachers are asked to continue teaching even if swearing is heard as long if it is not aimed at the teacher. There is no point sending a child out, for swearing because SLT will just re admit the child to the class . Isolation is the last resort and would probably require a physical assault to have taken place for it to be in-acted.

DD went to the head of Science and the Headteacher 4 weeks ago saying that she was not enjoying teaching and was thinking of quitting teaching. The truth was she had an interview for a Chemistry teacher for a Co-ed Independent, where the benchmark for GCSE grades are 8 and 9's . Despite having the interview, the head of Science talked her round, convincing her that she would be putting the department in a huge hole if she left. Because DD 2 is nice but naive, she agreed to stay at least until the end of July 2024. This, was on the proviso she would be teaching the top sets in years 9, 10 and 11. The behavior of her current year 10 top set Double Science is currently causing her concern for their immaturity . The kids don't swear or fight but act like 11 year old's. 15 year old girls putting their hands up and telling silly tales, boys laughing at very immature behavior reminiscent of year 6 boys. These kids are expected to get between grades 5 -8 in Double Science in June 2025 and DD says her top pupil is currently in line for a 4 if lucky ! DD is expected to plug the gaps left by the ex teacher in year 10 and these kids are the schools 'Cream'..

OP posts:
Goatymum · 05/12/2023 08:33

My DCs finished school - were pretty much top set for most subjects - and afaik they and their peers wanted to learn (in fact dd used to say that some of her classmates were so clever she couldn’t keep up)! It is probably different in different areas/schools and although theirs was a comp, it was one which was oversubscribed.
I think some of it can be attributed to covid lockdowns, they certainly affected the mental health of my DC - and also lack of consequences in the home - parents expect school to ‘parent’. Culture has changed so much in past 20
or so years - parents both work full time cos COL is so high (no judgment but it’s how it is), there’s more awareness of mental health (which is good), but a teacher can’t dismiss a kid who says they’re anxious so then everyone says they’ve got anxiety etc. (my DC actually do, clinically, but DD used to say people used it at school to get out of situations etc).
As for uni - both DCs are at uni now - DD has some accommodations but doesn’t take the piss and gets the work done. DS had a rough start and missed almost a couple of weeks, but has caught up now. They probably are a bit immature because at nearly 15 and 18 respectively their lives pretty much stopped for the first lockdown and dd started uni in 2020 - a false start because of all the lockdowns/tiers etc.

AngelinaFibres · 05/12/2023 08:33

Friends DIL is German but teaching in an English comp. She is applying for jobs away from teaching . She was shocked by the English system. In Germany ( where she taught before coming here) the student is held responsible for their achievements. If the teacher has planned and delivered appropriate lessons then ,if the pupil refuses to engage,doesn't do the work etc it's the students fault. In this country she said she is flogging herself to despair trying to get students to the expected grade and ,if they skive, disrupt etc etc she will be judged, not the child.

Catza · 05/12/2023 08:31

This doesn't surprise me. My step kid is just about to turn 14 and she is really young for her age. Unfortunately, I think a big part of it is parenting styles. Her mum and grandmother are very controlling while my partner is very allowing so she grew up not knowing how to make any decisions for herself and generally seems confused about life. This is quite to the point of being ridiculous, every task you ask her to do will be followed by "dad, can you come and help me". From making a cup of tea, to finding a bin bag under a kitchen sink. She came over last weekend without a jacket and attempted to go outside wearing a hoodie (-3 outside). When I told her to wear my coat, the response was "you are tripping, bro" so had to be told I am not her gangsta school mate to be addressed like that. She is a very bright and gentle kid, has good grades but completely lacks social skills and life skills. I can only imagine 30 of them in a classroom...

3Tunes · 05/12/2023 08:18

AussieManque · 05/12/2023 07:55

@fruitypancake kids were not at home for "a year" during lockdown.

Between Jan 2020 and July 2021, British children have been out of the classroom for nearly half (44 per cent) of days, according to a House of Commons Library analysis of data from the University of Oxford Covid-19 Government Response Tracker.

Many kids of essential workers also were in school more.

I'm not saying lockdowns were good for education and behaviour, but we seem to have blown them out of proportion in our memory.

Maybe not your kids. Mine left school in March 2020 and didn’t set foot there again until September. And then missed the first months of 2021, too. Plus lots of self isolating at home for two weeks due to contact. It was hugely disruptive.

One had online lessons, so some teacher contact. The other didn’t.

110APiccadilly · 05/12/2023 08:17

This, means classroom teachers are asked to continue teaching even if swearing is heard as long if it is not aimed at the teacher.

So their poor peers have to put up with something that's not acceptable if aimed at a teacher? I hope this doesn't also apply to sexualised language (but I bet it does).

Macaroni46 · 05/12/2023 08:15

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/12/2023 07:42

Is anyone considering that neurodiversity such as ADHD etc...can typically mean a delay of 3 to 4 years with behaviour issues?

Of course. For some. But not the numbers of children we're talking about. Children can be NT and basically, badly brought up and badly behaved.

waterdusky · 05/12/2023 08:12

Behaviour was deteriorating even before lockdown. But yes, I work in a nice, middle class area and my subject is only taught to those on the gifted and talented programme, but I would say my Year 11s are very immature and it does feel at times like teaching a year 9 class. I think what exasperated my feeling of frustration however, is the fact we are measured against predicted grades they are unlikely to get (because of poor MH, a parent has died, behaviour, massive class sizes, they just don't do homework or any revision etc etc). So teachers are under pressure to live up to these grades and the parents and students just think they are pushy, or mean, or their expectations are too high etc. I think if the FFTs/progress 8 didn't exist, I think behaviour would be less of an issue. Teachers are often nor leaving because they can't handle the behaviour, it's because they don't want to with insane pressure to force grades out of these kids that disrupt.

shockeditellyou · 05/12/2023 08:11

Another reason why I think it’s parenting/cultural problems: it would be a cold day in hell before any of the children from south or east Asian parent families in our local schools were causing trouble or not meeting age related expectations….

Trulywonderful · 05/12/2023 08:11

Coldcaller · 04/12/2023 19:56

DD 2 is a science teacher in ordinary Comprehensive school where grade 5 in English and Math's hovers around 40% and about 25% of pupils are in receipt of FSM. Therefore, in all probability it is a very average Secondary School. DD 2 is very reticent about continuing to teach at the school or possibly to give up teaching totally. This is down to the behavior of many of the children and DD was continually given the bottom sets to teach in year 7, 8 and 9. because she appeared to the SLT to be the teacher who could mostly engage with them. The behavior never mind any interest in the subject from many of the kids is horrific, swearing fighting refusal to sit down and general anarchy being regular. Despite the appearance DD was getting depressed teaching these groups and was using all her efforts on classroom management and not teaching. A lack of interest in handling the difficult and disengaged kids is shown by members of the SLT. This, means classroom teachers are asked to continue teaching even if swearing is heard as long if it is not aimed at the teacher. There is no point sending a child out, for swearing because SLT will just re admit the child to the class . Isolation is the last resort and would probably require a physical assault to have taken place for it to be in-acted.

DD went to the head of Science and the Headteacher 4 weeks ago saying that she was not enjoying teaching and was thinking of quitting teaching. The truth was she had an interview for a Chemistry teacher for a Co-ed Independent, where the benchmark for GCSE grades are 8 and 9's . Despite having the interview, the head of Science talked her round, convincing her that she would be putting the department in a huge hole if she left. Because DD 2 is nice but naive, she agreed to stay at least until the end of July 2024. This, was on the proviso she would be teaching the top sets in years 9, 10 and 11. The behavior of her current year 10 top set Double Science is currently causing her concern for their immaturity . The kids don't swear or fight but act like 11 year old's. 15 year old girls putting their hands up and telling silly tales, boys laughing at very immature behavior reminiscent of year 6 boys. These kids are expected to get between grades 5 -8 in Double Science in June 2025 and DD says her top pupil is currently in line for a 4 if lucky ! DD is expected to plug the gaps left by the ex teacher in year 10 and these kids are the schools 'Cream'..

I work in a state secondary school in London. The behaviour at my school is genuinely much better than most similar schools it seems. I believe that is because we have an excellent SLT that do their jobs very well. If a school doesn't have SLT that deal with behaviour in a quick appropriate way the moment the students get out of line the teachers are basically stuffed. Unfortunately your daughter can't do much to change here SLT apart from change jobs. Even then behaviour is an issue in a large number of secondary schools at the moment

Personally I would have stuck with the younger year groups if getting a headache about behaviour. The younger ones I find much easier because you can reset their behaviour and remind them of manners. In general the older year groups are more hormonal and tend to think they know everything. Once the bad behaviour has set in it is way harder to do anything with them. Unless you have taught then since their early at the school you would find it challenging. Even then it can have its moments. Once you get to year 11 and sixth form the behaviour of most students tends to start calming down again because they are past that 14/15 peak hormones stage.

I think overall your daughter should try changing schools unless she feels the school is going to get its act together behaviour wise. I know she probably feels very guilty at the idea of leaving a big gap in the teaching staff but she does have to do what is best for herself long term. If that doesn't work out and she is still unhappy then teaching is probably not for her. It would be a shame and we need more secondary teachers not less. However not everyone can handle the type of behaviour we are seeing in schools especially since the lockdowns made it way worse

aliceinanwonderland · 05/12/2023 08:09

Reugny · 05/12/2023 05:06

You have actually explained in your post why kids in another country end up being potty trained younger - hot weather.

My point, badly articulated I know, is that sometimes we keep small children as babies in all respects. On the continent ( at least ten years or so ago) they are expected to act their age. And whilst they don’t start formal school til 6, most can read and write at that age. We have low expectations in the UK.

HFJ · 05/12/2023 08:08

I think there are two key issues here:

  1. Lack of the right kind of culture and leadership in the school. It should be senior leaders who lead the way. There should be a ‘curriculum’ for behaviour that sets out the rules, routines and habits. Expectations, sanctions and rewards should be consistent. In the absence of all this, it tends to come down to individual teachers and this drives burnout and high turnover.
  2. An assumption that your job should make you happy. These messages start early with advertising ‘every lesson can change a life’. Young teachers are sold a dream and it takes maybe 3 years to realise the job is sometimes a nightmare. By then, they’re fully invested with debt incurred during training, and a two year ECT process that must be completed.

My suggestion would be to find a different school to work in. One where there are centralised detentions, leaders with gravitas, all teachers uphold the same habits, rules and routines, and a community of parents who value education, work ethic, politeness and self-discipline.

I would also suggest some reflection about ‘a job should make you happy’. It’s having goals, working hard, friendships and family that bring happiness.

AussieManque · 05/12/2023 07:55

@fruitypancake kids were not at home for "a year" during lockdown.

Between Jan 2020 and July 2021, British children have been out of the classroom for nearly half (44 per cent) of days, according to a House of Commons Library analysis of data from the University of Oxford Covid-19 Government Response Tracker.

Many kids of essential workers also were in school more.

I'm not saying lockdowns were good for education and behaviour, but we seem to have blown them out of proportion in our memory.

iloveeverykindofcat · 05/12/2023 07:47

I'm a sociologist and digital media is one of my interests. It's not screens per se. It's apps designed to maximise ad revenue and data extraction by generating an endless stream of increasingly shorter, shallower content (TikTok). Its addictive because it offers endless opportunities with randomized rewards: that click didn't provide a dopamine hit, try the next, try the next, get one. Its the same process as gambling. On balance, I think the internet is a good thing, but I'd support much tighter regulation. Apps designed on the TikTok model absolutely are damaging, particularly to developing brains, and we are only just beginning to see the results.

Newtonianmechanics · 05/12/2023 07:46

Another thing is parents treat school like customer service. It's thst old joke where it is the teaches fault for everything.

Newtonianmechanics · 05/12/2023 07:43

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/12/2023 22:16

I used to facilitate education (as a classroom guest) for 'challenging' youth. I was very good at it. I think it's a really interesting issue because of one thing.

Typically, teachers are people who broadly liked school, liked education, liked teachers. The kids like them don't need any special skills. Honestly, it's entirely possible they could learn with almost anyone. The kids who hated school, didn't have good relationships with teachers and saw flaws in mainstream education sometimes become youth workers, but they rarely become teachers. And so teachers don't tend towards understanding and empathising with the students with challenges. Many of them complain about student behaviour because of that. T'was ever thus.

I hated school and most teachers. I did well because I was bright but undiagnosed ADHD and school aren't friends. Most teachers hated me because doing well without doing what they told me too wasn't what they wanted. I see the children who do poorly in DD's class and they all have challenges. Crap home lives or ACE or something. But they get blamed, not the adults who fail them.

I think there is something in that. I am a teacher. I hated school y7-9 but loved GCSE years and was very academic.

My dd ASD abd ADHD is ESBA and has 50 percent attendance. Failing her mocks. It has opened my eyes a lot. It is hard. I keep thinking of the phrase you get the child you need.... it has made me super compassionate. I thought I was before but dd has made me see things differently.

I also agree on the huge classes and one size fits all doesn't work for a lot of pupils.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/12/2023 07:42

Is anyone considering that neurodiversity such as ADHD etc...can typically mean a delay of 3 to 4 years with behaviour issues?

Leah5678 · 05/12/2023 07:42

Naptrappedmummy · 04/12/2023 23:29

I’m absolutely mystified by the rise of non verbal children. I can see how a speech delay would be expected because of lockdowns causing a deficit in social interaction, or parents chatting less to their kids due to screens, but to have no language at all?? There have always been neglected children, whose parents would dump them in the high chair and switch TV on, yet I never met a single child growing up who couldn’t speak unless there was a clear reason (ie profound cerebral palsy). It feels like nobody wants to acknowledge there has been a rise in this sort of thing and instead it’s better diagnosis, but these issues are so evident they could never have flown under the radar even 40 years ago. What’s going on?

Yup and kids apparently starting school still in nappies because the parents are lazy.
Truth is lazy parents can't be doing with changing nappies and a nt 4 year old doesn't even need to be trained to go to the toilet they will just do it.
My son started reception last year and there was ONE kid in his class of 30 in nappies and she clearly has special needs. So much for the "shocking rise in lazy parents who just let their kids play on iPads all day so the kid can't talk, walk, shit on a toilet etc"

seenisambol · 05/12/2023 07:37

My best friend and sibling are both uni lecturers and I'm continually shocked by the stories they tell me of the current batch of uni students.

I do think that over parenting is a big issue. When I was growing up one of my friends had a really overbearing mum who was constantly checking up on her and wanting to know who she was with and why. We all used to think she was a total nutcase. Today this seems to be the standard way of parenting teenagers. Even my friend has said "now I'm a parent I realise my mum was right all along". How on earth are they going to cope as adults if they never learn to stand on their own two feet?

Inthebathagain · 05/12/2023 07:37

Schools are now considered to be the ones to solve all children's problems.

Mental health issue? School will deal with that.

No food/clothing? School will deal with that.

Child doesn't behave? School will deal with that.

Child isn't coming in to school? School will deal with that.

Child has nits? School will deal with that.

Parent having mental health issues? School will deal with that.

Child has no attention span? School will deal with that.

Child isn't potty trained? School will deal with that.

Child has no books at home, can't speak in sentences and doesn't know their colours? School will deal with that.

Several in society have very little problem with these statements.

NHS/Children's services have no capacity, so it's all being left on schools having to deal with these sorts of things every day, as they're on the coal face.

Schools are very different places to be now compared to 25 years ago when I started teaching. Schools used to educate. Now we just safeguard as the priority and everything else is a bonus.

COVID accelerated the trend.

electriclight · 05/12/2023 07:32

Yes it's the same in primary schools. In the whole, their behaviour can be managed because they still care about sanctions and can be motivated. But very, very immature. I don't know if it's Covid, screens or parenting but probably a mixture of all of them. Parenting is at insane levels of protection imo. Children cannot experience boredom, sadness or disappointment without a complaint. Disciplining a child for anything at all results in a complaint. Any disagreement with a peer is the other child being a bully and what are we doing about it. I am sorry for the children who are not allowed to experience normal life, and worry how they will cope at secondary, higher education, work.

Benibidibici · 05/12/2023 07:30

it's also that parents have become wildly overprotective and coddling, and unwilling to let children develop any sense of confidence, ability to judge risk or self-sufficiency.

This. My kid had a music exam recently. Do you know how many parents were aghast that i entered a 7 year old for an exam? Its perceived as "harsh", unnecessary and pointless.

Its a low stakes situation where they get the chance to show they can work for something and get a certificate to be proud of. If a child can't even cope with that, they are going to find life hard.

shockeditellyou · 05/12/2023 07:29

Stop blaming lockdown for something that is at least 70% parenting failure. I also don’t think the curriculum is to blame - you can bet your bottom dollar a damn sight more kids know their times tables since the times tables check was introduced, and I quite like my child understanding the fundamentals of English grammar.

Parents have such low expectations of behaviour and expect children to cope with blended families. Screens are also an issue.

However I do think there has been a deskilling of teachers - a friend’s son who was a model pupil with a 50 something “dragon” of a teacher, tried on all kinds of nonsense with a younger teacher whose approach to behaviour management consisted of phoning my friend to tell her that her son didn’t want to do X and had she considered assessment for PDA?

Loopytiles · 05/12/2023 07:29

IMO DD made a bad decision not to attend the interview at the private school, and should look now for other teaching or other jobs.

Benibidibici · 05/12/2023 07:26

Parenting has changed.

No one seems to focus on obedience any more. I'm perceived as "strict" by friends because i expect my kids (4 & 7) to do as they are bloody told and apply firm, unpleasant consequences (loss of screen time, temporary removal of favourite toys etc) when they don't. I don't explain at length why - I'm the parent, they are kids, the why is "because I say so". They know that if I'm asking them to do something its because it needs doing.

I see other parents at clubs, playdates etc and i see a lot of pleading and cajoling, giving in to tantrums and simply not applying any real consequences - saying "don't do that again" in a gentle voice is not a consequence and you need to do more if they continue the bad behaviour.

Independence is a massive issue, it seems to be unfashionable to give kids responsibilities and so you end up with 14 year olds who can't make so much as a alice of toast - at that age they should be able to make a proper cooked meal.

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 05/12/2023 07:25

@x2boys absolutely - that’s my point. Society has massively changed - and kids aren’t prepared for it. But this is far more about poor parenting than Covid. Leaving aside those kids who come from incredibly challenging backgrounds or who have SEN, there are millions of kids who are being helicopter parented to the point where you see all those behaviours described by a PP who works at uni. I did a uni course as a mature student last year and I saw firsthand the students who wanted no deadlines, no challenges, and to present in private 😬😳. It was crazy!

Swipe left for the next trending thread