Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
CormorantStrikesBack · 05/12/2023 19:05

Sad state of affairs but this country is now apparently 20% poorer than it was 15 years ago, a legacy of the financial crash followed by austerity then Brexit then COVID. We need a new government with some better ideas.

I do completely agree with this. Obviously Brexit and Covid have been shit shows for the economy but the thinking now is that actually austerity was the worst thing. The govt should have taken advantage of cheap interest rates at the time to borrow and invest in the country and stimulate the economy into growth. But it fucked up and did the opposite, the economy tanked even worse and now the government are having to borrow at a time of high interest rates. Which long term will also fuck the economy up. Not sure what the answer is but I suspect it’s not a Tory government. They have completely crucified the economy never mind all the other shit.

WhichIsItWendy · 05/12/2023 19:04

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:43

But there are already additional income requirements for foreign children. Any British children aren't subject to migration law. The foreign spouse and children aren't entitled to claim any benefits.
It's ethically uncomfortable? Yes it is, and I don't think unethical migration policy is ok just because other places are the same or worse.

There are lots of things that are ethically ideal but unrealistic. I'm sorry, but to ignore negative effects is just ridiculous.

Give me an adult who can survive independently on £18k in the south east and I'll eat my words. £38k is high, but so is the cost of living. If people want to move abroad, they need to meet the criteria. That's the case everywhere in the world.

fetchacloth · 05/12/2023 18:59

anon666 · 05/12/2023 18:17

I guess in effect what they're doing is setting an income threshold that represents what you need to live on without requiring a taxpayer subsidy to live here.

The factors that led to this state of affairs are miserable, namely that this is a rentier economy, with housing and energy costs being so high that the state has to subsidise every person on minimum wage. It's perverse.

Ironically, despite this, there are still lots of advantages here compared to other countries, including a very open lightly regulated market economy and an open job market.

However, each family on average wages costs more money to support than they pay in taxes, because of the free health service, free education, very different to most places that are similarly open.

In reality it's unsustainable. We can't keep importing people that are a net drain on the country's finances, when they are in such terrible shape. Housing shortages alone mean there just isn't the capacity to house people.

Employers will have to pay a living wage that allows people to pay for their own housing costs rather than import cheap labour from abroad. It's all a terrible imbalance anyway, with a lot of jobs needing the subsidy of council housing to make them viable.

Sad state of affairs but this country is now apparently 20% poorer than it was 15 years ago, a legacy of the financial crash followed by austerity then Brexit then COVID. We need a new government with some better ideas.

This gets the best post on the thread award and explains very clearly why we need to have an income threshold.

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:58

Notonthestairs · 05/12/2023 18:52

There are already 165,000 vacancies in social care. We've cut funding to local authorities that have a statutory duty to provide care.
There doesn't seem to be a social care workforce plan in place and we have an ageing population.

Absolute dereliction in duty towards vulnerable people.

They use agency workers, that is why more councils will eventually go bust, that and dabbling in commercial property like they were Buffet`s Apprentice or something.

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:56

CozmicBee · 05/12/2023 18:54

With the age of the Internet and global social networks it is very easy for 2 people from different countries to fall in love and want to spend their lives with each other. It seems that you can only do that if you have money though. It's really sad.

Tragic, Taxpayer isn`t very romantic though unfortunately, they just want the open door shut and the Tory clown show know they have to address this to get elected again.

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:54

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:48

This has been addressed on a similar thread. Do you really want people who have been "compelled" to work looking after vulnerable people?

Depends on the people, most work-shy people are probably honest and capable enough with a bit of training, and if their benefits have been cut they won`t want to lose the job by being dishonest or negligent will they?

CozmicBee · 05/12/2023 18:54

With the age of the Internet and global social networks it is very easy for 2 people from different countries to fall in love and want to spend their lives with each other. It seems that you can only do that if you have money though. It's really sad.

BraveToaster · 05/12/2023 18:53

I think it's very unfair. This post is concerning UK spousal visas (so spouses of UK citizens, not spouses of immigrants) so I'll address that. I originally came to the UK on a student visa, met my ex-husband, moved back to my home country (USA) and did the long distance thing for awhile until we eventually decided to get married. We decided to live in the UK because my ex was in the UK Armed Forces. Under the new rules he would not be able to bring me to the UK because at the time I think his wage was £30-£35k. I was the much higher earner between us and found a job easily when I came to the UK. (For those wondering, you do lose your visa when you get divorced. Thankfully I am a high earner and was able to switch to a work visa instead. And your visa needs to be renewed after 2.5 and 5 years and they ask for proof of marriage each time).

The other thing to note is they only count the income of the UK citizen, and it must be earned in the UK. A few years ago I read an article by an Australian journalist who lived in Australia with his British wife and children. She wanted to move home to be closer to her family but as she was a stay at home mum she didn't have much recent work history so was unlikely to find a job that met the income threshold. She would also need to leave her family in Australia to return to the UK, find a job, and work for six months in order to submit the visa application. She was essentially exiled from her own country due to visa requirements. I imagine this will happen a lot more with the new rules.

This isn't the article I was thinking of but a similar situation:

How new UK spouse visa rules turned me into an Englishman in exile | Richard Fabb

Richard Fabb: Changes to UK visas for foreign spouses are barring thousands of citizens from going home. My choice? Exile in Australia, or breaking up my family

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/jul/09/uk-australia-spouse-visa

Notonthestairs · 05/12/2023 18:52

There are already 165,000 vacancies in social care. We've cut funding to local authorities that have a statutory duty to provide care.
There doesn't seem to be a social care workforce plan in place and we have an ageing population.

Absolute dereliction in duty towards vulnerable people.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:48

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:45

The wages will need to go up and people in the UK on benefits who are fit and healthy will need to be "compelled" to pick up these jobs, their benefits will need to be cut until they feel the urge to work for a living.

This has been addressed on a similar thread. Do you really want people who have been "compelled" to work looking after vulnerable people?

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:47

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:44

No, I think you can fuck off with your crash agenda on a thread where it is entirely irrelevant. Surprised you aren't too busy buying all the mega cheap houses to be on mumsnet by now. LOL.

Edited

Immigration and rents/house prices are very interlinked, not as much as cheap debt and house prices but still very connected.

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:45

Lulu49 · 05/12/2023 18:32

I'm more worried about how social care is going to be affected by care workers not being able to bring their families which is already quite a long drawn out process. Sometimes I'm the only British member of staff at work, 7-8 staff all the rest being immigrants who have their family here as well already. New people simply won't come if there's never going to be a possibility their families can join them. I'm dreading what's going to happen to an already short staffed situation. British people don't want the care jobs 🤷

The wages will need to go up and people in the UK on benefits who are fit and healthy will need to be "compelled" to pick up these jobs, their benefits will need to be cut until they feel the urge to work for a living.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:44

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:41

So you think affordable housing for people who work and contribute is "nonsense"? The reason people are pissed off at immigration is that they think it inflates rents and house prices, why do you think the majority of voters voted Leave after being told by Remain that it would crash house prices, LOL.

No, I think you can fuck off with your crash agenda on a thread where it is entirely irrelevant. Surprised you aren't too busy buying all the mega cheap houses to be on mumsnet by now. LOL.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:43

WhichIsItWendy · 05/12/2023 18:35

Well, just from my experience, typically it's common for migrants to need a while to adjust and it's uncommon for both people, with kids, to go into full time employment immediately. In fact, I'd say it's very rare.

Even a single person wouldn't survive well on £18k currently with the cost of living (without benefits) in the UK. They'd need top ups which just isn't sustainable.

If I wanted to move to Canada, I'd understand if I didn't meet all the criteria, I'd either look at other countries or stay where I am. Whilst it's ethically uncomfortable that there's not open migration across the world, in reality we need limits to protect population management.

But there are already additional income requirements for foreign children. Any British children aren't subject to migration law. The foreign spouse and children aren't entitled to claim any benefits.
It's ethically uncomfortable? Yes it is, and I don't think unethical migration policy is ok just because other places are the same or worse.

zendeveloper · 05/12/2023 18:42

bombastix · 05/12/2023 18:37

I think it's a bigger change than some realise; what it says is both parties need to work, the UK is no longer interested in people who don't, and that is part of the economics of this. Immigration is about supporting the economy. I note Labour haven't said they will undo this. That indicates to me underlying agreement even if they said it should be referred to the Migration Committee.

There seem to be two exceptions on exceptional circumstances which might mean this requirement is waived or you have savings. So it is not s complete bar but it is very tough.

I think it has been repeated to death on this thread. This requirement only applies to the British party, not joint income, unless the other party is already in the country independently of marriage, then joint income can be taken into account. Both can work and the "foreign" partner can actually outearn the British several times over, but only the latter counts.

OP posts:
CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:41

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:08

Can you please take your house price nonsense somewhere else. Not the thread for it.

So you think affordable housing for people who work and contribute is "nonsense"? The reason people are pissed off at immigration is that they think it inflates rents and house prices, why do you think the majority of voters voted Leave after being told by Remain that it would crash house prices, LOL.

WhichIsItWendy · 05/12/2023 18:40

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:17

Any policy that excludes most women is inherently discrimatory. Don't really see how you can argue otherwise. Unless you think most women just don't matter?

Whilst I understand your rhetoric, I think you're ignoring the outcome of unlimited migration of people with low or no income. It's just completely unrealistic.

Leila7654321 · 05/12/2023 18:39

@WhichIsItWendy Yes

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 18:38

blah blah blah

bombastix · 05/12/2023 18:37

I think it's a bigger change than some realise; what it says is both parties need to work, the UK is no longer interested in people who don't, and that is part of the economics of this. Immigration is about supporting the economy. I note Labour haven't said they will undo this. That indicates to me underlying agreement even if they said it should be referred to the Migration Committee.

There seem to be two exceptions on exceptional circumstances which might mean this requirement is waived or you have savings. So it is not s complete bar but it is very tough.

WhichIsItWendy · 05/12/2023 18:36

Leila7654321 · 05/12/2023 18:30

I'm gutted about it. I'm a British citizen, my child is a British citizen, but this makes it so much harder to bring my husband here and reunite our family. I earn an ok salary, I own property outright, my husband has the potential to earn a good salary, but I'm now 5k short of the 38k.

Where were you living together as a family previously?

WhichIsItWendy · 05/12/2023 18:35

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 09:02

Why does it need to be enough for a family to live on? There's a higher figure again for foreign children. British children are exempt, obviously, unless you think we should start means testing fertility?

Well, just from my experience, typically it's common for migrants to need a while to adjust and it's uncommon for both people, with kids, to go into full time employment immediately. In fact, I'd say it's very rare.

Even a single person wouldn't survive well on £18k currently with the cost of living (without benefits) in the UK. They'd need top ups which just isn't sustainable.

If I wanted to move to Canada, I'd understand if I didn't meet all the criteria, I'd either look at other countries or stay where I am. Whilst it's ethically uncomfortable that there's not open migration across the world, in reality we need limits to protect population management.

Lulu49 · 05/12/2023 18:32

I'm more worried about how social care is going to be affected by care workers not being able to bring their families which is already quite a long drawn out process. Sometimes I'm the only British member of staff at work, 7-8 staff all the rest being immigrants who have their family here as well already. New people simply won't come if there's never going to be a possibility their families can join them. I'm dreading what's going to happen to an already short staffed situation. British people don't want the care jobs 🤷

Leila7654321 · 05/12/2023 18:30

I'm gutted about it. I'm a British citizen, my child is a British citizen, but this makes it so much harder to bring my husband here and reunite our family. I earn an ok salary, I own property outright, my husband has the potential to earn a good salary, but I'm now 5k short of the 38k.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 18:29

Boysgrownbutstillathome · 05/12/2023 18:25

Health and care workers are exempt. Not fair for other people coming here to work though.

Exempt from the income requirement changes. But can't bring their family.
Hostile environment indeed. None of it is designed to be fair.