Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
User123456713 · 05/12/2023 08:22

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 08:12

Reducing supply will increase price - which is staff pay.

It’ll have faster impact if higher wages are what you’re after

One reason we go after so many foreign students is because Uni funding has been cut, tuition fees (quite rightly) have been frozen for years but Govt funding hasn't compensated.

As for wages going UP, that might be the case in some sectors but not in health, we have 100k NHS vacancies, 150k vacancies in social care, yet wages are terrible, same in social work.
In fact wages have fallen against other sectors, one reason why care workers leave to work in Tesco etc.

Austerity has caused untold harm to this country, even a former Chief Sec to the treasury is on record as saying it was a mistake and UK should have been borrowing, to invest, post 2010 when interest rates super low, now we are borrowing to try and fix issues, but failing, at very high rates.

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 08:21

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 08:16

I don't think it needs to work so fast that spouses are separated. They've had 13 years to deal with this, why is it suddenly so urgent? Because its about winning the gammon votes, not bringing down migration for the good of the country.

The net migration figures were very high. People went nuts. Policies are brought in

Any gov is likely to keep net migration levels to a figure that doesn’t spark outrage

It has so down they go.

If supply falls, wages go up. Given our aging population and higher imo cultural use of care homes (against some other countries) those higher care fees will not be easy. So each time people say they want something it does have impact. Likely to be really hard to pay for care homes

Tacotortoise · 05/12/2023 08:21

Categorising everyone who thinks that the current rate of net migration is neither sustainable or desirable as a "gammon" doesn't exactly bolster you position (whatever that is).

bombastix · 05/12/2023 08:19

The question is whether Labour would change it. I did not actually hear that they would.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 08:16

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 08:12

Reducing supply will increase price - which is staff pay.

It’ll have faster impact if higher wages are what you’re after

I don't think it needs to work so fast that spouses are separated. They've had 13 years to deal with this, why is it suddenly so urgent? Because its about winning the gammon votes, not bringing down migration for the good of the country.

Tacotortoise · 05/12/2023 08:16

@Oliotya whilst I agree all those things would be good I don't understand how they'd help decrease migration. Surely they'd just make the UK an even more attractive destination?

Decreasing migration means either running the country into the ground so no one wants to come or saying "no" to some people.

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 08:12

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 08:08

Reduce demand. Pay health and social care properly, fund universities adequately, invest in agricultural tech. Attacking the right to a family life is just an easy target.

Reducing supply will increase price - which is staff pay.

It’ll have faster impact if higher wages are what you’re after

bombastix · 05/12/2023 08:09

@zendeveloper - setting an income limit for British citizens is lawful and has already been tested in the courts where the Government won.

Had they had an explicit list of countries to exclude people that would not be lawful.

You can discriminate in law. The point is where you draw the line, and why.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 08:08

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 08:03

I'm all for reducing immigration, but not like this.

How would you reduce it?

Reduce demand. Pay health and social care properly, fund universities adequately, invest in agricultural tech. Attacking the right to a family life is just an easy target.

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 08:07

Supply and demand is likely to impact care wages, if cheaper o/s staff go down, although it may just be fewer married o/s staff in any case, but if it does impact then wages go up

It means care fees go up though, and that will have other implications

Fewer can afford it and / or council bills are high

High low wage immigration does help keep all wages down, plus increase need for infrastructure, so it’s what do people prefer

silentpool · 05/12/2023 08:04

Endless cheap immigrant labour has held down British wages for at least 2 decades. The West needs to abandon the myth of endless growth, which is driving down living standards.

How much of the extra housing, infrastructure, nurses, multiple Prets etc would be really needed if population growth wasn't on steroids and was stable?

Groundhoghcg · 05/12/2023 08:03

And as for nursing, who would want massive stress, awful conditions and a big student loan for 28k? A small uplift would make a big difference, and I'm confident it would be cheaper than importing nurses who the existing nurse workforce have to train to UK standards.

I value my Nigerian colleagues but nursing in Nigeria is VERY different and it takes at least a year of on the job teaching for them to be able to work independently. It's exhausting.

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 08:03

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 08:00

This is like Brexit all over again. Numbers make good headlines but the consequences haven't really been thought through. Anyone who thinks fewer carers, fewer nursers and more single parents is a good thing hasn't got the brain capacity to vote. But then, that's what they're relying on isn't it.
I'm all for reducing immigration, but not like this.

I'm all for reducing immigration, but not like this.

How would you reduce it?

newusern99 · 05/12/2023 08:02

user1477391263 · 05/12/2023 00:08

I live in Japan with my Japanese husband. He earns about 120K a year and I am a part-time worker who earns below this threshold. Pretty sure we’d be barred from the UK under these rules, even though my husband is a high earner and our family would be a net contributor to the public purse!

Can they not at least look at both spouses’ incomes or the combined income, and make some sort of distinction between developed and developing countries? The rules are being brought in, I suspect, to stop “chain migration” where people bring in cousins from developing countries as spouses. Perhaps that is a bit dysfunctional, but there are surely more sensible ways of stopping such migration.

Surely if your DH is earning 120k he could still come to uk but would have to be via a worker visa and job? Not saying I agree with the policy but it does at least seem that there would be a way for some spouses to still come?

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 08:02

Groundhoghcg · 05/12/2023 08:00

So we either need to import more people to do these roles or find better ways to use existing workers through tech/working practices.

or funnel some of the bottomless pit of cash we have for controlling immigration into paying decent money for care work. If care paid decently and offered a career path it would appeal to school leavers.

This. Improve pay and conditions and we wouldn't need to import people in the first place.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 08:00

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 07:51

If everyone goes mad over high net migration then obviously the next stage is new policies to stop that outcry. (Nearly everyone for those who say I didn’t)

Not sure what people expected when they were annoyed saying it’s too high etc

This is like Brexit all over again. Numbers make good headlines but the consequences haven't really been thought through. Anyone who thinks fewer carers, fewer nursers and more single parents is a good thing hasn't got the brain capacity to vote. But then, that's what they're relying on isn't it.
I'm all for reducing immigration, but not like this.

Groundhoghcg · 05/12/2023 08:00

So we either need to import more people to do these roles or find better ways to use existing workers through tech/working practices.

or funnel some of the bottomless pit of cash we have for controlling immigration into paying decent money for care work. If care paid decently and offered a career path it would appeal to school leavers.

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 07:51

ElevenSeven · 05/12/2023 07:19

@EasternStandard Quite. Seems people want it reduced, but of course not in any way which might affect them personally.

If everyone goes mad over high net migration then obviously the next stage is new policies to stop that outcry. (Nearly everyone for those who say I didn’t)

Not sure what people expected when they were annoyed saying it’s too high etc

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 07:43

newusern99 · 05/12/2023 07:36

@WhenLoveIsDone in an earlier post someone said that once you are in the UK and applying for spousal visa the spouses salary can be used to make up the 38k. I think at the moment we have to wait for the details as only headlines have been published so far?

Once you are in the UK, yes both incomes are counted. But that doesn't help if you are not already in the UK, if your spouse is on a visa that doesn't allow work, if circumstances change before gaining ILR. It could affect families who have already been through 5 years of visas, just because they can't redesign their entire lives in a matter of months.

newusern99 · 05/12/2023 07:36

@WhenLoveIsDone in an earlier post someone said that once you are in the UK and applying for spousal visa the spouses salary can be used to make up the 38k. I think at the moment we have to wait for the details as only headlines have been published so far?

jasflowers · 05/12/2023 07:35

Rosiiee · 05/12/2023 06:58

@Groundhoghcg they don’t. Hence why they go to countries like Australia which pays healthcare workers a slightly more decent income. So UK is losing healthcare workers to other countries offering more money AND now will be losing some because foreign healthcare workers can’t afford to bring their family over so will return to their home country.

No matter how much money UK spends on education, it won’t make a difference unless they increase salaries to attract younger generations.

Edit: obviously as a previous nurse I’m focusing on healthcare but no doubt that also affects teachers and other essential jobs!

Edited

The hasn't a pool of young A Level students sitting around doing nothing, if you attract these students into Health or Education they wont be going into other sectors.
Having seen the stresses NHS workers are under, no surprise they move to countries that offer more money, less hours and lower stress.

We need face facts, we haven't enough younger people but do have a lot more older people but allowing workers to bring in dependent parents is a bit stupid.

So we either need to import more people to do these roles or find better ways to use existing workers through tech/working practices.

WhenLoveIsDone · 05/12/2023 07:26

Zamzamzamdeedah · 05/12/2023 07:11

These visa restrictions are not for people already living here. These are for bringing spouse over. So foreigner already living in UK can "date lower income Brit" because this restriction doesn't apply. Jnless something changed

Yes they do. For the spouse visa when you apply the spouse has to remain overseas for up to a year (more than 90% of applications which are 3 month long in theory are rejected, then you appeal). Then you reapply about halfway through your 5yr visa. Then at the end you have apply for leave to remain.

The new 38k also applies to leave to remain after five costly years of spousal visas (leave to remain currently costs nearly 3k to apply for, doubtless this will jump too). This has to be stable salaried income for more than 6months before application date (proved with wage slips, bank account statements and an employer letter). You can't just find another quick side job to make up the shortfall before applying.

My family have woken up today and the kids are oblivious but my husband's mind is all - where shall we go? Because these arbitrary huge and ever-growing requirements (this one more than doubling overnight!) can't be met. A foreign spouse/parent now a luxury item, like dental care. 38k overnight from 18.5k? We own our house and have never claimed any sort of benefit but it's irrelevant.

renthead · 05/12/2023 07:24

@CormorantStrikesBack no it doesn't include healthcare! Permanent residents have all the same entitlements as citizens, including healthcare.

I looked up the rules and the actual rule is that you have to promise to financially support them for 3 years. If there is a breakup and the spouse goes on welfare/benefits in the first three years, the government can claw that money back from the sponsoring spouse.

CormorantStrikesBack · 05/12/2023 07:20

Zamzamzamdeedah · 05/12/2023 07:11

These visa restrictions are not for people already living here. These are for bringing spouse over. So foreigner already living in UK can "date lower income Brit" because this restriction doesn't apply. Jnless something changed

Well I guess moving forward it’s less likely that a foreigner will be able to be here seeing as they’re also increasing the amount needed to be earned for a working visa. But yes some foreigners will still be able to come if they earn 38k or more.

But no idea what happens if then they meet a low earning Brit and get married, I assume they can’t convert their working visa to a spouse visa? So no long term security because if they lose their job do they have to leave? Even if they have kids?

ElevenSeven · 05/12/2023 07:19

@EasternStandard Quite. Seems people want it reduced, but of course not in any way which might affect them personally.