Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 14:28

@Seagrassbasket there is nothing wrong with my rhetoric. You are talking about people like they are numbers on a spreadsheet.

The reason the country has a failing NHS or failing schools or a crumbling welfare state isn't because a small number of British people bring their spouses here.

The country didn't even have a legislated workplace pension scheme place until the last decade. So you now have millions of retired Brits pulling from inhumanely low pensions, trying to survive in record inflation without their heating on.

Now all of a sudden, every single problem the country has is being blamed on immigration.

So yes, I do have an emotional response when someone claims the government needs to "hedge bets" against spouses and that we are a burden on the system.

I am confident that even if the government deported every single immigrant tomorrow, the country would still face the exact same problems everyone has pointed out in this thread.

Low wages. Crumbling healthcare. Housing crisis. Ageing population.

There would be just no boogeyman to blame.

chaosmaker · 06/12/2023 14:27

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:45

The wages will need to go up and people in the UK on benefits who are fit and healthy will need to be "compelled" to pick up these jobs, their benefits will need to be cut until they feel the urge to work for a living.

Then care is not the right sector to shove those people in and force them to work. Do you think the workshy should be foisted on vulnerable people so they can work? I'd rather shove them somewhere unimportant, like an office.

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 14:20

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 12:39

You do realise that you are basically saying the UK should create a system for British people to only reproduce with someone in the UK if they are British?

Not everyone has kids as soon as they arrive here. In many of the immigration forums (Reddit, ExpatForum etc), a lot of people actually delay having children until they are permanent residents- so five years.

So, even after 5 years of paying excess into the system, would you agree they can reproduce then? Or should Brits with foreign spouses have a child ban placed on them?

Oh for christs sake. I absolutely did not say that anywhere. (Puts head in hands).

Look you clearly have skin in the game here, and as I acknowledged anyone with an emotional connection to this is going to have an emotional response.

The fact is that there are thousands of people up and down the country who every day make decisions which balance the wants/needs/rights of the individual with the need to keep a society and public services functioning and the taxpayer to get value for money. This, albeit crudely and with a blunt tool, is what the government is doing on a much wider scale. 10% is quite a lot of percent really after all.

Responses and rhetoric like this is why we can’t have an adult reasonable discussion as a society about these sorts of issues and is part of the reason we’re in this bloody mess.

Edited to say - for the record, I absolutely don’t think this should apply to people already in the UK. That is just bloody cruel.

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 14:16

RedRidingGood · 06/12/2023 13:02

@CrashyTime As someone who is here on a Spousal visa, I think you do not understand how hard and expensive it is, even for someone on a 6 figure salary like myself and DH. As my very reputable immigration lawyer told me, the % of sham marriages is very low. People go by media headlines and think it forms a high % of marriages but that isn't the case.
Also for what it's worth the "blame the foreigner" rhetoric from the government is currently being used to mask their failings. Don't fall for it.

I dont fall for it, the UKs problems are mainly caused by the global debt bubble and ordinary folk thinking buying up loads of property with debt was the way to wealth, fix that problem and lots of other problems fix themselves, but in the meantime anything that puts downward pressure on rents and house prices is to be welcomed.

Oliotya · 06/12/2023 13:58

If we're going to account for the potential healthcare and benefits a migrant may at some point access, shouldn't we also account for all the healthcare and education they didn't get from us? Surely the cost of 12+ years of education alone more than covers a baby or 2.

EasternStandard · 06/12/2023 13:58

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:33

@Weegie91 I was replying to Arafina about her point on people in the U.K. not caring about immigration.

Edited

You’re right the 750k figure did get reaction, including on mn but elsewhere even more likely

Arafina · 06/12/2023 13:56

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:24

@Arafina May be you have not read the official reports on net migration from the last two years? This is not longer something people are pretending is not happening and the facts are concerning. Hence, the government trying to make it less of an issue.

I haven't read it, I'm just talking about the spin "it's what the people want" who are those people? I've never met them and no official body has asked me my opinion, it's all a smoke and mirrors to detract from the carnage that they have made of the immigration system

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:48

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:20

Its is misleading if you talk about the additional cost to the public purse of the person. Whether they become a citizen or not is irrelevant to the financial cost to society.

I stand by my point.

You can look it from another angle. You have immigrants disproportionally paying into a system they can't use (benefits, UC etc). So where is all the extra money going? Immigrants can't access it... so are immigrants subsidising British people?

Arafina · 06/12/2023 13:48

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:18

The problem is too much demand for too few public services. We could fix this by investing in training up e.g more doctors/nurses. But our society has chosen to, and keeps voting in parties with such policies, not do that and instead actively discourage people from these careers with poor pay rises, removing financial support for training etc. So if we don't want to do that, then the other answer is to throttle demand down by stopping immigration (debatable whether this works given most of the demand caused by old British people). The public seems to keep asking for this option and the parties are doing it.

I get what you're saying and of course we should be investing in training etc but my point is that I don't think it's the common man/woman that's choosing not to do this, it's government and they are using immigration as a scapegoat to hide behind, I'm saying that immigration isn't an everyday conversation in my circle anyway but it's possible that the average person could be asked a leading question and be led to the conclusion that everything that's wrong in this country is because of immigration which anyone with an ounce of critical thinking will know is absolute bollocks

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:39

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:33

@Weegie91 I was replying to Arafina about her point on people in the U.K. not caring about immigration.

Edited

I get that. I still think it’s important for the public to recognise that spousal applications have actually fallen and are not the issue.

This government allowed for hundreds of thousands of people to come in and plug gaps for skill shortages. And issued half a million student visas.

spousal visas make up less than 10%.

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:33

@Weegie91 I was replying to Arafina about her point on people in the U.K. not caring about immigration.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:29

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:26

Same here. Paid thousands of £££ in extra fees for the NHS on top of my taxes and can’t even get a GP appointment. My wife has private healthcare at her company which is lucky.

There you are. The U.K. would not be my first choice if I were emigrating now.

If we could go back in time we would make a different choice as well. We decided to live in the UK because we met here when I was on a youth visa travelling. If we knew the process like we do now, we would’ve just moved back to my home country.

wellwellso · 06/12/2023 13:29

@JassyRadlett Look, I don't know why you are following me. I did not respond to you, I responded to another poster and my post referred to them and they replied graciously.

Self-funding as you quoted: Can you not even see that it is only possible because of a standard test they are applying (aka box ticking and nothing forensic)? Of course nothing prevents people affected from asking the HO is come up with a system of invoicing total real time costs just before the decision is released, whether or not in their favourite. This then with a 10 year processing wait is just not helpful to anyone. So that's just that.

End of.

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:26

Same here. Paid thousands of £££ in extra fees for the NHS on top of my taxes and can’t even get a GP appointment. My wife has private healthcare at her company which is lucky.

There you are. The U.K. would not be my first choice if I were emigrating now.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:26

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:24

@Arafina May be you have not read the official reports on net migration from the last two years? This is not longer something people are pretending is not happening and the facts are concerning. Hence, the government trying to make it less of an issue.

Have you read the report? Because it states net migration for spousal visas (what this thread is about) have actually dropped.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:25

Zamzamzamdeedah · 06/12/2023 13:24

Most eu immigrants I know fly back to EU for doctors... It's simply often faster. I did too.

Same. I have a friend from France who has lived here for 10 years and she hasn’t ever used the NHS. She flies back to France.

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 13:24

@Arafina May be you have not read the official reports on net migration from the last two years? This is not longer something people are pretending is not happening and the facts are concerning. Hence, the government trying to make it less of an issue.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:24

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:22

Would be a good idea based on my wife's experience.....has to pay the NI, the surcharge and then has to pay private because the NHS can't give timely appointments.

Same here. Paid thousands of £££ in extra fees for the NHS on top of my taxes and can’t even get a GP appointment. My wife has private healthcare at her company which is lucky.

Zamzamzamdeedah · 06/12/2023 13:24

Most eu immigrants I know fly back to EU for doctors... It's simply often faster. I did too.

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:22

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:21

You bring up a fantastic point though. I have thought for YEARS that instead of paying an NHS surcharge, immigrants should have the option to take our private healthcare instead on their applications.

That way every time the NHS starts crumbling, the government can’t blame us. Because we wouldn’t be using it, we would be private.

Would be a good idea based on my wife's experience.....has to pay the NI, the surcharge and then has to pay private because the NHS can't give timely appointments.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:21

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:13

This is somewhat misleading.

The visa says no recourse to public funds, but you can use the NHS which is publically funded. So it's actually no recourse to benefits. Once you get ILR after 5 years you can access benefits for life. The NHS surcharge and NI is similar in cost to the private health insurance I was required to have when I lived in Europe, so its not that different in cost to comparator countries.

So the no access is to specific benefits and only for the first 5 years.

Edited

You bring up a fantastic point though. I have thought for YEARS that instead of paying an NHS surcharge, immigrants should have the option to take our private healthcare instead on their applications.

That way every time the NHS starts crumbling, the government can’t blame us. Because we wouldn’t be using it, we would be private.

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:20

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:17

It’s not misleading at all.

After 5 years you become a British citizen. So immigrants cannot access benefits, but yes British citizens can.

Its is misleading if you talk about the additional cost to the public purse of the person. Whether they become a citizen or not is irrelevant to the financial cost to society.

bombastix · 06/12/2023 13:18

It is hard and expensive because there is a problem. Marriages may be authentic in as much as they are validly done, but actual relationships behind them are not the same. Each year people are investigated in the UK when they get married to UK citizens for passports. This is s business for some. Some women seek British men to be the paper fathers of their children, ie paid to placed on the birth certificate. It is investigating spouses who claim to have the right level of English for their visa. It is checking students are attending universities and language schools instead of working.

There are problems. And they are expensive to fix and resolve with legal appeals and investigations when you try. That costs more money. This is why the Government is getting tougher and setting hard rules because the basic issue is that once a person is in the UK it is very difficult to trace or remove them or even to get interviews to start these processes.

I think in the end we will slash visas for all and do a deal on mobility with the EU. After the next election. Because EU migrants are perceived to leave.

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:18

Arafina · 06/12/2023 13:15

Who are these "people" that are putting pressure on the government? I keep being told this but I've actually yet to meet anyone that has ever mentioned it apart from my immediate family when it's on the news, most of us are having conversations about things that are personal to us or things like the price of lurpak or pot hole damage, is immigration something that keeps people awake at night if it's not directly affecting their life like it is for those who are awaiting home office decisions

The problem is too much demand for too few public services. We could fix this by investing in training up e.g more doctors/nurses. But our society has chosen to, and keeps voting in parties with such policies, not do that and instead actively discourage people from these careers with poor pay rises, removing financial support for training etc. So if we don't want to do that, then the other answer is to throttle demand down by stopping immigration (debatable whether this works given most of the demand caused by old British people). The public seems to keep asking for this option and the parties are doing it.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 13:17

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 13:13

This is somewhat misleading.

The visa says no recourse to public funds, but you can use the NHS which is publically funded. So it's actually no recourse to benefits. Once you get ILR after 5 years you can access benefits for life. The NHS surcharge and NI is similar in cost to the private health insurance I was required to have when I lived in Europe, so its not that different in cost to comparator countries.

So the no access is to specific benefits and only for the first 5 years.

Edited

It’s not misleading at all.

After 5 years you become a British citizen. So immigrants cannot access benefits, but yes British citizens can.

Swipe left for the next trending thread