Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
greengreengrass25 · 09/12/2023 23:39

BouncingJAS · 09/12/2023 17:57

@greengreengrass25

Birth rates in a country need to be looked at in two ways:

  1. Women (in general) are postponing having children to work (as a necessity and/or to develop a career)

I would argue that the interval for fertility has moved to 27 - 37 now in the UK (based on a normal distribution so 80% of births to women occurr then)

So what is impacting the ability of women to have children at those ages?

  1. Cost of childcare (number one driver) in UK
  2. Cost of living in general (housing included)
  3. Lower wages*
  4. A tax structure that discourages having more children (for higher earners we have cutoffs at £50k and £100k, and lower earners we also have cutoffs at 2 children).
  5. Fertility rates (globally) have been dropping due to environmental factors (due to pollution)

*This is being exacerbated by a higher tax burden now as graduates need to pay 9% above £25k to pay back their student loans. Graduates enter the workplace facing high debt loads and crushing taxes, so having children is the last thing on their minds. They tend to mostly save up for buying a house first. Having a family is a dream for many at that point.

These trends can be improved with adjustments to the tax structure (universal child benefit) investing more in childcare (nurseries), and by simplifying planning permission (so more housing gets built such as social housing).

Yes I don't disagree with what you are saying

izimbra · 09/12/2023 22:29

"But we don't have migrant hostels housing 200 angry young men making demands."

What 'demands' would those be?

As I said, I have two migrant hostels that are walking distance from my home. I live in an area which is pretty deprived - but predominantly non-white. There's very little complaining and angst about migrants or the migrant hostel on local facebook pages. And that's despite the fact that the area has suffered hugely and visibly from the fallout of a decade of austerity.

I don't think it's the case that local people are blase about the huge increase in population caused by immigration, and the impact this is having on communities in the context of collapsing public services, I think they just don't dehumanise and blame immigrants themselves for the faiings of government immigration policy and austerity.

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 22:26

Modestly successful in SE Cornwall means an average public sector monthly income... so a band 5 or 6 nurse, or a teacher's income. Those are considered high-ish earners locally, compared to cleaning B&B accommodation or seasonal hospitality.

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 22:15

The majority of the UKs 68m pop. have zero interaction with the migrants crossing the channel, its racism, pure and simple

I don't think that's true. I live in a 97% white area of the UK, and the POC who have come here seem to like it too. Even the young lads who wore doo-rags a few years ago seem to have given them up. But we don't have migrant hostels housing 200 angry young men making demands. Out here, we make a living to get by, nobody is getting filthy rich. Modestly successful is the goal.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 09/12/2023 22:12

izimbra · 09/12/2023 21:50

"Completely agree with cancelling them in event of divorce in the future"

This scenario: British man marries foreign woman, she comes to live in the UK and they have children together. The children are British citizens. British husband now becomes highly abusive. Points out to wife that if she leaves she'll lose her right to remain in the UK and share the parenting of their children.

Sounds a bit inhumane to me.

Not even share the parenting but lose the right to live in the same country as her children as she would need permission to take them abroad.

izimbra · 09/12/2023 22:08

"Yes I think it's fair."

I'm going to guess you're a high earner, and think that it's reasonable for poorer families to be torn apart by this change?

izimbra · 09/12/2023 22:05

BTW - young men lech at women all the time. It's horrible. I remember how it made me feel when I was young. But you seem to think there's something particularly heinous about asylum seekers letching at women, why?

izimbra · 09/12/2023 22:03

"But when those people see young men arriving on rafts being accommodated in hotels they can't afford for even a few days of holiday, for months, at taxpayers' expense, and then having them lech at their teenage daughters coming out of schools without anyone being able to do anything to disperse them, they feel powerless and become angry at immigrants."

But the OP wasn't asking about asylum policy.

She was asking about immigration policies for British people with foreign spouses, and obviously British children with foreign parents, who will be deeply harmed by the huge uplift in spousal income requirements.

I'm exactly the type of person you're referring to in terms of our income and lifestyle. I also live in an area where there are several migrant hostels within walking distance of our house. One of them is a hotel. I don't feel resentment of the people living in them at all. I have an 18 year old son and a 20 year old son. I imagine them leaving everything they know to try to make a life somewhere where they'll be safe. Remember that most of the people coming by boat are coming from places like Eritrea, Iran, Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan. I can't imagine how utterly depressing it must be for them to be here alone, far from friends and family, with so much uncertainty about their futures. But then I see them as human beings that aren't much different from my own sons. Maybe if I was Islamophobic and reading the Daily Mail every day, and constantly winding myself up by reading bigoted social media posts referring to these migrants as 'men of fighting age' I might feel different, but they're just people.

Smidge001 · 09/12/2023 21:59

Yes I think it's fair.
And I say this as someone whose husband is on this very visa.

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 21:58

I take your point, and I too live rurally, and there are so few POC locally they are not really relevant to my local debate.

However, my DM lives in a cul de sac in a VERY diverse medium sized town in the Midlands where her neighbours are mostly not UK born because the 2 up 2 down houses around her are mostly owned by BTL landlords. DM bought her house long ago and has watched the town change around her. And most of her neighbours now are East European. They re good, friendly and do look out for her, and she takes parcels in, if requested, as she's mostly at home. The same cannot be said about the taxi companies she uses regularly.

izimbra · 09/12/2023 21:50

"Completely agree with cancelling them in event of divorce in the future"

This scenario: British man marries foreign woman, she comes to live in the UK and they have children together. The children are British citizens. British husband now becomes highly abusive. Points out to wife that if she leaves she'll lose her right to remain in the UK and share the parenting of their children.

Sounds a bit inhumane to me.

User123456713 · 09/12/2023 21:35

But when those people see young men arriving on rafts being accommodated in hotels they can't afford for even a few days of holiday, for months, at taxpayers' expense, and then having them lech at their teenage daughters coming out of schools without anyone being able to do anything to disperse them, they feel powerless and become angry at immigrants

It was middle aged builders (uk white citizens) that leeched at my DD when she went back to her Halls a few years ago, forcing her to take a longer walk back home.

The majority of the UKs 68m pop. have zero interaction with the migrants crossing the channel, its racism, pure and simple

e.g i live rurally, we rarely see anyone who isn't white british, yet there is outright hatred towards migrants and the better off hate them more than say someone on NMW & that hatred is stirred up by people like Farage, Boris, Braverman etc etc

Same with friends of ours in France, they see no migrants in their Pyrenean town, yet due to people like Le Penn, detest them.

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 21:02

@izimbra , one of my favourite songs!

But I disagree otherwise. It's not all performative harshness (although it is a factor showing off how hard you can be). There is a largely quiescent conforming element in the UK, who work hard and want their kids to do well and to be left alone to get on with life. The 'just about managing' and the 'hard pressed middle' to borrow politicians' phrases.

But when those people see young men arriving on rafts being accommodated in hotels they can't afford for even a few days of holiday, for months, at taxpayers' expense, and then having them lech at their teenage daughters coming out of schools without anyone being able to do anything to disperse them, they feel powerless and become angry at immigrants.

It is individuals becoming angry. It's visible right across Europe, the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, Germany, France: come the EU elections next May, all bets are off. You don't have to think skin colour or religion are relevant, but they are visible symbols of 'outsider'.

Where as we taxpayers are actually much more pissed off at the fat idlers next door coasting on benefits and doing odd jobs (usually badly) for cash in hand, while dealing weed. The UK's informal economy has been allowed to run riot get out of hand.

AnneElliott · 09/12/2023 20:50

SpideyMum22 · 04/12/2023 20:53

Completely agree with cancelling them in event of divorce in the future. A very close friend married a man from Egypt who left her literally the day he got his British Passport after pretending everything was fine and they were happy. He never worked a day while living off her but was suddenly able to work enough hours to meet the threshold of 18,600 to bring his new Egyptian wife over (who it turned out had actually encouraged him to marry my friend in the first place to use her). Sadly we saw many similar cases

This is extremely common. I used to work in immigration and saw this a lot. British women would be completely taken in and convinced the 20 year old Turkish waiter was the love of their life.

British men viewed it as 2 years of sex on tap before the wife moved on and they got a new one. Absolutely grim.

izimbra · 09/12/2023 20:20

The benefits cap in the UK is set at about 22K a year for a couple, so I assume the government thinks that at a pinch a family could live on that.

The scheme is stupid and cruel, will cost the country money and damage the wellbeing of children with a foreign parent. It's particularly unfair to British women and mothers because as a group they have lower average earnings than British men. It will result in families being separated and British women with foreign spouses being more likely to need to claim universal credit and help with childcare.

But the cruelty is the point. The Conservatives have NOTHING to campaign on other than performative harshness towards immigrants to pander to people who have been left in despair by falling standards of living after 13 years of Tory government, who are willing to blame immigrants for everything.

User123456713 · 09/12/2023 19:43

@greengreengrass25 Migrants aren't eligible for council/social housing, as they a) not been here for long enough and b) in the case of most workers, will have a "no recourse to public funds" on the visa.

UK has a housing crisis because we don't build enough houses and what we do build is too expensive, even the so called "affordable ones" they are just a few % cheaper than open market.

BouncingJAS · 09/12/2023 17:57

@greengreengrass25

Birth rates in a country need to be looked at in two ways:

  1. Women (in general) are postponing having children to work (as a necessity and/or to develop a career)

I would argue that the interval for fertility has moved to 27 - 37 now in the UK (based on a normal distribution so 80% of births to women occurr then)

So what is impacting the ability of women to have children at those ages?

  1. Cost of childcare (number one driver) in UK
  2. Cost of living in general (housing included)
  3. Lower wages*
  4. A tax structure that discourages having more children (for higher earners we have cutoffs at £50k and £100k, and lower earners we also have cutoffs at 2 children).
  5. Fertility rates (globally) have been dropping due to environmental factors (due to pollution)

*This is being exacerbated by a higher tax burden now as graduates need to pay 9% above £25k to pay back their student loans. Graduates enter the workplace facing high debt loads and crushing taxes, so having children is the last thing on their minds. They tend to mostly save up for buying a house first. Having a family is a dream for many at that point.

These trends can be improved with adjustments to the tax structure (universal child benefit) investing more in childcare (nurseries), and by simplifying planning permission (so more housing gets built such as social housing).

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 09/12/2023 15:25

nationallampoons · 04/12/2023 20:06

I think it's very fair. I also think spousal visas should be restricted and be cancelled if they divorced within 10 years

I've seen too many people burned

What happens if they have children, will they be banned from living in the same country as their child?

Weegie91 · 09/12/2023 15:20

CrashyTime · 09/12/2023 14:12

Spoke to someone on a visa the other day, only been here a couple of years, they are not worried about this as they are a hard worker prepared to do an extra job, they agreed though that it disadvantages people with young children and that maybe that is the point of this?

The problem is getting the initial visa. The non-UK spouse may be earning £250k a year, but unless their British spouse earns the threshold, they don't qualify. After you cross that first hurdle, I think most people would be fine.

WhenLoveIsDone · 09/12/2023 14:35

It is going to depend on when their visa comes up for renewal whether they have enough time to satisfy the new requirements or not. The spouse visa has to be renewed about halfway through and you have to prove that stable income for a set period of time before applying.

CrashyTime · 09/12/2023 14:12

Spoke to someone on a visa the other day, only been here a couple of years, they are not worried about this as they are a hard worker prepared to do an extra job, they agreed though that it disadvantages people with young children and that maybe that is the point of this?

CrashyTime · 09/12/2023 14:09

Papyrophile · 08/12/2023 20:18

The recent increase in NMW that takes effect next spring and brings min wage to £11.44 per hour will mean that my chef DS with several years of five star kitchen experience is going to be earning £0.06 pence per hour more than the newest hire? He's not going to help that novice chef learn his trade and improve his skills. The going rate for a chef de partie (who runs a section of the kitchen but is not a senior) is £11.50 per hour, and the shifts are 11 am to 11 pm.

So what, a skilled chef needs to chase a pay rise or go elsewhere if they are so pissed off they wont pass knowledge onto new-starts because they earn nearly the same, people need a pay rise, commercial property has tanked because people wont let go of the WFH meme and the last thing the government needs now (especially an un-elected ex-banker PM) is for defaults on residential mortgages and BTL loans!

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 12:43

Sadly, I only have a Kiwi Fairy Godmother!

WhenLoveIsDone · 09/12/2023 12:06

Not for spouses and families, which is what this thread is about. I'm sorry you couldn't move there, though.

Papyrophile · 09/12/2023 12:01

NZ certainly used to have very strict immigration rules and quotas. We considered moving there and buying a business in 2008, and did not fulfil the requirements. Also decided it was too far from aged parents.