Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
beanontoast · 05/12/2023 00:43

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/12/2023 00:19

Personally, I think it's fairly obvious that a British citizen should have the right to return to the UK and that they should have the basic right to a life with their immediate family members such as their spouse and dependent children?

Personally, I think it's fairly obvious that anyone who tries to argue against that is quite simply devoid of any kind of basic moral compass?

Okay, I still don’t care 🤷🏻‍♀️

BritinDelco · 05/12/2023 00:39

Agreed! In response to @wordler

Recently emigrated to the US from the UK on a spouse visa and while health insurance is especially with the co-pays(excess) is expensive I got 2 MRIs and 2 treatments within 4 months. Out about 2k in total but with the FAR lower taxes I'm no worse off, even with the higher cost of living.

We had to jump a lot of hoops and spend thousands in the process, but it's worked out so far. DH makes decent money but below the median for our State, there are some V high earners here. The UK equivalent of the income threshold would be 125% of the living wage.

With an ageing parent in the UK we planned to return if necessary but now it won't be possible

RedRidingGood · 05/12/2023 00:38

user1477391263 · 05/12/2023 00:08

I live in Japan with my Japanese husband. He earns about 120K a year and I am a part-time worker who earns below this threshold. Pretty sure we’d be barred from the UK under these rules, even though my husband is a high earner and our family would be a net contributor to the public purse!

Can they not at least look at both spouses’ incomes or the combined income, and make some sort of distinction between developed and developing countries? The rules are being brought in, I suspect, to stop “chain migration” where people bring in cousins from developing countries as spouses. Perhaps that is a bit dysfunctional, but there are surely more sensible ways of stopping such migration.

Hi, is this 38k income threshold something the govt is talking about or is it actually in place? I'm reading about it on the Telegraph but I'm not clear on this. Surely it takes time for something like this to be put into place?

I'm an immigrant in the UK (originally from Asia) and a so-called high income earner. I am here on a Spousal visa but both DH and I are well above the income threshold. Still, I think it is a shame that there are people supporting this policy, it's obvious that Cleverly is using this as a way to get more Tory votes.

The trouble is, people think all immigrants and foreigners are low income earners, here to leech off etc. This isn't true, there's a wide variety of people. Also what % of spousal visas would consist of sham marriages? Why put something in place that will affect genuine couple to weed out what would be a very small % of people who are using it as a means to obtain a visa. I recall my immigration lawyer here mentioning that statistically it's a very small percentage that tries to manipulate the system.

This truly is a xenophobic policy.

user1477391263 · 05/12/2023 00:38

Seems to me like a lot of immigration policies would work “as intended” a lot more smoothly if it were lawful to make distinctions based on country of origin! We do treat different countries differently when trading with them; why not immigration?

bombastix · 05/12/2023 00:35

user1477391263 · 05/12/2023 00:23

Those of us impacted by this are going to have to decide: Are we going to push for:

a) Freer rules for every international couple
b) The creation of a sort of “Most Favored Nation” list, where couples containing a spouse from NZ, Oz, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Japan, USA, Canada, Singapore, Malaysia and EU countries (wealthy countries, basically) get a different set of rules applied to them. I may have missed out a couple of countries, but you get the gist.

Given that there is understandably some disquiet about people making use of international marriage for economic reasons, the second route may be more practicable.

A list of nations would be unlawful. You cannot discriminate by country lawfully. Income is however legal and will hold up on court. This policy does discriminate, but it does so lawfully.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/12/2023 00:26

wordler · 04/12/2023 23:59

I'd worked enough in the UK before I left to have earned my full pension credits in the UK, so definitely contributed to the UK.

My whole family outside of my husband and daughter are in the UK and I've visited 2-3 times a year since I moved apart from the Covid years.

I returned for five months to nurse one parent through end of life illness, and another for four months for the other parent to support through a major operation. I'm an only child so all falls on me.

I do consider the UK home. I am only living abroad while my husband has to work here.

I have had a freelance career to enable me to take care of my daughter through the early childcare years, to return to nurse and take care of my parents through their needs, and here in the US to take care of my inlaws through their operations. My spouse has earned enough to take care of the family here and our private healthcare.

As I mentioned I'd been planning to bring DH and DD to the UK to live for a period of time so that we can look after my Dad and keep him in his own home.

These rules are discriminatory. They affect anyone like me living abroad who has had to take time out of a regular job and income to take care of family. (this is usually the wife in the marriage).

But they also discriminate against any UK worker (who has never left the country like me) who happens to live in the part of the country where a good full time job for certain professions just doesn't meet this new level. The previous one was far more reasonable.

Without any provision for using a third party sponsor, or other economic options to tally the 'risk' to the country of a burden by the immigrant - it is a horrible policy.

Edited

I have had a freelance career

As I mentioned I'd been planning to bring DH and DD to the UK to live for a period of time so that we can look after my Dad and keep him in his own home.

I’m just curious and clearly you don’t have to answer. But how are you going to support the family if you are caring for your father and your husband can’t work?

ElevenSeven · 05/12/2023 00:26

Arafina · 04/12/2023 23:39

What a disgusting way to treat people, they want people to come and work here but not have a life here if they have to leave their partner and kids behind, we really are just numbers to them, humanity is dead with this government

They don’t want people to come, that’s the whole point. This measure was announced as part of a policy to reduce migration.

user1477391263 · 05/12/2023 00:23

Those of us impacted by this are going to have to decide: Are we going to push for:

a) Freer rules for every international couple
b) The creation of a sort of “Most Favored Nation” list, where couples containing a spouse from NZ, Oz, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Japan, USA, Canada, Singapore, Malaysia and EU countries (wealthy countries, basically) get a different set of rules applied to them. I may have missed out a couple of countries, but you get the gist.

Given that there is understandably some disquiet about people making use of international marriage for economic reasons, the second route may be more practicable.

wordler · 05/12/2023 00:23

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/12/2023 00:19

Personally, I think it's fairly obvious that a British citizen should have the right to return to the UK and that they should have the basic right to a life with their immediate family members such as their spouse and dependent children?

Personally, I think it's fairly obvious that anyone who tries to argue against that is quite simply devoid of any kind of basic moral compass?

Thank you 🙏

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/12/2023 00:19

beanontoast · 04/12/2023 23:58

Where did I say that? The poster I replied to presumably can return as a native citizen but whether her husband can not as a native is another matter. Personally I think it’s fairly obvious moving abroad for 20 years makes it risky as to whether you’ll be able to return with your family in tow and I’d expect the rules to change during that time too?

Personally, I think it's fairly obvious that a British citizen should have the right to return to the UK and that they should have the basic right to a life with their immediate family members such as their spouse and dependent children?

Personally, I think it's fairly obvious that anyone who tries to argue against that is quite simply devoid of any kind of basic moral compass?

CuteOrangeElephant · 05/12/2023 00:09

Tacotortoise · 04/12/2023 23:54

Yes well it's not a prison, he chose to leave and that's fine. But I'm OK with the rules being changed to suit those of us who live here rather than those who've left but want to keep their options open.

I hope you or your children will never fall in love with a foreign citizen.

user1477391263 · 05/12/2023 00:08

I live in Japan with my Japanese husband. He earns about 120K a year and I am a part-time worker who earns below this threshold. Pretty sure we’d be barred from the UK under these rules, even though my husband is a high earner and our family would be a net contributor to the public purse!

Can they not at least look at both spouses’ incomes or the combined income, and make some sort of distinction between developed and developing countries? The rules are being brought in, I suspect, to stop “chain migration” where people bring in cousins from developing countries as spouses. Perhaps that is a bit dysfunctional, but there are surely more sensible ways of stopping such migration.

BabaBarrio · 05/12/2023 00:06

Does anyone know if the new rules scrapped the ten year route? Right now the salary threshold for a British person to bring in a spouse is for the five year route to settlement partner visa. But there is also a ten year route to settlement partner visa for those who do not meet the salary threshold.

Does this scrap that whole route? It was originally designed for Brits who are disabled and their nonBritish partner is their carer. Or SAHP Brits where their partner will later meet the threshold after they move to the U.K. and can then upgrade from the ten year route to the five year route?

If they’ve scrapped this route for those who do not meet the salary threshold, it should be legally challenged as directly discriminatory towards disabled British and indirectly discriminatory towards female British parents.

Charlingspont · 05/12/2023 00:01

Another thing that I find abhorrent about this is that it appears that it's just care workers who can't bring their family, as opposed to doctors etc. Why's that? Is it because they're somehow less human? Less important? Less worthy?

The whole thing stinks.

TurningtheLightOff · 05/12/2023 00:00

HappySammy · 04/12/2023 20:40

Anyone earning less than £38k, migrant or not, is being supported by net contributor taxpayers. Basically we are importing vast swathes of people on low wages and then paying for them. It’s just bonkers.

Can I ask how? What is being paid for by other tax payers if you earn under £38k?

Quite. 74% of the U.K. earn less than this. So by the poster’s reckoning, the vast majority of us are not viable.

I am gutted by the ruling. I earn under 38k and though my American OH and I would be earning a really great wage combined, I don’t earn enough to get him here under these new rules.

I guess I am no longer welcome in my own country. So much for love, hey?

WhenLoveIsDone · 05/12/2023 00:00

This country is fucked irretrievably if people can't see how immoral this is.

wordler · 04/12/2023 23:59

beanontoast · 04/12/2023 23:49

Unless you believe in global free movement (which most don’t) if you left 20 years ago I wouldn’t consider you coming ‘home’. Surely wherever you live now is your home? I think you also said you’ve been out of the traditional work place, whatever that means, for some time - so surely you’d not think it would be easy?

I'd worked enough in the UK before I left to have earned my full pension credits in the UK, so definitely contributed to the UK.

My whole family outside of my husband and daughter are in the UK and I've visited 2-3 times a year since I moved apart from the Covid years.

I returned for five months to nurse one parent through end of life illness, and another for four months for the other parent to support through a major operation. I'm an only child so all falls on me.

I do consider the UK home. I am only living abroad while my husband has to work here.

I have had a freelance career to enable me to take care of my daughter through the early childcare years, to return to nurse and take care of my parents through their needs, and here in the US to take care of my inlaws through their operations. My spouse has earned enough to take care of the family here and our private healthcare.

As I mentioned I'd been planning to bring DH and DD to the UK to live for a period of time so that we can look after my Dad and keep him in his own home.

These rules are discriminatory. They affect anyone like me living abroad who has had to take time out of a regular job and income to take care of family. (this is usually the wife in the marriage).

But they also discriminate against any UK worker (who has never left the country like me) who happens to live in the part of the country where a good full time job for certain professions just doesn't meet this new level. The previous one was far more reasonable.

Without any provision for using a third party sponsor, or other economic options to tally the 'risk' to the country of a burden by the immigrant - it is a horrible policy.

beanontoast · 04/12/2023 23:58

LilyLemonade · 04/12/2023 23:54

Wow, so native-born British people, who by the way may not have any other nationality, shouldn’t have the right to return to the Uk?

Where did I say that? The poster I replied to presumably can return as a native citizen but whether her husband can not as a native is another matter. Personally I think it’s fairly obvious moving abroad for 20 years makes it risky as to whether you’ll be able to return with your family in tow and I’d expect the rules to change during that time too?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 04/12/2023 23:56

WhenLoveIsDone · 04/12/2023 23:02

A lot of Britons are going to give up and just go live abroad and raise their kids with their foreign spouses somewhere where it isn't so fucking hard and expensive just to live and be.

Right to a family life? What a fucking JOKE.

You're an English man or Scottish woman who fell in love during a stint abroad? Had kids with some dirty American or New Zealander or Polish man? The message is STAY THERE, WE DON'T WANT YOU BACK.

Would you like to detail where these Eldorados may be?

wellwellso · 04/12/2023 23:56

CuteOrangeElephant · 04/12/2023 23:49

DH is British and earns under the threshold, my earnings are more than double his.

We moved away from the UK. If my Settled Status lapses there is no easy way back for us, so we won't be moving back. It's not worth it when we can live in any of the EU countries without hassle.

The kicker is that DH has a vital job that the UK is now missing out on.

The kicker is that DH has a vital job that the UK is now missing out on.

Don't worry yourself, poster* *@beanontoast won't even notice your DH is missing. (Sorry, couldn't helping it, in light of their tone on this thread)

Oh and poster @Tacotortoise is also fine with the UK missing out on your DH's unique skills.

Edited to add poster Tacotortoise as I only saw their post after I posted. So it's fair it is not just one poster being quoted here. Or should I also add that these views are also held by some other people in the population?

LilyLemonade · 04/12/2023 23:54

beanontoast · 04/12/2023 23:49

Unless you believe in global free movement (which most don’t) if you left 20 years ago I wouldn’t consider you coming ‘home’. Surely wherever you live now is your home? I think you also said you’ve been out of the traditional work place, whatever that means, for some time - so surely you’d not think it would be easy?

Wow, so native-born British people, who by the way may not have any other nationality, shouldn’t have the right to return to the Uk?

Tacotortoise · 04/12/2023 23:54

CuteOrangeElephant · 04/12/2023 23:49

DH is British and earns under the threshold, my earnings are more than double his.

We moved away from the UK. If my Settled Status lapses there is no easy way back for us, so we won't be moving back. It's not worth it when we can live in any of the EU countries without hassle.

The kicker is that DH has a vital job that the UK is now missing out on.

Yes well it's not a prison, he chose to leave and that's fine. But I'm OK with the rules being changed to suit those of us who live here rather than those who've left but want to keep their options open.

wellwellso · 04/12/2023 23:53

beanontoast · 04/12/2023 23:47

I don’t know and to be honest can’t say I particularly care given you left 20 years ago?

😂😂😂Sorry, but the reply made me LOL

WhenLoveIsDone · 04/12/2023 23:52

wordler · 04/12/2023 23:46

And what do those of us do who married someone from another country 20 years ago and now can't come home unless we leave our spouse behind - either taking the children or leaving them - separating them from one parent?

I'm weeping with rage for you.

It's abhorrent.

SharSharBinks · 04/12/2023 23:51

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/12/2023 23:00

I think the only thing @lkwhjis missed in the good analysis is that the cheap laborers artificially keep the wages low. So instead of increasing demand for the lower paying jobs by increasing wages. You just bring in more labor willing to work at the lower wages.

It’s unlikely you’ll ever increase wages if there’s a steady supply of cheap labor.

It goes without saying that increasing wages is a magic bullet for all low wage jobs, but as a general rule it’s true. And it has to happen organically or it can go wrong in a hurry.

This is why truck drivers can now earn easily over £50k, with more specialist ones earning £65k+. A decade ago many were on £9-10 an hour rather than close to £30.