Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
bananamangoes · 05/12/2023 19:58

Seems
bonkers as we really really need more workers at junior level or even lower paid roles

What does an nhs nurse earn!

nomadmummy · 05/12/2023 19:56

I have so many questions.

But I'll start with some stats and numbers.

The average cost of living in the UK for a couple is £2500-3000 pm according to Kanan.co. (£30,000 to £36,000).

The UK spouse visa application fee in 2023 is £1,048 if your application is made inside the UK and £1,846 if your application is made outside the UK. Other costs include Immigration Healthcare Surcharge £624 for each year and biometric fee £19.20.

It is estimated that around 35,000 marriages or civil partnerships involving at least one non EEA national take place each year and that 4,000-10,000 applications a year to the Home Office are based on a sham marriage/CP. (UK Parliament)

32% of all foreign-born population living in UK had been here for at least 5 years. (UK Data Service)

45% of children of foreign-born parents live in poverty (UK Data Service)

Questions:

  • How are the people making lower wages affording to go abroad and meet people in the first place?
  • How do these foreign spouses afford to visit family?

-How long do people know each other (in real life not online) to foreign partners before bringing them here?

-How much do people know about the complications of having children with a foreign spouse if that spouse decides they don't want to stay in the UK?

-How often does abuse and coercive control happen in relationships once the spouse is here (which is known to be under-reported by victims)?

-How many of the people that come end up on benefits? Or working under the table? (Which is part of the reason for abolishing the Tier 1 highly skilled (general) visa scheme in 2009.

-How many overstayers are in the UK who originally entered on a spouse visa?

My view: There is no perfect immigration system anywhere. It's complicated. The UK has seen significant increases in visa and yet since 2012 removals have dropped significantly which means we have a huge population of overstyers. We have a lot of sham marriages. I often wondering (having been down this road) how many people really think through the challenges and consequences of bringing a foreign spouse to the UK.

DuesToTheDirt · 05/12/2023 19:48

In reality it's unsustainable. We can't keep importing people that are a net drain on the country's finances, when they are in such terrible shape.

In some sectors there is a shortage of workers - care work, for example.

So, let's say a carer gets paid 20k. Would you rather let people come to this country and do that job, with a subsidy from the taxpayer, or leave the job empty and the elderly struggling?

Employers will have to pay a living wage that allows people to pay for their own housing costs rather than import cheap labour from abroad.

This would be nice, but it's just unrealistic for some jobs. Take care work, again, or childcare. For these workers to be paid a decent salary, with no further government subsidy than there is already, care homes and childcare would go from very expensive to completely unaffordable.

User123456713 · 05/12/2023 19:47

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 19:32

They are financially compelled to do a job they may not have considered or aspired to if they want to live in the UK, many will be good at it, some not so good, it is the same for people lying about on the dole smoking weed, they might not have considered working three days at the local care home but if their money gets cut so they can`t afford their weed any more they might consider it? If they are too dodgy to be trusted around cash tins and medication they can get out and cut the grass or dig holes for some nice flowers that the residents can look at, or they could do a number on the piano in the communal area to keep people entertained, all better than being a taxpayer sucking waste of space?

I ve worked before in Social Enterprise, i can tell you that many people who are unemployed are also unemployable, variety of reasons, often MH related, some with physical health issues, most have not worked for many years.

They would require a great deal of effort to get to a state where you'd want them looking after your Gran or disabled son.

You'd want them working in a non care role for many months first, with extensive support & who have we got going spare to provide this? they'd need training up too

I really don't think a high motivated person, willing to leave their own country to seek work, can be compared to someone smoking weed & unemployed for years.

Arafina · 05/12/2023 19:38

Weegie91 · 05/12/2023 12:23

I have read this thread with interest but also, it has made me very sad. Some of these comments are very hurtful and I have found myself thinking... damn, I really wish we didn't choose the UK as our home because I am clearly not welcome.

My British wife and I have just finished a five year old path so I could become a permanent citizen. In that time, we have spent £8k+ in visa applications and processing fees and £3k+ in additional NHS fees (on top of what I already pay in my taxes).

I was not allowed to stay in the country while our first visa was being processed, so we were separated for months. After it was granted, I got a job within THREE days of arrival and have worked ever since. We have NEVER applied for benefits. If we did, my visa would be cancelled and I would get deported. I have since opened my own company which has been successful and earn a very good wage.

But it's the small things that make the entire process ridiculous. As part of my first visa application, we had to pay a legal firm to MEASURE my wife's apartment to make sure there was enough room for me to live there (?!?). When we purchased our first property, only ONE bank were willing to lend to us because of my immigration status, so we just had to take their rate. When COVID hit, I was so scared that any hint of government help to keep my business running would impact my next visa, I did not apply and struggled through.

We have put off having children because we were always scared the rules would change and suddenly we wouldn't meet the requirements. In return, I am looked at as a burden and some kind of leech on British taxpayers. In reality, I have paid double for services like the NHS and now I can't even get a doctors appointment.

So, am I the problem? Or is it because this country refuses to pay its citizens a decent wage and actually invest in services, like the NHS, that are so important apparently?

Absolutely wild.

I am so sad that you and thousands like you are made to feel like this, in my experience most of us don't see immigration as the biggest problem in this country even though that's what the government and the media want us to believe, unfortunately empty barrels make the most noise, please don't pay attention to them

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:37

We are going in circles here.

SherbetDips · 05/12/2023 19:37

Yes I think it’s fair.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 19:37

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 19:32

They are financially compelled to do a job they may not have considered or aspired to if they want to live in the UK, many will be good at it, some not so good, it is the same for people lying about on the dole smoking weed, they might not have considered working three days at the local care home but if their money gets cut so they can`t afford their weed any more they might consider it? If they are too dodgy to be trusted around cash tins and medication they can get out and cut the grass or dig holes for some nice flowers that the residents can look at, or they could do a number on the piano in the communal area to keep people entertained, all better than being a taxpayer sucking waste of space?

Gardening and piano playing? Tell me you haven't a clue about the state of the care sector without telling me you haven't a clue about the state of the care sector.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 19:35

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:27

You are saying you don't want anyone "compelled" to look after the vulnerable, in context of why British people can't do it, that means you don't think they will do a good a job as the immigrant ones.

The post I was responding to was suggesting cutting benefits as a method of compelling people into care work. I don't think forcing people into care work as a last resort is a good idea.
Improving pay and conditions so that people actively choose a career in care is far more likely to bring people suited to the job into the sector.

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 19:32

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 19:19

I don't think it's a strange statement at all.

It's not as if all fillipinos, eastern Europeans or Nigerians are care workers - most aren't. And I'm sure some of the ones that are probably shouldn't be. I know a number of desperately poor people who wouldn't (or certainly shouldn't be allowed to) do care work for all the money in the world, because they are horrible/lazy people. Same as some Brits.

They are financially compelled to do a job they may not have considered or aspired to if they want to live in the UK, many will be good at it, some not so good, it is the same for people lying about on the dole smoking weed, they might not have considered working three days at the local care home but if their money gets cut so they can`t afford their weed any more they might consider it? If they are too dodgy to be trusted around cash tins and medication they can get out and cut the grass or dig holes for some nice flowers that the residents can look at, or they could do a number on the piano in the communal area to keep people entertained, all better than being a taxpayer sucking waste of space?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:27

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 19:24

I didn't say they were?

You are saying you don't want anyone "compelled" to look after the vulnerable, in context of why British people can't do it, that means you don't think they will do a good a job as the immigrant ones.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:24

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 19:20

Not any more, this is timed to coincide with a recession (and election of course) I think, and the PTB know that people will take any job they can get to meet the bills (specifically the much more pricey mortgage debt) people will work in care home or social care settings to pay their bills, hoping to return to their main job when "things get better".

Let's see then.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 19:24

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:22

It's not as if all fillipinos, eastern Europeans or Nigerians are care workers - most aren't. And I'm sure some of the ones that are probably shouldn't be. I know a number of desperately poor people who wouldn't (or certainly shouldn't be allowed to) do care work for all the money in the world, because they are horrible/lazy people. Same as some Brits.

OK, so insert you preferred country of provenance care workers and tell me why they are better suited to wiping bums, rather then the "compelled" British variety?

I didn't say they were?

Weegie91 · 05/12/2023 19:23

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:19

Not sure what your point is.

I cannot explain it to you in even simpler terms, sorry you struggle with it.

😂

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:22

It's not as if all fillipinos, eastern Europeans or Nigerians are care workers - most aren't. And I'm sure some of the ones that are probably shouldn't be. I know a number of desperately poor people who wouldn't (or certainly shouldn't be allowed to) do care work for all the money in the world, because they are horrible/lazy people. Same as some Brits.

OK, so insert you preferred country of provenance care workers and tell me why they are better suited to wiping bums, rather then the "compelled" British variety?

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 19:20

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:10

Because they can afford not to.

Not any more, this is timed to coincide with a recession (and election of course) I think, and the PTB know that people will take any job they can get to meet the bills (specifically the much more pricey mortgage debt) people will work in care home or social care settings to pay their bills, hoping to return to their main job when "things get better".

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:19

Weegie91 · 05/12/2023 19:17

Oh, I thought Immigrants were sending the country broke? Or is that not the case?

Not sure what your point is.

I cannot explain it to you in even simpler terms, sorry you struggle with it.

Oliotya · 05/12/2023 19:19

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:06

This has been addressed on a similar thread. Do you really want people who have been "compelled" to work looking after vulnerable people?

This is a really strange statement.

Do you really think that the all Filipino, Eastern European and Nigerian careworkers who we currenty rely on do their job because they absolutely adore looking after vulnerable people? Do you really think that growing up all they dreamed about was a care home in Crawley full of people who need constant care?

They are the ones "compelled", as you put it, to do it because the money is better that what they can get in their home countries. Not because it's their childhood dream or vocation in life.

If they can do it, then so can the homegrown employment inactive.

I don't think it's a strange statement at all.

It's not as if all fillipinos, eastern Europeans or Nigerians are care workers - most aren't. And I'm sure some of the ones that are probably shouldn't be. I know a number of desperately poor people who wouldn't (or certainly shouldn't be allowed to) do care work for all the money in the world, because they are horrible/lazy people. Same as some Brits.

Weegie91 · 05/12/2023 19:17

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:10

Because they can afford not to.

Oh, I thought Immigrants were sending the country broke? Or is that not the case?

ThistleTits · 05/12/2023 19:14

@lkwhjis Where did you get the 5 million figure from?

OhmygodDont · 05/12/2023 19:11

Yeah I mean I’d rather shit in my own hands and clap than wipe an adults bum for £11 an hour.

Tbh I’d probably actually throw up anyway so be pretty bad at the job. Can’t even be sick myself without it making me sick. Even those long snots make me nearly puke.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:10

Weegie91 · 05/12/2023 19:09

So why aren't Brits doing these jobs then?

Because they can afford not to.

Weegie91 · 05/12/2023 19:09

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:06

This has been addressed on a similar thread. Do you really want people who have been "compelled" to work looking after vulnerable people?

This is a really strange statement.

Do you really think that the all Filipino, Eastern European and Nigerian careworkers who we currenty rely on do their job because they absolutely adore looking after vulnerable people? Do you really think that growing up all they dreamed about was a care home in Crawley full of people who need constant care?

They are the ones "compelled", as you put it, to do it because the money is better that what they can get in their home countries. Not because it's their childhood dream or vocation in life.

If they can do it, then so can the homegrown employment inactive.

So why aren't Brits doing these jobs then?

WhichIsItWendy · 05/12/2023 19:09

CrashyTime · 05/12/2023 18:56

Tragic, Taxpayer isn`t very romantic though unfortunately, they just want the open door shut and the Tory clown show know they have to address this to get elected again.

Exactly. Of course people fall in love. But love doesn't conquer all like in the films. If you can't practically live together, whether that's down to policy or finance, then people need to be realistic and either end their relationship, stay long distance, or find a country that will enable it.

That's life. Sorry. Adults forego things they want all the time for practical reasons. If you have a child with someone without permission to remain, then youve done so in the knowledge that it may not work out.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/12/2023 19:06

This has been addressed on a similar thread. Do you really want people who have been "compelled" to work looking after vulnerable people?

This is a really strange statement.

Do you really think that the all Filipino, Eastern European and Nigerian careworkers who we currenty rely on do their job because they absolutely adore looking after vulnerable people? Do you really think that growing up all they dreamed about was a care home in Crawley full of people who need constant care?

They are the ones "compelled", as you put it, to do it because the money is better that what they can get in their home countries. Not because it's their childhood dream or vocation in life.

If they can do it, then so can the homegrown employment inactive.