Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 20:30

It’s quite staggering that people simply don’t understand the economic of low skilled migration. No one earning under £38k is a net contributor. If we are importing people who are not net contributors, will need more people to come in and pay for them. And so the self perpetuating cycle continues.

Not only that, importing cheap labour lowers productivity. Instead of bringing people who work for less disincentivizes businesses from investing in automation. Low productivity is why UK economy is in so much trouble. And the root causes are low skilled mass migration and welfare topups for the indigenous population for whom work does not pay as well as benefits.

MissyB1 · 04/12/2023 20:29

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/12/2023 20:25

Have you ever, for a moment, considered why we need even more and more foreign nurses and why there are never enough?

Have you looked at this in conjunction with the population growth chart?

Have you ever considered why so many British nurses and Doctors are leaving the Uk?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/12/2023 20:29

It's depressing to see how many people think it's fair to deny people a family life. It's reasonable to expect people to be self supporting but the threshold is too high.

I met and married my DH while we were both living overseas in a third country. I had very little UK work experience when we moved back to the UK and my salary when we first moved back here to be nearer to my parents was pretty low, but we never claimed any benefits and we supported ourselves just fine. And my salary didn't stay low - I very soon increased my earnings substantially and we have been net contributors to the state for many years. Our dd is planning to be an NHS doctor and will likely become a net contributor too. And yet if this rule had been in place back when we moved, we'd have all ended up staying overseas and contributing our taxes there instead.

Bloody ridiculous that only the relatively better off will be entitled to a family life. Fuck this stupid government, I'm so ashamed to be British these days.

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:28

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:21

It is practically impossible to bring parents and parents in law from a country that is subject to immigration control under the current legislation. There are literally just a handful of successful cases per year, the threshold to meet is very high. People you meet in such high numbers must have a different story, not family visa immigration route.

Well it baffles me too. But just last week I saw a man who works on minimum wage in a warehouse, who has lived in the UK for a couple of years. Earlier this year he was joined by his girlfriend, from their native country, who speaks no English and doesn’t have a job. She is now pregnant.

I also saw a couple in their 60s, both with multiple health problems that will require a lot of hospital treatment. They have just moved from their native country to join their daughter, who has a (low but not minimum wage) job.

CormorantStrikesBack · 04/12/2023 20:28

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:21

Does he not have any qualifications? What were they planning to do for money?

Well she earns a bit under 30k. They were going to live here or possibly buy a house (she has a deposit saved) and he was going to get a job. I think they assumed they’d have to get married for him to work here. Maybe he can get a work visa first and come over, I don’t know. He works in marketing, he has a degree. Which probably counts for nothing.

shockeditellyou · 04/12/2023 20:28

It’s completely fucked the university sector. We can’t recruit post docs as it is, let alone lab staff. I also can’t think of anything more inflationary - salaries for UK graduates will go up as competition increases.

OhMehGoddess · 04/12/2023 20:27

Wow that's high.

HumanBurrito · 04/12/2023 20:26

I'm British, living in Europe. Moved over in the early 2000s, way before Brexit. I have British kids and a European husband. I earn a good wage, him less so because he works part time to look after the kids. This ruling means I and my British children would be unable to live in the country where we are citizens.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/12/2023 20:26

I think this debate isn't about race and immigration - it's about greedy employers and organisations wanting to recruit foreign workers on low wages and treat them badly with the "carrot" of permanent residency.

The NHS is one of the biggest overseas recruiters.

JassyRadlett · 04/12/2023 20:25

SutWytTi · 04/12/2023 20:22

The current rules just don't allow this. Is it possible this a made up story?

Maybe by some statistical freak event, @MumblesParty sees every single one of the successful adult dependent visa holders from the last five years through her work?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/12/2023 20:25

MissyB1 · 04/12/2023 20:18

Well it’s a massive blow for the care sector and NHS. Yes they may be exempt from the earning threshold but they won’t be able to bring their spouses and kids. Basically they won’t come then will they? It’s a global market, most countries need healthcare workers, so they will go to a more welcoming Country, and who could blame them?
Dh is Dr and they absolutely rely on foreign nurses and Drs, it’s becoming impossible to recruit from Uk, the staff just don’t exist. The foreign nurses and Drs nearly all have spouses /kids.

Have you ever, for a moment, considered why we need even more and more foreign nurses and why there are never enough?

Have you looked at this in conjunction with the population growth chart?

Halfemptyhalfling · 04/12/2023 20:25

I think there should be a swap scheme for partners so if someone wants to bring their partner from let's say Canada then they can only come if someone from the UK emigrates to Canada.

The problem with the money limit is that UK people increasingly can't afford to do the jobs either if they don't want to be homeless or a low standard of living.

People say bring back the Erasmus scheme but if young people go abroad and meet someone then they will never be able to live at home again

lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 20:24

Figment1982 · 04/12/2023 20:22

They don't. Any visa has a 'no access to public funds' restriction (albeit in your example some NI contribution related payments such as statutory maternity pay are permitted as they are not considered public funds). And anyone obtaining a visa has to pay, upfront, and NHS surcharge of £624 per year of the visa, which is being raised to £1,035 per year.

I'm currently working on a visa application for a family of 5. Their payments for the Immigration Health Surcharge (which is before the higher fee has come in) is around £13,000. All of which has to be paid upfront.

It’s smoke and mirrors. Of course they have recourse to public funds. If they are bringing children with them, how is their schooling paid for?

Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers.

AmberValencia · 04/12/2023 20:24

I think this debate isn't about race and immigration - it's about greedy employers and organisations wanting to recruit foreign workers on low wages and treat them badly with the "carrot" of permanent residency.

Take academia and universities.

The new threshold is above that of a postdoc salary (that's a role after a PhD).

Not surprisingly, lots of white liberal senior academics complaining about this, it's all "so cruel and heartless" and they all are ardently looking for photographs of a non-white female scientist to Tweet, to show how cruel the system is. "What a loss to British science!".

These are the same senior academics who basically shove scientists from India and China into 70 hour weeks of processing chemicals to produce results for them (whilst the white middle class academics go to social events and networking events).

They basically get indentured servants as they can threaten to take their visas away if they don't do as they are told.

They don't give a fuck about science or knowledge or non-white people. They care about their cheap labour drying up. Their social group will be entirely comprised of white faces (even in a very international environment).

Carer is one of THE most important jobs in society. Again, why not raise the salary and conditions? What are the profits of nursing home bosses?

Who is profiting from the cheap labour coming over?

I think some wealthy people are "playing both sides of the equation" - encouraging desperate people to immigrate, suggest they move to areas with elevated racial tension (away from wealthy white people) profit from them, then enjoy them being criticised.

Universities have offices devoted to recruiting foreign students (and suggest they can work afterwards). It's ALL profit. They sell Masters courses with huge fees (going to the university).

The world is levelling up.

Many countries have a burgeoning middle class now, and work opportunities galore. People can move cities to the capital or neighbouring countries for a change of scene (and most people do - the countries with the most refugees are Uganda, Pakistan, and Turkey last I heard).

People say Suella Braverman is cruel and racist (and of course like to remind everyone due to her dark skin colour she's "not and will never actually be a proper British person" despite being born here with a Cambridge degree).

I think it's incredibly cruel and racist to entice workers, encourage them with a "lottery ticket" of permanent residency, then exploit them and get them to run the gauntlet of racism and uncertainty over their living status, whilst some greedy university bosses and senior organisations wipe their grubby greedy hands.

TheThingIsYeah · 04/12/2023 20:23

@lkwhjis your post is bang on.

SutWytTi · 04/12/2023 20:22

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:17

It seems high, but something has to be done.
In my job I regularly see immigrants (who admittedly work very hard) with minimum wage jobs, being joined by spouses, parents and parents-in-law who speak not one single word of English, make seemingly no effort to learn the language, and never work. It’s just not sustainable.

Edited

The current rules just don't allow this. Is it possible this a made up story?

knit1pearl2 · 04/12/2023 20:22

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:01

Err... is £38K now a low earner on MN? Honestly, in some other threads people on these salaries are told to count their lucky stars. It is not too far from a teacher's or a nurse's salary, is it?

It's bonkers, STEM PhD graduates and doctors don't earn that much.

Figment1982 · 04/12/2023 20:22

roarrfeckingroar · 04/12/2023 20:17

I don't think anyone should get a penny in UC / housing benefit / any in work benefits until they've paid in for five years. There should be a higher threshold id bringing a spouse and higher if children too because of NHS / school costs.

They don't. Any visa has a 'no access to public funds' restriction (albeit in your example some NI contribution related payments such as statutory maternity pay are permitted as they are not considered public funds). And anyone obtaining a visa has to pay, upfront, and NHS surcharge of £624 per year of the visa, which is being raised to £1,035 per year.

I'm currently working on a visa application for a family of 5. Their payments for the Immigration Health Surcharge (which is before the higher fee has come in) is around £13,000. All of which has to be paid upfront.

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:21

CormorantStrikesBack · 04/12/2023 20:20

Maybe they don’t want to live in Canada? Not only are there are health issues but she’s half way through her RIBA qualifications to becoming an architect. Qualifications valid in this country not in Canada. Until today it would have made more sense for him to come here. Of course he would have got a job if allowed to work….but afaik it’s her salary which counts for the visa. Or can he get a job here and then get a visa?

Does he not have any qualifications? What were they planning to do for money?

gwenneh · 04/12/2023 20:21

CormorantStrikesBack · 04/12/2023 20:20

Maybe they don’t want to live in Canada? Not only are there are health issues but she’s half way through her RIBA qualifications to becoming an architect. Qualifications valid in this country not in Canada. Until today it would have made more sense for him to come here. Of course he would have got a job if allowed to work….but afaik it’s her salary which counts for the visa. Or can he get a job here and then get a visa?

He would have to get a work visa for his employment to count. His income doesn't count towards the requirement for a spouse visa.

menopausalmare · 04/12/2023 20:21

I would be very interested to hear about retention rates for migrants entering the care system or signing up for degrees. I suspect quite low, which isn't good value for the taxpayer.

IneedhandcreamandaNC · 04/12/2023 20:21

Dymaxion · 04/12/2023 20:01

I think its interesting that the limit is 3.5k above what most band 5 nurses will earn outside London, at the very top of that band.

Another attempt to undermine the NHS and privatise it by stealth. Not the main aim of the £38k policy but a "handy" benefit of it.

Milkmani · 04/12/2023 20:21

I know quite a few EU migrants going home after 10+ years here. They are unhappy with the education primary/secondary age, the emphasis on importance of education in state schools, high rental/property prices and the NHS infrastructure; unable to get appointments, wait lists, quality of care - many go home for treatment. Many saw the UK as the golden ticket especially during the recession but even they realise now how it is to live in a massively overpopulated country. One of my parents is an immigrant (refugee from Europe as a baby) and my partner is also an EU immigrant. Once we pay off our mortgage we’re hoping to head out too. I believe we need to draw the line somewhere with immigration. I know healthcare recruitment will suffer etc but the only solution shouldn’t be shipping in migrants from other countries.

SutWytTi · 04/12/2023 20:21

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/12/2023 20:18

Didn't realise we had all the care staff, agricultural workers, nurses, junior doctors, teachers, physiotherapists, support workers, theatre practitioners, gas engineers, lab technicians, HCP disability assessors for PIP/DLA...that we need.

We need none of these professions. We are happy for Canada, Australia, NZ etc. to attract any talented people looking for opportunities in English-speaking nations.

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:21

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:17

It seems high, but something has to be done.
In my job I regularly see immigrants (who admittedly work very hard) with minimum wage jobs, being joined by spouses, parents and parents-in-law who speak not one single word of English, make seemingly no effort to learn the language, and never work. It’s just not sustainable.

Edited

It is practically impossible to bring parents and parents in law from a country that is subject to immigration control under the current legislation. There are literally just a handful of successful cases per year, the threshold to meet is very high. People you meet in such high numbers must have a different story, not family visa immigration route.

OP posts: