Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
gotomomo · 04/12/2023 20:48

Don't forget healthcare workers have families too, even if they come on a separate scheme they can't bring family

Lolaandbehold · 04/12/2023 20:48

I think it's absolutely fair. Anecdotally, I've heard that anyone with children that isn't a higher or top rate tax payer is a net beneficiary of the state, when NHS, education, children's allowance etc are all taken into account. So if an immigrant on £25k a year gets a visa for his non working spouse and 3 kids, the family will ultimately cost the country money.

The more pressing issue is, perhaps, who is going to do all of these low paying jobs now that we've booted out the Europeans.

It's all a bit too little too late from the Conservatives though. Talk about clutching at straws. ~Not all~ voters are completely stupid.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/12/2023 20:47

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 04/12/2023 20:39

It has a great deal more to do with our ageing population than it has to do with the immigration of mostly young and relatively healthy migrants (who have to pay a surcharge to cover the cost of accessing the NHS in any case). Plus of course, we are losing lots of our home grown nurses and doctors to better terms and conditions overseas.

The magic immigrants that will always stay young and healthy....

Forgot about those. Of course you are right.

mindutopia · 04/12/2023 20:47

It’s not. When I immigrated, I think the threshold was like £21k for spousal income. Dh just managed to meet it. We were recent uni graduates in our 20s in new graduate jobs, which is surely the situation for most people just settling down and marrying.

Neither of us have ever been on any sort of benefits, other than SMP and child benefit for me. We have both always worked. Always paid for housing privately. In fact, I was ineligible for any sort of benefits anyway due to my immigration status (as is the case for most immigrants without indefinite leave to remain/citizenship or who aren’t asylum seekers). In fact, just my presence made Dh ineligible for benefits too, not that we ever needed them.

We collectively earn over £100k now as a household, but in our 20s, no it wouldn’t have been possible. It would have meant Dh would have had to move to my home country instead and the UK would have lost the benefit of all the (now) higher rate taxes we pay and the contributions we both make to life here.

lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 20:47

HappySammy · 04/12/2023 20:40

Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers.

Can I ask how? What is being paid for by other tax payers if you earn under £38k?

Schools, healthcare, roads, emergency services to name a few. Anyone earning less than £38k with children takes out more than £5k per child from the system to begin with. Then there is everything else.

Migrants may pay an NHS surcharge for some years. That surcharge does not even touch the sides if they or their children need healthcare. They will take out of the system many times over. Way more than they contribute. People are often defended by this but it’s just pure math. People form appreciate that importing people to pay for them to live here mean average standard of living for everyone else drops.

Tacotortoise · 04/12/2023 20:47

Ultimately I don't think importing cheap labour from abroad is a good way to prop up our health and social care sector. We can kick and scream all we like but we are going to have to fund them properly.

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:47

TravellingT · 04/12/2023 20:42

I do understand where he's coming from- but this is just going to cause uproar. When immigrants come to England and are earning £38k+, English people will scream "Why did they get the good jobs?" "Why is an immigrant earning more than me?" etc. Immigrants are damned if they do, damned if they don't.

I think ensuring immigrants aren't on benefits, are supported to get into good careers etc should be the priority. A cap like £20k would make more sense, as that's a much more attainable entry level full time salary.

If they're on a decent enough salary like £38k, maybe a contribution to the NHS/raised taxes would be appropriate.

But for spousal visas there's already additional contribution to the NHS - £1K extra per year, if I remember correctly, in addition to all usual taxes. Also, no benefits for the spouse until they naturalised (10 years now, if they don't work and contribute?). And ridiculous visa processing fees every 2.5 years, also in thousands.

I mean, it is already ridiculously restrictive, isn't it?

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 04/12/2023 20:46

TravellingT · 04/12/2023 20:42

I do understand where he's coming from- but this is just going to cause uproar. When immigrants come to England and are earning £38k+, English people will scream "Why did they get the good jobs?" "Why is an immigrant earning more than me?" etc. Immigrants are damned if they do, damned if they don't.

I think ensuring immigrants aren't on benefits, are supported to get into good careers etc should be the priority. A cap like £20k would make more sense, as that's a much more attainable entry level full time salary.

If they're on a decent enough salary like £38k, maybe a contribution to the NHS/raised taxes would be appropriate.

Anyone coming on a visa pays an NHS surcharge, it’s pretty expensive. To get a visa and pay the NHS surcharge for all you’re talking 20k plus, probably much more. It’s very expensive getting a visa to the U.K., which most people don’t realise, as they are all fed info from the press which doesn’t reflect the reality

PlainWoman · 04/12/2023 20:45

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:42

So a family on the joint income on £76K (£38 x 2) is supported by taxpayers? Sounds quite off the mark, to be honest, but obviously, I didn't do the detailed calculations.

Yes if there is a disability they would be entitled, and if they have children, child benefit.

BansheeofInisherin · 04/12/2023 20:45

TravellingT · 04/12/2023 20:42

I do understand where he's coming from- but this is just going to cause uproar. When immigrants come to England and are earning £38k+, English people will scream "Why did they get the good jobs?" "Why is an immigrant earning more than me?" etc. Immigrants are damned if they do, damned if they don't.

I think ensuring immigrants aren't on benefits, are supported to get into good careers etc should be the priority. A cap like £20k would make more sense, as that's a much more attainable entry level full time salary.

If they're on a decent enough salary like £38k, maybe a contribution to the NHS/raised taxes would be appropriate.

Just last week, I was told on one of these threads that by having high earning jobs, Dh and I were depriving British people of jobs and encouraging "reverse colonialism". Immigrants can't win these days.

We already contributed a massive surcharge to the NHS, btw.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/12/2023 20:44

And we have to recruit more and more because of the booming growth in population.

How many are leaving? This many?

"1. Main points. The provisional estimate of total long-term immigration for year ending (YE) June 2023 was 1.2 million, while emigration was 508,000, meaning that net migration was 672,000; most people arriving to the UK in the YE June 2023 were non-EU nationals (968,000), followed by EU (129,000) and British (84,000).23 Nov 2023

Long-term international migration, provisional: year ending ...

Office for National Statistics
www.ons.gov.uk › yearendingjune2023"

One year only.

JassyRadlett · 04/12/2023 20:44

roarrfeckingroar · 04/12/2023 20:17

I don't think anyone should get a penny in UC / housing benefit / any in work benefits until they've paid in for five years. There should be a higher threshold id bringing a spouse and higher if children too because of NHS / school costs.

We're talking about spouse visas here, so British citizens.

Immigrants on spouse/partner visas already have no recourse to public funds (meaning benefits) while they are under immigration control (a minimum of five years). They have to have extra earnings for each child that comes in under this route. In addition they pay the NHS fee for every year of their visa. And when they eventually qualify for settlement, they still have to reach the earnings threshold PLUS extra earnings for each child.

Did I miss anything off your list?

gotomomo · 04/12/2023 20:44

To anyone now panicking I would marry immediately, the legislation will take time to pass, could be defeated even but to be safe!

Zanatdy · 04/12/2023 20:44

It is high and it will be difficult for many Brits to bring a spouse to the U.K. with required salary being that high. That said someone I know brought over someone she met on Facebook, he sponged off her for 2yrs, had a mental health breakdown and 10wks in hospital, then she threw him out and he’s been working without paying taxes for the last year, cash in hand. So would it have been better if she wasn’t able to sponsor his visa, yes. Definitely

greengreengrass25 · 04/12/2023 20:44

I agree

It's not sustainable

EasternStandard · 04/12/2023 20:43

If both earn over £38k then I assume both in the married couple can get visas?

If on the visa list

NSA2103 · 04/12/2023 20:43

lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 19:52

Low skilled mass immigration is a ponzu scheme that’s gone far too far. It’s like Bernie Madoff on steroids.

since 1997, we have been importing cheap labour who bring their families with them. So then you need more immigrants to come in for jobs to support the previous round of low skilled migrants. More people need more taxes to pay for their needs. And on this merry go around goes. And during this time over 5 millions indingenous have decided that no longer need to work when they can just live for free.

All this is happening while the number of net contributor shrinks so fewer and fewer people paying for more and more. Half of the people in this country takes more from the system than it pays in. This upside down pyramid built on top of an ever shrinking number of people who actually contribute more than they take is starting to get really unstable. Welcome to UK, a country knocking on the door to enter the third world. Not offensive, just true.

I agree with you, even though many won't.

The peril of the country continuing to run an unsustainable financial model, is scary.

gotomomo · 04/12/2023 20:43

No because we need them to come! Or perhaps we should pay care workers, nurses, agricultural workers etc far more!!!

People willing to do the work those living here won't should be welcomed with open arms

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:42

HappySammy · 04/12/2023 20:40

Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers.

Can I ask how? What is being paid for by other tax payers if you earn under £38k?

So a family on the joint income on £76K (£38 x 2) is supported by taxpayers? Sounds quite off the mark, to be honest, but obviously, I didn't do the detailed calculations.

OP posts:
Milkmani · 04/12/2023 20:42

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/12/2023 20:18

Didn't realise we had all the care staff, agricultural workers, nurses, junior doctors, teachers, physiotherapists, support workers, theatre practitioners, gas engineers, lab technicians, HCP disability assessors for PIP/DLA...that we need.

But why are we not putting the emphasis on these types of careers in schools, many are put off by the bad press the NHS gets. The system here is terrible for helping guide young people. Many don’t realise the importance of agriculture. Where my partner is from the majority of teenagers spend time harvesting from June - September just like they used to here in the schools holidays, hence the 6 weeks. We ship in Eastern European labour purely for this purpose. Fruit and vegetable picking is tiring work but when you have done it as a summer job as a teenager it doesn’t seem so bad. Why are we not pumping money into educating our own and providing purpose for young people, this could have been fixed by now but it isn’t. Caring again I agree, the nurses who looked after my dad in palliative care couldn’t have been better but again were all non-British. Why are we not training our own people to take these jobs? We need a better vocational and future planning system for the young people in the UK.

Witsend101 · 04/12/2023 20:42

I find it ironic that the vast majority of those working in the civil service, public services etc would not earn enough to meet this threshold including the staff processing these visas! Yet the government think this is a reasonable threshold. So out of touch it's unbelievable.

TravellingT · 04/12/2023 20:42

I do understand where he's coming from- but this is just going to cause uproar. When immigrants come to England and are earning £38k+, English people will scream "Why did they get the good jobs?" "Why is an immigrant earning more than me?" etc. Immigrants are damned if they do, damned if they don't.

I think ensuring immigrants aren't on benefits, are supported to get into good careers etc should be the priority. A cap like £20k would make more sense, as that's a much more attainable entry level full time salary.

If they're on a decent enough salary like £38k, maybe a contribution to the NHS/raised taxes would be appropriate.

Backtomyoldname · 04/12/2023 20:42

There's an aspect of throwing a dead cat on the table here. Over and over.

Lots, in the country, getting hot under the collar about immigration. Papers/some TV channels 'telling' readers how to feel.

If there weren't vacancies to be filled many just wouldn't come here.

So what real issues are being masked by our immigration indignation?

NHS funding, vacancies. Where are the 40 new hospitals?

Social care funding?

Councils on the point of bankruptcy - barely due to 13 years of austerity.

SEN funding. etc etc

Sarah2891 · 04/12/2023 20:41

I think it's unfair, it's too high.

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:41

I can understand all the reasons why people might want to come here (despite the MN narrative that the UK is a vile racist rainy cold shithole), and obviously people don’t want to be separated from their families once that have emigrated.

But this is down to basic maths. In order to support people who can’t work, or who do minimum wage jobs, we need enough people paying enough tax. If we are struggling to support the British nationals who need financial assistance, then we can’t justify supporting people from other countries as well.

I’m sure many other countries have similar, if not stricter, rules.