Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
wordler · 04/12/2023 22:54

Figment1982 · 04/12/2023 22:50

@wordler In your situation the 'easiest' thing for you to would be to find an employer to sponsor your husband on a Skilled Worker visa, then once you have all arrived he can switch to the Spousal visa using his employment income.

I think your definition of easiest is different from mine - you might mean 'only'.

The frustration with this visa is that it's got no flexibility for personal situations.

We would have free accommodation, family who would pay for any needs and private health insurance. We'd be able to afford the visa fees, the NHS surcharge, and we'd be saving the state a potential lot of money and resources if we came back to take care of my elderly Dad in his own home.

What it means in reality is if the worst happens then we will just have to live apart in two different countries for at least six to 12 months.

Finlesswonder · 04/12/2023 22:52

@IceandIndigo
the biggest numbers of spouse visas were granted to spouses coming from South Asian countries, which was perceived to relate to arranged marriages involving people (especially women) who were relatively low skilled and less likely to be economically active once they arrived in Britain

We have a cultural expectation that able bodied adults be economically active. Why not these women too?

Figment1982 · 04/12/2023 22:50

wordler · 04/12/2023 22:46

But you can't get the foreign spouse in the country to get a contributing job under the current rules if the British spouse doesn't meet the income threshold.

I am in this situation - I can't currently come home to live with my British citizen daughter because I don't meet the income threshold - and would be unlikely to meet it with the full time jobs available in the northern town where we would want to live, with my American husband who once here would definitely be able to earn way above the limit.

It looks like we may be able to retire here using his retirement income in several years, so I just hope my 80 year old Dad can hang on long enough without our help until then.

@wordler In your situation the 'easiest' thing for you to would be to find an employer to sponsor your husband on a Skilled Worker visa, then once you have all arrived he can switch to the Spousal visa using his employment income.

IceandIndigo · 04/12/2023 22:48

The introduction of salary thresholds for spouse visas was always a racist policy. It was identified that the biggest numbers of spouse visas were granted to spouses coming from South Asian countries, which was perceived to relate to arranged marriages involving people (especially women) who were relatively low skilled and less likely to be economically active once they arrived in Britain. The salary threshold for the British spouse was introduced as a blunt mechanism to exclude these people. It’s also the reason why the earnings of the non-British spouse can’t be counted, because they weren’t really thinking about scenarios of educated couples where both partners work, returning expats or retired people.

The existing threshold has already led to many perverse and unintended consequences, I can’t even imagine how many more we’re going to see now that it’s being raised to £38k.

wordler · 04/12/2023 22:46

Ifonlyoneday · 04/12/2023 22:40

For migrant workers and students who cannot bring their families, it’s their choice whether to come here or stay in their native country or migrate to another country which will allow them to take their families. They have options.

for spousal visas I think the spousal support amount is fine, the person has to make enough money to support their spouse or the spouse can get a job or they can live in the spouses country. The 38k means they will be paying tax so will be contributing tax to pay for spouse and what they may need from the NHS.

But you can't get the foreign spouse in the country to get a contributing job under the current rules if the British spouse doesn't meet the income threshold.

I am in this situation - I can't currently come home to live with my British citizen daughter because I don't meet the income threshold - and would be unlikely to meet it with the full time jobs available in the northern town where we would want to live, with my American husband who once here would definitely be able to earn way above the limit.

It looks like we may be able to retire here using his retirement income in several years, so I just hope my 80 year old Dad can hang on long enough without our help until then.

SpacePatch · 04/12/2023 22:45

@Ifonlyoneday immigrants pay doubly for the NHS. They pay an immigration surcharge for every year their visa is valid for and it’s currently £624 PER YEAR. So for a 5 year visa (how long it takes before someone can apply for ILR at minimum) it’s an additional £3,120 on top of the THOUSANDS each visa costs.

Figment1982 · 04/12/2023 22:43

I wonder if they will change the rules and permit the non-UK partner to count their income towards the requirement for an entry clearance application, unlike now? That would seem a fair way to balance out the higher threshold.

If the goal of the policy is to prevent dependants coming to the UK and not contributing anything, which is what the Home Office statement says, then surely a couple should be able to take into account the non-UK partner's earnings history and job offer in the UK?

wellwellso · 04/12/2023 22:43

Cocacolathanks · 04/12/2023 22:12

Can anyone answer this?

if someone is granted the spouse visa now before the rules change to the increased wages, when it comes time for renewal after 2 and 5 years, will the new rules now apply or will the “old” minimum wage rules still apply?

None can answer you 100%, so don't believe anyone, but be prepared.

I was under a Highly Skilled Visa which after 4 years I could apply for indefinite leave to remain. One year in and that was changed to 5 years, and although I was already on the scheme, I was captured by the new change, so I also had to do 5 years.

WhenLoveIsDone · 04/12/2023 22:41

The families already pay an exorbitant NHS immigrant surcharge every couple of years on top of their own NI contributions from wages.

Ifonlyoneday · 04/12/2023 22:40

For migrant workers and students who cannot bring their families, it’s their choice whether to come here or stay in their native country or migrate to another country which will allow them to take their families. They have options.

for spousal visas I think the spousal support amount is fine, the person has to make enough money to support their spouse or the spouse can get a job or they can live in the spouses country. The 38k means they will be paying tax so will be contributing tax to pay for spouse and what they may need from the NHS.

SpacePatch · 04/12/2023 22:39

@CormorantStrikesBack
Once he’s here on the Youth Mobility Visa they can use the two years to live together and then apply for either the unmarried partner visa or get married and apply for the spousal visa. They’re the same visa so requirements are the same (only difference is unmarried partner visa requires them to live together for two years). But he will be able to use any earnings from his job to count for the total financial requirements for the spousal visa as income is based on earnings from both of them, so would probably make it easier for them if he could get a job here first and prove he has an income before going for spousal visa. Info here (obviously income limits haven’t been amended yet): https://www.gov.uk/uk-family-visa/proof-income

I have gone through the full process including Youth Mobility Visa, Spousal, ILR and now British Citizenship. It’s a long and very expensive road so I have every sympathy.

Family visas: apply, extend or switch

Get a family visa for the UK, live with your spouse or relative - eligibility, proof, renewing, financial and English language requirements.

https://www.gov.uk/uk-family-visa/proof-income

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 22:37

Crababbles · 04/12/2023 22:34

How many teachers and nurses do you know who have a husband or wife who doesn’t work, yet they don’t claim any benefits?

No idea tbh, don't have that level of insight into my friends finances. I'd say when the children were very young, most of these families had a stay at home parent, as childcare fees were impossible.

OP posts:
Version4needsabitofwork · 04/12/2023 22:35

I'm British by ancestry, although born out of the UK.

I am a University lecturer (and a private landlord) and my earnings (combined!) are nowhere near that figure. I would also probabably fail the citizenship test:

Which king was executed in 1649? ... NO CLUE
Who built the Tower of London? ... NOPE
Which territory is not part of Great Britain? EGH?

Luckily, by an accident of birth, I've a British passport and I live here now.

But what utter madness the whole thing is. Years ago you could just move to another EU country on a whim, and I did. Spent 3 years learning a language, arsing about and volunteering. Why is that not a thing any more?

It's all nonsense.

Crababbles · 04/12/2023 22:34

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 20:01

Err... is £38K now a low earner on MN? Honestly, in some other threads people on these salaries are told to count their lucky stars. It is not too far from a teacher's or a nurse's salary, is it?

How many teachers and nurses do you know who have a husband or wife who doesn’t work, yet they don’t claim any benefits?

wellwellso · 04/12/2023 22:33

IceandIndigo · 04/12/2023 22:27

Surely they could not apply the rules retrospectively to people who are already here? They would face massive legal challenges.

That's my concern too. However, they have always been very draconian with their immigration law changes in the past affecting people already under an existing scheme, so I will not be surprised. The main reason I became a British citizen although as a commonwealth citizen, I already had about 99% rights similar to Brits after living here for 10 years by then. Luckily swearing allegiance to the Queen was uncontroversial as she was already the Head of the Commonwealth and therefore I was already her subject no matter where I lived. That- UK HO changing immigration laws unexpectedly- and wanting a British passport for ease of travel especially within the then EU for short holiday trips.

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 22:33

Sahana28 · 04/12/2023 22:29

But surely if say one brit has sponsored his wife brought her over and he works full time and doesnt earn enough to meet this critera- all she has to do is also find full time work? And the criteria would be met? Then couples wouldn't have to worry about one of them being deported.
Yes I'm aware spouse visa applicants cannot claim benefits- which is why it's even more important that their sponsor has the funds to finacially take care of them

The point is that he wouldn't be able to sponsor her in the first place. So they will have to live elsewhere (of course, the wife's country must not apply a symmetrical rule, or they need to choose a third country). Feels stupidly harsh for a situation where there are already controls in place in respect of "becoming a burden".

OP posts:
fetchacloth · 04/12/2023 22:33

bombastix · 04/12/2023 22:15

The UK needs rather urgently to be a higher wage economy. I am not a supporter of the Conservatives; but I do approve of this, and I hope if a Labour government come in, they build on this regarding training and investment for young people. We've been bumping along on a low wage economy based on immigration for 15 years at least.

I agree. The last 20 years or so has felt like a race to the bottom really 🤔

scrimpton · 04/12/2023 22:32

My wife is here on a FLR(M) visa.

Thankfully, we both earn above the new proposed threshold when we come to renew the visa.

The govt is planning to raise the visa fee as well as the Immigration Health Surcharge by a large amount next month.

Along with the "STOP THE BOATS" campaign, I believe this to be a policy to appease the xenophobic Tory voters.

There is no recourse to public funds with spouse visas. My wife can't go on the dole or claim housing / disability benefits. We pay our own way.

Upping the financial requirement to £38k will prevent people British people having a family life in the UK. If you think that is right, then shame on you.

bombastix · 04/12/2023 22:32

The immigration rules change all the time. You can't expect them to stay static or have an idea they will never change. There's plenty on legal precedent on this point. And retrospective extent can also be legal.

Figment1982 · 04/12/2023 22:32

Cocacolathanks · 04/12/2023 22:12

Can anyone answer this?

if someone is granted the spouse visa now before the rules change to the increased wages, when it comes time for renewal after 2 and 5 years, will the new rules now apply or will the “old” minimum wage rules still apply?

@Cocacolathanks

That has not been confirmed, but I think it's possible that it will remain at £18,600 for those people. The Home Office historically has had a policy of not retro-actively applying more onerous requirements to those who started on a pathway with certain rules. Unfortunately however until the Statement of Changes to the Immigration Rules is published it won't be possible to know for certain. The Statement of Changes is, by convention, usually published 21 days in advance of the changes coming into effect, but this Government has recently been overriding this convention and implementing changes with less notice.

Sahana28 · 04/12/2023 22:31

IceandIndigo · 04/12/2023 22:27

Surely they could not apply the rules retrospectively to people who are already here? They would face massive legal challenges.

If the other person who was sponsored and is now a British/permanent uk citizen then no these new rules dont bother them
If the other person still needs to renew their spouse visa and is not a permeant citizen yet then yes, these rules will affect them

ListenLinda · 04/12/2023 22:31

ListenLinda · 04/12/2023 22:30

Just out of curiosity, did you have a blog on this where you documented the process?

@Relaxingweekendmaybe

ListenLinda · 04/12/2023 22:30

Just out of curiosity, did you have a blog on this where you documented the process?

Sahana28 · 04/12/2023 22:29

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 22:24

Even if they become sick or redundant, they still cannot claim benefits under the current system. It is indeed two full time min wage salaries, but it has to be earned by one (British) person.

But surely if say one brit has sponsored his wife brought her over and he works full time and doesnt earn enough to meet this critera- all she has to do is also find full time work? And the criteria would be met? Then couples wouldn't have to worry about one of them being deported.
Yes I'm aware spouse visa applicants cannot claim benefits- which is why it's even more important that their sponsor has the funds to finacially take care of them

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 22:28

IceandIndigo · 04/12/2023 22:27

Surely they could not apply the rules retrospectively to people who are already here? They would face massive legal challenges.

It happened in the past with immigration rules, more than once, in fact.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread