Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to believe that some children in the classroom are acting as if they are three or four years younger than their actual age.

137 replies

Coldcaller · 04/12/2023 19:56

DD 2 is a science teacher in ordinary Comprehensive school where grade 5 in English and Math's hovers around 40% and about 25% of pupils are in receipt of FSM. Therefore, in all probability it is a very average Secondary School. DD 2 is very reticent about continuing to teach at the school or possibly to give up teaching totally. This is down to the behavior of many of the children and DD was continually given the bottom sets to teach in year 7, 8 and 9. because she appeared to the SLT to be the teacher who could mostly engage with them. The behavior never mind any interest in the subject from many of the kids is horrific, swearing fighting refusal to sit down and general anarchy being regular. Despite the appearance DD was getting depressed teaching these groups and was using all her efforts on classroom management and not teaching. A lack of interest in handling the difficult and disengaged kids is shown by members of the SLT. This, means classroom teachers are asked to continue teaching even if swearing is heard as long if it is not aimed at the teacher. There is no point sending a child out, for swearing because SLT will just re admit the child to the class . Isolation is the last resort and would probably require a physical assault to have taken place for it to be in-acted.

DD went to the head of Science and the Headteacher 4 weeks ago saying that she was not enjoying teaching and was thinking of quitting teaching. The truth was she had an interview for a Chemistry teacher for a Co-ed Independent, where the benchmark for GCSE grades are 8 and 9's . Despite having the interview, the head of Science talked her round, convincing her that she would be putting the department in a huge hole if she left. Because DD 2 is nice but naive, she agreed to stay at least until the end of July 2024. This, was on the proviso she would be teaching the top sets in years 9, 10 and 11. The behavior of her current year 10 top set Double Science is currently causing her concern for their immaturity . The kids don't swear or fight but act like 11 year old's. 15 year old girls putting their hands up and telling silly tales, boys laughing at very immature behavior reminiscent of year 6 boys. These kids are expected to get between grades 5 -8 in Double Science in June 2025 and DD says her top pupil is currently in line for a 4 if lucky ! DD is expected to plug the gaps left by the ex teacher in year 10 and these kids are the schools 'Cream'..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
K4tM · 09/12/2023 21:51

Can I just say, teaching does wear you down, but there are a lot of good kids out there? And they are the majority, not the minority.

Curriculums may be outdated, but it’s still good to be able to evaluate data or interpret a graph. Critical thinking, if you like. I tell my students a GCSE in Science is a thing to have and they always agree (with the odd exception). We give them a lot of love, and they, for the most part, respond.

There’s always an argument for reform, but it’s helpful if people are not bringing us down and fighting against us. We’re doing our best and I feel as though the parents of the students I teach understand that and are supportive of us as well.

Idk about the rise in kids with special needs like ASD or ADHD. I suspect they’ve always been there but have previously slipped between the cracks and ended up up not coming to school at all. I also suspect some kids are mis diagnosed by some parents pushing for a diagnosis for a kid that’s perfectly normal, just not achieving as the parent might hope. And some kids with poor behaviour - speak to their parents and they are at a loss too. They often don’t know what to do and ask for help from us.

Screens are partly to blame, it’s true, but they are the new reality so we have to advocate their creative use, else miss out on a huge opportunity. I get my students to watch short revision videos on YouTube, download podcasts, video practicals and use clickable quizzes online. It’s much easier than slogging through a revision guide! How I wish this had been available when I was studying.

Finally, although covid is now behind us, it has had an impact. My own children rarely go out! I wish they would but they are too comfortable at home. But this impact can’t last forever - I think 100 years ago they were dealing with worse (WW1 and ‘flu). But then they didn’t have smartphones, did they? Much of the social commentary from that time is now lost, but it might be interesting to know what was being said of ‘the youth of today’ back then.

iloveeverykindofcat · 06/12/2023 06:15

@sashh I've only ever taught adults (18+). Its not that they're disruptive, but I agree with previous posters that there's a huge gap in maturity, responsibility and self-discipline from where they need to be at university. Not all students - by no means. Plenty are ready, and are an absolute pleasure to work with. But something has changed in the past few years, and its getting worse.

sashh · 06/12/2023 06:05

JustAMinutePleass · 05/12/2023 08:49

Kids being kids. Shocking. If your daughter wants impeccable behaviour all the time she should teach adults.

LOL.

I've done that, you would not believe how some adults behave.

Not doing home work, complaining that they have not been taught something they have.

I think the best was a complaint that I was, "trying to get us to do your job", that was because I'd asked a class, "What do you already know about X?"

Second to that was I'd marked a piece of work done for another teacher who had left. It wasn't very good so it didn't achieve a pass grade, apparently I'd marked her down because I'm racist!

I realise some names are more common in some communities but this student had a name like, "Mary Smith".

iloveeverykindofcat · 06/12/2023 04:57

@Inthebathagain Here's a readable article that summarises some of the recent research: https://theweek.com/health-and-wellness/1025836/tiktok-brain-and-attention-spans
What particularly concerns me is that the TikTok model is incredibly successful. Other platforms are now imitating it - hence YouTube shorts, Instagram Reels, etc. I'm a huge advocate of critical media literacy - I teach university, so no idea how this would work for children, but I find that young people are much more likely to be selective in their media usage once they better understand how they are being exploited and monetized via these platforms. I'm not saying its impossible for people to use sites like TikTok in healthy ways, I'm sure some do, particularly adults whose attention span and critical thinking skills are already well developed. But its designed to be addictive, and its business model depends on addiction, just like the gambling industry.

Ponyo911 · 05/12/2023 21:04

I really do think that, as another poster up thread mentioned, the immaturity from children is mainly a product of over-coddling parents. Even the OP is starting a thread about their ADULT daughters profession on behalf of their ADULT daughter. Mumsnet wasn't around when I was in my 20s but if it was, I can guarantee my mum would not be posting on there worried about my career choices. At work, the number of clients whose parents call on their behalf is increasing. Adult babies we call them. OP let your children be adults and make their own decisions. And then hopefully when they have children, they'll be out of nappies in time for school.

MalcolmsMiddle · 05/12/2023 20:55

NonanteNeuf · 05/12/2023 10:12

Beautiful demonstration of a big root of the problem.

Exactly. Parental involvement, then parental involvement then some more parental involvement is key. I work in educational data but never been a teacher so I hope I'm not being dismissed as biased in what I say. The trust I work for currently has 8 schools all with quite different profiles but the results absolutely follow the IDACI/PP "stereotype/profile". If kids don't feel they have to learn they won't.

Longma · 05/12/2023 19:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 19:20

That’s interesting as a relative has PCOS and a child with ASD and a speech delay.

Schooldinner2 · 05/12/2023 19:17

Sorry yes obviously not all severe asd is fasd.
however there is no talk about fasd. And the only kids diagnosed seem to be adopted.

with a dc with likely asd i know its not that as i didnt drink at all in pregnancy. (I do have pcos though..).
If it turnedcout to be high blood sugar or thyroid etc that would be somewhat good news as that would be hopefully treatable.
There are links out there saying a link to higher asd in pcos. (Not enough to cause this increase though. And increase from hacing GD early in pregnancy.
i saw a chart showing higher adhd in younger parents and higher asd in older bascially a sweet spot. Although the adhd could easily be increased genetic likelihood of having kids young through impulsive behaviour.

Inthebathagain · 05/12/2023 18:59

I want to hear more from you @iloveeverykindofcat

I've been saying to anyone who listens over the past 10 years that social media, the need for instantaneous responses and the addiction to screens have somehow played with our brain make up, and children are now being born with these changes.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/12/2023 17:06

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 10:37

But why is it so much more common now?

The termed was only coined in 2017 I believe. It used to come under various umbrellas but now it's recognised as a standalone disorder, not a leaning difficulty.

It affects about 8% of kids so approx 1 million in the UK apparently which is far more than common than autism and yet far less well known. I'm certain it's often misdiagnosed and people jump to autism when there can be other explanations.

I think the bulk of the increase is simply greater awareness of it being a diagnosis in its own right.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 05/12/2023 16:26

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 09:33

The problem is we have now moved to a culture where parents are less responsible for their children than wider society.

Wrote a long paragraph, posted too soon, went to edit then lost it argh. But essentially we have moved to a culture where support services are seen as being ultimately responsible for the actions of both children and parents. As the previous poster said, if the child has any problems the first response is ‘what are the school doing’.

Edited

This. I taught abroad and the tales I hear from my teacher friends are absolutely mad compared to what it was like there. Literally a different planet. But in that country, the government wasn't responsible for looking after all parents and kids in the way that's expected here.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 16:04

People have started to confuse children with small adults I think. They say ‘you wouldn’t make an adult ask permission to use the toilet’ but they are forgetting children and adults are not the same. Children don’t process information like adults do, they couldn’t care less about long term consequences (grown up life seems a million years away) and someone else is ultimately responsible for their food, roof over their head, and expenses. In the moment they need a sharp shock and real consequences, not to ‘help them understand the moral of the story’ but basically to moderate their behaviour until such a time they’ll understand why moderating it themselves is actually better for them. But that won’t be when they’re 5, or even 15.

JudgeJ · 05/12/2023 15:52

JustAMinutePleass · 05/12/2023 08:49

Kids being kids. Shocking. If your daughter wants impeccable behaviour all the time she should teach adults.

Typical of MN, always some who support shitty behaviour, the sort who turns on the school if any attempt is made to discipline their child. Often they can't manage a couple of children and support their children's appalling behaviour.

JudgeJ · 05/12/2023 15:46

IMHO the blame can surely only lie with parents. This is about children who are disruptive and disrespectful to professional adults or authority. No idea on how to behave. Not all of those children are ND.

They can do these things because there are no sanctions, if a parent objects then they can't be kept in detention, given lines because they're 'dehumanising' as I once told, the power lies with parents and so many couldn't care less, know all their rights but have no responsibilities. You only have to read MN where schools are expected to sort out so many problems that are not their responsibilities and posters keep their children as babies for far too long.

TiredEvenForAPhoenix · 05/12/2023 15:26

Where is the link to overweight parents having children with additional needs @Schooldinner2 ? Or a mother with pcos or diabetes? I've never heard that young parents increase likelihood of adhd in children, where has that come from?

Also, there has always been carpet time; I remember carpet time when I was in Reception in the 80s! Germs have always been rife in school.

I've certainly read on here before that improved infant survival rates might explain some increase in developmental delays or additional needs as very premature babies are more likely to live nowadays and might have ongoing needs which makes sense. And at the same time, schools are perpetually trying to do more with less so there is very little individual support remaining in classrooms.

x2boys · 05/12/2023 15:16

Schooldinner2 · 05/12/2023 15:08

Theres been a large shift in say 10 years to older parents. There always was women over 40 but its moved from 20yo in a generation to 30yo.
But with a large variation in a class so 1-2 with 20-25yo parents many whose parents were 26-30 some 30-6 and odd one or 2 up to 45.
Or having pcos thyroid issues or diabetes or overweight
I think young parents higher adhd risk and older ones higher asd.
But also apparently 5% of kids have fasd. The only severe asd child i know of in nappies and no speech was an alcoholic. The other asd kids have say a mum on medication in pregnancy or as i say older parents over 35. Previuosly when people had 4+ kids the kids were forced to be more flexible by parents or plder sibs.
There was no silly carpet time where you are sat too close.
Illness like ear infections and tonsilitis can affect behaviour.

At secondary dc has had kids kicking the stool next to her. Swearing. And this is art!

The primary curriculum probably is fine - for the eldest in the year but too fast for some others.
Some kids have missed 70% of a year of primary between covid 2 lockdowns, Queen funeral, coronation, off for testing or class cases, strikes. But even if not the teaching lost the kids who werent in for strikes were out roaming with no supervision and has affected their later attendance.
Eldest did fine on ks2 sats but obviously the science sats dont exist. And they missed science history and geography during covid.
I think secondaries need to set more subjects. Her spanish tests some got 0 and had to retake compared to others getting full marks.

Thanks for that🙄
My son is severely autistic and non verbal.and I know many children like him non of the mothers are alcoholics autism even severe autism is not the same as Foetal alcohol syndrome .

Schooldinner2 · 05/12/2023 15:08

Theres been a large shift in say 10 years to older parents. There always was women over 40 but its moved from 20yo in a generation to 30yo.
But with a large variation in a class so 1-2 with 20-25yo parents many whose parents were 26-30 some 30-6 and odd one or 2 up to 45.
Or having pcos thyroid issues or diabetes or overweight
I think young parents higher adhd risk and older ones higher asd.
But also apparently 5% of kids have fasd. The only severe asd child i know of in nappies and no speech was an alcoholic. The other asd kids have say a mum on medication in pregnancy or as i say older parents over 35. Previuosly when people had 4+ kids the kids were forced to be more flexible by parents or plder sibs.
There was no silly carpet time where you are sat too close.
Illness like ear infections and tonsilitis can affect behaviour.

At secondary dc has had kids kicking the stool next to her. Swearing. And this is art!

The primary curriculum probably is fine - for the eldest in the year but too fast for some others.
Some kids have missed 70% of a year of primary between covid 2 lockdowns, Queen funeral, coronation, off for testing or class cases, strikes. But even if not the teaching lost the kids who werent in for strikes were out roaming with no supervision and has affected their later attendance.
Eldest did fine on ks2 sats but obviously the science sats dont exist. And they missed science history and geography during covid.
I think secondaries need to set more subjects. Her spanish tests some got 0 and had to retake compared to others getting full marks.

stickygotstuck · 05/12/2023 14:42

BelindaOkra · 05/12/2023 06:59

I work with kids who are out of school - primary and secondary. There are growing numbers of children and young people who cannot cope with school. There used to be a bit more choice in school style - my youngest went to a free school with quite a different approach for example. First names for teachers, project based learning etc. it suited him. He did well with that, was always an anxious child and that very human approach built his confidence and worked well with him.

Schools now pretty much have to be bootcamp, The govt loves the Michaela style or slogan shouting style schools. My youngest son’s school is now bootcamp. And there are whole bunch of kids who can’t cope with that style of school, and a whole bunch who don’t care & fight against it. But there is little room for schools to do anything except be very very directive & disciplined and imo it doesn’t work with kids who are not able to regulate well. And they end up out of school.

Immature uni kids are interesting - these are people who have reached a certain standard & won’t be the huge disrupters.. But again in an education system & exam system that does not support thinking for yourself. Which of course is what they should be doing at university.

This is, in a way, a very 'helpful' post for me personally.

It articulates very well that feeling I keep having that 'school is not supposed to be like this'.

I have a bright teen DC who can barely cope with school (ND). All her energy goes into putting up with 'hours in prison, with a lot of unfair and pointless rules' - as she puts it. While all the joy of learing has gone.

She says that behaviour is generally awful, that a lof of her peers are 'disgusting and stupid' (we gather she means immature) and she feels trapped and drowing everyday surrounded by them.

This is a local well-regarded school, with a long-standing reputation pre-pandemic BTW.

I'm certain she'd actually enjoy school and get a lot out of it in a 'free -school' type of place. Or, as we used to call them when I was a teen, 'a school'. As it is, she is being crushed, everything feels pointless.

There is no way we can afford to HE, but I find myself thinking daily that she'd be better off out of school altogether.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 14:03

x2boys · 05/12/2023 13:43

Your right in some ways though in my town we have four special schools ,two primary ,and two secondary ,all.of them have doubled in capacity in the last few years i have my own personal thoughts about some of the reasons for this .

Would you mind sharing them?

x2boys · 05/12/2023 13:43

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 13:14

I think there could be some truth in that. I’m really struggling to think of what children come in contact with more now than they used to. There’s been TV for years, both my parents smoked, mums used to drink wine in pregnancy albeit in smallish amounts, there’s always been ‘chemicals’ (asbestos, lead paint etc) and junk food definitely isn’t a new invention. I’m wracking my brains. I worry if they don’t find out soon we will end up with an absolutely enormous cohort of disabled adults that the system just won’t be able to cope with alongside the ageing population and a smaller workforce as it is.

Your right in some ways though in my town we have four special schools ,two primary ,and two secondary ,all.of them have doubled in capacity in the last few years i have my own personal thoughts about some of the reasons for this .

x2boys · 05/12/2023 13:39

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 12:59

What kind of learning disabilities? Was it tied to a concrete diagnosis? I think you’ve misunderstood what I meant (sorry I probably didn’t word it well), but I meant the rise of non verbal children with some kind of learning disability (very usually autism) where there is no clear medical reason for this, like with @x2boys son who has a genetic condition. I mean children who for no reason just don’t develop as expected, their speech is behind, they have autistic traits or ADHD traits. These type of children just seem to be far far far more common than they ever were before. I live in a large town and there are probably 2 or 3 posts to our mums fb chat about children who are behind with speech and have asd/adhd.

I don’t think it’s the fault of ‘lazy parents’ I have already said this. I have a feeling there is something else behind it but what that is I have no idea.

Another reason might be your hearing about it more now with the internet and online forums and chat groups etc,20,30years ago when the internet was in its infancy and before ,people just didn't use the same connections they do now

squirrelnutkin10 · 05/12/2023 13:24

It is very sad to hear this but ultimately it is poor parenting that has led to this.

Parents need to take responsibility for their childrens bad behavior.

I feel so sorry for both the teachers and the well behaved children whose life chances are being eroded but the disruptive ones.

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 13:14

Leah5678 · 05/12/2023 13:08

Last time I spoke to her parents they said she was being tested for autism If I remember rightly. My comment about people blaming lazy parents was more aimed at people in general who believe that then you specifically.

I have a personal theory that the rise in learning disabilities in children may be related to the rise in cancer and that the many things which cause cancer may also affect children's brains. I appreciate there might not be any actual proof for that though

I think there could be some truth in that. I’m really struggling to think of what children come in contact with more now than they used to. There’s been TV for years, both my parents smoked, mums used to drink wine in pregnancy albeit in smallish amounts, there’s always been ‘chemicals’ (asbestos, lead paint etc) and junk food definitely isn’t a new invention. I’m wracking my brains. I worry if they don’t find out soon we will end up with an absolutely enormous cohort of disabled adults that the system just won’t be able to cope with alongside the ageing population and a smaller workforce as it is.

Leah5678 · 05/12/2023 13:08

Naptrappedmummy · 05/12/2023 12:59

What kind of learning disabilities? Was it tied to a concrete diagnosis? I think you’ve misunderstood what I meant (sorry I probably didn’t word it well), but I meant the rise of non verbal children with some kind of learning disability (very usually autism) where there is no clear medical reason for this, like with @x2boys son who has a genetic condition. I mean children who for no reason just don’t develop as expected, their speech is behind, they have autistic traits or ADHD traits. These type of children just seem to be far far far more common than they ever were before. I live in a large town and there are probably 2 or 3 posts to our mums fb chat about children who are behind with speech and have asd/adhd.

I don’t think it’s the fault of ‘lazy parents’ I have already said this. I have a feeling there is something else behind it but what that is I have no idea.

Last time I spoke to her parents they said she was being tested for autism If I remember rightly. My comment about people blaming lazy parents was more aimed at people in general who believe that then you specifically.

I have a personal theory that the rise in learning disabilities in children may be related to the rise in cancer and that the many things which cause cancer may also affect children's brains. I appreciate there might not be any actual proof for that though