Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
User123456713 · 08/12/2023 07:18

Realistically, reducing immigration even modestly is not going to happen unless Brits are OK with working several more years on average, and prepared to keep themselves in physically better shape so that they are able to do so

According to recent figures 145k care workers came in on visas (2022/23) they bought with then an ADDITIONAL 175k dependents.

Same with students.

& yes dependents can include parents plus no limit on family sizes, many dev countries have bigger families than most in Europe.

Why could we manage just a few years ago with migration around 200k net but now we need 750k but aren't even filling the vacancies? and why are we so reliant on students to fund Uni's ? if they are sooooo underfunded, why the fcuk was 20billion handed out in tax cut bribes?

Something is very amiss, so i disagree there is nothing we can do, just needs a change in political will.

waytooearlyforthis · 08/12/2023 06:46

SkyFullofStars1975 · 04/12/2023 20:36

If we stopped the 5 million unemployed from having an equivalent/better lifestyle on benefits to those working... we wouldn't need to import labour.

I don't think the Government will ever figure this out, mind.

Completely ignores the reason why some are unemployed and not everyone would want just about anyone doing care work for their relatives, I know I wouldn't

EasternStandard · 08/12/2023 06:30

user1477391263 · 08/12/2023 06:04

Realistically, reducing immigration even modestly is not going to happen unless Brits are OK with working several more years on average, and prepared to keep themselves in physically better shape so that they are able to do so.

I don't see much sign of this happening, though.

The Nordic and many East Asian countries seem to be able to manage OK-ish with less immigration, for the moment. (I know Sweden has quite a bit of immigration, but that seems to be about "being kind to refugees" rather than desperately trying to fill vacant posts). But these are countries where populations are slimmer, sprier and healthier into old age - more walking, better diet. And people of all ages have a more austere work ethic. Not saying that's always a good thing, to be honest, but it probably does help when it comes to getting older folk to stay in the workforce longer.

Meanwhile, in the UK, years of "healthy life expectancy" have gone down slightly, not up, in recent years, and obesity rates are worse than ever following the pandemic. I'm always seeing posts on here about people saying "AIBU to retire at 53?" The responses are generally along the lines of "as long as you've got the money, GO FOR IT, girl!" Of course, people do have the right to retire early if they have the private means to afford to do so. Just making the point that if you are a society which is broadly OK with this and is not inclined to shame those who retire from the workforce early, you'll need more immigration to fill the gaps.

Edited

You make good points. We are unhealthier generally and also less likely to do care at home. Both these mean higher immigration

We either see those high net migration figures that everyone went nuts about (although you can get them down a bit before getting to care workers) or we pay loads more for care homes, or we do it ourselves

Zamzamzamdeedah · 08/12/2023 06:18

CharlotteRumpling · 08/12/2023 06:13

Asian countries look after their elderly at home. We will be moving to that soon.

Interestingly that is now being under threat in many countries where it was a standard because families now have to work. DH's family is having that issue. The younger ones simply cannot afford for just 1 person to work anymore so there is nearly no one at home to do the care as it used to be. With the next gen who is soon entering adulthood, sahm/sahw (who was traditionally the carer) will be impossible financally for most people.

CharlotteRumpling · 08/12/2023 06:13

Asian countries look after their elderly at home. We will be moving to that soon.

user1477391263 · 08/12/2023 06:07

A lot of other over 55s I know have "retired" to basically do childcare for their grandchildren. The UK has among the highest daycare costs in the world, in part due to insisting on very high adult-child ratios. These could be reduced, but again, it's all about deciding that you are OK with some trade offs.

Starting to feel like we should build on all the golf courses, judging by the number of my father's doctor friends who have retired in their 50s to basically play golf all week....

user1477391263 · 08/12/2023 06:04

Realistically, reducing immigration even modestly is not going to happen unless Brits are OK with working several more years on average, and prepared to keep themselves in physically better shape so that they are able to do so.

I don't see much sign of this happening, though.

The Nordic and many East Asian countries seem to be able to manage OK-ish with less immigration, for the moment. (I know Sweden has quite a bit of immigration, but that seems to be about "being kind to refugees" rather than desperately trying to fill vacant posts). But these are countries where populations are slimmer, sprier and healthier into old age - more walking, better diet. And people of all ages have a more austere work ethic. Not saying that's always a good thing, to be honest, but it probably does help when it comes to getting older folk to stay in the workforce longer.

Meanwhile, in the UK, years of "healthy life expectancy" have gone down slightly, not up, in recent years, and obesity rates are worse than ever following the pandemic. I'm always seeing posts on here about people saying "AIBU to retire at 53?" The responses are generally along the lines of "as long as you've got the money, GO FOR IT, girl!" Of course, people do have the right to retire early if they have the private means to afford to do so. Just making the point that if you are a society which is broadly OK with this and is not inclined to shame those who retire from the workforce early, you'll need more immigration to fill the gaps.

Winter2020 · 07/12/2023 23:06

OhmygodDont · 05/12/2023 19:11

Yeah I mean I’d rather shit in my own hands and clap than wipe an adults bum for £11 an hour.

Tbh I’d probably actually throw up anyway so be pretty bad at the job. Can’t even be sick myself without it making me sick. Even those long snots make me nearly puke.

Care pays pretty much minimum wage. As do other sectors such as supermarkets and other retail; a lot of hospitality; a lot of leisure.

A lot of people find care unattractive when compared to similar money in another sector. It's not just the unpleasant parts of the job that are off putting but the fact you are unlikely to be able to influence your shifts much. They are likely to be random and anti-social hours. You are also likely to be put under pressure to do additional shifts when you don't want to. I think in other sectors you are more likely to have set hours and they are more likely to work around your preferences for e.g. mornings.

E.g. if you are a parent with a working partner why would you try to work around random care shifts when a supermarket will allow you fixed mornings or evenings for the same hourly rate?

Sectors that I mentioned above do also often pay more than care and have perks such as tips or staff discount.

I remember seeing an advert for an assistant for Subway the sandwich shop and realising on their first day making sanwiches they will earn the same as I do after years in care and all the training I have done (medication, safeguarding, autism, all sorts of health courses, fire warden, First aid etc etc. and the responsibility of the work we do). I expect they get a staff discount on the food too.

If you can force or incentivise people into work a lot of people are still going to go for anything other than care - that's why wages for care should rise in comparison to the other similar paying sectors.

Fortunately for me I really like my job but I can see parts of it are off-putting.

SoNotRainbowRhythms · 07/12/2023 20:04

WhenLoveIsDone · 07/12/2023 14:57

It's getting some media traction now, even in the Murdoch press.

We need to coordinate somehow, protest this en masse.

Is there a petition?

https://news.sky.com/story/amp/uk-citizens-will-have-fewer-rights-than-migrants-under-new-family-visa-rules-researchers-say-13024220

Search for a Facebook group called Reunite Families UK. There is an organisation campaigning against this. also Joint Council for Welfare Of Immigrants (JCWI)and I Love My Foreign Spouse on Face book. Look for these on Twitter too.

Weegie91 · 07/12/2023 14:36

Oliotya · 07/12/2023 14:19

I was browsing the Migration Observatory reports yesterday, and there's some very interesting stats on migrants earnings and occupations.IMO, it will be a painful transition if we block migration without filling the gaps first. These new restrictions are putting the cart before the horse and its neither fair nor sensible. I don't think it's a realistic expectation that "native" brits are able or willing to replace the lost taxes or labor.

I also looked deeper into some statistics after the discussions here yesterday. The latest statistics from Oxford found the only negative net contributors in the country were.... British natives.

Oliotya · 07/12/2023 14:19

Weegie91 · 07/12/2023 12:20

This is a very interesting take. In my case, I moved to the UK when I was 26. I am university educated and now a higher tax payer. In my case, the UK paid for none of the things talked about on this thread like childcare or university, but now I am paying disproportionally back into the system. Even if I had a child, I would still be a net contributor - by a wide margin.

So when folks talk about net contributors, consider that most immigrants aren't going to be using services that are the heaviest burden on the state, like schooling or state pensions. We literally arrive in our prime earning years to contribute.

I was browsing the Migration Observatory reports yesterday, and there's some very interesting stats on migrants earnings and occupations.IMO, it will be a painful transition if we block migration without filling the gaps first. These new restrictions are putting the cart before the horse and its neither fair nor sensible. I don't think it's a realistic expectation that "native" brits are able or willing to replace the lost taxes or labor.

whoamI00 · 07/12/2023 14:16

What does £38.7k annual salary mean? Does it mean double the minimum annual wage? Does it average annual earning? Where did the £38700 salary come from?

WhenLoveIsDone · 07/12/2023 14:10

Indeed. I'd rather pay for private health insurance (as is quite standard when working in foreign countries) than the NHS surcharge, as if I ever required such services at least I would be able to access them.

In fact it would also be good if NI were not deducted from spouses' wages, since on the whole they cannot claim benefits, draw a pension or use the NHS. For the most part such immigrants are paying for services they cannot avail themselves of.

By all means start charging them for that if they have the desire and means to apply for leave to remain or become a citizen. But as the welfare system is more generous in my country (as well as the health care system being more accessible), I'd have stayed at home if going on welfare were my nefarious endgame.

I just want to live with my family and pay my way.

Weegie91 · 07/12/2023 12:20

Oliotya · 06/12/2023 13:58

If we're going to account for the potential healthcare and benefits a migrant may at some point access, shouldn't we also account for all the healthcare and education they didn't get from us? Surely the cost of 12+ years of education alone more than covers a baby or 2.

This is a very interesting take. In my case, I moved to the UK when I was 26. I am university educated and now a higher tax payer. In my case, the UK paid for none of the things talked about on this thread like childcare or university, but now I am paying disproportionally back into the system. Even if I had a child, I would still be a net contributor - by a wide margin.

So when folks talk about net contributors, consider that most immigrants aren't going to be using services that are the heaviest burden on the state, like schooling or state pensions. We literally arrive in our prime earning years to contribute.

Oliotya · 07/12/2023 09:05

SutWytTi · 07/12/2023 05:50

This is so damaging for our country, in addition to being awful for those affected.

I work in a sector where talented people doing vital work that benefits all of our health would be at risk of deportation.

This government seems determined to break as much as it can this last year.

Yes, foreign born people are massively over represented in the health and social care industries, and there doesn't seem to be any plan to replace them now that they can't, or won't want to come. Scary really.

SutWytTi · 07/12/2023 05:50

Oliotya · 06/12/2023 14:50

It absolutely applies to people already here. People only months away from ILR will now be ineligible to apply, with no time to make the necessary changes.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/britons-downing-street-james-cleverly-prime-minister-gavin-barwell-b2458731.html

This is so damaging for our country, in addition to being awful for those affected.

I work in a sector where talented people doing vital work that benefits all of our health would be at risk of deportation.

This government seems determined to break as much as it can this last year.

Zamzamzamdeedah · 07/12/2023 05:36

Imho applying iy to renewal of already existing visa IS basicaly applying it retrospectively and that is shitty.

Crispedia · 07/12/2023 05:18

From Colin Yeo, immigration barrister.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?
exexpat · 06/12/2023 22:56

@Another2Cats I think the national pay scales thing just applies to overseas workers applying for visas in their own right; the family visa thing is purely on income (it's a separate section in the BBC news story).

And the problem with being a wife of a diplomat is that your career is very disrupted, so if/when they return to the UK after an overseas posting she probably will not have a job waiting for her, so her visa would be assessed on his income, as far as I understand the rules. But of course I hope I am wrong.

Another2Cats · 06/12/2023 22:17

@exexpat Sorry, also to say that if his wife is already in the UK and works then her salary is also counted towards the £38k requirement.

The bit about it only being the British spouse's salary applies just to families where the foreign spouse is not already in this country.

Another2Cats · 06/12/2023 22:14

exexpat · 06/12/2023 21:13

Does anyone know what the Foreign Office pays graduates in their mid-20s? I know one young diplomat-in-training who may have to hope for a first overseas posting before his wife's visa comes up for renewal, and a big pay rise before returning to the UK.

I am not sure of his current salary, but I suspect they would be in the ridiculous position of being allowed to live together while representing the UK overseas, in accommodation paid for by the British government, but not being eligible to live together in the UK. This is how cruel and stupid the policy is.

@exexpat According to the BBC, people employed on "national pay scales", for example nurses, teachers etc are exempt from these new higher limits.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-67623131

It may be the case that civil servants are also exempt as well, but I don't know.

As I understand things, graduates with five years experience (so mid to late 20s) will certainly be earning above this limit in any event.

Builder

Changes to UK visa requirements: Key points at-a-glance

Increasing minimum salary requirements is among a package of measures to cut migration to the UK.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-67623131

exexpat · 06/12/2023 21:44

@Seagrassbasket I have to hope you are right, though if we still have anything like the current lot in power, I would not be so sure.

And I wonder about people in the military too?

I know another young couple who are almost certainly going to be affected at visa renewal time (he is also mid-20s, they are both creative types, getting by but not in high-paying jobs). I don't know what they will do.

And there are others in my extended family who have already had to jump through hoops and some who have failed. One family spent two years in Ireland to get in on the Surinder Singh route, now no longer available post-Brexit; luckily I think the overseas spouse now has settled status so won't be caught out on the visa renewal.

Another who has been married decades but lived overseas; her husband has been unable to join her and their two children here after she came back to support elderly parents, and retrain in a different career (worthy but low paid), and yet another who is living and working in Asia with his wife and three children and will now probably never be able to return to the UK.

These are all British citizens, born and bred, who married years ago and had children, and will be denied the right to a family life in the country of their birth and citizenship purely on financial grounds.

Seagrassbasket · 06/12/2023 21:22

exexpat · 06/12/2023 21:13

Does anyone know what the Foreign Office pays graduates in their mid-20s? I know one young diplomat-in-training who may have to hope for a first overseas posting before his wife's visa comes up for renewal, and a big pay rise before returning to the UK.

I am not sure of his current salary, but I suspect they would be in the ridiculous position of being allowed to live together while representing the UK overseas, in accommodation paid for by the British government, but not being eligible to live together in the UK. This is how cruel and stupid the policy is.

In all honesty I would assume in those specific circumstances the rules would be, ahem, massaged.

Diplomats get a pass for a LOT of things.

exexpat · 06/12/2023 21:13

Does anyone know what the Foreign Office pays graduates in their mid-20s? I know one young diplomat-in-training who may have to hope for a first overseas posting before his wife's visa comes up for renewal, and a big pay rise before returning to the UK.

I am not sure of his current salary, but I suspect they would be in the ridiculous position of being allowed to live together while representing the UK overseas, in accommodation paid for by the British government, but not being eligible to live together in the UK. This is how cruel and stupid the policy is.