Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
CormorantStrikesBack · 06/12/2023 20:05

(The Prime Minister’s spokesman said that while the minimum income rules for family visas will not apply retrospectively, they will apply when existing visas for foreign spouses come up for renewal.

this is disgusting. People,will have made decisions based on the old rules, left their old lives behind, moved here, possibly have had children believing they were safe here because they comfortably met the requirements. And now they may be kicked out? Away from their children?

RedRidingGood · 06/12/2023 18:58

Isabellivi · 06/12/2023 18:25

Unfortunately citizens are not legally obligated to support their spouse after divorce so this law keeps a spouse from becoming tax payers liability. I do feel sorry for people but it’s not worth bankrupting services for our children and grandchildren!

There are billions of unskilled people from poor countries and it isn’t sustainable to our economic future to allow them all to become citizens and receive the benefits of developed public systems.

And unfortunately there is a lot of fraud. I know personally of an example of someone marrying a Russian woman for citizenship. She was alcoholic who spoke no English and had no job skills. She wasn’t capable of working because she drank liters of vodka all day and she had a disabled daughter (she drank while pregnant) who also became citizen.

After they got citizenship they were divorced and ejected from the house. They were of no use to the people who helped them immigrate so now they are entitled to free education, housing, and health care for all their medical issues. Lots of medical issues. Taxpayers are paying all this as they have no ability to pay into the system. They simply found a man who was willing to marry and support them for a few years. I think family in Russia paid for visa fraud somehow, or they were literally prostitutes since the daughter was 13 (I suspect both as possible)

This happens a lot! And it has also enabled organized crime from former Soviet countries Asia and Latin America. It isn’t fair to future generations. Would you let a bunch of homeless drug addicts come into your home and throw your children on the street? No, it would be very unfair

Are you seriously saying this is a fair policy based on your very unique anecdote?

WhenLoveIsDone · 06/12/2023 18:39

This happens a lot! And it has also enabled organized crime from former Soviet countries Asia and Latin America. It isn’t fair to future generations. Would you let a bunch of homeless drug addicts come into your home and throw your children on the street? No, it would be very unfair

Shh, my hubby don't know I'm a Latin American gangsta.

hides the machine gun under her large mustachios

You utter fool.

Thanks for your concern for our children. They're a bit more bothered that one of their parents faces deportation.

Oliotya · 06/12/2023 18:39

Isabellivi · 06/12/2023 18:25

Unfortunately citizens are not legally obligated to support their spouse after divorce so this law keeps a spouse from becoming tax payers liability. I do feel sorry for people but it’s not worth bankrupting services for our children and grandchildren!

There are billions of unskilled people from poor countries and it isn’t sustainable to our economic future to allow them all to become citizens and receive the benefits of developed public systems.

And unfortunately there is a lot of fraud. I know personally of an example of someone marrying a Russian woman for citizenship. She was alcoholic who spoke no English and had no job skills. She wasn’t capable of working because she drank liters of vodka all day and she had a disabled daughter (she drank while pregnant) who also became citizen.

After they got citizenship they were divorced and ejected from the house. They were of no use to the people who helped them immigrate so now they are entitled to free education, housing, and health care for all their medical issues. Lots of medical issues. Taxpayers are paying all this as they have no ability to pay into the system. They simply found a man who was willing to marry and support them for a few years. I think family in Russia paid for visa fraud somehow, or they were literally prostitutes since the daughter was 13 (I suspect both as possible)

This happens a lot! And it has also enabled organized crime from former Soviet countries Asia and Latin America. It isn’t fair to future generations. Would you let a bunch of homeless drug addicts come into your home and throw your children on the street? No, it would be very unfair

You do realise "our children and grandchildren" are also the children of these spouses. Equating spouses with, homeless drug addicts? Seriously? One person divorced their alcoholic wife? Hardly a representative study is it?
The thinly veiled racism and xenophobia is appalling.

Isabellivi · 06/12/2023 18:25

Unfortunately citizens are not legally obligated to support their spouse after divorce so this law keeps a spouse from becoming tax payers liability. I do feel sorry for people but it’s not worth bankrupting services for our children and grandchildren!

There are billions of unskilled people from poor countries and it isn’t sustainable to our economic future to allow them all to become citizens and receive the benefits of developed public systems.

And unfortunately there is a lot of fraud. I know personally of an example of someone marrying a Russian woman for citizenship. She was alcoholic who spoke no English and had no job skills. She wasn’t capable of working because she drank liters of vodka all day and she had a disabled daughter (she drank while pregnant) who also became citizen.

After they got citizenship they were divorced and ejected from the house. They were of no use to the people who helped them immigrate so now they are entitled to free education, housing, and health care for all their medical issues. Lots of medical issues. Taxpayers are paying all this as they have no ability to pay into the system. They simply found a man who was willing to marry and support them for a few years. I think family in Russia paid for visa fraud somehow, or they were literally prostitutes since the daughter was 13 (I suspect both as possible)

This happens a lot! And it has also enabled organized crime from former Soviet countries Asia and Latin America. It isn’t fair to future generations. Would you let a bunch of homeless drug addicts come into your home and throw your children on the street? No, it would be very unfair

RedRidingGood · 06/12/2023 16:11

MrsRachelDanvers · 06/12/2023 15:20

There’s a blinkered opinion that measures one’s value to society in purely monetary terms. So people earning less that 40k are a ‘drain on the system’. But we actually need people to work in jobs paying less than 38k. Who empties your bins? Looks after your toddlers? Makes your restaurant meals? Cares for livestock? Butchers your meat? Without those ‘drain on the system’ type jobs, our society would soon collapse. Enough of this myth that people earning under 40k take more out than they put in. However rich you are, you can’t do without those people. Are they less worthy of marriage?

Wow well put! :)

Arafina · 06/12/2023 15:39

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 15:11

@Arafina you have not read the reports or do not know the numbers yet talk about lacking of critical thinking. Probably just as a way to insult? Europe is receiving massive increases in immigration and is unsustainable. Overpopulation brings poverty and yes there is concern from governments across Europe. If you or your friends are indifferent to this fine but do not deny facts or gaslight others because you are perhaps an idealistic individual?

Edited

I'm not trying to gaslight anyone fgs just passing on my observations, obviously immigration needs to be controlled but I think this knee jerk reaction is cruel and unnecessary, panicking people who are in the process of visa applications by more than doubling the salary requirement is adding stress to an already stressful situation, maybe they should get their finger out. sort out all the pending asylum claims and allow those people to work which would bring down the job vacancies a little bit

Oliotya · 06/12/2023 15:38

I wonder what fraction of a fraction of net migration that this change to family visas will even affect?

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 15:33

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 15:29

“household as a whole”.

Does that include two couples living together, or four people living together? That would make it easier to hit the targets?

No it is based purely on a couple. The UK Home Office classifies the British spouse as the "sponsor" throughout the process. Plus, only the British spouse may use their income to meet the threshold during the first application if their spouse is outside of the UK.

So most couples will earn over £38k when they are both working. No problem. But the real barrier is that a lot of British people can't meet the threshold just with their income to meet the requirements of the first visa.

It's essentially a very cruel way of blocking the pathway for 75% of the population.

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 15:29

Another2Cats · 06/12/2023 15:18

@Oliotya From the Independent article you linked to it said:-

In a bid to allay concerns, No 10 clarified that the minimum income of £38,700 was for a “household as a whole”.

So that is £38.7k for both people combined.

At the moment, a person working a 37.5 hour week on minimum wage earns £20,319 per year and from next April will earn £22,308.

So, two people, each working full time on minimum wage will currently be earning £40,638 or £44,616 from next April. This is above the limit of £38.7k.

On the new minimum wage, if both people are working at least 32.75 hours per week then they will meet the income requirement.

Yes, it will definitely affect those whose spouses are not yet in the country. But for those whose spouses are already in this country then as long as they are both earning the equivalent of minimum wage for 32.75 hours per week then there is no problem.

“household as a whole”.

Does that include two couples living together, or four people living together? That would make it easier to hit the targets?

MrsRachelDanvers · 06/12/2023 15:20

There’s a blinkered opinion that measures one’s value to society in purely monetary terms. So people earning less that 40k are a ‘drain on the system’. But we actually need people to work in jobs paying less than 38k. Who empties your bins? Looks after your toddlers? Makes your restaurant meals? Cares for livestock? Butchers your meat? Without those ‘drain on the system’ type jobs, our society would soon collapse. Enough of this myth that people earning under 40k take more out than they put in. However rich you are, you can’t do without those people. Are they less worthy of marriage?

Another2Cats · 06/12/2023 15:18

@Oliotya From the Independent article you linked to it said:-

In a bid to allay concerns, No 10 clarified that the minimum income of £38,700 was for a “household as a whole”.

So that is £38.7k for both people combined.

At the moment, a person working a 37.5 hour week on minimum wage earns £20,319 per year and from next April will earn £22,308.

So, two people, each working full time on minimum wage will currently be earning £40,638 or £44,616 from next April. This is above the limit of £38.7k.

On the new minimum wage, if both people are working at least 32.75 hours per week then they will meet the income requirement.

Yes, it will definitely affect those whose spouses are not yet in the country. But for those whose spouses are already in this country then as long as they are both earning the equivalent of minimum wage for 32.75 hours per week then there is no problem.

Pomonas · 06/12/2023 15:11

@Arafina you have not read the reports or do not know the numbers yet talk about lacking of critical thinking. Probably just as a way to insult? Europe is receiving massive increases in immigration and is unsustainable. Overpopulation brings poverty and yes there is concern from governments across Europe. If you or your friends are indifferent to this fine but do not deny facts or gaslight others because you are perhaps an idealistic individual?

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 15:08

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 14:54

Yes it does.

A spouse visa lasts 2.5 years, then you have to apply for another one. When you do the latter the new salary thresholds will apply. So if you don't meet them the spouse will be deported.

Edited

So heading into a likely recession that isn`t looking good for a lot of people?

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 15:02

@Weegie91 you said:

‘You do realise that you are basically saying the UK should create a system for British people to only reproduce with someone in the UK if they are British?’

Thats hysteria really, and it’s just not true, when you compare it to my post. I didn’t say anything of the sort. So it just undermines everything else you’re saying.

I’m sorry about my language sounding cold. I spend most of my life divorcing my emotions from the decisions I make as a professional. I have expressed lots of sympathy and empathy on a human level though.

I’m not going to reply to you anymore. No disrespect I’m just done and we will never come to a middle ground I suspect.

Merry Christmas!

Addicted2Kale · 06/12/2023 15:01

No, it isn't fair. At all.

It should be £100,000.

EssexMan55 · 06/12/2023 14:54

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 14:44

That’s seems to be what people up thread have been saying. It might just be people panicking. I haven’t read the announcement myself.

Yes it does.

A spouse visa lasts 2.5 years, then you have to apply for another one. When you do the latter the new salary thresholds will apply. So if you don't meet them the spouse will be deported.

Weegie91 · 06/12/2023 14:51

Erm... Where was I shouting? Or being hysterical?

I was just pointing out how cold it was to use the language you were using, talking about government hedging bets and saying people need to contribute if they want to bring their spouse over... which they already do.

I am not shutting down any discussions. I am pointing out the many, many inaccuracies that people believe about spousal immigration to the UK. Hardly anybody understands the process, the costs and the restrictions.

You are right: A low wage economy with underfunded public services has us fucked.

But an overcorrection to banning British people from bringing their spouses here unless they earn above average median wage is hardly going to solve it.

Zamzamzamdeedah · 06/12/2023 14:49

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 14:44

That’s seems to be what people up thread have been saying. It might just be people panicking. I haven’t read the announcement myself.

I laos assumed before it would apply only to newcomers. Application of ghe rule to those already here and on that visa would be ultra shitty.

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 14:44

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 14:40

Does it apply if you are already here?

That’s seems to be what people up thread have been saying. It might just be people panicking. I haven’t read the announcement myself.

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 14:43

@Weegie91 but that’s the point I’m trying to get across. To the government we are all just numbers on a spreadsheet. Nothing in the country would function at all if we weren’t.

The problems in the UK are of course far far more complex than just blaming everything on immigration despite what the press would have us believe. A low wage economy with underfunded public services has us fucked.

But I think it’s unreasonable to just immediately shut down any discussions about whether it’s sensible to allow people to live here who might not be able to support themselves. And this is supposed to be a discussion. Not hysterically shouting at people who don’t agree with your views.

I really honestly do hope you can figure out your own situation to your satisfaction if you are affected by this.

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 14:43

chaosmaker · 06/12/2023 14:27

Then care is not the right sector to shove those people in and force them to work. Do you think the workshy should be foisted on vulnerable people so they can work? I'd rather shove them somewhere unimportant, like an office.

Fair points, office, gardening, cleaning etc. is more suitable for breaking someone away from their couch/weed habit.

CrashyTime · 06/12/2023 14:40

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 14:20

Oh for christs sake. I absolutely did not say that anywhere. (Puts head in hands).

Look you clearly have skin in the game here, and as I acknowledged anyone with an emotional connection to this is going to have an emotional response.

The fact is that there are thousands of people up and down the country who every day make decisions which balance the wants/needs/rights of the individual with the need to keep a society and public services functioning and the taxpayer to get value for money. This, albeit crudely and with a blunt tool, is what the government is doing on a much wider scale. 10% is quite a lot of percent really after all.

Responses and rhetoric like this is why we can’t have an adult reasonable discussion as a society about these sorts of issues and is part of the reason we’re in this bloody mess.

Edited to say - for the record, I absolutely don’t think this should apply to people already in the UK. That is just bloody cruel.

Edited

Does it apply if you are already here?

EasternStandard · 06/12/2023 14:34

The 750k was pretty high, various sectors do need people atm so some visas are necessary, there was discussion on here from some around dependants being too high

If it goes down to say 450k (everyone will have their own it’s too high number) I reckon pressure for policy change would decrease

Where not to decrease is around shortage occupations - ie keep those, it doesn’t leave much to change