Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
caringcarer · 05/12/2023 12:27

SkyFullofStars1975 · 04/12/2023 20:36

If we stopped the 5 million unemployed from having an equivalent/better lifestyle on benefits to those working... we wouldn't need to import labour.

I don't think the Government will ever figure this out, mind.

I agree. Tory's keep saying work pays but often if you have 2 DC and disabilities benefits pay more.

caringcarer · 05/12/2023 12:25

HumanBurrito · 04/12/2023 20:26

I'm British, living in Europe. Moved over in the early 2000s, way before Brexit. I have British kids and a European husband. I earn a good wage, him less so because he works part time to look after the kids. This ruling means I and my British children would be unable to live in the country where we are citizens.

Once kids are at school your DH could get a full time job. Then between you you'd earn enough.

caringcarer · 05/12/2023 12:23

roarrfeckingroar · 04/12/2023 20:17

I don't think anyone should get a penny in UC / housing benefit / any in work benefits until they've paid in for five years. There should be a higher threshold id bringing a spouse and higher if children too because of NHS / school costs.

I agree.

Weegie91 · 05/12/2023 12:23

I have read this thread with interest but also, it has made me very sad. Some of these comments are very hurtful and I have found myself thinking... damn, I really wish we didn't choose the UK as our home because I am clearly not welcome.

My British wife and I have just finished a five year old path so I could become a permanent citizen. In that time, we have spent £8k+ in visa applications and processing fees and £3k+ in additional NHS fees (on top of what I already pay in my taxes).

I was not allowed to stay in the country while our first visa was being processed, so we were separated for months. After it was granted, I got a job within THREE days of arrival and have worked ever since. We have NEVER applied for benefits. If we did, my visa would be cancelled and I would get deported. I have since opened my own company which has been successful and earn a very good wage.

But it's the small things that make the entire process ridiculous. As part of my first visa application, we had to pay a legal firm to MEASURE my wife's apartment to make sure there was enough room for me to live there (?!?). When we purchased our first property, only ONE bank were willing to lend to us because of my immigration status, so we just had to take their rate. When COVID hit, I was so scared that any hint of government help to keep my business running would impact my next visa, I did not apply and struggled through.

We have put off having children because we were always scared the rules would change and suddenly we wouldn't meet the requirements. In return, I am looked at as a burden and some kind of leech on British taxpayers. In reality, I have paid double for services like the NHS and now I can't even get a doctors appointment.

So, am I the problem? Or is it because this country refuses to pay its citizens a decent wage and actually invest in services, like the NHS, that are so important apparently?

Absolutely wild.

altmember · 05/12/2023 12:21

It should be 100k. But we need to fix lots of other problems with the British economy/workforce as well.

caringcarer · 05/12/2023 12:18

I think the average wage is fair. £18k was way too low as few could support themselves without social housing or benefits on that low income.

BestBadger · 05/12/2023 12:15

Good question.

IceandIndigo · 05/12/2023 12:09

I wonder if there have been any challenges to the rules on gender discrimination grounds? We also know that women are more likely to be taking on caring responsibilities within a family, which makes it more difficult to meet the income thresholds.

bombastix · 05/12/2023 11:21

@fetchacloth / yes. To grow any public spending now we need to change our economy into one with more contributors and greater contribution. Otherwise we will stagnate economically. Immigration is about the economy. We don't have it because it's nice to be diverse.

fetchacloth · 05/12/2023 11:17

silentpool · 05/12/2023 08:04

Endless cheap immigrant labour has held down British wages for at least 2 decades. The West needs to abandon the myth of endless growth, which is driving down living standards.

How much of the extra housing, infrastructure, nurses, multiple Prets etc would be really needed if population growth wasn't on steroids and was stable?

The only thing that is growing is our population. Economically we are hardly growing at all which is why we are struggling to fund our public services.

fetchacloth · 05/12/2023 11:16

Crispedia · 05/12/2023 01:19

2.6 million of those receive sickness benefits due to long-term sickness or disability. This was the same number in 2010, decreased a bit (about 200,000) now back to 2.6 million. Get away with your lazy accusations!

I agree @Crispedia and I would add that there are several tens, maybe hundreds of thousands of over 50s that are willing to work, and looking for it, but employers just don't want to employ these people. That is a shocking waste of talent and work experience!

Refbuckethat · 05/12/2023 10:48

@Rosiiee agree re the issues around retention. I'm sure if hospital staff had access to 24/7 cheap childcare on site it would be a very different picture. I had a friend who used a cheap hospital based nursery but the hours were still only 7.30-6pm
Useless for a lot of staff

Rosiiee · 05/12/2023 10:39

What @Refbuckethat said but also it’s not just about getting people to get into health. It’s about keeping them there. The turnaround for nurses is ridiculous! I was a nurse for 5 years and then changed careers when I had children because we couldn’t afford a private childminder/no crèche spots! It’s a bloody vicious circle!

Rocket1982 · 05/12/2023 10:39

Everyone who is telling people they can just go and live in the spouse's country is relying on the spouse's country not being the arseholes that we are. If the spouse's country imposed reciprocal rules (as they have every right to do), how exactly would a married couple then live together?

HumanBurrito · 05/12/2023 10:39

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 09:49

Please remember that we're talking about the spouses and children of British people. I don't think it's right to reduce the value of that to an arbitrary figure. Besides, they are ineligible for any benefits anyway. No recourse to public funds.

We are talking about British children, who are not going to be able to live in Britain.

Refbuckethat · 05/12/2023 10:28

I think it's high but I also think effort should be made to encourage people to go into these jobs desperate for workers. I know a number of people who could get a job but they don't fancy shifts / care work / manual work so don't.

Foxsoxandgloves · 05/12/2023 10:26

I think in order to offer family visas, you need to have an infrastructure. I have an Iraqi colleague who just completed his asylum and finally got his British passport and is now booking his flight back to Baghdad to get a filling!

Foxsoxandgloves · 05/12/2023 10:24

I'm ancient, I did project 2000. No tuition fees, lived rent free in Central London for 3 years on nurse training and also, in the mid 90s, got £600 a month to luce on plus travel expenses. Term time only placements so plenty of capacity to earn extra without burning out. Perfect experience for me, lived in a tower block inside Charing Cross Hospital grounds, 2 minutes from Hammersmith Broadway, 2 seconds from a bus stop. Amazing how many Thatcher inventions now look positively inspired.

Tohaveandtohold · 05/12/2023 10:20

I think this is not fair as it’s such a big jump as well but then dh and I are immigrants and this has been the case for foreign nationals on a work visa for years, even though the foreign nationals had no recourse to public funds so no matter what they were earning, that’s what they will have to support their family with anyway.
I remember when DH had his first work visa, he had to be earning 26k for it and to have a dependent. By the time we were applying for indefinite leave to remain some 6 years ago, it had jumped to 36k and overtime earnings don’t count. We’re thankfully British now but the way the laws are changed is a lot. It’s m ridiculous that people who are working for the nhs as nurses, ot, physios, even junior doctors who are much needed can’t bring their spouses and family in here from overseas if needed.

BansheeofInisherin · 05/12/2023 10:16

It is a great summary @JassyRadlett.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 10:15

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 09:58

That's not really the right question - as a PP said, the issue is what's caused such a rapid increase in net migration since 2019, and what levers would affect it.

Students and their dependents make up 43% of the increase. That was a deliberate government strategy to make immigration rules more liberal for dependents and post-study work to attract foreign students. The income requirement does not impact this group - the government announced changes to these rules in the summer.

Humanitarian visas are next at about 30% of the increase, which is almost solely Ukraine and Hong Kong. These are unlikely to be permanent features of our immigration system.

Work visas (including dependents) are about 24% of the increase, with the main driver being health and social care (exempt from the new income requirement, though they will not be prevented from bringing dependents). We need to look at why the demand for these workers is so high - it's a poorly paid area that is increasingly unattractive to domestic workers, and demand is going through the roof as our population becomes increasingly unhealthy and increasingly elderly. If we want to sort out immigration, we need to sort out our health. The health impact of bad diets alone is going to explode in the next decade - reducing the available workforce and increasing demand for health and social care.

The family visa numbers have actually decreased since 2019 and make up less than 10% of not just the increase but the whole net migration figures. Spouses and family visas aren't driving the increase in net migration - this policy is just cruel, anti-family window dressing to try to distract from bad headlines.

All figures courtesy of Migration Observatory

Thanks for this response. Great summary for those who have formed opinions but haven't taken the time to understand the ins and outs of migration.

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 10:14

If people think net migration is too high but don’t want this policy how would you reduce it?

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 10:12

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 09:58

That's not really the right question - as a PP said, the issue is what's caused such a rapid increase in net migration since 2019, and what levers would affect it.

Students and their dependents make up 43% of the increase. That was a deliberate government strategy to make immigration rules more liberal for dependents and post-study work to attract foreign students. The income requirement does not impact this group - the government announced changes to these rules in the summer.

Humanitarian visas are next at about 30% of the increase, which is almost solely Ukraine and Hong Kong. These are unlikely to be permanent features of our immigration system.

Work visas (including dependents) are about 24% of the increase, with the main driver being health and social care (exempt from the new income requirement, though they will not be prevented from bringing dependents). We need to look at why the demand for these workers is so high - it's a poorly paid area that is increasingly unattractive to domestic workers, and demand is going through the roof as our population becomes increasingly unhealthy and increasingly elderly. If we want to sort out immigration, we need to sort out our health. The health impact of bad diets alone is going to explode in the next decade - reducing the available workforce and increasing demand for health and social care.

The family visa numbers have actually decreased since 2019 and make up less than 10% of not just the increase but the whole net migration figures. Spouses and family visas aren't driving the increase in net migration - this policy is just cruel, anti-family window dressing to try to distract from bad headlines.

All figures courtesy of Migration Observatory

Well it was the right question in that it’s what I was interested in getting an answer to

At some point a net migration figure prompts a reaction and going by recent figures 750k has done that

Beyond that any country that has a high use of care homes will be struggling more in next few decades so that’s us. We’ll have to figure out if we want cheaper care labour or pay more for care or do it ourselves

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 09:58

EasternStandard · 05/12/2023 09:07

Were you ok with the net migration figures at 750k?

I don’t recall many saying they were, if not what number is more ok

That's not really the right question - as a PP said, the issue is what's caused such a rapid increase in net migration since 2019, and what levers would affect it.

Students and their dependents make up 43% of the increase. That was a deliberate government strategy to make immigration rules more liberal for dependents and post-study work to attract foreign students. The income requirement does not impact this group - the government announced changes to these rules in the summer.

Humanitarian visas are next at about 30% of the increase, which is almost solely Ukraine and Hong Kong. These are unlikely to be permanent features of our immigration system.

Work visas (including dependents) are about 24% of the increase, with the main driver being health and social care (exempt from the new income requirement, though they will not be prevented from bringing dependents). We need to look at why the demand for these workers is so high - it's a poorly paid area that is increasingly unattractive to domestic workers, and demand is going through the roof as our population becomes increasingly unhealthy and increasingly elderly. If we want to sort out immigration, we need to sort out our health. The health impact of bad diets alone is going to explode in the next decade - reducing the available workforce and increasing demand for health and social care.

The family visa numbers have actually decreased since 2019 and make up less than 10% of not just the increase but the whole net migration figures. Spouses and family visas aren't driving the increase in net migration - this policy is just cruel, anti-family window dressing to try to distract from bad headlines.

All figures courtesy of Migration Observatory

Net migration to the UK - Migration Observatory

An overview of net migration in the UK – defined as the difference between immigration and emigration of people moving for at least a year.

https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/long-term-international-migration-flows-to-and-from-the-uk/

bombastix · 05/12/2023 09:53

I see some discussion of a cap on migration which is really the Conservatives floating the idea pre-election. If you think this is unfair, a cap is in principle much worse, because you either get your application in at the right time to be included, or if you could cap applications per month, leaving a random element as to who qualifies for visas dependent who else applies in that month.

Incidentally I often hear people putting of UK citizenship applications; the direction of travel is pretty clear. I would assume that can get harder and the rules changed there too. Do not put it off. Get it done, because ILR could also be changed as a status.