Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe that some children in the classroom are acting as if they are three or four years younger than their actual age.

137 replies

Coldcaller · 04/12/2023 19:56

DD 2 is a science teacher in ordinary Comprehensive school where grade 5 in English and Math's hovers around 40% and about 25% of pupils are in receipt of FSM. Therefore, in all probability it is a very average Secondary School. DD 2 is very reticent about continuing to teach at the school or possibly to give up teaching totally. This is down to the behavior of many of the children and DD was continually given the bottom sets to teach in year 7, 8 and 9. because she appeared to the SLT to be the teacher who could mostly engage with them. The behavior never mind any interest in the subject from many of the kids is horrific, swearing fighting refusal to sit down and general anarchy being regular. Despite the appearance DD was getting depressed teaching these groups and was using all her efforts on classroom management and not teaching. A lack of interest in handling the difficult and disengaged kids is shown by members of the SLT. This, means classroom teachers are asked to continue teaching even if swearing is heard as long if it is not aimed at the teacher. There is no point sending a child out, for swearing because SLT will just re admit the child to the class . Isolation is the last resort and would probably require a physical assault to have taken place for it to be in-acted.

DD went to the head of Science and the Headteacher 4 weeks ago saying that she was not enjoying teaching and was thinking of quitting teaching. The truth was she had an interview for a Chemistry teacher for a Co-ed Independent, where the benchmark for GCSE grades are 8 and 9's . Despite having the interview, the head of Science talked her round, convincing her that she would be putting the department in a huge hole if she left. Because DD 2 is nice but naive, she agreed to stay at least until the end of July 2024. This, was on the proviso she would be teaching the top sets in years 9, 10 and 11. The behavior of her current year 10 top set Double Science is currently causing her concern for their immaturity . The kids don't swear or fight but act like 11 year old's. 15 year old girls putting their hands up and telling silly tales, boys laughing at very immature behavior reminiscent of year 6 boys. These kids are expected to get between grades 5 -8 in Double Science in June 2025 and DD says her top pupil is currently in line for a 4 if lucky ! DD is expected to plug the gaps left by the ex teacher in year 10 and these kids are the schools 'Cream'..

OP posts:
Coldcaller · 05/12/2023 13:05

It is really quite sad because DD 2 has wanted to be a teacher from being 14 . This is in contrast to DD 1 who just stumbled in to teaching. Yet DD 1 founds she loves teaching. This most probably being due to the environment of a highly selective grammar school. Whereas the natural teacher in DD 2 is inhibited by the restrictions of class management due to time taking up dealing with behavior and outside issues. I wish the two girls were in each others schools, because DD 1 would leave teaching or have no regrets about teaching in the independent . DD 2 though has a more caring attitude to those who are less fortunate hence a desire to teach in a non selective ordinary school.

The school have asked her previously if she can teach English to year 7-9 despite her degree being in Chemistry. This being because the Head of English noticed that DD 2 has a A* at A Level English and thinks the school could get away with it. The school are unable to recruit an English teacher. The school are prepared to ruin the Science Department if they can prop up English and Math's results.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/12/2023 13:01

Well yes they will be. They missed a big chunk of their education and social learning during Covid.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 12:59

2 or 3 posts a day I meant

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 12:59

Leah5678 · 05/12/2023 11:17

In my humble personal experience of working in schools with reception aged children I am yet to meet a child who cannot speak/is still in nappies due to the parents laziness and excessive Screentime.
And I do KNOW parents who are very lazy and their children are on iPads why too much. The children can still talk though. When my son started reception last year there was ONE child who couldn't talk and was still in nappies and she has learning disabilities.
Don't get me wrong I've seen the clickbait headlines saying there's a "drastic rise in children starting school unable to talk or shit on a toilet" but those articles don't mention whether the children have special needs?

When I was a child I was cripplingly shy and wouldn't talk to anyone unless they were close family according to many on Mumsnet I was a rude child and my parents neglected me. Wrong my parents are lovely and iPads did not exist when in was a child.

What kind of learning disabilities? Was it tied to a concrete diagnosis? I think you’ve misunderstood what I meant (sorry I probably didn’t word it well), but I meant the rise of non verbal children with some kind of learning disability (very usually autism) where there is no clear medical reason for this, like with @x2boys son who has a genetic condition. I mean children who for no reason just don’t develop as expected, their speech is behind, they have autistic traits or ADHD traits. These type of children just seem to be far far far more common than they ever were before. I live in a large town and there are probably 2 or 3 posts to our mums fb chat about children who are behind with speech and have asd/adhd.

I don’t think it’s the fault of ‘lazy parents’ I have already said this. I have a feeling there is something else behind it but what that is I have no idea.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 05/12/2023 11:46

I dislike the "lazy parents" trope. A two parent household with two full time working adults is at best going to have 30 minutes in the morning and 1 hour in the evening if the kids 1-4 are doing full time nursery hours.

This household will have maybe 30 hours quality, awake contact time a week with their kids. How on god's green earth is ANYONE supposed to potty train a kid in that time?

We aren't raising our own children anymore. Maybe in the 80s it would be a granny or a local childminder that would look after you, but these days granny is working and the local childminder isn't old Doris 5 doors down who lets you muck about with your friends as long as you mind your manners, it's someone with a EYFS framework getting a 18 month old to focus on their early phonics with flashcards.

This is why helicopter parents exist - we've got to entrust the most precious part of our lives to "for profit" nurseries and organisations. Childrearing has become KPI'd and over engineered.

You have to take your pick of what kind of gentle authoritarian tiger passive parent you're going to be, and get backlash from the other types if woebetide you dare set boundaries, slap a wrist, give a hug, or upset your kid.

Then you get to school, and there's no peace there. My 7 year old is learning grammar that I didn't approach until A levels. She's doing year 2 Maths that I did in year 6. And I was pretty smart at school. Her teachers are utterly amazing, I don't know how on earth they're cramming this into her head. It's impressive. And she's still "behind where she should be" for her year group.

But, is it the right thing to do? Are we seeing education over exploration, dulling self sufficiency and imagination? I think we are. And then, when that happens. We kick the parents.

They're just right lazy bastards after all.

x2boys · 05/12/2023 11:30

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 10:37

But why is it so much more common now?

One reason used to be that children were not allowed to start school in nappies ,thankfully the law has changed to stop children who are delayed for whatever reason from being discriminated against
My child is non verbal he also has severe autism and severe learning disabilities and an underlying rare chromosome disorder
I think there maybe multiple reasons why some more children have such disabilities, better health care premature children having a better survival rate ,sometimes resulting in more disabilities
.I also have my own thoughts on why there are more genetic disorders resulting in increased children with disabilities

StaunchMomma · 05/12/2023 11:23

As an aside - I just wanted to point out that there is also a real consequence for the teachers if disruptive kids affect grades, not just the kids in the class.

If the disruptive kids have, as mine did in the last school I worked at, HUGE problems at home (parents in prison/in care/drugs/abuse/prostitution/gang members/crime etc), ALL issues that impact on expected grades enormously, the school will still expect YOU to get them to that grade. End of.

You try sitting with a child who hasn't slept for days because he's forced out to work by gangs at night and isn't eating because Mum spends all of her money earned on the street on drugs that he really needs to prioritise a science exam and see where it gets you. No services to step in and help, no adults to turn to to save them, no mental health services to support them. The only place on the horizon with a bed and a regular meal the prison they'll inevitably end up in. Utterly heart breaking.

The whole system is madness.

Honestly, parents don't know the half of what teachers, or a lot of the kids, go through.

Leah5678 · 05/12/2023 11:17

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 08:54

But they weren’t - there are more special schools now than there ever were before. And there was a long period before the ‘locking disabled children away’ came to an end and this enormous rise began - i grew up in the 90s and while it wasn’t the most enlightened times they simply were not locking away disabled children. Yet I never met a child who couldn’t speak without an obvious reason (like I said cerebral palsy, Down’s syndrome, and so on).

My Gran worked with thousands of families in her career from the 60s through to the 90s and reported the same. She’s not at all rose tinted and can remember all the issues many children had, but non verbalism without clear reason was not one of them.

I’m not blaming parents, I’m not seeking to minimise their children’s difficulties or make out they would talk if they did X or Y. I’m genuinely mystified and think we need some kind of urgent investigation into this as a society, before we fail thousands of children by writing their delays off as ‘simply how kids are now and have probably always been’.

In my humble personal experience of working in schools with reception aged children I am yet to meet a child who cannot speak/is still in nappies due to the parents laziness and excessive Screentime.
And I do KNOW parents who are very lazy and their children are on iPads why too much. The children can still talk though. When my son started reception last year there was ONE child who couldn't talk and was still in nappies and she has learning disabilities.
Don't get me wrong I've seen the clickbait headlines saying there's a "drastic rise in children starting school unable to talk or shit on a toilet" but those articles don't mention whether the children have special needs?

When I was a child I was cripplingly shy and wouldn't talk to anyone unless they were close family according to many on Mumsnet I was a rude child and my parents neglected me. Wrong my parents are lovely and iPads did not exist when in was a child.

PippyLongTits · 05/12/2023 11:16

There are obviously issues related to the pandemic and being out of the classroom for a year. There are also issues with class sizes too. And of course there are also issues with respect and discipline. I haven't been in a classroom for 20+ years, but I remember there were teachers that we (as a class) behaved well for and teachers that had no control and that we could get away with murder in their lessons. Perhaps your DD could benefit from some assertiveness training or other soft skills that might help her manage the class better. I'm not saying that to be rude, just to offer a suggestion of something that might help going forward. The children aren't going to change if nothing else changes.

StaunchMomma · 05/12/2023 11:13

Welcome to education!!!

Add to that SLTs who are often absolute evil and you understand why teachers are leaving the profession in droves!!

Not worth the money or stress AT ALL!!

(The kids are ace. Even the anarchic ones. Literally only good bit).

cerisepanther73 · 05/12/2023 10:40

@IveOnlyEverHeardOutwithONHere

Hear Hear hear well said !

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 10:37

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/12/2023 10:27

DLD is more common than autism. Typically 3 kids in every class. You can be non verbal but the reason not be obvious. It doesn't affect intelligence. My friends daughter took until 11 for a diagnosis. That's only one disorder. There are many more.

But why is it so much more common now?

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/12/2023 10:27

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 08:54

But they weren’t - there are more special schools now than there ever were before. And there was a long period before the ‘locking disabled children away’ came to an end and this enormous rise began - i grew up in the 90s and while it wasn’t the most enlightened times they simply were not locking away disabled children. Yet I never met a child who couldn’t speak without an obvious reason (like I said cerebral palsy, Down’s syndrome, and so on).

My Gran worked with thousands of families in her career from the 60s through to the 90s and reported the same. She’s not at all rose tinted and can remember all the issues many children had, but non verbalism without clear reason was not one of them.

I’m not blaming parents, I’m not seeking to minimise their children’s difficulties or make out they would talk if they did X or Y. I’m genuinely mystified and think we need some kind of urgent investigation into this as a society, before we fail thousands of children by writing their delays off as ‘simply how kids are now and have probably always been’.

DLD is more common than autism. Typically 3 kids in every class. You can be non verbal but the reason not be obvious. It doesn't affect intelligence. My friends daughter took until 11 for a diagnosis. That's only one disorder. There are many more.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/12/2023 10:20

Macaroni46 · 05/12/2023 08:15

Of course. For some. But not the numbers of children we're talking about. Children can be NT and basically, badly brought up and badly behaved.

Of course.

It's just with lockdown and the state of the NHS and the backlogs, there will be a lot of ND kids out there who haven't been diagnosed yet when they otherwise would have.

NonanteNeuf · 05/12/2023 10:12

JustAMinutePleass · 05/12/2023 08:49

Kids being kids. Shocking. If your daughter wants impeccable behaviour all the time she should teach adults.

Beautiful demonstration of a big root of the problem.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 09:33

The problem is we have now moved to a culture where parents are less responsible for their children than wider society.

Wrote a long paragraph, posted too soon, went to edit then lost it argh. But essentially we have moved to a culture where support services are seen as being ultimately responsible for the actions of both children and parents. As the previous poster said, if the child has any problems the first response is ‘what are the school doing’.

ALittleDropOfRain · 05/12/2023 08:57

I had a guest lectureship at a uni before, during and immediately after Covid. Not in the UK. The maturity difference, motivation and self initiative of the 18/19 year old freshers before and after a year (and more) of lockdown was immense. The academic standard dropped too. I needed completely different teaching and management techniques.

Allaboutthepeople · 05/12/2023 08:55

My child psychologist friend say her colleagues all say this. That behaviourally, kids at these ages are several years behind where kids that age used to be.

It’s not surprising. Kids used to have loads of free, unsupervised play with their peers, out and about on their own, building independence, problem solving, resilience and managing g social interactions and difficulties themselves. All that helped them on their journey to young adulthood.

That has disappeared. Now kids have very little free play, and instead spend their time at adult managed organized activities.

And you can see on here how parents on chastised for not micro managing their children at every moment, ‘ you should have been watching them OP’’. Even if the child is in a safe enclosed environment the expectation is parents need to watch their child continually.

No wonder we have developmentally immature teenagers. We’ve never given them the space to learn and grow!

Noicant · 05/12/2023 08:55

It’s a bit worrying, this is our future workforce.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 08:54

x2boys · 05/12/2023 07:08

They used to be locked up in years gone byi have a non verbal 13 year old
Children that remain non verbal do so becsuse of complex disabillitues
Some children will have speech delay
But thats not the same as non verbal

But they weren’t - there are more special schools now than there ever were before. And there was a long period before the ‘locking disabled children away’ came to an end and this enormous rise began - i grew up in the 90s and while it wasn’t the most enlightened times they simply were not locking away disabled children. Yet I never met a child who couldn’t speak without an obvious reason (like I said cerebral palsy, Down’s syndrome, and so on).

My Gran worked with thousands of families in her career from the 60s through to the 90s and reported the same. She’s not at all rose tinted and can remember all the issues many children had, but non verbalism without clear reason was not one of them.

I’m not blaming parents, I’m not seeking to minimise their children’s difficulties or make out they would talk if they did X or Y. I’m genuinely mystified and think we need some kind of urgent investigation into this as a society, before we fail thousands of children by writing their delays off as ‘simply how kids are now and have probably always been’.

BobbleWobbleHat · 05/12/2023 08:53

I have 3 DC and my youngest missed much of preschool and almost all of their Reception year, plus several disruptions in Year 1 due to a "firebreak" closure etc.

He and his peers are way behind where my older children were at this stage. Both in terms of handwriting, reading etc but especially in terms of social skills and emotional behaviour. They have been to relatively few birthday parties (my older ones went to absolutely loads in Reception), fewer play dates and activities/clubs. Whilst it's all fairly 'back to normal' now, that important stage of whole class parties and free play at preschool/school has been missed almost entirely. This has a very obvious impact on friendship development.

My older ones are subjected to and have to tolerate really poor behaviour from others in their classes at secondary school. They are unable to play in teams for sports sometimes because others just don't turn up. They have inter house/form competitions that are often forfeited because of many pupils just not participating. Many of their friends don't want to join in with anything or meet up at weekends. In their cases, social media, phones and screen time are a MASSIVE problem. These kids literally don't want to put their phone or controller down and leave the house, almost ever. My DC are fairly unusual in that they participate in after school clubs and sports teams and come for dog walks and bike rides as a family etc. We are outliers as parents in terms of how controlling we are about the use of phones and devices at home. I would say that my DC absolutely see and feel the benefit of these choices and don't really want to spend more time engaging online.

I did some lay teaching in HE and agree with previous comments. The students all seemed to need special accommodations, like not waiting with others or not being assessed in the mornings. Endless queries for black and white, right or wrong, directions for exams/assessments and needing endless extensions to deal with fairly run of the mill life events. As these were vocational courses into structured careers, it was really hard to see how these young people were readying themselves for their future careers (that simply can't accommodate individual needs to that extent).

There are huge societal issues feeding into all these problems and they're going to need huge resources and will to change. It cannot be left solely to schools and teachers to correct the course.

JustAMinutePleass · 05/12/2023 08:49

Kids being kids. Shocking. If your daughter wants impeccable behaviour all the time she should teach adults.

Sensibleandboring · 05/12/2023 08:48

BelindaOkra · 05/12/2023 06:59

I work with kids who are out of school - primary and secondary. There are growing numbers of children and young people who cannot cope with school. There used to be a bit more choice in school style - my youngest went to a free school with quite a different approach for example. First names for teachers, project based learning etc. it suited him. He did well with that, was always an anxious child and that very human approach built his confidence and worked well with him.

Schools now pretty much have to be bootcamp, The govt loves the Michaela style or slogan shouting style schools. My youngest son’s school is now bootcamp. And there are whole bunch of kids who can’t cope with that style of school, and a whole bunch who don’t care & fight against it. But there is little room for schools to do anything except be very very directive & disciplined and imo it doesn’t work with kids who are not able to regulate well. And they end up out of school.

Immature uni kids are interesting - these are people who have reached a certain standard & won’t be the huge disrupters.. But again in an education system & exam system that does not support thinking for yourself. Which of course is what they should be doing at university.

Yes also, if your child falls within the approximately 20% of the population considered highly sensitive, these bootcamp schools would not suit

TiredEvenForAPhoenix · 05/12/2023 08:46

AutismProf · 04/12/2023 23:16

My opinions, for what they are worth:

The rise of smartphones mean parents (especially mums, sorry to say, as they tend to be main carer on mat leave) are not co-regulating with their infants as much or as well. They are looking over baby's shoulder at their phone while feeding, instead of into their eyes. This has a huge impact on emotional regulation and language development. And so it goes on, with parental attention repeatedly drawn away from parent/child interaction, send then very young children given screens to keep them quiet and compounding that loss of interaction.

COVID exacerbated this because young children were sharing space with parents trying to work and having to dismiss their very young children's bids for attention and interaction repeatedly. There was also a loss of opportunities for social growth in baby and toddler groups, nurseries, playdates etc. So vulnerabilities were exacerbated.

With older kids, the impact was more on missing underpinning curricular skills (more than knowledge content) eg missing reception and year 1 has had a big impact on current year 4 and 5 who missed the chance to really consolidate early skill acquisition in literacy and numeracy. Many have caught up of course, but again, pre-existing vulnerabilities are exaggerated. Older kids missed early independence skills - my most impacted kid was about to do GCSEs when COVID struck, his year struggled with A levels exams as hadn't been through the GCSE system, and also limited independence in things like nights out with mates, first trips off camping with friends, etc. he started uni a long way behind, maturity wise, but has made massive progress.

This has all been compounded by a newly challenging "Gove" curriculum which only started a couple of years pre pandemic and which places huge expectations on very young children. With COVID impact many simply haven't been able to reach the incredibly challenging expectations on them academically, and the government has gone very little to help. They certainly haven't stressed play, socialisation, and independence skills which are the fundamental prerequisites really - a little support was offered for knowledge catch up but that was a misunderstanding of the most vital stuff kids missed in lockdown. This means that teachers are trying to get kids to do things that a higher proportion than before COVID are simply not able to attain. These kids by the time they are in year 8 or 9 know they aren't going to pass GCSEs in these subjects, there's no alternative curriculum or qualifications offered in most schools, is it any wonder they don't see the point? And start mucking about, swearing etc? They are exposed to their own inability to meet expectations every day. I think I would get ground down in that situation, too.

Edited

I breastfed a baby pre-smartphone and would read a book, put the tv on or chat to a friend/family member while feeding. Newborns feed for hours and hours every day - has anyone ever gazed into the baby's eyes for the full duration?

I absolutely agree with a lot of your points by the way but I'd hate for a new mum to read that comment and find something else to feel guilty about - breastfeeding takes up an enormous amount of day and night in the first couple of months and I'm sure every mother since the dawn of time has found ways to entertain herself during it without unbroken eye contact.

Hadebough · 05/12/2023 08:40

Schools are outdated. The way they expect children to learn is outdated. The pressures on kids these days is massive inside and outside of school who can blame them for becoming disengaged. If most kids in schools are misbehaving then really we need to look at the way schools work.
the education system needs to be completely changed.