Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
OhmygodDont · 04/12/2023 21:03

And when the private health care fucks up or fails is an nhs ambulance to an nhs hospital.

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 21:02

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 21:01

A&E and other emergency is actually a small proportion of the overall average, people just overreact to loud / expensive cases.

If I have a heart attack, definitely not going to NHS A&E, I'd be dead before the sunrise lol.

Where will you go?

lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 21:02

BansheeofInisherin · 04/12/2023 20:59

James Cleverley's own mum would not have been able to enter the country, under this law. But that's in keeping with the entire Tory cabinet.

And?

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 21:01

BansheeofInisherin · 04/12/2023 20:59

James Cleverley's own mum would not have been able to enter the country, under this law. But that's in keeping with the entire Tory cabinet.

She was a midwife, so she might have been, I’m not sure. But it was the 60s, a very different time, with very different challenges.

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 21:01

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:57

Does your insurance cover A&E and emergency surgery? If you have a heart attack, where will you go?

A&E and other emergency is actually a small proportion of the overall average, people just overreact to loud / expensive cases.

If I have a heart attack, definitely not going to NHS A&E, I'd be dead before the sunrise lol.

OP posts:
Goodornot · 04/12/2023 21:01

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:45

It is 21st century... often both spouses work, but in this case (for the initial application) only the British spouse's income will be taken into account.

An old friend of mine brought her spouse back from South Africa. He changed jobs as often as he changed his underwear once he got here. Kept giving up of too difficult and got sacked from some. Then a long spell of unemployment in which she had to keep him

It isn't always the case that both partners work and if you want to bring someone in tou need to be able to pay their way.

BansheeofInisherin · 04/12/2023 20:59

James Cleverley's own mum would not have been able to enter the country, under this law. But that's in keeping with the entire Tory cabinet.

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 04/12/2023 20:58

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:53

I am paying less than £1K for private medical insurance for three people per year, to a company that makes profits out of it.

Your private medical insurance doesn’t cover everything though. It doesn’t cover child birth, and all the medical appointments around it. It doesn’t cover primary care. It doesn’t cover emergency care….

SneakyMcFlurry · 04/12/2023 20:58

It's sad really. I have 2 lovely friends, British citizens, who live overseas with their spouses. Who would love to come back home to live but won't be able to bring their spouses but would not meet the requirements and, though have skills, would find it hard to get this sort of salary but would both want to work and contribute to our society.

Wonderfulstuff · 04/12/2023 20:58

decionsdecisions62 · 04/12/2023 20:38

50000 nursing vacancies. It's hardly going to help is it? They are deranged!

Yep and sadly many of their true blue Tory supporters are too short sighted to recognise that they or a family member might come to rely on the care given from these migrant workers. My DM is currently receiving extensive medical treatment and she'd be lost without the wonderful Pilipino nurses and carers who work in the local NHS hospital. Whilst they deserve to earn considerably more than £38k I doubt they are.

Vettrianofan · 04/12/2023 20:57

kirbykirby · 04/12/2023 19:56

Yes, very fair. It should be higher.

Careful there. That's almost subtext for keeping the UK "white"🙄

MumblesParty · 04/12/2023 20:57

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:53

I am paying less than £1K for private medical insurance for three people per year, to a company that makes profits out of it.

Does your insurance cover A&E and emergency surgery? If you have a heart attack, where will you go?

OhmygodDont · 04/12/2023 20:56

SpideyMum22 · 04/12/2023 20:53

Completely agree with cancelling them in event of divorce in the future. A very close friend married a man from Egypt who left her literally the day he got his British Passport after pretending everything was fine and they were happy. He never worked a day while living off her but was suddenly able to work enough hours to meet the threshold of 18,600 to bring his new Egyptian wife over (who it turned out had actually encouraged him to marry my friend in the first place to use her). Sadly we saw many similar cases

Like those “enter country” young men who suddenly really really love and fancy the pants off 67 year Irene. Get married move in and fuck off.

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:56

Lolaandbehold · 04/12/2023 20:48

I think it's absolutely fair. Anecdotally, I've heard that anyone with children that isn't a higher or top rate tax payer is a net beneficiary of the state, when NHS, education, children's allowance etc are all taken into account. So if an immigrant on £25k a year gets a visa for his non working spouse and 3 kids, the family will ultimately cost the country money.

The more pressing issue is, perhaps, who is going to do all of these low paying jobs now that we've booted out the Europeans.

It's all a bit too little too late from the Conservatives though. Talk about clutching at straws. ~Not all~ voters are completely stupid.

The decision is clear, no one should have children then. That's it, problem solved.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 04/12/2023 20:55

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:42

So a family on the joint income on £76K (£38 x 2) is supported by taxpayers? Sounds quite off the mark, to be honest, but obviously, I didn't do the detailed calculations.

No, they're not.

The median household income in 2022 was £35,000 before taxes and benefits were netted off.

From the ONS:

In FYE 2022, 53.8% of all UK individuals were net recipients (living in households receiving more in benefits than they paid in taxes), a reduction of 1.2 percentage points since FYE 2021. A much greater proportion of retired individualswere net recipients (89.2 %) in comparison with non-retired people (46.0%), largely because of the classification of State Pension and Pension Credit as cash benefits.

So most households made up of non-retired people are net contributors in calculations of cash and in-kind benefits, as carried out by the ONS, not net recipients, regardless of how many people in that household are working.

Effects of taxes and benefits on UK household income - Office for National Statistics

The redistribution effects of individuals and households of direct and indirect taxation and benefits received in cash or kind, analysed by household type.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personalandhouseholdfinances/incomeandwealth/bulletins/theeffectsoftaxesandbenefitsonhouseholdincome/financialyearending2022#glossary

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 04/12/2023 20:55

my dd remains in immigration limbo. coming up on 10 years, at least 3 lawyers and still not granted the indefinite leave. the last visa recently expired, one lawyer said to leave the country one said to stay.
lots of nuance in the policy i gather.

SpideyMum22 · 04/12/2023 20:53

Completely agree with cancelling them in event of divorce in the future. A very close friend married a man from Egypt who left her literally the day he got his British Passport after pretending everything was fine and they were happy. He never worked a day while living off her but was suddenly able to work enough hours to meet the threshold of 18,600 to bring his new Egyptian wife over (who it turned out had actually encouraged him to marry my friend in the first place to use her). Sadly we saw many similar cases

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:53

Tacotortoise · 04/12/2023 20:49

1k extra per year (for the nhs) isn't much, neither are the extra taxes if the visa holder is poorly paid and their dependents don't work (a statistic quoted on the radio this evening was that only 1 in 4 dependents are in work).

I am paying less than £1K for private medical insurance for three people per year, to a company that makes profits out of it.

OP posts:
Paperbagsaremine · 04/12/2023 20:53

willstarttomorrow · 04/12/2023 19:56

Not fair in any way at all but this is about trying to win votes. It is also not fair to invite people to take jobs we cannot fill from the home grown workforce but to then say but 'not your partner and children- that is just taking the piss incomer' (paraphrasing slightly there) is crazy . My 101 year old nan was in a lovely care home which was then staffed by EU workers, mostly from Poland. After Brexit, my mother who needs nursing care and has very advanced dementia is in an amazing nursing home staffed by nurses from the Philippines and also care staff.

My SIL is from the Philippines and whilst it is very usual for women to leave their children with grandparents and send money home, the current proposal is cruel. It just stinks of a colonial mindset in that they are bloody lucky to be here. The only thing which probably remains on our side in the UK when recruiting talent from overseas is that English is the universal language.

When people grumble about immigration, my impression was that "Nice ladies from Ghana, Poland and the Philippines who are looking after my Gran" never even entered their head.
But it's not like I've done research or anything so feel free to broaden my perspective here, fellow posters.

It's not easy NOW to get care workers, and it's not something you want unwilling or unsuited people to be doing, because BY DEFINITION their clients are extremely vulnerable!

So policy in this area has implications. If you say, Okay, we don't want to have care workers come from overseas. Granny isn't miraculously going to leap from her bed like Jesus just laid hands on her. She's still going to need looking after.

So how does that happen? At first, there will be resistance to raising wages. Granny's carers don't turn up because of staff shortages / her family have to take unpaid leave to step in, which affects their family, career, and workplace / she gets substandard carers who neglect, abuse or steal from her.
Say then that wages go up to attract people into the sector. Councils' costs go up. Their ability to raise money is capped, so either they cut back on education and child social care to fund it and/or the central grant from government has to be raised which means we all pay more in tax or see further cuts in other areas (NHS, benefits, pensions...).

As a country we do get to make choices, but whether we admit it or not, those choices come with consequences.

greengreengrass25 · 04/12/2023 20:52

Are other European countries having to import migrants in the same way as the UK?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/12/2023 20:51

The more pressing issue is, perhaps, who is going to do all of these low paying jobs now that we've booted out the Europeans.

Have we?

What about the 6 million who have applied and received EUSS and the many more who have joined then on a joiner status?

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:51

PlainWoman · 04/12/2023 20:45

Yes if there is a disability they would be entitled, and if they have children, child benefit.

Well, disability benefits are quite a niche case, and it is not like child benefit offsets the taxes they pay.
So, say, our family of a teacher and a nurse on £76K joint income, house with mortgage, two kids and a labrador. Are they sponging off the taxpayer?

OP posts:
therealcookiemonster · 04/12/2023 20:50

and at the same time, they are planning to introduce legislation allowing immigrant workers to be paid 20% less than British nationals? and not to mention we need carers and other workers who are paid very little anyway. I mean we could just pay everyone a decent wage (and therefore encourage british people to join these sectors in higher numbers) but none of our overlords are interested in doing that of course.

OhmygodDont · 04/12/2023 20:50

I mean I doubt 1k per year would actually pay for much nhs care when needed tbh. One child birth would wipe out years or a bad a&e visit.

Anyway with lack of trained medical professionals what should be done is the courses should be fully funded on the condition of working it off by working for the nhs for a minimum of X years otherwise you pay it back. Better working hours and improved pay.

Importing workers just kills that’s countries workforce and doesn’t encourage training of homegrown workers.

Tacotortoise · 04/12/2023 20:49

1k extra per year (for the nhs) isn't much, neither are the extra taxes if the visa holder is poorly paid and their dependents don't work (a statistic quoted on the radio this evening was that only 1 in 4 dependents are in work).