Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
SutWytTi · 05/12/2023 06:02

GreenwichOrTwicks · 05/12/2023 05:57

But she could go there? What v are the Canadian rules about spouse incomes?

And this demonstrates why this policy is so stupid. We're talking about a young couple choosing to base themselves in Canada instead of the UK, at a time when the UK really needs young people.

Anycrispsleft · 05/12/2023 05:57

Rosiiee · 05/12/2023 05:41

Have only read the first few pages so maybe someone else already raised this question but wondering if the UK have essentially shot themselves in the foot? Won’t the intake of ‘low’ earning healthcare workers drop now? People deciding to leave the UK because they can’t bring their spouse/family? And isn’t that also encouraging illegal immigration by making the legal pathways so difficult?

I can't see how it can fail to reduce the numbers of people looking to take up e.g. care and NHS jobs in the UK, meaning costs will go up. And at the same time the UK government has done things like reduce the bursaries for nursing courses and limit the number of university places for medics. If they don't want more foreigners they need to invest in training locals. And they would need to have done that first!

GreenwichOrTwicks · 05/12/2023 05:57

CormorantStrikesBack · 04/12/2023 20:04

No he doesn’t. So that’s it then. They can’t get married. 🤷‍♀️

But she could go there? What v are the Canadian rules about spouse incomes?

Anycrispsleft · 05/12/2023 05:53

RedRidingGood · 05/12/2023 00:38

Hi, is this 38k income threshold something the govt is talking about or is it actually in place? I'm reading about it on the Telegraph but I'm not clear on this. Surely it takes time for something like this to be put into place?

I'm an immigrant in the UK (originally from Asia) and a so-called high income earner. I am here on a Spousal visa but both DH and I are well above the income threshold. Still, I think it is a shame that there are people supporting this policy, it's obvious that Cleverly is using this as a way to get more Tory votes.

The trouble is, people think all immigrants and foreigners are low income earners, here to leech off etc. This isn't true, there's a wide variety of people. Also what % of spousal visas would consist of sham marriages? Why put something in place that will affect genuine couple to weed out what would be a very small % of people who are using it as a means to obtain a visa. I recall my immigration lawyer here mentioning that statistically it's a very small percentage that tries to manipulate the system.

This truly is a xenophobic policy.

It will be interesting to see how the political situation changes if the UK government manages to achieve its stated aim of reducing low paid/unskilled immigration. I work in Switzerland and am part of the influx of high skilled immigration - wages are high for the highly skilled but prices are high for everyone and Swiss find themselves increasingly on the edges of their own economy. The Swiss nationalist/populist party, the SVP, have long been the biggest party and increase their share of the vote at every election. Swiss would also claim to be against low skilled migration but they seem to be pretty unhappy about the high skilled too.

Rosiiee · 05/12/2023 05:41

Have only read the first few pages so maybe someone else already raised this question but wondering if the UK have essentially shot themselves in the foot? Won’t the intake of ‘low’ earning healthcare workers drop now? People deciding to leave the UK because they can’t bring their spouse/family? And isn’t that also encouraging illegal immigration by making the legal pathways so difficult?

Kokeshi123 · 05/12/2023 05:31

Until recently, EU and non-EU spouses got different rules. Not sure it's true that spouse rules have to be the same for every country.

zendeveloper · 05/12/2023 05:26

bombastix · 05/12/2023 00:35

A list of nations would be unlawful. You cannot discriminate by country lawfully. Income is however legal and will hold up on court. This policy does discriminate, but it does so lawfully.

At the moment the whole immigration law discriminates by country of origin, I don't think what you are saying is true at all.

OP posts:
elp30 · 05/12/2023 03:40

Oops, I meant £38,700

elp30 · 05/12/2023 03:32

The income-threshold increase for spouses of UK Citizens is significantly unfair.

I am the wife of a UK Citizen and my children are dual USA/UK Citizens and we live in the USA.

For the past few years, my husband has wanted to return to the UK and be closer to his parents. His parents are in their 70's and his mother has a life-limiting illness and it's a very huge pull to be back to spend as much time as he can with them and help in their care when needed. We've been waiting for our children to finish high school and university so we can return to the UK together.

My husband is self-employed in the US and his business will not be able to continue in the UK so we would be using the savings route to return and he would start another business once we arrive. That savings route is £62,500. That's not even counting the cost of the visas leading up to ILR and citizenship and the yearly health surcharge and all our other moving costs and the money to start another business. It's been a very long time saving but we were very close. Now that the threshold has been increased, we have to prepare ourselves for a few more years of savings and we have genuine worry about the health of my husband's mother.

Our son is a healthcare worker in the US and has expressed interest in moving to the UK with us and work for the NHS (he's a UK citizen). He has a partner whom he'd like to bring with him but as the threshold has now been increased to £37,600, it doesn't look like he would be able to earn enough money to sponsor his US-born partner to join him. It's very upsetting.

Topsyturvy78 · 05/12/2023 02:31

Two of my sons carers are from European countries. I don't think they will be earning that much. They live in a HMO the house he lives are always short staffed.

ElevenSeven · 05/12/2023 02:24

“The largest impacts will fall on lower-income British citizens, and particularly women and younger people who tend to earn lower wages.”

But this is exactly what it’s designed for. They want to reduce low-income immigration. Polls quite clearly show the majority of people want immigration numbers reduced; there are going to be people affected by it, that’s the whole rationale behind it.

user1492757084 · 05/12/2023 01:42

I'm surprised the level was set so much higher all in one swipe!

Crispedia · 05/12/2023 01:40

“Madeleine Sumption, the director of the Migration Observatory at Oxford University, said the home secretary’s decision to raise the family income threshold to £38,700 could have the most significant impacts on individuals.
“This threshold determines whether British citizens can bring a foreign partner to live with them in the UK, and the level has been more than doubled,” she said.

“Family migration makes up a small share of the total, but those who are affected by it can be affected very significantly.. “The largest impacts will fall on lower-income British citizens, and particularly women and younger people who tend to earn lower wages.”

Tinkerbyebye · 05/12/2023 01:39

Yes. If it’s to support two people it’s more than fair

Kokeshi123 · 05/12/2023 01:37

Honestly you cannot have what would appear to the world as a wyattz only immigration policy which is potentially what such s change would represent.

Half the countries on that list are mostly nonwhite.

Kokeshi123 · 05/12/2023 01:35

bombastix · 05/12/2023 00:49

Honestly you cannot have what would appear to the world as a wyattz only immigration policy which is potentially what such s change would represent.

Money works well as a proxy. The Home Office won this point in principle nearly a decade ago.

Money works well as a proxy. The Home Office won this point in principle nearly a decade ago.

It doesn't work well as a proxy, though, does it?
There are loads of British women married to men from developed, wealthy countries who earn decent salaries who can't come in. Even if their husbands are in roles that are in demand in the UK.

At the very least, they need to look at the combined family income; I mean, you'd think that would be common sense, frankly.

Crispedia · 05/12/2023 01:19

It’s too high.

Crispedia · 05/12/2023 01:19

lkwhjis · 04/12/2023 19:46

It’s high. As long as we have jobs that the lazy 5 million brits on out of work benefits don’t want to do.

2.6 million of those receive sickness benefits due to long-term sickness or disability. This was the same number in 2010, decreased a bit (about 200,000) now back to 2.6 million. Get away with your lazy accusations!

BestBadger · 05/12/2023 01:14

Crababbles · 04/12/2023 19:58

It’s completely fair. If two married low earners want visas, they can both apply for work visas. You can’t support two people on 18k.

Depends who you ask. Apparently Income support for a couple, where both are over 18 is £133.30 a week, or £6931.60 a year. Less if one or both are under 18.

Is that right? Is it really for a couple or do they get that each? I know people who spend more than that on their pets.

No wonder we're regularly admonished by the UN for our treatment of the poor.

Dibbydoos · 05/12/2023 01:08

£38k is high. The av salary in the UK is below this ffs https://www.statista.com/statistics/416139/full-time-annual-salary-in-the-uk-by-region/

How does it affect non economic immigrants? In and amongst real refugees/asylum seekers are the freeloaders and isn't it those people we can't afford to house/support?

I honestly think they've done nothing but put in jeopardy what is a good process for economic migration.... Another Tory failing.

UK full-time annual salary by region 2023 | Statista

Average earnings in London were higher than the rest of the UK in 2023, with earnings varying significantly across UK regions.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/416139/full-time-annual-salary-in-the-uk-by-region

Rocket1982 · 05/12/2023 01:00

Of course it's not fair. Rich people can marry whoever they like (and live in the same country as them). Poor people can't. That's the bottom line.

wordler · 05/12/2023 00:55

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/12/2023 00:52

Fair enough. I missed that those on a spouse visa can work.

Thanks - that’s what makes this such a messed up system

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/12/2023 00:52

wordler · 05/12/2023 00:47

Well -

  1. my DH can and would work but the level of income he would provide isn’t taken into account in the initial application so he can’t get here to start a job
  2. I’d be able to work too - between us we’d be able to cover any caretaking needs but likely looking at local wage rates not enough on my own to meet the 38,000 threshold, however
  3. We’d have no rent or household bills those would be covered by family and we’d have enough from savings and work to cover everything else including the NHS fees for spouse.
Edited

Fair enough. I missed that those on a spouse visa can work.

bombastix · 05/12/2023 00:49

user1477391263 · 05/12/2023 00:38

Seems to me like a lot of immigration policies would work “as intended” a lot more smoothly if it were lawful to make distinctions based on country of origin! We do treat different countries differently when trading with them; why not immigration?

Honestly you cannot have what would appear to the world as a wyattz only immigration policy which is potentially what such s change would represent.

Money works well as a proxy. The Home Office won this point in principle nearly a decade ago.

wordler · 05/12/2023 00:47

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/12/2023 00:26

I have had a freelance career

As I mentioned I'd been planning to bring DH and DD to the UK to live for a period of time so that we can look after my Dad and keep him in his own home.

I’m just curious and clearly you don’t have to answer. But how are you going to support the family if you are caring for your father and your husband can’t work?

Well -

  1. my DH can and would work but the level of income he would provide isn’t taken into account in the initial application so he can’t get here to start a job
  2. I’d be able to work too - between us we’d be able to cover any caretaking needs but likely looking at local wage rates not enough on my own to meet the 38,000 threshold, however
  3. We’d have no rent or household bills those would be covered by family and we’d have enough from savings and work to cover everything else including the NHS fees for spouse.