Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think the new £38K income visa threshold for UK spouse visas is fair?

936 replies

zendeveloper · 04/12/2023 19:32

It is set at the same level as for work visas.

Feels completely crazy to me, but then, I am also an immigrant (although the changes don't affect me), so probably too sensitive to the topic. Would be interesting to hear MN opinion.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 21:20

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:16

I have tried not to answer you directly. However, you do realise it costs taxpayers billions to process HO applications ( and other applications like at DWP ) that the gov had to find something standard that caseworkers at HO can quickly check if it ticks the main boxes to say yes or no and, therefore cannot carefully look at your individual circumstances as that may come with a 10 year wait for processing? So we all have to accept the reality. But then I think you left teh UK many years ago (20?)? Everything has gone down in teh UK, hence this attitude to immigration and therefore to people which may include you.

Sorry for your situation.

Edited

According to the House of Commons Library, visa fees are set at around twice the cost of the actual processing, and the profit used to subsidise the Border Force. So the visa system is entirely user-funded.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 05/12/2023 21:19

It is not supposed to be fair.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:18

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 21:16

The last ten posts explain why a government policy is so difficult to get right!

This speaks to what I just posted immediately above.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 21:16

The last ten posts explain why a government policy is so difficult to get right!

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:16

wordler · 05/12/2023 21:10

But the rules for the spouse visa are ignoring the fact that many if not most couples/families can afford to live in the UK even if they don't meet the new financial threshold.

These rules don't take into account:

  • Where you live
  • The foreign spouse's work history and potential
  • Family or third party support
  • Equity you have in your primary residence.

Someone earning 38K in London is allowed to bring their spouse
Someone earning 32K in Penrith, Cumbria is not allowed to bring their spouse

Out of those two couples I bet the Penrith couple have more disposible income left at the end of the month to save for emergencies etc.

Also in these following scenarios, the immigrant spouse is going to be no more burden to the taxpayer than the person living in the South East who earns 38K.

Someone earning 22K in a small town in Scotland who owns their house outright and with a spouse who is experienced and employable and will easily be earning at least 30K when there - who could also downsize to a smaller property if necessary to free up assets for an emergency.

Someone earning 28K who is moving in with their parent who will be covering all housing and living expenses for the couple.

Edited

I have tried not to answer you directly. However, you do realise it costs taxpayers billions to process HO applications ( and other applications like at DWP ) that the gov had to find something standard that caseworkers at HO can quickly check if it ticks the main boxes to say yes or no and, therefore cannot carefully look at your individual circumstances as that may come with a 10 year wait for processing? So we all have to accept the reality. But then I think you left teh UK many years ago (20?)? Everything has gone down in teh UK, hence this attitude to immigration and therefore to people which may include you.

Sorry for your situation.

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 05/12/2023 21:16

wordler · 05/12/2023 21:10

But the rules for the spouse visa are ignoring the fact that many if not most couples/families can afford to live in the UK even if they don't meet the new financial threshold.

These rules don't take into account:

  • Where you live
  • The foreign spouse's work history and potential
  • Family or third party support
  • Equity you have in your primary residence.

Someone earning 38K in London is allowed to bring their spouse
Someone earning 32K in Penrith, Cumbria is not allowed to bring their spouse

Out of those two couples I bet the Penrith couple have more disposible income left at the end of the month to save for emergencies etc.

Also in these following scenarios, the immigrant spouse is going to be no more burden to the taxpayer than the person living in the South East who earns 38K.

Someone earning 22K in a small town in Scotland who owns their house outright and with a spouse who is experienced and employable and will easily be earning at least 30K when there - who could also downsize to a smaller property if necessary to free up assets for an emergency.

Someone earning 28K who is moving in with their parent who will be covering all housing and living expenses for the couple.

Edited

All very true, but the time and cost involved in setting different amounts based on where you live or any of the other factors you mention and then monitoring it (what if they immediately move to London?) would be impractical and hardly cost effective. Realistically there has to be a single limit.

wordler · 05/12/2023 21:10

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 05/12/2023 20:53

On its own it won’t of course, but it all adds up. The popular consensus here is that you shouldn’t be having children unless you can afford it, so why should getting married be any different?

But the rules for the spouse visa are ignoring the fact that many if not most couples/families can afford to live in the UK even if they don't meet the new financial threshold.

These rules don't take into account:

  • Where you live
  • The foreign spouse's work history and potential
  • Family or third party support
  • Equity you have in your primary residence.

Someone earning 38K in London is allowed to bring their spouse
Someone earning 32K in Penrith, Cumbria is not allowed to bring their spouse

Out of those two couples I bet the Penrith couple have more disposible income left at the end of the month to save for emergencies etc.

Also in these following scenarios, the immigrant spouse is going to be no more burden to the taxpayer than the person living in the South East who earns 38K.

Someone earning 22K in a small town in Scotland who owns their house outright and with a spouse who is experienced and employable and will easily be earning at least 30K when there - who could also downsize to a smaller property if necessary to free up assets for an emergency.

Someone earning 28K who is moving in with their parent who will be covering all housing and living expenses for the couple.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:09

There will be countless families like ours who met and married EU citizens (and had families) when there was freedom of movement.

This point I have sympathy with. Welcome to the world and life of all people in UK who are not British citizens. HO keeps upping fees etc etc and changing laws in a second. But I bet you didn't even know any of this before! Well, now you know! None is immune from the f!kery of the UK gov love.

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 21:07

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 05/12/2023 20:53

On its own it won’t of course, but it all adds up. The popular consensus here is that you shouldn’t be having children unless you can afford it, so why should getting married be any different?

Because it's not a question of whether they can afford to be married, but a question of whether they can afford to be married to the person they love if that person happens to be foreign, I guess?

I'd be interested to know how many people on spouse visas went into shortage occupations. We've already established that they can't get benefits for at least five years, pay the NHS surcharge - but spouse visas also cost significantly more than a Health and Care Worker visa, for example (and I'm pretty sure all shortage occupation visas) so it may not be that helpful to skills gaps...

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 21:06

It's also ignored that a huge number of over 55's no longer in employment have taken early retirement to help out with childcare of their grandchildren or caring for elderly relatives, most people I know in this situation aren't living the high life choosing not to work

This is my family, but not us because we are 200 miles away. But my sister and BIL do a lot of pick-ups and babysitting for their daughter and SIL, so they can work and have fun, and they enjoy their grandchildren. They also do a lot of helping for DM, who is well but 88 yo. It works, and we would help too, but it can't be casually shared around at this distance. However, they are off to spend Christmas in the sun with their other child and I shall drive 800 miles back and forth to collect and return x2 DM so she is looked after while they holiday.

beanontoast · 05/12/2023 21:04

HappyChick23 · 05/12/2023 20:57

i am British and married to a Spanish man (we met at school in the UK). We moved to spain with our small children who are British also. This change would make it impossible for us to move back to the UK ever. I am a qualified nurse and couldn’t ever earn this salary in the NHS.

There will be countless families like ours who met and married EU citizens (and had families) when there was freedom of movement. At least when you are going through the immigration process within the EU you can stay together in the country and not be separated.

Of course you could earn 38k in the NHS. It’s the middle spine point of band 6 upwards. Not if you were planning to be a band 5 your whole career, no, but it’s not impossible to achieve

RedRidingGood · 05/12/2023 21:02

Jaxhog · 05/12/2023 21:00

The problem is that immigrants and students are bringing ever larger numbers of dependents with them. While they are dependents, it is putting a greater and greater strain on our social support costs.

You can bring over your spouse and children. That's it. Not extended family, parents etc.

Jaxhog · 05/12/2023 21:00

The problem is that immigrants and students are bringing ever larger numbers of dependents with them. While they are dependents, it is putting a greater and greater strain on our social support costs.

wellwellso · 05/12/2023 21:00

WhenLoveIsDone · 05/12/2023 20:44

More reckons from people who don't understand what the thread is about. This thread is about British citizens' right to family life and the draconian and inhumane policies that tear apart British families.

Not true. And I saved this for exactly this ridiculous post.

Anyone with the right to remain in the UK ( aka permanent resident aka indefinite leave to remain) and some people with limited leave to remain and similar categories- ARE NOT British citizens, however, they too - including - pay attention- our golden British citizens, are captured by this rule (old and new).

Hence it say's 'spouse' and not 'spouse of a British citizen'. Shows people shouting from the rooftop about immigration have no clue what they are talking about! But I knew that already!😀

OhcantthInkofaname · 05/12/2023 20:59

So nurses don't earn that amount in the UK? Nurse Practitioners? Physicians Assistants?
In the US basic RN are paid a lower scale than Nurse Practitioners but at almost twice that.

HappyChick23 · 05/12/2023 20:57

i am British and married to a Spanish man (we met at school in the UK). We moved to spain with our small children who are British also. This change would make it impossible for us to move back to the UK ever. I am a qualified nurse and couldn’t ever earn this salary in the NHS.

There will be countless families like ours who met and married EU citizens (and had families) when there was freedom of movement. At least when you are going through the immigration process within the EU you can stay together in the country and not be separated.

Jaxhog · 05/12/2023 20:56

Noicant · 04/12/2023 19:56

Feel conflicted about this one on one hand it’s quite high and plenty of people on lower wages make a meaningful contribution to society and people can progress etc.

On the other the reality is no country is obliged to have you and ideally you would be self sustaining.

I agree.

Umbrella15 · 05/12/2023 20:56

Noicant · 04/12/2023 19:57

I do think though people who are actively recruited by the government such as the NHS should be allowed to bring families with them.

They do. I am a nurse in the NHS, and many of my coleagues come from overseas. All of them bought their families with them when they came over here.

Arafina · 05/12/2023 20:54

User123456713 · 05/12/2023 19:47

I ve worked before in Social Enterprise, i can tell you that many people who are unemployed are also unemployable, variety of reasons, often MH related, some with physical health issues, most have not worked for many years.

They would require a great deal of effort to get to a state where you'd want them looking after your Gran or disabled son.

You'd want them working in a non care role for many months first, with extensive support & who have we got going spare to provide this? they'd need training up too

I really don't think a high motivated person, willing to leave their own country to seek work, can be compared to someone smoking weed & unemployed for years.

It's also ignored that a huge number of over 55's no longer in employment have taken early retirement to help out with childcare of their grandchildren or caring for elderly relatives, most people I know in this situation aren't living the high life choosing not to work

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 05/12/2023 20:53

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 20:47

I'm not entirely clear how reducing the (already relatively small) number of spouse visas for the partners of British citizens is going to save us from our criminal lack of investment in skills or our rather enormous demographic and public health catastrophe, and might not even make it worse by forcing some of those skilled-but-not-raking-it-in-yet British citizens offshore, but sure. Why not.

On its own it won’t of course, but it all adds up. The popular consensus here is that you shouldn’t be having children unless you can afford it, so why should getting married be any different?

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 20:47

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 05/12/2023 20:27

Importing cheap workers, with their families, is a very short term solution that is just kicking the can further down the road for our children and grand-children to have to deal with. This seems like a sensible measure to start slowly weaning us off imported labour, rather than simply waiting until the pyramid scheme collapses.

Given the story on the BBC today about the elderly lady who died partly because her care workers could not speak good enough English, it would seem that cheap imported care workers are not even solving the problem anyway.

I'm not entirely clear how reducing the (already relatively small) number of spouse visas for the partners of British citizens is going to save us from our criminal lack of investment in skills or our rather enormous demographic and public health catastrophe, and might not even make it worse by forcing some of those skilled-but-not-raking-it-in-yet British citizens offshore, but sure. Why not.

JassyRadlett · 05/12/2023 20:44

In reality it's unsustainable. We can't keep importing people that are a net drain on the country's finances, when they are in such terrible shape.

If only there was a source of immigration that significantly helped to plug the gaps in the labour market while also being an overall net contributor to the economy, in large part because of proximity to their home nations.

Oh wait we did have that, but we chose this path instead. Brexit really is the gift that keeps on giving.

WhenLoveIsDone · 05/12/2023 20:44

More reckons from people who don't understand what the thread is about. This thread is about British citizens' right to family life and the draconian and inhumane policies that tear apart British families.

Papyrophile · 05/12/2023 20:34

It's fairly straightforward to understand. The government (any government, regardless of badge colour) do not want to import low wage labour, and are finally deciding not to subsidise cheap skate employers, because I can't see Labour rowing back from the Tories' recent decision. It costs the host country too much. I returned from the USA after a divorce in 1986 and took a 50% paycut in the process. But I earned over £18k in 1986, and by the time I went freelance in 1990, I was on £27k. Bad luck can happen to anyone, whatever shape it may take. It's the old Gary Player proverb: the harder I work, the luckier I get.

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 05/12/2023 20:27

Importing cheap workers, with their families, is a very short term solution that is just kicking the can further down the road for our children and grand-children to have to deal with. This seems like a sensible measure to start slowly weaning us off imported labour, rather than simply waiting until the pyramid scheme collapses.

Given the story on the BBC today about the elderly lady who died partly because her care workers could not speak good enough English, it would seem that cheap imported care workers are not even solving the problem anyway.